BILL ANALYSIS ------------------------------------------------------------ |SENATE RULES COMMITTEE | AB 32| |Office of Senate Floor Analyses | | |1020 N Street, Suite 524 | | |(916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) | | |327-4478 | | ------------------------------------------------------------ THIRD READING Bill No: AB 32 Author: Nunez (D), et al Amended: 8/30/06 in Senate Vote: 21 SENATE ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY COMMITTEE : 5-2, 6/26/06 AYES: Simitian, Chesbro, Escutia, Kuehl, Lowenthal NOES: Runner, Cox SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE : 8-4, 8/17/06 AYES: Murray, Alarcon, Alquist, Escutia, Florez, Ortiz, Romero, Torlakson NOES: Aanestad, Ashburn, Battin, Dutton NO VOTE RECORDED: Poochigian ASSEMBLY FLOOR : 50-27, 4/11/05 - See last page for vote SUBJECT : Air pollution: greenhouse gases: California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 SOURCE : Natural Resources Defense Council Environmental Defense DIGEST : This bill enacts the Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006. ANALYSIS : Existing law: CONTINUED AB 32 Page 2 1. Provides for the California Climate Action Registry and the voluntary reporting of greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions to establish baselines against which future GHG emission reduction requirements may be applied. [SB 1771 (Sher), Chapter 1018, Statutes of 2000 and SB 527 (Sher), Chapter 769, Statutes of 2001.] 2. Requires the Air Resources Board (ARB) to regulate GHG emissions emitted by passenger vehicles and light-duty trucks to achieve maximum feasible reductions [AB 1493 (Pavley), Chapter 200, Statutes of 2002]. 3. Requires ARB to develop regulations to prevent diesel truck engine idling at ports pursuant to AB 2650 (Lowenthal), Chapter 1129, Statutes of 2002. 4. Requires the state's retail sellers of electricity to achieve at least 20 percent of energy sales from renewable sources, pursuant to SB 1078 (Sher), Chapter 516, Statutes of 2002 5. Requires the California Energy Commission (CEC) to develop and adopt by June 30, 2007, a state plan to increase the use of alternative transportation fuels to achieve multiple objectives, including the reduction of GHG emissions, pursuant to AB 1007 (Pavley), Chapter 371, Statutes of 2005. This bill: 1. Requires ARB, on or before January 1, 2008, to adopt regulations requiring GHG emission sources to monitor and report their emissions to the ARB, and specifies detailed criteria for the adoption and compliance with those regulations. 2. Requires ARB, on or before January 1, 2008, to adopt a statewide emissions limit on GHG emissions, specifies both a process and criteria for the adoption of the limit, and provides that the limit shall remain in effect after 2020 until otherwise amended or repealed. 3. Requires ARB to adopt the maximum feasible and AB 32 Page 3 cost-effective reductions in GHG emissions for sources and categories of sources subject to the Act, in accordance with the following schedule: A. On or before July 1, 2007, ARB shall adopt a list of those discrete early action emission reduction measures that can be achieved prior to the adoption of market based compliance mechanisms and other measures and limits under the bill's provisions. B. On or before January 1, 2010, ARB shall adopt and enforce those measures on the list described above in order to achieve the maximum technologically feasible and cost-effective reductions of GHGs. C. On or before January 1, 2009, ARB shall prepare and adopt a rulemaking scoping plan for the rules and regulations it is required to adopt pursuant to the bill's provisions, and shall comply with specified criteria in developing and adopting the plan. ARB further is required to update the plan every five years. D. On or before January 1, 2011, ARB shall adopt GHG emission limits and measures to achieve the maximum feasible and cost-effective reductions in GHG emissions in furtherance of the GHG emission limit. E. In adopting the regulations described in #3D, ARB may adopt a so-called "cap and trade" system (i.e. "a system of market-based declining annual aggregate emission limits" as described in the bill), provided it complies with specified conditions prior to authorizing the use of those mechanisms. F. In adopting the regulations described in #3D above, ARB may adopt market-based compliance mechanisms and specifies conditions and criteria for the adoption and use of those mechanisms. G. In adopting regulations, requires ARB to take into account environmental justice, equitable distribution of emission reductions, best available scientific and economic information, and other factors. AB 32 Page 4 H. Provides that ARB shall consult with various other state agencies that have jurisdiction over utilities and other sources of GHG emissions in order to minimize any overlap among those agencies. 4. Authorizes ARB to impose administrative, civil, and/or criminal penalties consistent with its authority under air quality statutes for violations of any rule, regulation, order, or standard adopted by ARB pursuant to the bill's provisions. 5. Authorizes the Governor to adjust applicable deadlines for individual regulations, or for the state in aggregate, to the earliest feasible date in the event of extraordinary circumstances, catastrophic events, or significant economic harm, limits that adjustment to one year in duration, specifies procedures for notifying the public and provides that this provision does not affect the Governor's authority under the Emergency Services Act. 6. Requires ARB to establish an environmental justice advisory committee and an economic and technology advisory committee for the purposes of advising ARB on implementation of the bill's provisions, and specifies appointment processes and procedures for those committees. 7. Provides that if the regulations adopted pursuant to AB 1493 (Pavley), Chapter 200, Statutes of 2002, to reduce GHG emissions from vehicular sources do not remain in effect, ARB shall adopt alternative regulations that achieve the equivalent or greater reductions. 8. Requires all state agencies to consider and implement GHG emission reduction strategies, and provides that nothing in the bill affects the authority of any other state agency to reduce GHG emissions, the authority of air districts, the authority of the Public Utilities Commission, or utilities' obligation to provide electric serves. 9. Authorizes ARB to adopt a schedule of fees to pay for AB 32 Page 5 the costs of implementing the program established pursuant to the bill's provisions. 10.Provides that the provisions of the bill are severable. 11.Makes detailed findings and declarations relative to the economic and environmental effects of global warming and climate change. 12.Establishes definitions of terms used under the bill. Comments According to the Senate Environmental Quality Committee analysis, there is broad scientific consensus that rising concentrations of GHG emissions in the atmosphere are resulting in climate changes that will continue to accelerate during this century. A statement in June 2006, from the Attorney General's Office, provides a succinct statement about the perceived threats from global warming. The statement was provided in support of the Public Utility Commission's promulgating a rule to integrate GHG emission standards into procurement policies and included the following findings: "?the best available science establishes that GHG-induced climate change is occurring and is fast approaching a critical 'tipping point' and that California has a substantial stake in taking every possible action at the earliest juncture to mitigate the potentially devastating impacts - economic as well as environmental - of climate change? "Impacts from anthropogenic CO2 emissions that have occurred, are occurring, and will occur, include: temperature increases, heat waves, loss of Artic ice and habitat, loss of Antarctic ice, melting of glaciers and related glacial lake outburst flows, loss of snowpack in California and elsewhere, changes in precipitation patterns, increased hurricane intensity, sea level rise and coastal flooding, public health harms such as increased heat-related illness and smog, harm to habitats, and the potential for substantial social upheaval resulting from significant AB 32 Page 6 environmental changes. ?[a one meter sea level rise threatens $48 billion of commercial, industrial, and residential structures in the San Francisco Bay]? "In litigation between the automakers and the State of California, the automakers have challenged the authority of the State to regulate greenhouse gases from mobile sources. In response to the automakers claims, the State has gathered declarations from some of the world's leading climate scientists concerning impacts of anthropogenic greenhouse gas emissions on climate broadly and on California in particular. Many of these declarations, which starkly establishes the threat to the world and to California: "At the same time as climate change is likely to cause a significant reduction in California's effective water supply, it is also likely to cause an increase in California's demand for water because of the sharp increase in summertime temperatures. "The effects of global warming are already observed in the decrease in snow water equivalent and in the earlier snowmelt and streamflow timing of the past several decades. "Climate change will increase global sea levels?Sea level rise will have two effects (a) ?increase the intrusion of salt water [into the Sacramento delta]; and (b) increase water levels in the channels [of the Delta] and so threaten the integrity of the levees in the Delta. "The findings strongly suggest that a climate change consistent with any of the four [commonly employed] climate projections?will lead to a significant increase in heat-related deaths. This increase will number in the thousands for the five California cities [Fresno, Los Angeles, Riverside, Sacramento and San Francisco] over a period of a decade. "If additional human-made global warming (above that in 2000) is so large, say 2-3 degrees C, that the expected equilibrium (long-term) sea level rise is of the order AB 32 Page 7 of 25 meters, there would be a potential for a continually unfolding planetary disaster of monstrous proportions." Background In June 2005, the Governor issued an executive order that established the following GHG emission reduction targets for the state: By 2010, reduce GHG emissions to year 2000 levels. By 2020, reduce GHG emissions to year 1990 levels. By 2050, reduce GHG emissions to 80 percent below year 1990 levels. As noted in a report by the Legislative Analyst, between 1990 and 2000, annual California GHG emissions increased by approximately 13 percent, from about 396 million metric tons in 1990 to 449 million metric tons in 2000. The Governor's Climate Action Team has estimated that achieving the Governor's GHG reduction targets for 2010 and 2020 will result in GHG emissions that are 11 percent and 29 percent, respectively, below that which would otherwise occur according to "business as usual". The initial draft of recommendations drafted by the Climate Action Team included four actions essential to meeting the Governor's GHG reduction goals: 1. Require climate change emissions reporting from all emitters of GHGs, starting with the largest emitters. 2. Levy fees on gasoline and diesel sales to reduce demand for these fuels and to fund promotion of alternative, cleaner fuels. 3. Coordinate state investment funds to reward industry development of emission reduction technologies. 4. Encourage companies to take early action to reduce their climate change emissions in anticipation of subsequent state, federal, or international emissions reduction programs. AB 32 Page 8 FISCAL EFFECT : Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes SUPPORT : (Verified 8/30/06) Natural Resources Defense Council (co-source) Environmental Defense (co-source) Federal Elected Officials from California Hon. Dianne Feinstein, U.S. Senator Hon. Barbara Boxer, U.S. Senator Hon. Howard Berman, U.S. Representative Hon. Tom Lantos, U.S. Representative Hon. Sam Farr, U.S. Representative Hon. Zoe Lofgren, U.S. Representative Hon. Michael Honda, U.S. Representative Hon. George Miller, U.S. Representative Hon. Adam Schiff, U.S. Representative Hon. Hilda Solis, U.S. Representative Local/County Governments City of Agoura Hills City of Berkeley City of Beverly Hills City of Burbank City of Carson City of Chino City of Chula Vista City of Cloverdale City of Cotati City of Fairfax City of Foster City City of Grand Terrace City of Hayward City of Healdsburg City of Huntington Park City of Los Angeles City of Long Beach City of Monterey Park City of Moorpark City of Morgan Hill City of Oakland AB 32 Page 9 City of Petaluma City of Pleasanton City of Rialto City of Richmond City of Rohnert Park City of Sacramento City of San Bernardino City of San Francisco City of San Luis Obispo City of San Mateo City of Santa Barbara City of Santa Cruz City of Santa Monica City of Santa Rosa City of Sausalito City of Sebastopol City of Sonoma City of South San Francisco City of Stockton City of Sunnyvale City of West Hollywood County of Contra Costa County of Marin County of San Mateo County of Sonoma Town of Windsor Hon. Ronald Albert, Mayor, City of Sausalito Air, Water, and Utility Districts California Air Pollution Control Officers Association (if amended) East Bay Municipal Utility District Marin Municipal Water District Sacramento Metropolitan Air Quality Management District Sacramento Municipal Utility District Santa Clara Valley Water District Health & Medical Organizations & Professional Organizations American Academy of Pediatrics, California Division American Lung Association of California California Nurses Association California Thoracic Society AB 32 Page 10 Catholic Healthcare West Community Action to Fight Asthma Medical Advocates for Healthy Air Regional Asthma Management & Prevention Initiative (RAMP) Faith-Based Organizations California Church IMPACT California Catholic Conference of Bishops Fresno Metro Ministry Interfaith Power and Light Lutheran Office of Public Policy Westminster Presbyterian Church Organized Labor American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, AFL-CIO California Nurses Association California Federation of Teachers CDF Firefighters Public Interest Groups League of Women Voters of California Republicans for Environmental Protection (REP America) Business Organizations Bay Area Council (if amended) Bay Area Development Corp. Industry Association California Ski Industry Association California Solar Energy Industries Association California Wind Energy Association Environmental Entrepreneurs/E2 The New Voice of Business PVNOW San Francisco Chamber of Commerce (if amended) Santa Rosa Chamber of Commerce Small Business California Small Business Majority Businesses AB 32 Page 11 Agoura Technologies Bentley Prince Street CalWind Resources, Inc Christopherson Homes Cenveo Anderson Lithograph Clif Bar & Co. Codding Investments, Inc Energy Solutions Environmental Solar Design Eurus Energy America Corporation Interface, Inc. Ion America KEMCO Mendocino Wine Company Mindjet Corporation Mountain High Ski Resort Northstar-at-Tahoe Ski Resort Oak Creek Energy Systems Paul Terry & Associates PowerLight Corp. Progressive Asset Management San Gorgonio Farms, Inc. Solar Integrated Technologies Sonoma Wineco Straus Family Creamery Sun Light & Power VentureSpark Vita Gabrielli, Inc Waste Management, Inc. Whitewater Energy Corp Whitewater Maintenance Corp Witt Rylander Advertising Working Assets Agriculture, Food Processing and Food Services California Restauarants: Antica Trattoria, Ruggero Gadaldi Ajanta, Laxman Moorjani B 44, Daniel Olivella Boulevard, Nancy Oakes Enrico's, Hal Russek Hayes Street Grill, Patrician Unterman The Last Supper Club, Ruggero AB 32 Page 12 O Chame, David Vardi Oliveto, Bob & Maggie Klein Pesce, SF, Ruggero Gadaldi Rivoli, Wendy Brucker & Roscoe Skipper Tosca, Jeannette Etheridge Walzwerk, Christiane Schmidt & Isabell Mysyk George H. Hume, President & CEO, Basic American, Inc. San Gorgonio Farms Thomas B. Klein, Owner & Proprietor, Rodney Strong Vineyards CleanTech Aimee Christensen, Team Member, Google.org Al Rich, CEO, Solarroofs Alvin Duskin, CEO, Clean Coal Energy Andrew Beebe, President, Energy Innovations Bill Roth, President, Cleantech America Carol Weisskopf, Pilz & Co., Inc. Chris Copeland, Wintec Energy, Ltd. Curt Maloy, WindPro Insurance Dave Pearce, CEO, Miasole Dennis Scullion, EnXco Doug Levitt, CalWind Resources Doug Ogden, Executive Vice President, The Energy Foundation Dr. Robert Knight, Bevilacqua-Knight, Inc. Edward Shonsey, CEO, Diversa Corp. Eurus Energy American, Corp. Felix Kramer, Founder, California Cars Initiative Geraldine Schumacher, Windkraft Nord, USA, Inc. Gordon Mitchard, CEO, Pionetics Jack Newman, Cofounder and VP Research, Amyris Jay Bhalla, Intergy Jeff Welton, Wintec Energy Jody London, Jody London Consulting Joel Makower, Founder, Greenbiz.com & Co-Founder, Clean Edge, Inc. John Cheney, CEO & Chairman, Renewable Ventures John Guice, VP of Business Development, Green Mountain Engineering John Heinzmann, Fuel Cell Energy Ken Moore, RLW Analytics Krista Kisch, UPC Wind Management, LLC Larry Gross, CEO, Altra AB 32 Page 13 Louis Romo, VP of Business Development, Vycon Mahlon Aldridge, Ecology Action Mark Tholke Martin Roscheisen, Founder & CEO, Nanosolar, Inc. Matt Brost, RLW Analytics Michael Santullo, President of Executive Council, California Clean Tech Open Mickey Oros, Altergy Systems Mike Little, Agoura Technologies Niels Rydder, Green Ridge Power, LLC Rana Mookherjee, CFO, Cleantech America Ray Larocca, Ion America Rob Erlichman, President, Sunlight Electric, LLC Robert Mowris, Robert Mowris & Associates Ron Pernick, Co-Founder & Principal, Clean Edge Sam Cohen, Energy Solutions Steve Chadima, CMO, Energy Innovations, Inc. Steven Shallenber, American Synergy Corp. Tom Conlon, GeoPraxis Tom Eckhart, UCONs, LLC Entertainment Industry Bill Clark, Red Board Productions Dana Walden, President, Twentieth Century Fox Television David Milch, Red Board Productions David O'Connor, Managing Partner, Creative Artists Agency Elizabeth Wiatt, NRDC Trustee, & Jim Wiatt, CEO, William Morris Agency Gary Fleder, Mojo Films Jonathan Shaw, President, Depth Q Media Paul Junger Witt, Partner, Witt Thomas Productions Paul Miloknay, Rohner, Walerstein & Miloknay Reginald Hudlin, President, Black Entertainment Television Richard Rudolph, Chief Creative Executive, Music Sales West/Rudolph Productions Rob Newell, Main Street Media Inc. Steven Bochco Productions Ted Harbert, President & CEO, E! Networks The Jim Henson Company Financial & Investment Communities Alex Osadzinski, Venture Partner, Trinity Ventures AB 32 Page 14 Andy Funk, CEO, Chairman & Managing Director, Funk Ventures Bill Unger, Partner Emeritus, Mayfield Bob Welch, President, Coast Ventures Brook Byers, Former Partner, Kleiner Perkins Caufield & Byers Bud Colligan, Accel Partners Chris Eyre, Managing Director, Legacy Venture Dave Edwards, Managing Director, ThinkEquity Partners David Liddle, General Partner, USVP David Roux, Managing Director, Silver Lake Partners David Taylor, Venture Capitalist Diane Christensen, President, Manzanita Management Corp. Don Garman, First Vice President, Merrill Lynch Private Advisory Group Doug Shorenstein, Chairman & CEO, Shorenstein Properties, LLC Ellen Pao, Partner, Kleiner Perkins Caufield & Byers Eric Bowen, VP Energy and Director Biofuels, Sigma Capital Group Eric Hippeau, Managing Partner, Softbank Capital Eric Ramberg, Atrium Capital F. Warren Hellman, Chairman, Hellman & Friedman, LLC George A. Miller, Retired Chairman, Capital Research Co. George Hardie, Babcock & Brown, LP George Montgomery, Sr. Advisor, Seven Hills Group George Phipps, Partner, Oak Hill Investment Management Gib Myers, Partner Emeritus, Mayfield Fund & Founder/Board of the Entrepreneurs Foundation Herbert M. Sandler, Chairman & CEO, Goldern West Financial Corp. Ion Yadigaroglu, Partner, Capricorn Management, LLC James Higgins, General Partner, Lakeside Enterprises Janet McKinley, Retired Chairman, Income Fund of America Jeff Lawrence, Founder, President & CEO, Clivia Systems Inc. Jill Tate Higgins, General Partner, Lakeside Enterprises John Doerr, Partner, Kleiner Perkins Kaufield & Byers John Swift, President, Swift Development, Inc. Kate Mitchell, Managing Partner, BankAmerica Ventures Larry Orr, Managing Partner, Trinity Ventures Lynn Feintech, Managing Director, Citigroup Global Investment Madelyn Mallory, President & CEO, Catalyst Financial Planning & Investment Management Corp. AB 32 Page 15 Marianne Gaddy, VentureSpark Mike Dierks, Director, Strategic Investments, Intel Capital Reid Dennis, Managing Director, Institutional Venture Partners Russell Hall, Managing Director, Legacy Venture Ruthann Quindlen, Institutional Venture Partners Ted Driscoll, Venture Partner, Claremont Creeks Venture Tim McAdam, General Partner, Trinity Ventures Tim Newell, Managing Director, Element Venture Partners Tod Francis, Founding Partner, Shasta Ventures Tom Cole, General Partner, Trinity Ventures Vic Parker, General Partner, Spectrum Equity Wes Mitchell, President, Foto Forum, SFMOMA Zeb Rice, Partner, Angeleno Group Professional Services Andrew Deitz, Director, Symphony Technology Group David Hessel, Operations Manager, CB Richard Ellis, Inc., Natl. Procurement Jane Downs, President. Along Came Mary! Productions, Inc. Mark Parnes, Attorney, Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati Mary Micucci, Founder & Owner, Along Came Mary! Productions. Inc. Matthew Fisher, Nixon Peabody, LLP Michael Rylander, Witt Rylander Advertising Peter Davis, Appellate Department, Reed Smith Crosby Heafy Renee Miller, President/Creative Director, The Miller Group Advertising Renee White Fraser, PhD., President & CEO, Fraser Communications Technology & Biotechnology Anne Feldhusen, Marketing Program Manager, Hewlett-Packard Bob Epstein, Co-Founder, Sybase, GetActive Software, Environmental Entrepreneurs Bob Fisher, Director, Gap, Inc. & Sun Microsystems Brian Dougherty, CEO, Airena, Inc. Bryan Martel, Chief Executive Officer, Mobius Technologies, Inc. David Rosenstein, President, Intex Solutions Eric Schmidt, Chairman & CEO, Google AB 32 Page 16 George Dies, Director, Strategic Planning, HP Labs, Hewlett-Packard Company Jiali Osadzinski, Controller, Applied Biosystems Joe Costello, Former Chair & CEO, Cadence Design Systems John Mayerhofer, Chairman, CEO, VoiceIndigo, Inc. Kathy Nyrop, Vice President & CFO, GetActive Software Lisa Gansky, Co-Founder, Ofoto (Kodak) & GNN (AOL) Michael Delapa, President, Delapa Consulting; Co-Founder Arena Solutions Nathan Diemer, Executive VP & COO, DreamHammer, Inc. Rick DeGolia, Chairman, Apptera Shelby Bonnie, Chairman & CEO, CNET Networks, Inc. Stephen Torres, Magnetek Steve Farrell, Chairman Emeritus, Netigy Corporation, ENS Inc. Steve Fioretti, Senior Director Product Marketing, Siebel Systems Tim Newell, Vice President & CFO, GetActive Software Other E2 Business Leaders Amy Santullo, Chairman, Downtown College Prep Scholarship Committee Carol Mon?, President, Our Earth Music, Inc. Drew Maran, President, Drew Maran Construction/Design Jeffrey Neu, Sr. Vice President - General Manager, SIMS Hugo Neu Nicole Lederer, Co-Founder, E2 Peter Fortenbaugh, Executive Director, Boys and Girls Club of the Peninsula Susie Roos, Cook & Roos Tushar Gheewala, CEO & Chairman, Inventions Outsource Editorial Support Los Angles Times Pasadena Weekly San Francisco Chronicle The Mercury News (San Jose) The New York Times The Sacramento Bee Conservation, Natural Resources, & Environmental Organizations AB 32 Page 17 Amigos de Bolsa Chica Audubon California Baykeeper Bluewater Network California Coastal Commission Calif. League of Conservation Voters California Native Plant Society California Oak Foundation California Outdoor Heritage Alliance Californians Against Waste Californians for Alternatives to Toxics Central Valley Air Quality Coalition Steering Committee Members (if amended) Clean Power Campaign Climate Protection Campaign (600 Signatures) Coalition for Clean Air Community Fuels Defenders of Wildlife Deltakeeper Endangered Habitats League Environment California Environmental Justice Coalition for Water Environmental Defense Global Green USA Greenpeace Institute for Deep Ecology Kirsch Foundation KyotoUSA League of Conservation Voters Literacy for Environmental Justice Marin Conservation League National Audubon Society National Environmental Trust National Wildlife Federation Natural Resources Defense Council Odyssey Orange County League of Conservation Voters Pacific Forest Trust Planning and Conservation League Sierra Club CA Sierra Club - Loma Prieta Chapter Sierra Nevada Alliance Steven and Michele Kirsch Foundation AB 32 Page 18 Turtle Island Restoration Network Union of Concerned Scientists U.S. Public Interest Research Group OPPOSITION : (Verified 8/30/06) 1 Icon (Foothill Ranch) Alert-O-Life, Inc (Fresno) Alliance of Automobile Manufacturers American Canyon Chamber of Commerce American Optisurgical Inc, (Lake Forest) American Vanpac Carriers, Inc (Lake Forest) Asphalt Pavement Association Associated General Contractors of California, Inc Association of International Automobile Manufacturers Athena Enterprises, Inc (Chico) Automobile Refrigeration Products Institute Boeing Company C & R Plumbing Co. Inc, Westminster California Automobile Wholesalers Association California Bean Shippers Association California Beer and Beverage Distributors California Building Industry Association California Business Properties Association California Business Roundtable California Cement Manufacturers Environment Coalition California Chamber of Commerce California Circuits Association California Council Environmental Economic Balance California Forestry Association California Grocers Association California Independent Grocers and Convenience Stores California Hotel and Lodging Association California Independent Oil Marketers Association California Independent Petroleum Association California Grain and Feed Association California League of Food Processors California Manufacturers and Technology Association California Mining Association California/Nevada Automotive Wholesalers Association California Nevada Cement Promotion Council California Portland Cement Company California Precast Concrete Association California Poultry Federation AB 32 Page 19 California Refrigeration Products Institute California Restaurant Association California Retailers Association California State Floral Association California Warehouse Association CalCars, The California Cars Initiative Calistoga Chamber of Commerce Carris Reels of California, Inc (Madera) Castro Valley Chamber of Commerce Center for Energy and Economic Development Cerritos Regional Chamber of Commerce Chemical Industry Council of California Clovis Chamber of Commerce Construction Materials Association of California Consumers First, Inc. Cornerstone of Southern California County of Santa Barbara Industrial Association Dublin Chamber of Commerce El Monte Chamber of Commerce EMC Planning Group, Inc (Monterey) Engine Manufacturers Association Engineering and Utility Contractors Association Faust Printing (Rancho Cucamonga) Foasberg Laundry and Cleaners (Long Beach) Forest Lawn Memorial Parks (Glendale) General Carbon Company (Los Angeles) Greater Bakersfield Chamber of Commerce Greater Fresno Area Chamber of Commerce Hayward Chamber of Commerce Home Instead Senior Care (Rancho Cucamonga) Imperial County Farm Bureau Independent Oil Producers Agency Industrial Environment Association Irvine Chamber Kern County Farm Bureau Irwindale Chamber of Commerce LA Envelope Inc. (Montebello) Milpitas Chamber of Commerce Orange Chamber of Commerce Orange County Business Council Oxnard Chamber of Commerce Pacific Egg and Poultry Association Palestro Distribution Centers Petz Enterprises Inc. (Tracy) AB 32 Page 20 Pleasanton Chamber of Commerce Plumbing Manufacturers Institute Rancho Cordova Chamber of Commerce Rubber Manufacturers Association San Joaquin County Farm Bureau Santa Barbara County Farm Bureau Santa Barbara County Taxpayers Association SDH Enterprises, Inc. (Fairfield) SEE California (a Chamber sub-group) Searless Valley Minerals Smiley Motor Sports (Fairfield) Stanislaus County Farm Bureau Stokes Ladders, Inc (Kelseyville) TAMCO TelePacific Communications (Los Angeles) Tuolumne County Chamber of Commerce Ventura Chamber of Commerce Western Growers Association Western Plant Health Association Western States Petroleum Association Western United Dairymen WH Breshars, Inc (Modesto) Wine Institute (Oppose Unless Amended) Agricultural Council of California Alliance of Western Milk Producers BP (Oppose unless Amended) California Association of Winegrape Growers California Citrus Mutual California Farm Bureau Federation California Cotton Ginners Association California Cotton Growers Association California Grape and Tree Fruit League Nisei Farmers League PG & E Company ASSEMBLY FLOOR : AYES: Arambula, Baca, Bass, Berg, Bermudez, Blakeslee, Calderon, Canciamilla, Chan, Chavez, Chu, Cohn, Coto, De La Torre, Dymally, Evans, Frommer, Goldberg, Hancock, Harman, Shirley Horton, Jones, Karnette, Klehs, Koretz, AB 32 Page 21 Laird, Leno, Levine, Lieber, Liu, Matthews, Montanez, Mullin, Nation, Nava, Negrete McLeod, Oropeza, Parra, Pavley, Richman, Ridley-Thomas, Ruskin, Saldana, Salinas, Torrico, Umberg, Vargas, Wolk, Yee, Nunez NOES: Aghazarian, Benoit, Bogh, Cogdill, Daucher, DeVore, Garcia, Haynes, Houston, Huff, Keene, La Malfa, La Suer, Leslie, Maze, McCarthy, Mountjoy, Nakanishi, Niello, Plescia, Sharon Runner, Spitzer, Strickland, Tran, Villines, Walters, Wyland NO VOTE RECORDED: Emmerson, Gordon, Jerome Horton CTW:mel 8/30/06 Senate Floor Analyses SUPPORT/OPPOSITION: SEE ABOVE **** END ****