BILL ANALYSIS SB 1614 Page 1 Date of Hearing: June 21, 2006 ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION Jackie Goldberg, Chair SB 1614 (Simitian) - As Amended: May 3, 2006 SENATE VOTE : 24-14 SUBJECT : Teacher identification number. SUMMARY : Requires the development of a teacher data system to serve as a central state repository of information on the teacher workforce to inform policy, identify trends, and identify future teacher workforce needs. Specifically, this bill : 1)Makes findings and declarations regarding the need for accurate teacher information service in regard to recruitment, movement, professional development, departure and retirement in a central data base. 2)Expresses Legislative intent that this be accomplished through the establishment of a comprehensive state education data information system in the State Department of Education (SDE). 3)Specifies that the existing California Education Information System (CEIS) include: a) The California Longitudinal Pupil Achievement Data System (CALPADS) which maintains pupil data, regarding demographics, program participation, enrollment, and statewide assessments in addition to data gathered through the California Basic Educational Data System (CBEDS) through the Professional Assignment Information Form prepared by the SDE and filled out each year at every public school; and b) The California Longitudinal Teacher Integrated Data Education System (CALTIDES) to enable the analysis of workforce trends, including mobility, retention, attrition, evaluation of teacher preparation and professional development programs, and monitoring of teacher assignments as required by the federal No Child Left Behind Act of 2001 (NCLB) by consolidating data that is already collected through a variety of data systems by state SB 1614 Page 2 agencies and county offices of education, as well as data collected by SDE. 4)Requires the SDE and California Commission on Teacher Credentialing (CCTC) to contract for the development of CALTIDES, based on the findings of a teacher data feasibility study conducted pursuant to Item 6110-001-0890 of Section 2.00 of the Budget Act of 2005 (Chapter 38 of the Statutes of 2005). 5)Requires the CCTC to establish nonpersonally identifiable teacher identification numbers for each person authorized to teach in the state. 6)Permits public disclosure of this number with information regarding credentials, permits, or other documents the CCTC issues. 7)Prohibits use of data in either CALPADS of CALTIDES for purposes of pay, promotion, sanction, or personnel evaluation of an individual teacher or groups of teachers, or of employment decisions related to individual teachers. 8)Requires CALTIDES to include all of the following information: a) Age profiles of teachers in the workforce; b) Projections of retirements over the next ten years throughout the state; c) Identification of severe shortages of teachers in specific subject matter areas; d) Geographical distribution of teachers by credential type; and e) Present patterns of in-service education for teachers. 9)Requires that the system shall: a) Utilize and maximize existing databases; b) Maintain longitudinally linked data without including names of teachers; and SB 1614 Page 3 c) Comply with all state and federal confidentiality and privacy laws. 10)Requires the Superintendent of Public Instruction (SPI) to convene a working group to provide advice and guidance on the development of the CALTIDES; specifies that the group should include representatives of the CCTC, the Department of Finance, the Secretary for Education, the Legislative Analyst's Office, the Employment Development Department, and representatives of local education agencies, postsecondary institutions, researchers, teachers, administrators, and parents. EXISTING LAW : 1)Establishes CALPADS to track student data longitudinally. 2)Permits the CCTC to disclose information on teachers regarding credentials, certificates, permits, or other documents that it issues and prohibits the CCTC from disclosing any other information except by court order. FISCAL EFFECT : According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, the SDE Budget Change Proposal for the CLTIDES estimates one time first year costs of $468,000 and one time vendor costs of $678,000, for a total of $1,146,000. The SDE estimated ongoing costs of $1,132,871 in 2009-10, $2,013,780 in 2010-11, and $1,945,796 in 2011-12. There are one time data center services ($389,577) and software purchases ($422,200) in 2008-09. COMMENTS : AB 1213 (Wyland) of 2005 which failed in the Assembly Education Committee required the SPI to adopt a unique teacher identifier and to preserve student and teacher confidentiality. This bill, by allowing the CCTC to disclose the teacher identification number, has the potential to disclose unknown amounts of personal information in the CALTIDES data base to the public. In Strengthening California's Teacher Information System, the Center for the Future of Teaching and Learning states: "In developing a comprehensive data system, policy-makers will need to consider several additional issues. First, a new system will SB 1614 Page 4 need to include strong safeguards to keep any unique identifier out of the public domain and protect the identity of individual teachers." This bill makes the identifiers open to the public. Staff recommendation : This bill should delete the amendment that allows the CCTC to release the unique teacher identifier to the public. The author has agreed to this amendment. REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION : Support Berkeley Evaluation and Assessment Research Center California Teachers Association Ed Voice Pacific Institute for Community Organizations Public Advocates, Inc. Springboard Schools Stanford University School of Education Opposition None on file. Analysis Prepared by : Dee Brennick / ED. / (916) 319-2087