BILL ANALYSIS ------------------------------------------------------------ |SENATE RULES COMMITTEE | AB 142| |Office of Senate Floor Analyses | | |1020 N Street, Suite 524 | | |(916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) | | |327-4478 | | ------------------------------------------------------------ THIRD READING Bill No: AB 142 Author: Hayashi (D), et al Amended: 3/11/10 in Senate Vote: 27 - Urgency SENATE GOVERNMENTAL ORG. COMMITTEE : 9-0, 2/23/10 AYES: Wright, Harman, Calderon, Florez, Negrete McLeod, Oropeza, Padilla, Price, Yee NO VOTE RECORDED: Denham, Wyland SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE : 9-0, 3/15/10 AYES: Kehoe, Cox, Alquist, Corbett, Denham, Leno, Liu, Price, Wyland NO VOTE RECORDED: Walters, Yee ASSEMBLY FLOOR : Not relevant SUBJECT : California State Lottery SOURCE : Author DIGEST : This bill modifies the allocation formula of revenue generated from the California State Lottery, and contains language to require the repeal of the modified formula if the Controller determines that the revenue allocated to benefit public education is less than a specified amount. ANALYSIS : The California State Lottery Act of 1984, enacted by initiative, authorizes a California State CONTINUED AB 142 Page 2 Lottery and provides for its operation and administration by the California State Lottery Commission (Commission) and the Director of the California State Lottery, with certain limitations. The Act requires that: 1. Not less than 84 percent of the total annual revenues from the sale of state lottery tickets or shares be returned to the public in the form of prizes and net revenues to benefit public education, and that no more than 16 percent of those revenues be used for expenses of the lottery. 2. All unclaimed prize money revert to the benefit of public education, and that all of the interest earned upon funds held in the State Lottery Fund be allocated to the benefit of public education. 3. Fifty percent of the total annual lottery revenues be returned to the public in the form of prizes, and that 34 percent of those revenues be used to benefit public education. 4. Beginning in the 1998-99 fiscal year, 50 percent of any increase above the amount allocated to education for the 1997-98 fiscal year shall be allocated to school districts and community college districts for the purchase of instructional materials, as specified. 5. To the extent that expenses of the lottery are less than 16 percent of the total annual revenues, any surplus funds be allocated to the benefit of public education. 6. None of its provisions may be changed except to further its purpose by a bill passed by a 2/3 vote of each house of the Legislature and signed by the Governor. This bill: 1. Amends Section 8880.4 of the Government Code to require the total revenues of the lottery to be allotted so as to maximize the amount of funding allocated to public education, as follows: AB 142 Page 3 A. Not less than 87 percent (an increase of three percent from current law) of the amount of the total revenues shall be returned to the public as follows: (1) Not less than 50 percent of the total revenues shall be returned to the public in the form of prizes, as determined by the Commission. Repeals the requirement that a fixed 50 percent of the total annual revenues shall to be returned to the public in prizes. (2) The percentage of the total revenues to be allocated for public education shall be established by the Commission at a level designed to maximize the total net revenues for public education. Repeals the requirement that at least 34 percent of the total annual revenues are to be allocated to the benefit of public education. B. No more than 13 percent (a decrease of three percent from current law) of the total revenues shall be allocated for the payment of expenses of the Lottery. 2. Adds Section 8880.4.5. to require: A. The Lottery, following the end of each full fiscal year, to calculate and report to the Controller and to the Legislature the amount of total net revenues allocated to the benefit of public education from the California State Lottery Education Fund for that fiscal year. B. The Controller, no later than September 1 of each of the first five full fiscal years in which the changes by this bill are in effect, to determine if either of the following have occurred: (1) The total net revenues allocated to AB 142 Page 4 the benefit of public education by the Lottery are less than the total net revenues allocated to the benefit of public education by the Lottery in the last full fiscal year prior to enactment of this bill. (2) The annual average of total net revenues allocated to the benefit of public education from the Lottery after enactment of this bill is less than the total net revenues allocated to the benefit of public education by the Lottery in the last full fiscal year prior to enactment of this bill, adjusted for an annual growth rate of 1.8 percent or the actual growth rate of lottery revenues since enactment of the bill, whichever is greater. C. If both 2(b)(i) and 2(b)(ii) occur within the first five full fiscal years in which the changes by this bill are in effect, then: (1) The Controller shall notify the Legislature and Governor of his or her determination and report his or her findings on the Controller's Internet Web site. (2) The changes to the Lottery Act made by this bill shall become inoperative and the language in the Act as it existed immediately prior to enactment of the bill shall become operative. 3. Requires the Controller, at the end of the first five full fiscal years following enactment of this bill, to convene a lottery review group consisting of the Superintendent of Public Instruction and the Chairperson of the Commission to report to the Legislature, no later than December 31 following the final fiscal year, on whether the amendments made by this bill have furthered the purposes of the Lottery Act, as intended. 4. Makes other technical and conforming changes. 5. Declares that the bill furthers the purpose of the Act. AB 142 Page 5 Comments This bill requires the State Controller to review the amount of revenue that gets allocated to public education at the end of each year for five years, and then repeals the modified allocation formula in this bill if in any of those five years the Controller determines that the revenue to public education fell short of the amount allocated in the last full fiscal year prior to the enactment of this bill (presumably FY 2008-09). Consequently, this bill does leave the allocation to public education vulnerable for one year in the event that a determination is made that funding provided to schools was less than the amount in FY 2008-09 - $1,048,694,000. However, if the modification of the allocation formula does result in additional lottery sales as the Lottery Commission believes, there could be a significant increase in the amount of funding that is allocated to the benefit of public education. The Lottery currently generates total sales revenue of approximately $2.96 billion annually, with over $1 billion allocated to the benefit of public education. The intent of this bill is to allocate more money to prizes which in turn is expected to generate an increase in total sales revenue, allowing for an increase in the current level of funding allocated to public education. However, the exact impact of these changes will be a result of allocation strategies of the Lottery Commission, incentives to retailers, and other marketing events, all of which may ultimately influence the consumers' behavior on lottery spending. FISCAL EFFECT : Appropriation: Yes Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No Fiscal Impact (in thousands) Major Provisions 2010-11 2011-12 2012-13 Fund Controller: review/report minor, absorbable General Funding for public educationpotential for unknown increase in revenue possibly multi-million AB 142 Page 6 Special* potential for unknown one-time decrease in revenue Special* *State Lottery Education Fund SUPPORT : (Verified 3/16/10) Superintendent of Public Instruction Jack O'Connell Association for California State Supervisors California Independent Grocers Association California PTA California Retailers Association GTECH Service Employees International Union ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT : According to GTECH Corporation which has served as the technology and services partner for the California State Lottery for the past 25 years: "This legislation would eliminate outdated rules that prevent the California Lottery from maximizing payments to schools. As a result of the outdated operating rules, the California Lottery currently has the lowest per capita sales, the lowest per capita net transfers to beneficiaries (public schools), and the lowest prize percentage payout of the 10 most populous lottery states. "These proposed reforms would bring the California Lottery in line with the best performing lotteries. Out of 44 lotteries in the United States, California is in the bottom five in terms of Scratchers prize payouts at 58%. The best performing lotteries have prize payouts between 65% and 70%. Massachusetts has the highest per capita return to beneficiaries and the highest Scratchers prize payout at 76%. The formula is simple - higher prize payouts equal more sales and more net revenue. Virtually every U.S. lottery has implemented higher prize payouts in their Scratchers-type games and, every time without exception, raising the payout has increased sales and profits returned to beneficiaries. If the prize payout restrictions were amended for the California Lottery, when the changes are fully implemented, a profit forecast predicts the Lottery AB 142 Page 7 would increase annual profit by $400 million, bringing total lottery profits for public education to $1.5 billion annually." Other proponents contend that the changes to the California State Lottery Act proposed by this bill has the potential to increase revenue available for our schools, and also has provisions that protect the current amount of funding for education in the event revenues are less than anticipated. TSM:nl 3/17/10 Senate Floor Analyses SUPPORT/OPPOSITION: SEE ABOVE **** END ****