BILL ANALYSIS SB 1402 Page 1 SENATE THIRD READING SB 1402 (Dutton) As Amended August 16, 2010 2/3 vote. Urgency SENATE VOTE :33-0 NATURAL RESOURCES 7-0 JUDICIARY 10-0 ----------------------------------------------------------------- |Ayes:|Chesbro, Gilmore, |Ayes:|Feuer, Tran, Brownley, | | |Brownley, | |Evans, Hagman, Huffman, | | |De Leon, Hill, Huffman, | |Jones, Knight, Monning, | | |Logue | |Saldana | | | | | | ----------------------------------------------------------------- APPROPRIATIONS 17-0 ----------------------------------------------------------------- |Ayes:|Fuentes, Conway, | | | | |Bradford, | | | | |Huffman, Coto, Davis, De | | | | |Leon, Gatto, Hall, | | | | |Harkey, Miller, Nielsen, | | | | |Norby, Skinner, Solorio, | | | | |Torlakson, Torrico | | | ----------------------------------------------------------------- SUMMARY : Requires the Air Resources Board (ARB) to provide a specified written explanation prior to imposing an administrative or civil penalty for a violation of air pollution law, make these explanations available to the public, annually report specified administrative penalties imposed, and publish a penalty policy pertaining to vehicular air pollution control. Specifically, this bill: 1) Requires a written communication from ARB alleging an administrative or civil penalty for violation of air pollution law to contain a clear explanation of the following: a) The manner in which the penalty amount was determined; SB 1402 Page 2 b) The law or regulation under which the penalty is being assessed; and, c) Whether the penalty is being assessed under a law that prohibits a specified level of pollution, and if so, a quantification of the specific amount of pollution emitted 2) Requires ARB to make this information, and all final mutual settlement agreements between ARB and the alleged violator, available to the public. 3) Requires ARB to prepare and submit to the Legislature and the Governor an annual report summarizing administrative penalties pertaining to vehicular air pollution control. 4) Requires ARB to publish a civil and administrative penalty policy pertaining to vehicular air pollution control by March 1, 2011, and requires the policy to consider specified circumstances similar to those that ARB and the courts are currently required to consider when determining penalty amounts. 5) Contains an urgency clause. EXISTING LAW : 1)Generally establishes processes for assessing fines and penalties and specifies the deposit of fines and penalties for violations of vehicular air pollution control laws into the Air Pollution Control Fund (APCF) or the General Fund (GF). 2)Establishes a process to assess administrative penalties in lieu of civil penalties for violation of specified vehicular air pollution control laws up to $100,000 and establishes a threshold of $100,000 for penalty assessments that qualify a person for mutual settlement agreements and requires the proceeds be deposited into the GF. 3)Requires ARB and the courts to consider specified conditions when considering the amount assessed for administrative or civil penalties for violations of vehicular air pollution control laws such as: a) the extent of harm to public health, safety, and welfare caused by the violation; b) the nature and persistence of the violation, including the magnitude of the SB 1402 Page 3 excess emissions; c) the compliance history of the defendant, including the frequency of past violations; d) the preventive efforts taken by the defendant, including the record of maintenance and any program to ensure compliance; e) the innovative nature and the magnitude of the effort required to comply, and the accuracy, reproducibility, and repeatability of the available test methods; f) the efforts to attain, or provide for, compliance; and, g) the cooperation of the defendant during the course of the investigation and any action taken by the defendant, including the nature, extent, and time of response of any action taken to mitigate the violation. 4)Requires any person who violates any vehicular air pollution control law as specified to be liable for a civil penalty not to exceed $5,000 per vehicle and those penalties be deposited in the APCF. 5)Prohibits the sale of any new motor vehicle that does not meet emission standards adopted by ARB, and any manufacturer who sells, attempts to sell, or causes to be offered for sale a new motor vehicle that fails to meet the applicable emission standards must be subject to a civil penalty of $5,000 for each such action, with the penalty to be deposited into the General Fund. FISCAL EFFECT : According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, costs of an unknown amount, potentially in excess of $150,000 per year, for up to one position at ARB to include specified information in written communication and to make it available to the public, update and publish penalty policy, and report to the Legislature and Governor. (APCF) COMMENTS : Under current law, the ARB and/or local air pollution control districts are authorized to impose civil or administrative penalties for a variety of violations of state air pollution laws and regulations. Administrative penalties of up to $100,000 may be assessed for certain violations. ARB and the courts are required to consider several factors when determining the amount of an administrative or civil penalty - including the harm to the public, the compliance history of the defendant, preventative efforts made by the defendant, and other factors. Fine and penalty revenues are generally deposited in the APCF (where they are available, upon appropriation of the SB 1402 Page 4 Legislature, for environmental cleanup, abatement, or pollution prevention) or the GF. ARB has articulated three main goals of its enforcement program: 1) to foster compliance; 2) to deter violations; and, 3) to create a level playing field for the community ARB regulates. ARB currently handles approximately 2,000 violations a year. ARB has a long history of obtaining compliance along with substantial penalties. In over 99 percent of its cases, ARB engages violators in a settlement process to reach resolutions. However, where an appropriate settlement cannot be reached, ARB refers the matter to a prosecutor, usually the Attorney General, for civil litigation or criminal prosecution. Injunctions to halt violations are an important tool in these actions. ARB maintains that its enforcement process is highly transparent. All ARB settlements are public documents. Case resolutions are publicized through news releases. ARB publishes a comprehensive annual report that documents the results of its enforcement efforts. According to the author: Affected stakeholders have expressed concern over the lack of information on how ARB determines and assesses penalties as well as the lack of consistency from one violation to the next. Although ARB notes that they provide this information, many regulated parties state that they do not receive this information. This bill would ensure that this information is provided. Additionally, this bill would codify some of the important strides that ARB has taken to improve the transparency of its penalty policies, provide a role for legislative oversight, and ensure that penalties are assessed consistently by establishing a written penalty policy. Analysis Prepared by : Elizabeth MacMillan / NAT. RES. / (916) 319-2092 FN: 0005944