BILL ANALYSIS SB 1413 Page 1 Date of Hearing: June 30, 2010 ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION Julia Brownley, Chair SB 1413 (Leno) - As Amended: June 22, 2010 SENATE VOTE : 21-13 SUBJECT : Schools: pupil nutrition: availability of tap water. SUMMARY: Requires school districts to provide students with access to free drinking water beginning January 1, 2012. Specifically, this bill : 1)Requires by January 1, 2012, a school district to provide access to free, fresh drinking water during meal times in the food service areas of the schools under its jurisdiction, including, but not necessarily limited to, areas where reimbursable meals under the National School Lunch Program (NSLP) or the federal School Breakfast Program are served or consumed. 2)Specifies that school districts may comply, among other means, by providing cups and containers of water or soliciting or receiving donated bottled water. 3)Authorizes a school district to opt-out of this requirement by adoption of a school district governing board resolution stating the reasons why it is unable to comply with the requirements; and, requires the resolution to be publicly noticed on at least two consecutive board meeting agendas and approved by a majority of the board. EXISTING LAW requires all beverages sold to a pupil from one-half hour before the start of the schoolday until one-half hour after the end of the schoolday to be on the following list, with specified exceptions: 1)Fruit-based drinks with at least 50% fruit juice and no added sweetener; 2)Vegetable-based drinks with at least 50% vegetable juice and no added sweetener; 3)Drinking water with no added sweetener; SB 1413 Page 2 4)Two percent fat milk, one percent fat milk, non-fat milk, soy milk, rice milk, and other similar non-dairy milk; and, 5)An electrolyte replacement beverage (ERB) with no more than 42 grams of added sweetener per 20-ounce serving. (Middle and High School only) FISCAL EFFECT : This bill is keyed non-fiscal. COMMENTS : This bill requires school district to provide access to free drinking water in food service areas during meal time, and authorizes districts to opt-out of this requirement by passing a board resolution that specifies the reasons the school district cannot comply. SB 965 (Escutia), Chapter 237, Statutes of 2005, created specific standards regarding the types of beverages sold in California schools. One of the allowable beverages under SB 965 is bottled water without added sweetener. According to the California Department of Education (CDE), SB 965 sets clear nutrition standards on what is sold by schools, and would not affect a district's ability to offer free tap water in their cafeterias. While conducting a study, the RAND Corporation learned that some school administrators and school employees have the perception that a school cannot provide free bottled water because of existing district contracts for the sale of bottled water. RAND researchers also learned that some school employees also had the perception that schools could not provide free tap water in the area where the NSLP meal is being served because of the federal government's definition of a reimbursable school meal, which includes milk as the beverage. According to CDE, the distinction is made between "offer vs. serve." Schools must "offer" milk as part of the reimbursable school meal program, but that does not in any way prohibit schools from also offering water in the area where the NSLP meal is being served. Some school employees also indicated to RAND researchers their concerns about needing appropriate staff resources to facilitate providing free tap water to students during meal times, including the possibility of the following duties: filling water pitchers, replacing five gallon water jugs, supplying appropriate cups, etc. SB 1413 Page 3 Students told RAND researchers they felt that even if they had access to free tap water at lunch from a drinking fountain, they did not choose to access it because of the cleanliness of existing drinking fountains and the fact that some drinking fountains do not provide chilled water. Students also said they felt that the bottled water being sold was too costly to buy. According to RAND, Berkeley Unified School District provides filtered tap water for students during lunch in schools district-wide. Each school eating area has a five gallon water container that is refilled each day with filtered tap water and the school provides cups for students to use. According to the author, many California schools currently do not provide drinking water in food service areas, where students eat their meals. Studies show that water consumption and adequate hydration in schools can help fight obesity and can even improve cognitive function and student academic performance. According to the California Food Policy Advocates, kids need to drink water for good health and learning. The Institute of Medicine recommends the consumption of water with meals. The Surgeon General promotes drinking water as an obesity prevention strategy. Meeting students' needs for adequate supplies of fresh, safe drinking water should not be dependent upon kids' financial ability to purchase bottled water at school nor their prospect of carting jugs of drinking water from home. A recent survey found that at least 40% of schools in responding districts reported no access to free drinking water for students during meals. Many students report inoperable, poorly maintained, and/or unhygienic water fountains on their school sites. Even where water fountains function, the CDE has acknowledged there are not enough fountains on schools sites. Committee Amendments : Staff recommends the bill be amended to make the provisions operative on either July 1, 2011 or July 1, 2012, instead of January 1, 2012, to accommodate the school calendar. Staff further recommends the bill be amended to require school boards, if they choose to pass a resolution stating that they cannot comply, to demonstrate in the resolution why they are unable to comply specifically due to fiscal restraints or health and safety concerns. In addition, the bill should be amended to clarify that the first board SB 1413 Page 4 agenda notice shall be an information item and the second board agenda notice shall be an action item. Related Legislation : SB 1255 (Padilla), from 2010, pending hearing in the Assembly, prohibits ERBs that contain 42 grams or less of added sweetener per 20-ounce serving, from being sold to middle or high school students from one-half hour before the start of the schoolday until one-half hour after the end of the schoolday, commencing July 1, 2011. AB 2084 (Brownley) from 2010, pending in the Senate, would require licensed child day care facilities to follow specified guidelines relating to the provision of beverages, including serving only one percent milk to children ages two or older; limiting juice to not more than one serving per day of 100% juice; serving no beverages with added sweeteners, either natural or artificial; and, making clean and safe dinking water readily available and accessible for consumption throughout the day, particularly with meals and snacks. Previous Legislation : AB 2704 (Leno) from 2008, would have prohibited a school district from entering or renewing a contract that restricts the availability of free tap water on the school campus; and, authorized schools to provide free tap water in school food service areas. AB 2704 was vetoed by the Governor with the following message: "This bill authorizes schools to provide free tap water for students in the food service area during the school day. Nothing under current law prohibits a school from providing free tap water to its students. This bill also prohibits a district from entering into contracts that prohibit the availability of free tap water. This bill essentially seeks to regulate a perceived lack of common sense amongst California's school administrators, implying that they are not acting in the best interest of our students, by denying kids access to free tap water. I do no believe this particular bill is necessary. Instead of signing this bill, I would much rather work with the Legislature in finding more positive and constructive ways to promote the accessibility and consumption of clean water in our schools." SB 965 (Escutia) Chapter 237, Statues of 2005, modified the list SB 1413 Page 5 of beverages that may be sold to pupils at an elementary, middle and high school, and phased in a prohibition on the sale of soda in high schools. SB 19 (Escutia) Chapter 913, Statutes of 2001, established the Pupil Nutrition, Health and Achievement Act of 2001, and enacted, as of January 1, 2004, various prohibitions on the sale of beverages in elementary and middle schools and placed nutritional standards on the type of foods that may be sold to pupils a la carte, as specified. REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION : Support American Cancer Society American Heart Association Board of Chiropractic Examiners California Chiropractic Association California Department of Public Health California Park and Recreation Society California School Employees Association California Teachers Association County Health Executives Association of California Environmental Working Group Health Officers Association of California San Mateo County Board of Supervisors Opposition None on file. Analysis Prepared by : Chelsea Kelley / ED. / (916) 319-2087