BILL ANALYSIS Senate Appropriations Committee Fiscal Summary Senator Christine Kehoe, Chair 2503 (J. Perez) Hearing Date: 08/12/2010 Amended: 08/10/2010 Consultant: Brendan McCarthy Policy Vote: NR&W 9-0 AB 2503 (J. Perez), Page 2 _________________________________________________________________ ____ BILL SUMMARY: AB 2503 establishes a program to allow for the partial removal of existing off-shore oil platforms. Under the bill, any cost savings realized from partial removal would be split between the state and the platform owner. The bill specifies that any state proceeds would largely be provided to a new endowment corporation and would be used for various ocean-related purposes. _________________________________________________________________ ____ Fiscal Impact (in thousands) Major Provisions 2010-11 2011-12 2012-13 Fund Fish and Game review $750 $1,700 $1,700 Special * State Lands Commission $450 $450 $1,900 General ** review Revenues from cost savings Unknown revenues, potentially in the tens Various or hundreds of millions in future years * Fish and Game Preservation Fund. Ultimately offset with fees. ** Ultimately offset with fees. _________________________________________________________________ ____ STAFF COMMENTS: SUSPENSE FILE. Under current state and federal law, as well as leases authorized by the state and federal government, owners of offshore oil platforms are required to fully remove platforms at the end of their lease term. There are 27 oil platforms off the California coast (4 are in state waters and 23 are in federal waters). Federal law allows for partial removal of oil platforms, provided that certain conditions are met, including the enactment of a law allowing for partial removal in the adjacent state. AB 2503 establishes a program under which an offshore oil platform owner is allowed to partially remove a platform, AB 2503 (J. Perez), Page 3 leaving behind some of the underwater structure for marine habitat. Under the bill, a platform owner could (voluntarily) apply to the Department of Fish and Game for permission to partially decommission an oil platform. The applicant would be responsible for reimbursing the state for costs incurred reviewing the application and taking other actions under the bill. The Ocean Protection Council would determine whether partial removal of a platform would provide a net environmental benefit. The State Lands Commission would be responsible for determining the cost savings associated with partial removal of an oil platform, as opposed to full removal. Under the bill, the Department of Fish and Game is authorized to approve partial removal of an oil platform if: 1) partial removal conforms to all existing state and federal laws, 2) partial removal would result in a net environmental benefit, 3) the cost savings from partial removal have been determined, 4) the platform owner has agreed to provide sufficient funds to cover state regulatory costs, 5) the platform owner has agreed to provide funding sufficient to manage the remaining structure, 6) the platform owner has indemnified the state from any liability associated with the structure, and 7) the platform owner has received all required permits. In order for the Department to provide final approval for partial removal, the applicant must provide a portion of the cost savings to the state. Before 2017, the applicant must provide the state 55 percent of the cost savings, from 2017 to 2023, the state share is 65 percent, and after 2023, the state share is 80 percent. The state share of the cost savings is to be apportioned as follows: 85 percent shall be transferred to an endowment corporation created under the bill; 3 percent shall be provided to the county adjacent to the platform; 10 percent is to be deposited in the General Fund; and 2 percent shall be deposited in a special fund and used for coastal protection activities. The bill creates the California Endowment for Marine Preservation as a public benefit corporation. The Endowment is governed by a board made up of the Secretary for Natural Resources, the Secretary for Environmental Protection, one member appointed by each of the Governor, the Senate Rules Committee, and the Speaker of the Assembly. The Endowment would AB 2503 (J. Perez), Page 4 directly receive 85 percent of the state's share of any cost savings from a partial removal of an offshore oil platform. The Endowment is directed to hold those funds in trust as an endowment and generally to only use interest earnings from the endowment to fund a variety of activities related to the protection of the marine environment. The bill requires the Endowment to report annually to the Governor and the Legislature on its activities and makes the Endowment subject to audit by the Bureau of State Audits. The Department of Fish and Game and the State Lands Commission will both need additional staff resources to review applications, determine environmental benefits, and evaluate cost savings. Staff estimates annual costs (once applications have been submitted) of about $3.6 million. Most of those costs will reimbursed by applicants. In addition, the program may generate significant revenues to the state and the Endowment created by the bill. The amount of those revenues will depend on the number of applications the state receives and their timing. According to a report prepared by the California Ocean Science Trust, the total cost to remove all 27 offshore oil platforms will be just over $1 billion. The cost to partially remove all 27 platforms is estimated to be about $500 million. Under the bill, the state could receive between 55 percent and 85 percent of those potential cost savings.