BILL ANALYSIS Senate Committee on Labor and Industrial Relations Mark DeSaulnier, Chair Date of Hearing: June 23, 2010 2009-2010 Regular Session Consultant: Alma Perez Fiscal:Yes Urgency: No Bill No: AB 2058 Author: Block Version: As amended June 21, 2010 SUBJECT Unemployment insurance: retraining benefits KEY ISSUES Should the Legislature require that an unemployed individual who is receiving Unemployment Insurance (UI) benefits be automatically eligible to receive California Training Benefits while in full-time training? Should an unemployed individual receiving UI benefits through a federal extension be allowed to continue receiving benefits if he/she is enrolled in a community college or other accredited postsecondary education program? Should the Legislature require that the Employment Development Department prepare a report evaluating the effectiveness of the California Training Benefits Program? PURPOSE To modify current eligibility requirements necessary for an unemployed individual to be approved to participate in the California Training Benefits program. ANALYSIS Existing law provides for the payment of unemployment compensation benefits through the Unemployment Insurance (UI) program, administered by the Employment Development Department (EDD). The UI program is a federal-state program that provides weekly unemployment insurance payments to eligible workers who lose their jobs through no fault of their own. Existing law authorizes an unemployed individual who files a claim for unemployment compensation benefits or extended duration benefits, to apply to the EDD for a determination of potential eligibility for benefits during a period of training or retraining through the California Training Benefit (CTB) program. The CTB program allows eligible UI claimants to receive their UI benefits while attending a training or retraining program approved by EDD. Claimants attending an approved training course are not required to look for work, be available for work or accept work while in training. EDD is required to inform, either verbally or in written form, all UI claimants of the retraining benefits. Under the required application process , the EDD schedules a phone interview with the applicant to determine his/her eligibility for CTB after the training has begun. The EDD is prohibited from pre-determining CTB eligibility until the individual has started to attend school or training. Existing law requires EDD to issue a determination of potential eligibility for retraining benefits to an unemployed individual if the EDD Director finds that the training is authorized by the following government programs: Workforce Investment Act (WIA); Employment Training Panel (ETP); Trade Adjustment Assistance (TAA); or California Work Opportunity and Responsibility to Kids (CalWORKs) Existing law also allows the approval of other training programs, not authorized by one of the above, that are determined by EDD to be eligible. Among other things, the training must be: Full-time and must be completed in one year from the beginning date of CTB approval, even if the UI benefits expire before the conclusion of the training. Hearing Date: June 23, 2010 AB 2058 Consultant: Alma Perez Page 2 Senate Committee on Labor and Industrial Relations Related to an occupation or skill for which there are, or are expected to be, reasonable employment opportunities in the labor market area in this state. If the person is a journey level union member, the training course of instruction must be job-related and necessary due to changes in technology, or necessary to retain employment or to become more competitive in obtaining employment. Existing law provides that a UI benefits recipient, who applies for retraining benefits no later than the 16th week of receiving UI benefits, and is determined eligible for the retraining benefits shall be entitled to a training extension on his or her UI claim to complete the approved training. Benefits paid under a training extension are charged to the employer reserve accounts. This Bill would modify the requirement for participation in the state's retraining benefits program in order to allow unemployed individuals to receive Unemployment Insurance (UI) benefits while enrolled in a training program on a full-time basis. Specifically, this bill: 1. Establishes the California Training Benefits (CTB) Program in code and declares the policy of this state to assist individuals with UI benefits if these individuals need training or retraining to upgrade their skills in demand occupations to become competitive in the labor market. 2. Provides that UI benefits shall not be denied to an otherwise qualified unemployed individual because he or she is participating in eligible training or retraining. 3. Would revise current eligibility requirements to specify that an unemployed individual, who qualifies for UI benefits (and subsequent state or federal extensions) and applies for the CTB program, shall be deemed to be automatically eligible for the program during a period of training or retraining. Hearing Date: June 23, 2010 AB 2058 Consultant: Alma Perez Page 3 Senate Committee on Labor and Industrial Relations 4. Requires that a determination of automatic eligibility for benefits be issued to an unemployed individual if the director of EDD finds that: a. The training is authorized by the federal Workforce Investment Act (WIA), the state Employment Training Panel (ETP), the federal Trade Adjustment Assistance (TAA) as amended, or the California Work Opportunity and Responsibility to Kids (CalWORKs). b. The individual is a participant in training with a provider that is certified and on the state's Eligible Training Provider List (ETPL). c. The individual is a journey level union member in industry-related training necessary to employment. 5. Provides that if training is not automatically authorized under the above provisions, the director of EDD shall issue a determination of potential eligibility for benefits if the director finds that specified criteria apply that includes, among others: a. That the director approved training be completed within a reasonable period of time (current law requires that it be completed within one year). b. If an unemployed individual is eligible for training benefits and when federal extended UI benefits are in effect, the individual can receive benefits if he/she is enrolled in a community college or other accredited postsecondary education program with the purpose of preparing the applicant in academic or job skills that will increase employment opportunities or that leads to an industry-recognized credential or certificate designed for a specific occupation. 6. Allows EDD to inform all UI claimants of the availability of training benefits online (in addition to current laws requirement that it be provided verbally or in written form) and requires that this information be made available on the EDD's Web site in close proximity to Hearing Date: June 23, 2010 AB 2058 Consultant: Alma Perez Page 4 Senate Committee on Labor and Industrial Relations information on UI claim forms. 7. Deletes the requirement that the unemployed individual submit written certification of participation in approved training with each claim, and instead allows EDD to prescribe the required certification through regulations. 8. Requires that EDD, not later than September 1, 2016, prepare and submit to the Governor and the Legislature a report evaluating the effectiveness of the California Training Benefits Program, as specified. COMMENTS 1. Need for this bill? According to EDD, 19,868 individuals were approved to participate in the CTB program in calendar year 2009. Also during 2009, the number of individuals receiving UI benefits each month ranged from 947,753 (January 2009) to a high of over 1.4 million (December 2009). California's unemployment rate is currently at 12.6% and there are over 1.4 million individuals collecting unemployment insurance benefits. Based on this data, EDD estimates that in any given month the number of individuals receiving UI benefits and who are approved to participate in the CTB program ranges from 1.4 percent to 2.0 percent of the total number of individuals receiving UI benefits. Concerns have been raised regarding the delays in the current application and determination process that EDD follows when approving an unemployed individual for CTB benefits. EDD is prohibited from pre-determining CTB eligibility until the individual has started to attend school or training, and thus, if an individual enrolls in a training program that may hinder that person's availability to work, EDD suspends their UI benefits until a telephone interview takes place to confirm eligibility. With this bill, the author seeks to allow unemployed workers receiving UI benefits to automatically continue coverage Hearing Date: June 23, 2010 AB 2058 Consultant: Alma Perez Page 5 Senate Committee on Labor and Industrial Relations through the CTB program while enrolled in an approved training program. This bill would also allow unemployed workers to receive benefits while they are enrolled in community college or other accredited postsecondary education program as long as they are receiving benefits through a federal UI extension. 2. Guidance from the U.S. Department of Labor : This bill affects "retraining benefits" (as phrased in Sections 1266 to 1274.10 of the Unemployment Insurance Code), or the "California Training Benefits Program," as called by EDD on its printed materials and its website. The retraining benefits program allows people receiving UI benefits to participate in approved training programs without actively seeking work. EDD is responsible for determining whether UI recipients are eligible for retraining benefits and may continue to receive UI compensation. In May 2009, the U.S. Department of Labor issued a guidance letter to state agencies that administer the UI Program. Specifically, Training and Employment Guidance Letter No. 21-08 encourages states to widen the types of training and the conditions under which education and training are considered "approved training" for purposes of the state's UI law. States are also asked to reconsider their laws and regulations, and applicable administrative requirements, to determine if their approved training requirements are appropriate to the current economy. That guidance letter strongly encourages states to broaden their definition of approved training for UI beneficiaries during economic downturns. Currently, until a determination of eligibility for retraining benefits is complete, EDD will suspend the UI benefits. As a result, many Californians decide to drop out of the job training to preserve their eligibility for UI benefits. This is contrary to the direction of the federal Department of Labor which has been strongly encouraging states to streamline their administrative procedures and laws, if necessary, to assist unemployed people to regain competitive job skills for the current economy. Hearing Date: June 23, 2010 AB 2058 Consultant: Alma Perez Page 6 Senate Committee on Labor and Industrial Relations 3. EDD's CTB Streamline Approval Project : EDD has been working to develop a process that will streamline and expedite the approval process for the CTB program once UI claimants have actually begun training. EDD's CTB streamline solution seeks to eliminate the need for UI claimants attending training to wait for a telephone interview to receive approval for CTB because eligibility can be determined as soon as EDD receives training verification from the program authorizing training or the training provider. The solution will allow for the agencies to submit via fax the training information necessary to confirm enrollment in an authorized training program. For the authorizing programs and training providers, the streamline solution will also reduce disruptions by eliminating the need for EDD staff to call these entities to gather and verify the training information necessary for CTB approvals. The CTB Streamline solution is planned for release in two phases. The first phase will focus on claimants whose training is authorized under certain federal or State programs under California UI law, including training under the Workforce Investment Act (WIA), the Federal Trade Adjustment Assistance (TAA), the State Employment Training Panel (ETP), and the State California Work Opportunity and Responsibility to Kids (CalWORKs). Phase II will include all other UI claimants attending full-time school or training outside of the designated federal and State programs and whose CTB eligibility is dependent on meeting additional specific criteria required by UI law for CTB approval. In March 2010, EDD began implementation of Phase I by streamlining the approval process for claimants whose training is authorized under the WIA. EDD is next working towards implement the streamline approval project for TAA, ETP and CalWORKSs authorized trainings. 4. Proponent Arguments : Hearing Date: June 23, 2010 AB 2058 Consultant: Alma Perez Page 7 Senate Committee on Labor and Industrial Relations According to proponents, California is facing a job loss crisis with unemployment at historic highs of 12.6% in May 2010, and to make matters worse, job seekers are spending longer periods of time looking for work. Over 34% of the unemployed have been looking for work for over 6 months, up 170.5% since 2008. The author believes that today's unpredictable economic climate demands that we have a modernized system capable of providing unemployed Californians with the training they need to once again contribute to our economy. In addition, proponents argue that we must break down barriers preventing laid-off workers from participating in training and skill development that makes them competitive for jobs as our economy recovers. Proponents believe that this bill will make it easier for unemployed Californians to access unemployment benefits while enrolled in training programs to upgrade job skills. This bill will also revise the Unemployment Insurance Code to conform to federal guidance. Proponents believe that automatically approving UI recipients for training programs will allow the unemployed to register and attend training without fear of an interruption or possible loss of their benefits. In addition, proponents argue that automatic enrollment into pre-approved training programs will streamline the approval process and save EDD significant resources and staff time. Overall, proponents argue that helping the unemployed access retraining will greatly benefit our local state economy, and will lure more companies to do business in our state and hire skilled and educated California workers. 5. Opponent Arguments : According to opponents, although they support benefits being paid timely to individuals enrolled in training with a connection to employment upon completion, they are opposed to this bill because it would expand and increase the payment of training and/or retraining UI benefits. Opponents argue that already current law allows unemployed workers receiving UI benefits to continue their coverage while enrolled in specified training or retraining as approved by the Director of EDD. They feel that by establishing a general broad Hearing Date: June 23, 2010 AB 2058 Consultant: Alma Perez Page 8 Senate Committee on Labor and Industrial Relations threshold, this bill could open the door to not only fraud and abuse, but also establishes a very different public policy. Opponents contend that in its October "Unemployment Insurance Fund Forecast," EDD projected that the state's UI Fund balance would have a deficit of $7.4 billion at the end of 2009. They believe that it is inappropriate to expand the payment of UI benefits a time when the UI Fund is depleted and California is compelled to borrow from the Federal Government in order to pay UI benefits. Opponents argue that this is not the time to incur still higher UI costs by expanding available training benefits. Furthermore, opponents argue that this bill allows individuals that are unemployed to take this opportunity to use their unemployment benefits to make lifestyle changes beyond those required for re-employment, regardless of real employment opportunities. Opponents believe that job training benefits should be targeted to the needs of the job market and the individual, not unilaterally provided without qualification and without specific nexus to employment. 6. Related Legislation : SB 968 (Negrete McLeod) of 2010: Currently in Assembly Insurance Committee SB 968 is similar to this bill; however, SB 968 does not deem an unemployed individual automatically eligible for training benefits. SB 968 would delete the provision of existing law that requires the determination of potential eligibility and instead, specifies that an unemployed person who is able to work is eligible to receive training and retraining benefits if he/she certifies on the UI claim form that he/she is enrolled in a training program and lists a responsible person connected with the program that certifies that the person is enrolled and satisfactorily pursuing the program. SUPPORT California Labor Federation - Co-Sponsor California Workforce Association - Co-Sponsor American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, Hearing Date: June 23, 2010 AB 2058 Consultant: Alma Perez Page 9 Senate Committee on Labor and Industrial Relations AFL-CIO California Nurses Association/National Nurses Organizing Committee California Professional Firefighters (CPF) Council of California Goodwill Industries National Association of Workforce Boards (NAWB) OPPOSITION California Chamber of Commerce California Department of Finance California Hospital Association California Manufacturers and Technology Association * * * Hearing Date: June 23, 2010 AB 2058 Consultant: Alma Perez Page 10 Senate Committee on Labor and Industrial Relations