BILL ANALYSIS SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE Senator Ellen M. Corbett, Chair 2009-2010 Regular Session SB 127 Senator Calderon As Introduced Hearing Date: May 12, 2009 Civil Code BCP:jd SUBJECT Mortgages DESCRIPTION Existing law governs both the non-judicial foreclosure process and the trustee's sale at which foreclosed properties are sold. To provide greater information to prospective bidders about properties sold at a trustee's sale, this bill would require a mortgagee or trustee to make specified disclosures on an Internet Web site or in a 24-hour telephone recording at least one week before the scheduled sale of a property. This bill would additionally: require a beneficiary to provide an opening bid to a trustee at least one week prior to the first scheduled sale date; and require a trustee to provide a list of liens and encumbrances on a foreclosed property and to charge a reasonable fee for that information, as specified. This bill would also expand the trustee's current exemption from liability for good faith errors, as specified, and create a new immunity for title and escrow companies, as specified. BACKGROUND In California, the nonjudicial foreclosure process begins with the filing of a Notice of Default and concludes with a trustee's sale where the property is sold to the highest bidder. If there are no bids over and above the opening bid, the property reverts back to the lender or servicer who placed that opening bid (thus, becoming a bank-owned property). Those lenders are then left with an abundance of properties that may then be sold or (more) SB 127 (Calderon) Page 2 of ? auctioned off at a later date. Until their later sale, those foreclosed homes are generally unoccupied and risk becoming a nuisance to surrounding properties or subject to vandalism or theft. This bill seeks to address the above issues by providing additional information to prospective bidders prior to the trustee's sale at which the property is initially sold. If those properties are directly purchased by individual bidders (instead of reverting back to the lender), the above issues relating to bank-owned properties may be mitigated. Specifically, this bill would require the posting of information at least one week before a scheduled sale date, and would allow a person to request a list of liens and encumbrances on the property. This bill would also expand the current immunity for trustees in the nonjudicial foreclosure process, and create a new immunity for title and escrow companies, as specified. CHANGES TO EXISTING LAW 1. Existing law regulates the non-judicial foreclosure of properties pursuant to the power of sale contained within a mortgage contract. To commence the process, existing state law requires the trustee, mortgagee, or beneficiary to record a Notice of Default and allow three months to lapse before setting a date for sale of the property. (Civ. Code Secs. 2924, 2924f.) Existing law governs the issuance of the Notice of Sale, and requires that notice to be recorded at least 14 days prior to the date of sale. (Civ. Code Sec. 2924f.) Existing law requires a mortgagee, trustee, or other person authorized to record the Notice of Default or Notice of Sale to make specified disclosures after the recording of those notices and prior to the sale of the property. (Civ. Code Sec. 2924b.) This bill would additionally require the mortgagee, trustee, or other person authorized to record the notice of sale to make information available about each property at least one week before sale. This bill would require that information to be posted on an Internet Web site or in a telephone recording that is accessible 24 hours a day, at least one week before the scheduled sale of property. The information shall include: (1) a contact name and phone number; (2) the identifying SB 127 (Calderon) Page 3 of ? number for the sale of the property; (3) the date, time, and location of the sale; (4) the estimated total amount of debt; (5) the minimum opening bid, if any; (6) the outcome of the auction, as specified; and (6) a statement that any interested bidder may request information about liens and encumbrances for a reasonable fee. Any errors must be corrected as soon as practicable after identifying the error or being informed of the error. This bill would, upon oral, written, or electronic request by a person, and if known by the trustee, require the trustee to provide a list of the liens and encumbrances on a property as of a date certain. The trustee may charge a reasonable fee not to exceed $30, per property, for providing that information. This bill would require each beneficiary (i.e., the lender) to provide an opening bid on property to the trustee at least one week prior to the first scheduled sale date. The beneficiary may update that bid at any time prior to sale, and the trustee shall update its information regarding the sale on its phone recording or Internet Web site as soon as practicable after receiving the revised opening bid. A beneficiary who provides an opening bid to a trustee may accept a higher bid on the property. This bill would also extend the time during which the notice of sale must be recorded from 14 to 20 days. 2. Existing law generally regulates the conduct of trustees in the above process, and their actions at the resulting trustee's sale. (Civ. Code Sec. 2924h.) Existing law also exempts a trustee from liability for any good faith error resulting from reliance on information provided in good faith by the beneficiary regarding the nature and the amount of the default. (Civ. Code Sec. 2924(b).) This bill would, instead, exempt a trustee from liability for any good faith error resulting from reliance on information provided in good faith by the beneficiary, or resulting from any clerical error the trustee makes, despite adherence to procedures intended to prevent the error. This bill would additionally exempt a trustee from liability for any good faith error resulting from reliance on SB 127 (Calderon) Page 4 of ? information provided in good faith by third parties who perform title and records searches. That immunity would apply only when the trustee, as required by this bill, provides a list of liens and encumbrances in response to a request. This bill would exempt a title insurance company, underwritten title company, or controlled escrow company from liability with respect to the validity of information the company provides in good faith to a trustee, and which is subsequently requested of the trustee by a third party. 3. Existing law limits the costs and expenses that may be charged in the nonjudicial foreclosure process to, among other things, the costs incurred for the recording, mailing, publishing, and posting of notices. (Civ. Code Sec. 2924c(c).) This bill would include the cost of posting information on an Internet Web site or making that information available on a 24-hour telephone recording. COMMENT 1. Stated need for the bill According to the author: California's housing market is currently suffering from historically high rates of default and foreclosure. Nearly 250,000 properties were sold through non-judicial foreclosure in California during 2008, and nearly all of those properties (96.4%) reverted to the lender, after no bid was received on the property from a third party. Lenders are trying to draw bids from third parties by discounting properties sharply, but are still failing to attract bidders. In December 2008, 40% of the properties up for auction on the courthouse steps were discounted by at least 50%. When lenders take back properties through non-judicial SB 127 (Calderon) Page 5 of ? foreclosure, the properties often remain unoccupied and unsold for months. Financial institutions are overwhelmed by the vast number of properties they have taken back onto their books, and are selling these properties any way they can - often at deep discounts. These vacant, deeply discounted properties are depressing property values in the neighborhoods in which they are located, harming hard-working, neighboring homeowners who are watching their own home values plummet through no fault of their own. Decreasing the number of properties that revert to financial institutions on the courthouse steps by increasing the number of people who bid at non-judicial foreclosure sales will help reverse harmful housing trends in several ways. First, the properties will spend less time vacant, which, in turn, will reduce levels of blight and other problems, like theft and vandalism, which frequently characterize vacant, foreclosed properties. Second, housing values will begin to stabilize at levels higher than those at which the banks are currently selling their bank-owned inventory. Third, reducing the number of bank-owned properties will help free financial institutions to focus on helping borrowers before they enter foreclosure. 2. Immunity provisions By requiring the posting of information relating to foreclosure sales, this bill would require trustees to provide borrowers with essential information about a foreclosed property with the intended result of increasing the number of individuals who do bid (and as a result purchase properties) at trustee's sales. To provide liability protection for the entities who would provide information regarding foreclosed properties, this bill would expand an existing immunity for trustees, and create a new immunity for a title insurance, title, or escrow company. a) Expanded immunity for trustees In the nonjudicial foreclosure process, trustees are the individuals who are enlisted to file the notice of default, notify necessary parties, and conduct the sale of the property in accordance with statute. Those trustees currently have no liability under existing law for good faith errors that result from their reliance on specified information provided in good faith by the beneficiary (the lender or servicer). This bill would revise that immunity to cover good faith errors SB 127 (Calderon) Page 6 of ? involving any information provided in good faith by the beneficiary, or resulting from any clerical error the trustee makes despite adherence to procedures intended to prevent the error. The author's staff notes that the revised immunity is intended to ensure that trustees are not held liable for complying with their proposed statutory duties. Although a trustee arguably should not be liable when performing statutorily required actions in good faith (posting provided information on a Internet Web site or telephone hotline), the bill should be amended to narrow the proposed immunity by clarifying that: (1) the good faith requirement also applies to the immunity regarding clerical errors; and (2) the new immunity for clerical errors only applies with regards to information posted on their Internet Web site or phone recording. Suggested amendment : 1) On page 3, line 27 after "any" insert: good faith 2) On page 3, line 28 after "makes" insert: when complying with the requirements of subdivision (g) of Section 2924b b) Immunities relating to liens and encumbrances In addition to posting information, this bill would require a trustee, upon request, to provide a list of liens and encumbrances on a foreclosed property, and allow the trustee to charge a reasonable fee for that information. (See Comment 4.) The author notes that the trustee's source of information regarding those liens and encumbrances would be a trustee sale guarantee (TSG) or similar product. (A TSG provides a trustee with necessary information about a property in foreclosure, including individuals who must receive notice, owners of the property, lien information, and publication requirements, and includes a limited guarantee against losses as a result of incorrect information.) It should be noted that those products are provided to trustees so that they have the information necessary to fulfill their current duties (including notice to subordinate lienholders, publication requirements, and distribution of proceeds). Those products SB 127 (Calderon) Page 7 of ? are not currently provided with the intent that the included information be subsequently relayed to a third party. Accordingly, this bill would not impose liability on a title or escrow company with respect to any information that is provided to a trustee, in good faith, and which is subsequently requested by a third party. The author notes that this immunity is intended to protect those companies from liability to third parties who may receive that information from the trustee. In response to concerns about the breadth of the proposed immunity, the author has agreed to remove the proposed immunity with the understanding that the author's staff will continue to work with committee staff to craft an immunity that is appropriate to the circumstances. Amendment: On page 5, strike out lines 1 through 5, inclusive. The bill would also grant a similar immunity for trustees when they provide information, in good faith, regarding liens and encumbrances on a foreclosed property. The author has also agreed to strike this provision with the understanding that the author's staff will continue to work with committee staff to craft an immunity that is narrowly tailored to the circumstances in which the trustee provides that information (which, in itself, is generated by a third party). Amendment: On page 4, strike out lines 36 through 39, inclusive. From a public policy standpoint, the consequences of granting both those immunities should be balanced against the benefit to prospective bidders (and the public at large) as a result of the disclosure of that information. The rationale for providing escrow and title companies with a narrow immunity is that their products are not intended for use by a party other than the trustee. Similarly, the trustees should be granted a narrow immunity from inaccuracies in the data they provide to prospective bidders because they are statutorily required to act as the conduit between those companies and the borrower. That immunity should not extend beyond the ministerial tasks that the trustees are required to perform pursuant to this bill. SB 127 (Calderon) Page 8 of ? 3. Benefits of posting information As noted above, nearly all of the properties sold through non-judicial foreclosure in California reverted back to the lender after receiving no bids. Those bank-owned properties often remain unoccupied for months, raise the issue of maintenance (required pursuant to SB 1137 (Perata, Corbett, Machado)), and are at risk of other serious problems, such as vandalism and blight, that affect the surrounding community. This bill is intended to address the above issues by facilitating the sale of properties at the trustee's sale - thus, encouraging properties to be transferred directly from a defaulting borrower to a new homeowner (instead of reverting to the lender). To accomplish that goal, this bill would require a mortgagee, trustee, or beneficiary to post specified information about a property on an Internet Web site or a 24-hour telephone recording at least one week prior to the sale date of the property. This bill would also require a beneficiary (the lender) to provide an opening bid to the trustee at least one week prior to the first scheduled sale date, and require the trustee to place that minimum bid on their Internet Web site or phone recording. The author notes that much of the information is not currently available to bidders, and that it is currently difficult for potential bidders to find out where and when to go, as well as the minimum opening bid, if any. 4. Ability to request liens and encumbrances As a general rule, a bidder who purchases a property at a trustee's sale receives title that is free of all claims subordinate to the mortgage or deed of trust under which the sale was made. Subordinate claims are generally those that were recorded after the mortgage or deed of trust that was foreclosed on (unless there is a subordination agreement). The purchased property does remain subject to all senior liens, including liens for property taxes, and the bidder must satisfy those liens or risk foreclosure by the holder of those interests. The author states that the unknown nature of these liens "can make bidding a risky proposition, because the winning bidder must satisfy all outstanding [senior] liens and encumbrances on a property, before taking possession of it." That situation arises when the bidder bids on a junior lien, but later discovers there are senior liens on the property that must be SB 127 (Calderon) Page 9 of ? satisfied. To address that issue, this bill would allow any person to request information about liens and encumbrances from the trustee, and allow the trustee to charge a reasonable fee, not to exceed $30, for that information. The author notes that this provision is based on an Arizona statute - that statute allows the trustee to recover between $30 and $100 for similar information. (A.R.S. Sec. 33-809.) The author notes that this information is not readily available to bidders because many title and escrow companies do not currently offer title searches on foreclosed properties. While the bill does not specify how a trustee will know information about liens and encumbrances on the property, the author's staff notes that the trustee may receive that information from a TSG, title search, or other product that would have been purchased to aid the trustee in the foreclosure. (See Comment 2(b).) Depending on the type of products purchased, that product may, or may not, disclose all liens, including government tax liens which take priority. Additionally, the bill's definition of liens and encumbrances would exclude taxes or assessments, reservations in patents, easements, rights-of-way, reservation of mineral rights, covenants, conditions, or restrictions. Given the potentially incomplete information, the bill should be amended to require the trustee to notify consumers that the information provided may not contain all outstanding liens and encumbrances, and of the exemptions to the definitions of liens and encumbrances. Suggested amendments: 1) On page 4, line 32 after the period, insert: That list shall include a statement that the provided information may not disclose all liens and encumbrances, and, that the information does not include any information regarding taxes or assessments, reservations in patents, easements, rights-of-way, reservation of mineral rights, covenants, conditions or restrictions. 2) On page 11, line 9 after the period, insert: The statement shall also notify the borrower that the information may not disclose all liens and encumbrances, and that the provided list of liens and encumbrances will not include any information regarding taxes or assessments, SB 127 (Calderon) Page 10 of ? reservations in patents, easements, rights-of-way, reservation of mineral rights, covenants, conditions or restrictions. 5. Trustees able to recoup costs incurred in posting information Under existing law, trustees may only be reimbursed for costs and expenses that are authorized by statute. Those costs and fees are currently limited to the costs incurred in recording, mailing, publishing, posting specified notices, a fee not to exceed $50 for postponement, and the purchase of a trustee's sale guarantee. This bill would additionally allow a trustee to be reimbursed for the cost of posting information on an Internet Web site or making that information available on a 24-hour phone recording, as required by this bill. Consistent with the $50 cap on the fee that may be charged for a postponement, and the requirement that a trustee sale's guarantee must be at a rate meeting specified standards, the Committee should consider whether the bill should be amended to include a specific cap (such as $50) on the amount that may be charged for the posting of information on the Internet Web site or phone recording. Those costs and fees are recovered by the trustee upon the sale of the property from the sale proceeds. (Civ. Code Sec. 2924k.) Suggested Amendment: On page 15, line 32 after 2924b insert: not to exceed fifty dollars ($50) Support : None Known Opposition : None Known HISTORY Source : Author Related Pending Legislation : SB 109 (Calderon), would delete the exemption for sales of real property under the Auction law, thereby bringing specified real property auctions within those restrictions. This bill is currently in the Senate Committee on Appropriations. SB 127 (Calderon) Page 11 of ? Prior Legislation : SB 1137 (Perata, Corbett, Machado, Chapter 69, Statutes of 2008), enacted changes to the procedures that must be followed before the holder of a mortgage may issue a notice of default or notice of trustee sale, requires the holder of a mortgage to mail a specified notice to the tenant(s) of a property on which foreclosure proceedings have begun, and imposes penalties on property owners who fail to adequately maintain foreclosed properties, as specified. **************