BILL ANALYSIS SENATE COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION Gloria Romero, Chair 2009-2010 Regular Session BILL NO: SB 1122 AUTHOR: Wright AMENDED: March 22, 2010 FISCAL COMM: Yes HEARING DATE: April 14, 2010 URGENCY: No CONSULTANT:Kathleen Chavira SUBJECT : University of California (UC) Public Contracting KEY POLICY ISSUES Should the threshold for requiring the UC to competitively bid contracts for materials, goods and services be increased from $50,000 to $100,000? Should students employed by the UC be exempt from conflict of interest provisions that prohibit university employees from receiving additional university compensation for employment activity which is outside the scope of their regular university employment? SUMMARY This bill increases the threshold above which the University of California (UC) is required to competitively bid contracts for materials, goods and services from $50,000 to $100,000, and expands an exemption from conflict of interest provisions to include student employees engaged in multiple campus employment positions. BACKGROUND Current law establishes UC competitive bidding law within the Public Contract Code and outlines specific procurement priority, methods and exceptions, with regards to contracting for materials, goods, and services. The Public Contract Code also establishes various conflict of interest provisions and requirements regarding UC contracting. Current law requires the UC to annually competitively bid all contracts for goods and materials to be sold to the University if the expenditure is greater than fifty SB 1122 Page 2 thousand dollars ($50,000) and to award the contract to the lowest responsible bidder, as specified. If the successful bidder refuses or fails to execute a tendered contract, current law authorizes the UC, when it deems it in the University's best interest, to award the contract to the second lowest responsible bidder, or third lowest responsible bidder meeting specifications. (Public Contract Code 10507.7) Current law also prohibits officers/employees of the UC from engaging in any employment, activity, or enterprise from which they receive compensation or in which they have a financial interest if it is sponsored and/or funded, by any university department via a university contract if such is outside the course and scope of their regular university employment. Officers/employees are also prohibited from contracting on their own behalf as independent contractors with any university department to provide services or goods. Officers/ employees of the university with teaching or research responsibilities are specifically exempted from these prohibitions. (Public Contract Code 10516) ANALYSIS This bill : 1) Increases the threshold above which the UC is required to competitively bid contracts for materials, goods and services from $50,000 to $100,000. 2) Exempts student employees receiving payment for campus activities or engagements outside the scope of their primary UC employment from prohibitions against their contracting for employment sponsored and/or funded by another university department. STAFF COMMENTS 1) Need for the bill . According to the author, the cost of goods and services has more than doubled since the $50,000 competitive bid threshold was put in place in 1985, with no adjustment since then to reflect inflation or the erosion of the value of the dollar. In addition, the author contends that compelling a formal bid process on relatively small contracts adds significantly to costs and the complexity can serve as SB 1122 Page 3 a barrier to small businesses. Current law prohibits university employees, including student employees from being an independent contractor with any university department to provide services or goods. According to the UC, these provisions continually raise issues for student employees employed by campus departments but receiving payment for other campus activities as well. Though these students eventually get paid, this requires issuance of an exception, review and research by campus purchasing and human resource directors, then manual keying of each check by staff processors, resulting in delayed payment to students and increased administrative costs. 2) What's affected ? According to the UC, the change in the bid threshold proposed by this bill affects contracts for goods, materials and services that can include items such as laboratory instruments and supplies, chemical reagents, computer software licenses and updates, janitorial supplies, commercial kitchen supplies, furniture, consultant services, and equipment repair, among other things. This bill does not affect UC contracts for labor and materials related to construction projects, which, under current law, are subject to a $50,000 competitive bid threshold. (Public Contract Code 10500) 3) Fiscal impact . According to the UC, administrative costs related to the management of a competitive bid proposal would be reduced by $780,000 annually as the result of the reduced number of bids which would be issued with the increase in the bid threshold authorized by this bill. The UC also reports that approximately 500 students a year are affected by the conflict of interest provisions. The UC estimates that this bill would result in administrative cost savings of $175,000 as a result of the student exemption. SUPPORT University of California OPPOSITION SB 1122 Page 4 None received.