BILL ANALYSIS Ó AB 69 Page 1 ASSEMBLY THIRD READING AB 69 (Beall) As Amended May 27, 2011 Majority vote HUMAN SERVICES 6-0 APPROPRIATIONS 12-5 ----------------------------------------------------------------- |Ayes:|Beall, Jones, Ammiano, |Ayes:|Fuentes, Blumenfield, | | |Grove, Butler, Swanson | |Bradford, Charles | | | | |Calderon, Campos, Davis, | | | | |Gatto, Hall, Hill, Lara, | | | | |Mitchell, Solorio | | | | | | |-----+--------------------------+-----+--------------------------| | | |Nays:|Harkey, Donnelly, | | | | |Nielsen, Norby, Wagner | | | | | | ----------------------------------------------------------------- SUMMARY : Allows counties to identify, through the Social Security Administration (SSA) benefits database, needy seniors who may be eligible for CalFresh benefits in order to enroll them and improve their nutrition. Specifically, this bill : 1)Requires the Department of Social Services (DSS) to allow counties to use existing information from SSA to identify low-income seniors and simplify their CalFresh enrollment as long as the counties have the ability to adapt their existing automation systems without significant changes or costs. 2)Requires DSS to support enrollment efforts by: a) Working with SSA to identify low-income seniors age 60 or older whose income and other factors are likely to qualify them for CalFresh benefits; b) Simplifying the application process which may include strategies used by other states, as specified; and, c) Seeking waivers, grants, or other necessary federal authority and support. FISCAL EFFECT : According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee: AB 69 Page 2 1)Data suggest that there are currently 440,000 CalFresh eligible households with Social Security recipients. If this streamlined system allows 100,000 people who would otherwise not receive CalFresh benefits to participate in the program it would result in almost $10 million in additional federal CalFresh benefits flowing into California. 2)Unknown one-time costs, potentially in excess of $100,000, for DSS to develop a streamlined application process for SSA recipients. COMMENTS : According to the author, senior participation in the CalFresh program is disturbingly low and this bill attempts to reach out to this vulnerable group and enroll them in CalFresh. Background : Good nutrition is especially important for seniors. It can help improve resistance to illness and disease or help manage existing health problems. It can improve mental acuity and increase longevity. And for many seniors relying on prescription medications, nutrition is vital - as many medications are required to be taken with food. But many seniors are struggling. According to the Elder Economic Security Standard Index, about half a million seniors who live alone are not able to make ends meet. Many struggle to afford nutritious food. According to the California Health Interview Survey, nearly 20% of low-income seniors in California are "food insecure" or an inability to secure adequate food. While a number of programs exist to increase resources for food, one of the largest remains severely underutilized: only 10% of eligible seniors participate in CalFresh and only 5% of eligible Social Security recipients in California participate in CalFresh. Since the creation of the Food Stamp Program, very few seniors have participated. In the 1970's, "Cashout" was established and since then seniors on Supplemental Security Income (SSI) in California have been prohibited from participating. This has meant a large segment of the senior population has been ineligible for quite some time while non-SSI (i.e., eligible) senior populations have been confused over their eligibility (especially those receiving other benefits from SSA). AB 69 Page 3 Since 1997, the federal government has required SSA to give SSI applicants the opportunity to file a food stamp application. This requirement and a general interest in increasing enrollment among seniors have led many states to develop and test the now proven successful strategies that have increased enrollment among SSI recipients. However, no such efforts have occurred to enroll recipients of Social Security. Why senior participation is so low : CalFresh participation is low across all populations, but there are clearly some unique barriers to participation among seniors such as transportation, a confusing application process, and the perceived stigma of receiving "charity." Despite some special rules for seniors the application process is still challenging for many. Other states have taken steps to make it easier for some seniors to participate. For example, many states operate Combined Application Projects (CAPs) to enroll elderly SSI recipients into SNAP (the federal name for CalFresh). Though SSI recipients in California are ineligible for CalFresh, the approaches used in other states may prove successful if applied to other California senior populations that are indeed eligible. Given that the SSA was the primary partner in the CAP projects in other states, the hope is that they could be enlisted in an effort to test strategies for enrolling Social Security recipients in California into CalFresh. This bill seeks to design and implement a simplified application process that would use the existing information within the SSA database to identify eligible CalFresh seniors and enroll them in a very streamlined fashion. If successful, counties could increase senior participation and obtain critical nutrition benefits for this vulnerable group. At the same time, the increase in participation would have the added plus of infusing much needed economic stimulus for grocery stores, farmers, and related businesses involved in the growing, selling, and distribution of food. Indeed, this effect is recognized with the support from the California Farm Bureau Federation, California Retailers Association, California Grocers Association, and the California Restaurant Association. Positive fiscal effect of food stamp benefits : According to Moody's Investor Services, an independent provider of credit ratings and financial services research, CalFresh benefits have AB 69 Page 4 the highest economic multiplier effect out of all government programs or fiscal policy tools that stimulate the economy. Moody's finds that for every CalFresh dollar spent, $1.74 is generated in economic activity. (The U.S. Department of Agriculture finds this amount to be $1.84). Additionally, these benefits generate sales tax revenue for county and the state coffers. To the extent that this bill increases CalFresh participation, the state could expect to receive additional state General Fund revenue due to increased taxable purchases by recipients. This is possible because studies show that low-income families such as CalFresh recipients spend approximately 45% of their income on taxable goods. By providing these families with CalFresh benefits, 45% of the money previously used by the family to purchase food would now be used for purchasing taxable goods. Analysis Prepared by : Frances Chacon / HUM. S. / (916) 319-2089 FN: 0001021