BILL ANALYSIS Ó AB 1022 Page 1 Date of Hearing: April 5, 2011 Counsel: Kimberly A. Horiuchi ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY Tom Ammiano, Chair AB 1022 (Fletcher) - As Introduced: February 18, 2011 As Proposed to be Amended in Committee SUMMARY : Authorizes local enforcement to provide information available on the Department of Justice's (DOJ) Internet Web site of sex offenders, as specified, upon request, by email or other electronic notification. EXISTING LAW : 1)Provides that notwithstanding any other provision of law, and except as provided, any designated law enforcement entity may provide information to the public about a person required to register as a sex offender, as specified, by whatever means the entity deems appropriate, when necessary to ensure the public safety based upon information available to the entity concerning that specific person. ĘPenal Code Section 290.45(a)(1).] 2)Requires that community notification by way of an Internet Web site shall be governed by existing law, and a designated law enforcement entity may not post on an Internet Web site any information identifying an individual as a person required to register as a sex offender except as provided in that section unless there is a warrant outstanding for that person's arrest. ĘPenal Code Section 290.45(a)(3).] 3)Mandates DOJ make available information concerning persons who are required to register as a sex offender to the public via an Internet Web site, as specified. DOJ shall update the Internet Web site on an ongoing basis. All information identifying the victim by name, birth date, address, or relationship to the registrant shall be excluded from the Internet Web site. The name or address of the person's employer and the listed person's criminal history other than the specific crimes for which the person is required to register shall not be included on the Internet Web site. The AB 1022 Page 2 Internet Web site shall be translated into languages other than English as determined by DOJ. ĘPenal Code Section 290.46(a)(1).] 4)States that, on or before July 1, 2005, with respect to a person who has been convicted of the commission or the attempted commission of any of the offenses listed in, or who is described in, existing law, DOJ shall make available to the public via the Internet Web site his or her name and known aliases, a photograph, a physical description, including gender and race, date of birth, criminal history, prior adjudication as a sexually violent predator, the address at which the person resides, and any other information that DOJ deems relevant, but not the information excluded, as specified. On or before January 1, 2013, DOJ shall make available to the public via the Internet Web site his or her static SARATSO score and information on an elevated risk level based on the SARATSO future violence tool. ĘPenal Code Section 290.46(b)(1).] 5)Requires persons convicted of specified sex offenses to register, or reregister if the person has been previously registered, upon release from incarceration, placement, commitment, or release on probation. States that the registration shall consist of all of the following ĘPenal Code Section 290.015(a)]: a) A statement signed in writing by the person, giving information as shall be required by DOJ and giving the name and address of the person's employer, and the address of the person's place of employment, if different from the employer's main address; b) Fingerprints and a current photograph taken by the registering official; c) The license plate number of any vehicle owned by, regularly driven by or registered in the name of the registrant; d) Notice to the person that he or she may have a duty to register in any other state where he or she may relocate; and, e) Copies of adequate proof of residence, such as a AB 1022 Page 3 California driver's license or identification card, recent rent or utility receipt or any other information that the registering official believes is reliable. 6)Provides that willful violation of any part of the registration requirements constitutes a misdemeanor if the offense requiring registration was a misdemeanor, and constitutes a felony of the offense requiring registration was a felony or if the person has a prior conviction of failing to register. ĘPenal Code Section 290.018(a)(b).] 7)Provides that within three days thereafter, the registering law enforcement agency or agencies shall forward the statement, fingerprints, photograph, and vehicle license plate number, if any, to the DOJ. ĘPenal Code Section 290.015(b).] 8)States that a misdemeanor failure to register shall be punishable by imprisonment in a county jail not exceeding one year, and a felony failure to register shall be punishable in the state prison for 16 months, 2 or 3 years. ĘPenal Code Section 290.018(a)(b).] FISCAL EFFECT : Unknown COMMENTS : 1)Author's Statement : According to the author, "Megan's law Internet website provides registered sex offender information that can be accessed any time by the public. The public must actively seek out the information. There is no system notifying interested residents that sex offenders have moved in or out of given neighborhoods. That prompted the County to explore establishing a web-based subscription service by which residents could designate geographic areas and receive email alerts of changes to sex offender information within the specified areas. "However, California Penal Code sections 290.45 and 290.46 restrict local law enforcement's use of an internet website to disseminate information about registered sex offenders. These statutes allow a local law enforcement agency to post certain sex offender information only when the local agency determines, based upon specific information concerning that specific offender, that such dissemination is necessary to ensure the public safety. These sections even further AB 1022 Page 4 restrict the disclosure of a registered sex offender's address. In other words, current state law says that a sex offender's inclusion on the Megan's Law website does not, by itself, constitute justification for local law enforcement notification. These restrictions have been interpreted to apply to the County's plan for web-based subscription email alerts." 2)Purpose and Requirements of Sex Offender Registration : California was the first state to require sex offender registration in 1947. The stated purpose for sex offender registration is to deter offenders from committing future crimes, provide law enforcement with an additional investigative tool, and increase public protection. ĘWright vs. Superior Court (1997) 15 Cal.4th 521, 526; Alissa Pleau (2007) Review of Selected 2007 California Legislation: Closing a Loophole in California's Sex Offender Registration Laws, 38 McGeorge L. Rev. 276, 277; Hatton vs. Bonner (2004) 365 F. 3rd 955, 961.] Penal Code Section 290 requires life-time registration by persons convicted of specified sex crimes that reside in, attend school or work in California. ĘPenal Code Section 290(a).] Sex offenders are required to register annually within five working days of his or her birthday. ĘPenal Code Section 290(b).] If the offender has no fixed address, he or she is required to register every 30 days. ĘPenal Code Section 290.011(a).] A person is also required to notify law enforcement of any change of address within five days of moving. (Penal Code Section 290.014.) A person who fails to register as a sex offender within the period required by law is guilty of a felony punishable by 16 months, 2 or 3 years. ĘPenal Code Section 290.018(b).] In 1996, California enacted "Megan's Law" allowing the public to access an address list of registered sex offenders. Before 2003, members of the public could only obtain the information on the Megan's Law list by calling a "900" or visiting certain designated law enforcement agencies and reviewing a CD-ROM. However, in 2003, California required the DOJ to put the Megan's Law list of offenders on a public access Web site with the offender's address, photo and list of offenses. ĘSee Penal Code Section 290.46(a).] For some offenders with less serious offenses, only his or her ZIP code is listed. Now, a citizen can enter his or her address and see if there are registered sex offenders living in his or her community or even next door. AB 1022 Page 5 The registration statute does not distinguish crimes based on severity and instead requires all persons convicted of a listed crime must register annually within five days of his or her birthday and for the rest of his or her life. ĘPenal Code Section 290.012(a).] Although most registerable offenses are felonies, there some alternate felony/misdemeanor penalties and a few straight misdemeanors. ĘSee Penal Code Section 243.4 (sexual battery); Penal Code Section 266c (obtaining sexual consent by fraud); Penal Code Section 311.1, 311.2(c), 311.4, 311.11 (child pornography); Penal Code Section 647.6 (annoying or molesting a child); and, Penal Code Section 314(1)(2) (indecent exposure).] This bill authorizes local law enforcement to provide electronic mail (e-mail) updates to citizens who have submitted an email address of any information on DOJ's Web site. The information disseminated by local law enforcement is information available to the citizen on DOJ's Web site; there appears to be no expansion of the law. 3)Community Notification : Existing law authorizes law enforcement to notify the general public when a sex offender is returned to that community. Penal Code Section 290.45(a) states, "Any designated law enforcement entity may provide information to the public a person required to register as a sex offender, as specified, by whatever means the entity deems appropriate, when necessary to ensure the public safety based upon information available to the entity concerning that specific person." ĘPenal Code Section 290.46(a)(1).] As noted above, DOJ maintains a publically accessible Internet Web site where any person may simply enter an address and see where registered sex offenders reside within a specified distance from that address. ĘPenal Code Section 290.46(a).] This bill allows local law enforcement to notify members of the public of information and changes available on DOJ's Web site through e-mail to community members who request the information. 4)Argument in Support : According to the San Diego County Board of Supervisors , "Under current law, persons convicted of specified sex crimes are required to register as sex offenders with a local law enforcement agency. The California Department of Justice (DOJ) operates the Sex Offender Tracking Program, maintains the registered sex offender database and posts sex offender information on Megan's Law website. The AB 1022 Page 6 DOJ updates the database and website on a daily basis, based on information received from local agencies. Penal Code sections 290.45 and 290.46 specify in great detail the registered sex offender information that can be posted on Megan's Law website depending on the specific crimes committed and other factors. "The Megan's Law website is a valuable public service but members of the public must pro-actively seek out the information it provides. When changes in the database occur, such as a registered sex offender moving in or out of an area, the public is not pro-actively informed. Unless a person is continually monitoring the website, and recalls what information may or may not have been listed before, she or he would not know what sex offender information may have changed. Local law enforcement may only use the internet to provide registered sex offender information when the local agency determines, based on specific information concerning that specific offender, that such dissemination is necessary to ensure public safety. Local agency notification of simple sex offender residency changes is prohibited. "AB 1022 would change existing law and allow local governments to be able to use internet websites and email to actively notify subscribing members of the public of important Megan's Law database changes - especially changes in registered sex offender residency. This measure would use only information that is currently available via the Megan's Law website. Such a change would enhance community awareness of dangerous predators, improve community safety, and help parents keep their children safe." 5)Argument in Opposition : According to the California Public Defenders Association , "This legislation specifically authorizes the transmission of information about 290 registrants for purposes of community notification under Penal Code Section 290.45, to be upon request, by means of email or other electronic notification. And, any information that is posted on the Megan's Law website, under the proposed amendments to Penal Code Section 29.46(g), can be disseminated upon request, by means of email or other electronic notification. "As the law presently exists, anyone who has legitimate concerns can easily access the Megan's Law website and obtain the AB 1022 Page 7 information available about 290 registrants. As is, there have been instances of vigilantism as a result of the information being made available to the public. Indeed, Section 290.45(e) specifically provides for a five year additional consecutive term for anyone who uses information disclosed to commit a felony, and an additional penalty assessment for anyone who uses information disclosed to commit a misdemeanor. "Allowing individuals to make a onetime request and then be emailed every time data is updated on Megan's Law listing will breed hysteria and vigilantism. Further, stranger victim is not the typical risk. According to the U.S. Department of Justice, 86% of all sexual assault cases reported to law enforcement were committed by someone known to the victim - a family member or acquaintance (Bureau of Justice Statistics 2000). The U.S. Department of Justice reports that 93% of victims under the age of 17, and 73% of victims age 18 and older, were assaulted by someone they knew. Where they victim was a child, 34% of offenders were family members and 59% were acquaintances (Bureau of Justice Statistics, 2000). And perhaps even more on point, "The vast majority of sex crimes are committed by someone who is not on the Sex Offender Registry. During 2005-2006, approximately 94% of the persons arrested for sexual offenses in New York State had no prior sex convictions. As a result, these people would not have been on the Sex Offender Registry (New York Sex Offender Management Grant, 2007)." 6)Related Legislation : a) AB 755 (Galgiani) requires every registered sex offender to inform the law enforcement agency with which he or she last registered of all Internet identifiers or service providers and must sign a statement acknowledging this responsibility. AB 755 is pending hearing by this Committee. b) AB 757 (Blumenfield) authorizes any law enforcement agency to re-include a registered sex offender granted an exclusion from DOJ's Internet Web site where the agency believes that public safety may be compromised by the continued exclusion from DOJ's Web site. Upon receiving notice from a law enforcement agency requesting re-inclusion, DOJ shall notify the offender and thereafter AB 1022 Page 8 make information about the offender available to the public on the Web site within 30 days. AB 757 is scheduled to be heard by Committee today. REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION : Support Crime Victims United of California Peace Officers Research Association of California San Diego County Board of Supervisors San Diego County Sheriff's Department Opposition California Public Defenders Association Analysis Prepared by : Kimberly Horiuchi / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744