BILL ANALYSIS AB 1708 Page 1 Date of Hearing: April 7, 2010 ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON INSURANCE Jose Solorio, Chair AB 1708 (Villines) - As Amended: April 5, 2010 SUBJECT : Surplus Lines Insurers: Capital and Surplus SUMMARY : Increases the capital and surplus requirements for nonadmitted insurers to be placed on the list of eligible surplus lines insurers from $15 million to $45 million. Specifically, this bill : 1)Raises the minimum capital and surplus requirements for nonadmitted insurers to be placed on the List of Eligible Surplus Lines Insurers (LESLI) from $15 million to $45 million. 2)Increases from $15 million to $25 million the amount of this capital and surplus that must be in cash or liquid securities. 3)Provides that any nonadmitted insurer already on the LESLI list that does not currently meet the new capital and surplus requirements is entitled to a phase-in as follows: a) by December 31, 2011, capital and surplus must total $30 million; and b) by December 31, 2012, capital and surplus must total $45 million. EXISTING LAW : 1)Requires insurers that "transact" insurance in California to be "admitted" to transact in the state. "Admitted" is the Insurance Code terminology for being licensed to transact insurance in this state. 2)Authorizes "nonadmitted" insurers to sell insurance to Californians on a limited basis, through specially licensed "surplus lines brokers." 3)Provides broadly that nonadmitted insurers may sell insurance to Californians when the insurance is needed by the policyholder, but generally not available from admitted AB 1708 Page 2 insurers. 4)Requires that, before selling insurance on a nonadmitted basis in California, the nonadmitted insurer must apply to be placed on the LESLI list, and the Insurance Commissioner (IC) must approve the application based on statutory criteria before placing the nonadmitted insurer on the list. 5)Prohibits in virtually all circumstances a nonadmitted insurer from selling insurance in California except though a surplus lines broker, who reaches out and places the California insurance with the nonadmitted insurer outside of the state. In this sense, the nonadmitted insurer is not "transacting" insurance in California. 6)Places a series of duties on the surplus lines broker to ensure that these requirements are met. 7)Recognizes the role of the Surplus Lines Association (SLA), a nongovernmental entity, as an administrative agent of the IC for carrying out certain functions, including a role in tax collection and a role in pre-screening applicants for placement on the LESLI list. 8)Establishes the California Insurance Guarantee Association (CIGA) as essentially the guarantor for the payment of covered claims in the event an admitted insurer becomes insolvent. There is no comparable entity for nonadmitted insurers. FISCAL EFFECT : Undetermined minor administrative costs on the Department of Insurance (DOI). The bill is not tagged fiscal. COMMENTS : 1)Purpose . According to the author, and the sponsor, the DOI, the current capital and surplus requirements are over 15 years old, and experience has taught that levels much higher than current requirements are necessary for security in our current volatile economic times. The sponsor points out that 80% of the insurers currently on the LESLI list, accounting for over 90% of the premium written by nonadmitted insurers, already meet or exceed the bill's proposed capital and surplus requirements. From this fact, DOI argues that the market has already spoken, and that capitalization at the levels proposed by the bill are consistent with what the market has determined AB 1708 Page 3 is necessary to protect solvency and the interests of policyholders and claimants. 2)Background . In the 1980s and early 1990s, the surplus lines market was far less regulated than it is today. As a result, extremely poorly capitalized insurers would start writing business to unsuspecting consumers, and all too frequently these insurers would default on their obligations. The automobile insurance crisis was at the point where hundreds of thousands of Californians were purchasing basic automobile insurance from nonadmitted insurers. At that time, the law did not require nonadmitted insurers to apply for and be placed on an eligibility list. Indeed, there were not even financial filing requirements. The DOI attempted to deal with this problem by adopting a regulation that mandated a contemporaneous financial filing at the time when a nonadmitted insurer first sold a policy to a Californian. However, even this approach proved inadequate, as the courts made it extremely difficult for DOI to shut down financially unsound nonadmitted insurers, because these insurers had established a "property right" in the business that they were conducting. The Legislature responded to this problem by enacting laws that in most circumstances prohibit private passenger automobile insurance to be sold by nonadmitted insurers, and by creating the LESLI list to ensure no nonadmitted insurer could establish the foothold "property interest" unless the IC had affirmatively approved the nonadmitted insurer's status as financially sound. 3)Support . In support of this proposal, DOI argues that with the continuing defaults in loans, many of which support securities that insurers invest in, it is only prudent to ensure that the nonadmitted insurers whose policies are not backed by a guarantee association are financially stable. DOI notes that New York, the no. 1 state in nonadmitted premium volume (Florida is currently no. 2, and California is no. 3) has already implemented, and is currently adopting formally by regulation, the $45 million capital and surplus rule. This is further evidence of the consensus within the nonadmitted community - insurers and regulators alike - that increasing the capital and surplus requirements for nonadmitted insurers is appropriate. AB 1708 Page 4 The SLA, the California Insurance Wholesalers Association (CIWA), and the Insurance Brokers and Agents of the West (IBA West) all write in support of this proposal, making arguments similar to the points made by the DOI. The SLA, as mentioned above, is a private entity that carries out public functions as an agent of the IC. CIWA is an association of surplus lines brokers, and IBA West includes among its insurance agent and broker members individuals and firms licensed as surplus lines brokers. In the view of these organizations, the bill is necessary to protect the interests of the policyholders - their customers - to whom they are selling surplus lines insurance. REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION : Support Department of Insurance Surplus Lines Association of California California Insurance Wholesalers Association Insurance Agents and Brokers of the West Opposition None received. Analysis Prepared by : Mark Rakich / INS. / (916) 319-2086