BILL ANALYSIS Ó
AB 386
Page 1
Date of Hearing: May 18, 2011
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Felipe Fuentes, Chair
AB 386 (Galgiani) - As Amended: May 11, 2011
Policy Committee: HealthVote:15-3
Public Safety 5-2
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program:
No Reimbursable:
SUMMARY
This bill requires the CA Department of Corrections and
Rehabilitation (CDCR) to establish a telehealth program at all
state prisons by January 1, 2016. Specifically, CDCR:
1)Must include guidelines for determining when and where
telehealth is preferable.
2)Must be used only in the best interest of the patient.
3)Must ensure telehealth does not supplant civil service
physician and dental positions.
4)Must annually report to the Legislature regarding telehealth
objectives and performance.
FISCAL EFFECT
No new net costs or savings as this bill essentially codifies
current CDCR/federal medical receivership practice and planning.
The receivership estimates continued implementation of the
existing telehealth program could result in annual GF savings in
the range of $10 million. Telehealth is a significant component
of the receiver's ongoing prison health care "turn-around plan"
as well as the governor's proposal to reduce correctional health
care spending.
COMMENTS
1)Rationale . According to the receivership, the sponsor of this
AB 386
Page 2
measure, while this bill is not necessary for implementation
of the ongoing telehealth program, it is important to "to
ensure the sustainability of a cost-effective prison health
care system once the Receivership has returned control of
prison health care back to some State entity. By codifying
these nationally recognized standards of effective medicine,
the legislature will establish some oversight of the State
prison health care system in order to ensure that it does not
once again backslide to an unconstitutional level in the
future."
2)Telehealth , or telemedicine, provides interactive healthcare
via telecommunication technology. Telehealth allows patients
to visit with physicians live over video for immediate care,
or via recorded video/still images, patient data is stored and
sent to physicians for diagnosis and follow-up treatment at a
later time.
3)The CDCR telehealth problem, as stated by the receivership in
its October 2009 Utilization Management Project Charter, is
"the absence of strong leadership to nurture the program, as
well as insufficient expanded telemedicine infrastructure to
support a significantly expanded telemedicine program. The
Receiver will put in place strong leadership within the
telemedicine program with a direction to upgrade CDCR's
telemedicine technologies, assess and expand staffing as
appropriate and engage with the UC system and others to
establish a vastly expanded telemedicine program."
According to the receivership in its April 2010 Cost
Containment Report, telehealth will result in significant
savings in contract medical and medical custody transportation
and guarding as well as protecting public safety by having
fewer inmates in transit.
4)Background - The California Prison Health Care Receivership is
a non-profit organization created to house the activities of
the federal Receiver. The Receivership was established by U.S.
District Court Judge Thelton E. Henderson as the result of a
2001 class action law suit (Plata v. Schwarzenegger) over the
quality of medical care in the state's 33 prisons. The court
found that the care violated the Eighth Amendment of the U.S.
Constitution, which forbids cruel and unusual punishment of
the incarcerated.
AB 386
Page 3
In 2006, the court appointed the receiver to oversee the
delivery of inmate medical care within CDCR. According to the
Department of Finance (DOF) in a 2010-11 budget change
proposal, since 2006 the receiver has significantly increased
the number of clinical staff, clinician pay, access to CDCR
clinicians, and referrals to specialists and contracted
providers, which has resulted in the cost of inmate medical
services increasing from $883 million in 2005-06 to $2 billion
in 2008-09 with a moderate reduction in expenditures
anticipated in recent years.
5)Prior Legislation .
AB 1785 (Galgiani), 2010, was similar to AB 386 and was held
in this committee.
AB 1289 (Galgiani), 2009, which required CDCR to establish
guidelines and performance targets for prison telemedicine,
was held on this committee's Suspense File.
Analysis Prepared by : Geoff Long / APPR. / (916) 319-2081