BILL ANALYSIS SB 1221 Page 1 Date of Hearing: June 29, 2010 ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY Mike Feuer, Chair SB 1221 (Calderon) - As Amended: April 6, 2010 PROPOSED CONSENT SENATE VOTE : 32-0 SUBJECT : MORTGAGES: NOTICE OF SALE KEY ISSUE : SHOULD THE NOTICE OF SALE IN A NON-JUDICIAL FORECLOSURE BE ALLOWED TO BE GIVEN FIVE DAYS EARLIER THAN CURRENT LAW ALLOWS, I.E. 85 DAYS, INSTEAD OF THREE MONTHS AFTER THE FILING OF THE NOTICE OF DEFAULT? FISCAL EFFECT : As currently in print this bill is keyed non-fiscal. SYNOPSIS This non-controversial bill, sponsored by the United Trustees Association, would permit a notice of sale to be given five days earlier than allowed under current law for properties in non-judicial foreclosure, i.e. 85 days after recording the Notice of Default, rather than three months after the notice of default is recorded. According to the author, this technical change to the law is needed to alleviate a potential unintended consequence arising from SB 306 (Calderon) of 2009, namely, possible delay of the foreclosure sale that could arise from innocent delays in recording the Notice of Sale, especially if those delays create technical violations of the non-judicial foreclosure law. Although this bill permits the notice of sale to be filed up to five days earlier than allowed under current law, this bill does not move up the actual sale date of the property or otherwise shorten the foreclosure process. This bill passed the Senate by a 32-0 vote and has no known opposition. SUMMARY : Authorizes notice of sale of a property in non-judicial foreclosure to be given five days earlier than current law allows-a total of 85 days, instead of three months, after the filing of a Notice of Default. Specifically, this bill : SB 1221 Page 2 1)Authorizes the mortgagee, trustee, or other person authorized to take sale of the property pursuant to non-judicial foreclosure to file a notice of sale up to five days before the lapse of the three-month period, provided that the date of sale is no earlier than three months and 20 days after the filing of the notice of default. 2)Makes corresponding changes to the codified notice that must be included in the notice of default. EXISTING LAW regulates the non-judicial foreclosure of property pursuant to the power of sale contained within a mortgage contract: 1)Requires the trustee, mortgagee, or beneficiary to record a Notice of Default and allow three months to pass before setting a date for sale of the property. (Civil Code Sections 2924(a), 2924f(a).) 2)Requires the notice of sale to be published and recorded at least 20 days prior to sale of the property. (Civil Code Section 2924(b)(1), 2924f(b)(1).) COMMENTS : This non-controversial bill, sponsored by the United Trustees Association, would permit a notice of sale to be given five days earlier than allowed under current law for properties in non-judicial foreclosure, i.e. 85 days after recording the Notice of Default, rather than three months after the notice of default is recorded. According to the author, this technical change to the law is needed to alleviate a potentially problematic unintended consequence arising from SB 306 (Calderon) of 2009, namely, possible delay of the foreclosure sale that could arise from innocent delays in recording the Notice of Sale, especially if those delays create technical violations of nonjudicial foreclosure law. Background on Non-Judicial Foreclosure . Non-judicial foreclosure (sometimes referred to as a "private trustee's sale") is the preferred method used by lenders in California to exercise the remedy of foreclosure when the loan is not repaid by the borrower according to the terms of a mortgage agreement. The procedural requirements for non-judicial foreclosure are set forth in Civil Code Sections 2924 to 2924(h). SB 1221 Page 3 Ordinarily, the borrower will execute a deed of trust in favor of the lender which makes the real property the security for the loan and names someone to act as trustee. The function of this trustee under a deed of trust is either to initiate foreclosure at the lender's direction in the event of a breach, or to reconvey the trust deed once the obligation has been satisfied in full. The trustee initiates the foreclosure process by preparing, executing, and recording the Notice of Default. For the next three months, there is a redemption period in which the borrower may attempt to cure the default. If the borrower is unsuccessful, then a Notice of Sale is recorded and the process culminates in a trustee's sale where the property is sold to the highest bidder. The auctioneer conducts this sale as instructed by the trustee and reports the results back to the trustee. The trustee will notify the beneficiary and prepare the Trustee's Deed, which will vest title into the name of the successful bidder. If there are no bids for the property which exceed the opening bid, the property reverts to the beneficiary (in this case, the bank or lender) who will then take title to the property under the Trustee's Deed. Because there is no statutory right of redemption following a non-judicial foreclosure under California law, at this point the property officially becomes "bank-owned." This bill addresses timing issues arising from SB 306 (2009) . According to the author, this bill is needed to address a workability issue that arose after the author's previous bill SB 306 of last year required that the notice of sale be posted 20 days prior to the date of the sale. The author explains: Prior to enactment of SB 306, notices of sale were required to be published in newspapers of general circulation at least 20 days prior to the sale of the property, and recorded with the county recorder at least 14 days prior to the sale. SB 306 conformed these dates, so that notices of sale must now be published and recorded at least 20 days prior to sale. The change was intended to give the public and those relying on the recording process as much advance notice of sales as possible. The problem with the law, as amended by SB 306, is that, while publication dates can be coordinated very precisely between trustees and newspapers, the recording process is subject to greater opportunity for error. If recorders SB 1221 Page 4 close early on a given day due to budget cutbacks, or if the notice of sale document is delivered to the recorder's office, but not actually recorded until the next day, a technical violation of the law can occur. In nonjudicial foreclosures, a foreclosure sale can be subject to challenge, and possible revocation, if the requirements of the law are not strictly followed. SB 306 requires that at least 20 days pass between the date of recordation and the date of sale. Existing law also prohibits the recordation of a notice of sale until at least three months have passed since recordation of the notice of default. The interaction of these two rules leaves trustees no room for error. If there is a one or two day delay in recording the notice of sale, the foreclosure sale may also have to be delayed. Delays in a foreclosure sale can result in significant expense. To address that issue, SB 1221 would permit a notice of sale to be given five days earlier in the process - 85 days after recording the Notice of Default, rather than three months after the notice of default is recorded. According to the author, those extra five days seek to account for any delays in the recording process, and that the bill is not intended to propose any change in sale dates. Although this bill permits the notice of sale to be filed up to five days earlier than allowed under current law, this bill does not move up the actual sale date of the property or otherwise shorten the foreclosure process. Under this bill, the actual sale date may not occur any sooner than allowed by existing law-to be precise, three months and 20 days after the notice of default is filed. REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION : Support United Trustees Association Opposition None on file SB 1221 Page 5 Analysis Prepared by : Anthony Lew / JUD. / (916) 319-2334