BILL ANALYSIS AJR 39 Page 1 Date of Hearing: May 5, 2010 ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION Julia Brownley, Chair AJR 39 (Torlakson) - As Amended: April 26, 2010 SUBJECT : Common state education standards. SUMMARY : Calls upon the National Governors Association (NGA) and the Council of Chief State School Officers (CCSSO) to develop common core state standards in the core academic disciplines of English-language arts, mathematics, history-social science, and science, and to replicate the process used to develop English-language arts (ELA) and mathematics common core state standards to develop common core state standards for social studies and science. Specifically, this bill : 1)Makes findings and declarations relative to the common core state standards initiative as an opportunity for states to collectively drive education reform toward graduating pupils from high school ready for college, work and success in the global economy. 2)Makes findings and declarations relative to science and social science education and the importance of ensuring pupils have the knowledge of history, geography, economics, and government, and the understanding of the physical world, including biology, chemistry, geology, astronomy and physics and a grasp of the scientific method of discovery. 3)Resolves that the NGA and the CCSSO also examine the viability of developing common standards in other subject areas including, but not limited to, foreign language, arts, physical education, and career technical education (CTE). EXISTING LAW : 1)Requires the Superintendent of Public Instruction (SPI), the State Board of Education (SBE), and any other entity designated by the Governor to participate in the Common Core State Standards Initiative Consortium (CCSSIC) sponsored by the NGA and the CCSSO, or any associated or related interstate collaboration to develop common high-quality standards or assessments. AJR 39 Page 2 2)Establishes the Academic Content Standards Commission, as specified, to develop academic content standards in language arts and mathematics and present recommended academic content standards to the SBE by July 15, 2010. 3)Requires that at least 85% of the new standards include the common core academic standards developed by the CCSSIC sponsored by the NGA and the CCSSO or any associated or related interstate collaboration to jointly develop common high-quality standards or assessments aligned with the common set of standards, and requires the SBE to adopt or reject the recommended standards by August 2, 2010. 4)Requires, if the standards are rejected, the SBE to provide a specific written explanation to the SPI, the Governor, and the Legislature of the reasons why the proposed standards were rejected. 5)Requires the SPI and the SBE to present to the Governor and to the appropriate policy and fiscal committees of the Legislature a schedule and implementation plan for integrating the revised adopted academic content standards into the state educational system. 6)Requires the SBE to adopt statewide academic content standards and performance standards in core curriculum areas not later than January 1, 1998, based on the recommendation of the Commission for the Establishment of Academic Content and Performance Standards and the SPI, and allows the SBE to adopt content and performance standards in individual core curriculum areas as those standards are submitted to the SBE. FISCAL EFFECT : This resolution is keyed nonfiscal. COMMENTS : California has adopted content standards in the areas of reading/language arts, math, history/social science, science, visual and performing arts, career technical education, physical education, health education, and most recently world languages. The Common Core State Standards Initiative is an effort to establish a single set of content standards for English-language arts (ELA) and math that states can share and voluntarily adopt. The CCSSO and the NGA Center for Best Practices have AJR 39 Page 3 coordinated the effort and the process of developing common core standards in consultation with teachers, parents, experts and administrators. 48 states, two territories and the District of Columbia joined the CCSSI and committed to developing a common core of state standards in ELA and math for grades K-12. Legislation enacted for purposes of satisfying part of the criteria for the Race to the Top (RTTT) program, namely, SB 1 X5 (Steinberg), Chapter 2, Statutes of 2009-10, Fifth Extraordinary Session, establishes the Academic Content Standards Commission to develop academic content standards in language arts and math and to present recommended academic content standards to the SBE by July 15, 2010. SB 1 X5 (Steinberg) requires that at least 85% of these standards be comprised of the common core academic standards developed by the CCSSIC or any associated or related interstate collaboration to jointly develop common high-quality standards or assessments aligned with the common set of standards, and requires the SBE to adopt or reject the recommended standards by August 2, 2010. Additionally, the SPI and SBE are required to present to the Governor and to the appropriate policy and fiscal committees of the Legislature a schedule and implementation plan for integrating the revised adopted academic content standards into the state educational system. According the CDE, a plan will be submitted to the Legislature, if and when the common core state standards in math and ELA are adopted. In March of this year, the draft common core state standards in ELA and math for K-12 were released for public comment. The draft ELA standards set requirements for ELA but also for reading, writing, speaking, listening and language in history, social studies and science. However, supporters of history-social science and science would argue that important literature is left out of the history-social studies and science exemplars in the draft ELA standards and that it is important to have common core state standards in social studies and science in preparing all students for college and careers. According to the NGA and the CCSSO, "These English language arts and mathematics standards represent a set of expectations for student knowledge and skills that will result in high school graduates who are prepared for success in college and careers." Furthermore, the NGA and the CCSSO note that the standards are research and evidence based, aligned with college and work expectations, rigorous, and internationally benchmarked. AJR 39 Page 4 According to the NGA and the CCSSO, the final common core state standards are expected to be finalized in late spring of this year. This resolution calls on the NGA and the CCSSO to replicate the process used to develop ELA and math standards to also develop common core state standards for social studies and science. The existing work of the CCSSIC, similar to our assessment and accountability system, has focused solely on reading and math. This heavy emphasis on these two subjects has often led to a reduced focus on equally important subjects such as science, foreign languages, civics and government, economics, arts, history, and geography, which the federal No Child Left Behind Act (NCLB) considers "core academic subjects." This resolution seeks to ensure that efforts to create common core state standards take into account subjects other than reading and math and calls on the NGO and the CCSSO to develop common core state standards in social science and science and it further calls on these organizations to examine the viability of developing common core state standards in foreign language, the arts, physical education and CTE. This resolution emphasizes the importance of each of these subjects in ensuring pupils have access to a comprehensive and well-rounded curriculum. Information on the CCSSIC Internet Web site stipulates that, "English-language arts and math were the first subjects chosen for the common core state standards because these two subjects are skills, upon which students build skill sets in other subject areas. They are also the subjects most frequently assessed for accountability purposes." Information on the Web site further points out, "Of course, other subject areas are critical to young people's education and their success in college and careers. Once the English-language arts and math standards are developed, CCSSO and NGA Center, on behalf of the states, plan to develop a common core of standards in science and potentially additional subject areas." No further information is available regarding a specific plan for the development of common core state standards in science or social studies as part of the CCSSIC. History-social science or social studies : This resolution makes inconsistent references to social studies as an academic subject. One paragraph of the resolution refers to this subject as "history-social science" and a separate paragraph as "social studies." While in California, this subject is referred to as AJR 39 Page 5 history-social science for purposes of curriculum, at the national level, the more common term appears to be social studies as it is argued that this term encompasses all disciplines including history, civics, government and geography, without singling one discipline over another. However, there appears to be disagreement amongst the social studies community on using a consistent term of reference and therefore this resolution purposely uses both terms. The author states, "Each new generation of students needs to be equipped with the knowledge of mathematics, English-language arts, history, geography, economics and government, skills needed to make informed decisions about complex public issues, attitudes that support democratic practices, commitment to engage in civic life, a strong understanding of the physical world, including biology, chemistry, geology, astronomy and physics, and a firm grasp of the scientific method of discovery." Arguments in support : One of the co-sponsors of this resolution, the California Science Teachers Association writes, "Having a common set of standards is seen as important in the education of America's students and in their preparation for college and careers. We believe that, like language arts and mathematics, social studies and science are integral to the preparation of students for success in college and the workforce. Through AJR 39, we, therefore, are urging that NGA and CCSSO develop common core standards for science and social studies." Previous legislation: SB 1 X5 (Steinberg), Chapter 2, Statutes of 2009-10, Fifth Extraordinary Session, proposes comprehensive changes to the Education Code consistent with the federal RTTT program. Establishes the Academic Content Standards Commission to develop academic content standards in language arts and mathematics and present recommended academic content standards to the SBE by July 15, 2010 and requires the SBE to adopt or reject the recommended standards by August 2, 2010. Requires the SPI and the SBE to present to the Governor and to the appropriate policy and fiscal committees of the Legislature a schedule and implementation plan for integrating the revised adopted academic content standards into the state educational system. REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION : AJR 39 Page 6 Support California Council for the Social Studies (Co-sponsor) California Science Teachers Association (Co-sponsor) California Language Teachers Association Educating for Democracy, the California Campaign for the Civic Mission of Schools Individuals Opposition None on file. Analysis Prepared by : Marisol Avi?a / ED. / (916) 319-2087