BILL ANALYSIS AB 2336 Page 1 Date of Hearing: March 23, 2010 ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON WATER, PARKS AND WILDLIFE Jared William Huffman, Chair AB 2336 (Fuller) - As Introduced: February 19, 2010 SUBJECT : Delta Stewardship Council: Striped Bass SUMMARY : States Legislative findings and intent regarding striped bass, and requires the Delta Stewardship Council (DSC) to assess the adverse impacts of invasive species predation on native species, to evaluate predator suppression options, and to recommend changes in laws and actions by state agencies. Specifically, this bill : 1)Makes Legislative findings and declarations regarding striped bass, including that striped bass are harmful and highly invasive species that are not native to this state, the history of striped bass introduction in California, past population levels of striped bass in the Delta, and the predatory habits of striped bass. 2)States Legislative intent that in order to preserve native fish populations in the San Francisco Bay and the Delta the DSC include in the Delta Plan programs to discourage promotion of the Bay and Delta as a striped bass sport fishery, and to eliminate all existing programs and legal protections for striped bass. 3)Requires the DSC in developing the Delta Plan, to assess the adverse impacts of invasive species predation on native species, to evaluate predator suppression options in areas of the Delta that evidence the highest levels of predation, and to recommend changes in law and actions by state agencies to remedy the situation in as timely a manner as is practicable. EXISTING LAW : 1)Establishes the DSC, the initial members of which are to be appointed by July 1, 2010. Requires the DSC to develop and adopt a Delta Plan by January 1, 2012 that furthers the coequal goals of ecosystem restoration and water supply reliability. AB 2336 Page 2 2)SBX7 1, part of the water package enacted last year, requires DSC in developing the Delta Plan to include, among other things, sub-goals and strategies to promote self-sustaining populations of native and valued species by reducing risk of take and harm from invasive species, and by improving water quality. SBX7 1 also requires DSC in developing the Delta Plan, to consider each of the strategies and actions in the Delta Strategic Plan. The Delta Strategic Plan, among other things, recommends actions to control invasive species, to re-evaluate wastewater treatment plant discharges, to regulate discharges from irrigated lands, and to reduce impacts from urban runoff. 3)Establishes the Delta Independent Science Board which shall provide oversight of the scientific research, monitoring, and assessment programs that support adaptive management of the Delta. 4)Allows monies in the Bay-Delta Sportfishing Enhancement Stamp fund to be used for the benefit of Bay-Delta sport fisheries, including but not limited to striped bass, sturgeon, black bass, halibut, salmon, surf perch, steelhead trout, and American shad. Requires that the funds be expended consistent with requirements of state and federal endangered species acts and the ecosystem restoration component of CALFED. 5)Prohibits striped bass from being transported or carried out of or into California except striped bass taken from the Colorado River by sportfishing licensees. Allows striped bass legally taken in another state that permits the sale of striped bass to be imported into the state subject to Fish and Game Commission (FGC) regulations. 6)Prohibits striped bass from being possessed aboard a commercial fishing vessel, or by a commercial fisherman, and prohibits striped bass from being taken by any kind of net. Allows striped bass to be sold or offered for sale only by an aquaculturalist, or if it was taken legally in another state. 7)The FGC by regulation sets seasons, bag limits and size limits for take of striped bass. Current regulations establish a statewide limit of 2 fish, 18 inches minimum in length, except in the Colorado River District, the Southern District and certain lakes, where the limit is 10 fish with no minimum size restriction. AB 2336 Page 3 FISCAL EFFECT : Unknown COMMENTS : This bill makes Legislative findings that striped bass are a harmful and highly invasive species, states Legislative intent that promotion of the San Francisco Bay and Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta as a striped bass sport fishery be discouraged and all legal restrictions on take of striped bass be removed, and directs the DSC, in developing the Delta Plan, to assess the adverse impacts of invasive species predation on native species and make recommendations to address those impacts. The sponsors of this bill assert that striped bass have become a harmful and invasive species, and are a major cause of the decline of native species, including endangered or threatened salmon, steelhead and Delta smelt. They believe that having the DSC evaluate predator suppression options and recommend actions to reduce predation will help to address water supply management and ecosystem restoration in the Delta. While they acknowledge that striped bass predation is not the only cause of native fish declines, they assert that too much emphasis is being placed on water exports as the source of the problems, and not enough on predation by these introduced species. Striped bass, which are native to the east coast, were introduced into the Delta in 1879, and have been managed as a game fish in California for the past 100 years. Striped bass are a prized sport fish, supporting a valued and economically important sport fishery in California, and have made the Delta a world class destination for striped bass fishing. According to the Department of Fish and Game's (DFG's) website, over 300,000 anglers fish for striped bass each year in the Delta, annually catching over 200,000 fish, and spending $24 million for goods and services directly connected with striped bass. In the1990s DFG stocked large numbers of striped bass, which reached a record low adult population in 1994. The federal Central Valley Project Improvement Act (CVPIA) calls for a doubling of both salmon and striped bass populations. DFG received a permit from the federal government to stock striped bass in the 1990s, but stopped stocking striped bass around 2000, when the population reached an abundance of 1.5 million adults. At that time, federal biologists estimated that about 1 percent of migrating salmon and smaller numbers of Delta smelt would be impacted by the stocking and required that stocking be stopped if the population estimate exceeded 950,000. AB 2336 Page 4 Since 2000 the striped bass population in the Delta has been in decline. The most recent population numbers available on DFG's website estimate adult striped bass abundance in the estuary at approximately 800,000. Since 2000 the number of juvenile striped bass produced in the Delta have been at record lows. Striped bass were included in the CALFED pelagic organism decline (POD) project, along with Delta Smelt, Longfin Smelt, and Threadfin Shad, as conditions in the Delta are negatively impacting all four species. According to the 2007 POD Progress Report, trawl indices showed abundance of all four species began to decline sharply in 2000. Abundance indices for 2002-2006 show record lows for juvenile smelt and striped bass. Several studies on striped bass were summarized in the committee analysis on AB 1253 (Fuller), a related bill heard by this committee in 2009. In general, the studies showed that while it is clear striped bass are apex predators that feed on other small fish, including salmon and juvenile steelhead, and have been identified as one of several stressors on these populations, the studies were not conclusive as to whether striped bass predation is having a population level effect on these species. Given the complexity of the food web and predator prey relationships, it was also unclear what the effects of different predator control actions might be. For instance, several fishery scientists opined that for a predator control program to have a chance of being effective it would necessarily have to focus on multiple species, since striped bass also feed on other fish that in turn prey on salmon or compete with them for food. In addition, several studies noted that artificially created structures, like Clifton Court Forebay and the Red Bluff Diversion Dam, create special problems by attracting predators, and that both pumping operations and current mitigation protocols contribute to conditions that make fish particularly vulnerable to predation. (See the analysis on AB 1253 for a more in depth review of various prior studies.) The committee should be aware there are several other processes currently ongoing where the impacts of invasive species, as one of the other stressors on native fish in the Delta, are being analyzed, including the following: National Academy of Sciences (NAS) : The NAS's recently released report on alternatives for reducing water management effects on threatened and endangered fishes in the Delta included a section AB 2336 Page 5 on other stressors, including invasive species. The report notes that multiple other stressors affecting fish in the Delta need to be considered, as well as their comparative importance with respect to the effects of export pumping. Given the time constraints, the NAS indicated they will be conducting further study on these other stressors, which will be described in further detail in a second NAS report to be released next year. The NAS report does point out that a holistic approach to managing the ecology of imperiled fishes will be required if species declines are to be reversed. With regard to introduced fishes, the NAS notes the Delta is a substantially altered ecosystem, and that some of these changes likely enhance spread of nonnative species. The report notes that striped bass and Sacramento pikeminnow prey on juvenile Chinook salmon, especially where they congregate below Red Bluff Diversion Dam and other structures, and at the Suisun Marsh salinity control gates, where they are the predominant predators of juvenile Chinook salmon. The report also notes that other introduced species may be even more threatening to native species, for example, silverside, which likely prey on juvenile Delta smelt or compete for similar copepod prey, largemouth bass, catfish, and other species of introduced smelt such as the wakasagi. The report notes that Delta smelt have co-existed with these non-native fish for over 100 years before the recent declines, and so the decline of smelt cannot be attributed entirely to their presence. Nevertheless, some other predator species have increased recently (though not striped bass), and their effects on salmonids and the potential for smelt populations to recover have not been well studied. The report is consistent with other studies showing there is a complex and largely unknown relationship between non-native predatory fish species and their population level impacts on native species, and that, more scientific analysis is to be conducted. Bay Delta Conservation Plan (BDCP) : The BDCP steering committee's list of proposed Other Stressor Conservation Measures includes measures to reduce the effects of predators on covered fish species by conducting localized predator control of high predator density locations. The report also calls for research on increasing the harvest of non-native predatory fish to decrease their abundance. Fish and Game Commission (FGC) : The FGC at their February AB 2336 Page 6 meeting agreed to consider a regulatory action to relax the bag limit and other restrictions on take of striped bass to allow increased harvest. FGC staff was directed to prepare an evaluation of the proposal which was scheduled for further consideration on the FGC's April and May meeting agendas. Pending Litigation : The committee should be aware that the issues raised by this bill are also the subject of a lawsuit that is currently pending in federal court before Judge Wanger. A trial date has been set in the case for June 22, 2010. SBX7 1 (Simitian) (Chapter 5, Statutes of 2009) : The Delta governance legislation enacted last year requires that the Delta Plan to be developed by the DSC include measures that promote characteristics of a healthy ecosystem, including, among other things, viable populations of native resident and migratory fish species, reduced threats and stresses on the Delta ecosystem, and conditions conducive to species recovery plans and meeting federal salmon doubling goals. In addition, the plan is required to include measures to promote a more reliable water supply that, among other things, meet the needs for reasonable and beneficial uses of water and improve water quality. SBX7 1 also requires the plan to include certain sub goals and strategies, including measures to promote self-sustaining populations of native and valued species by reducing risk of take and harm from invasive species, and by improving water quality. SBX7 1 also requires DSC in developing the Delta Plan to consider each of the strategies and actions in the Administration's Delta Strategic Plan. The Delta Strategic Plan contains several strategies related to other stressors. For example, the Plan recommends actions to control invasive species at existing locations and in new restoration areas, to re-evaluate wastewater treatment plant discharges into Delta waterways, to regulate discharges from irrigated lands, and to reduce impacts of urban runoff. Arguments in Support : Supporters assert this bill would ensure a significant Delta stressor, predation on native species, would be adequately considered in the Delta Plan development and adoption, as a crucial part of an overall Delta solution. Supporters assert the state has focused on the export pumps for restrictions, but that without acknowledging and eliminating the effects of invasive and predatory species, restrictions at the AB 2336 Page 7 pumps will not restore the populations of listed fish species. The sponsors of this bill assert data on the effects of predation is overwhelming, and that with water shortages, job losses and billions in economic losses, it is crucial that all factors affecting the Delta be addressed. They note DFG estimates striped bass consume 5.3% of the Delta smelt population annually, and 6% of Sacramento winter-run Chinook salmon, and that recent radio tagging surveys on the Sacramento and San Joaquin Rivers show salmon smolt mortality at or above 50% from predator species. They assert all stressors to native Delta species should be fully and independently analyzed, and problems with non-natives assessed now in light of the crisis affecting the state's salmon populations and water supply reductions. Arguments in Opposition : Opponents strongly oppose this bill, particularly Section One, which states Legislative intent to discourage promotion of the Delta as a striped bass fishery, eliminate all programs to improve striped bass, and eliminate all restrictions on take of the species. Opponents assert that although there are currently no active programs to enhance striped bass populations, this statement of intent represents a fundamental shift in state policy away from regulation of striped bass as a game fish. Opponents assert this bill lacks scientific justification, and note the SWRCB science panel, at a March 23, 2010 workshop, identified control of predatory fish as the lowest priority item when compared with other stressors, based on importance and likelihood of having a beneficial effect. Opponents further assert this is a disguised effort to obtain more water for exports by destroying a publicly owned natural resource, when the facts show excessive water exports from the Delta to be the main cause of the collapse of California's anadromous and pelagic fisheries. Opponents argue the issue of striped bass predation should be left to state and federal fishery agencies charged with managing these resources. Some opponents also argue a practicable alternative to this bill would be to screen Clifton Court Forebay as required in the CALFED Record of Decision. REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION : Support Kern County Water District (co-sponsor) Metropolitan Water District of Southern California (co-sponsor) AB 2336 Page 8 Modesto Irrigation District (co-sponsor) San Luis & Delta-Mendota Water Authority (co-sponsor) American Society of Civil Engineers - Region 9 Association of California Water Agencies California Cattlemen's Association California Chamber of Commerce California Citrus Mutual California Cotton Ginners Association California Cotton Growers Association California League of Food Processors California Manufacturers and Technology Association Desert Water Agency Eastern Municipal Water District Friant Water Authority Glenn-Colusa Irrigation District Industrial Environmental Association Northern California Water Association San Diego County Water Authority Turlock Irrigation District Valley Ag Water Coakition Western Agricultural Processors Association Western Growers Association Westlands Water District Several individuals Opposition Allied Fishing Groups Bass Classics of Santa Clara Black Bass Action Committee California Fly Fishers Unlimited California Sportfishing Protection Alliance California Striped Bass Association Chico Flyfishers Coastside Fishing Club Delta Bass Tactics Club Delta Fly Fishers Diablo Valley Fly Fishermen E.C.Powell Fly Fishers Fishery Foundation of CA Eddo's Harbor & RV Park Inc. Fly Fishers for Conservation Fly Fishers of Davis Friends of Butte Creek Gold Country Fly Fishers Golden Gate Angling & Casting Club Golden Gate Fishermen's Association AB 2336 Page 9 Golden West Women Flyfishers Granite Bay Flycasters Grizzly Peak Flyfishers Mission Peak Fly Anglers Monterey Peninsula Flycasters Northern CA Council Federation of Fly Fishers NORCAL Kayak Anglers North Coast Fishermen's Association Pacific Coast Federation of Fishermen's Associations Palo Alto Flyfishers Pasadena Casting Club Peninsula Fly Fishers Recreational Fishing Alliance Salmon Restoration Association San Jose Flycasters Santa Cruz Fly Fishermen Shasta Trinity Fly Fishers SWC Federation of Fly Fishers Tracy Fly Fishers Tri-Valley Fly Fishers United Outdoorsmen, Inc. United Pier & Shore Anglers of California USA Fishing Wilderness Fly Fishers Over 100 individuals Analysis Prepared by : Diane Colborn / W., P. & W. / (916) 319-2096