BILL ANALYSIS Ó AB 1082 Page 1 Date of Hearing: May 10, 2011 ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY Mike Feuer, Chair AB 1082 (Gatto) - As Introduced: February 18, 2011 PROPOSED CONSENT (As Proposed to be Amended) SUBJECT : Powers of attorney: statutory form KEY ISSUE : Should the same protections that are granted to non-statutory form powers of attorney be granted to powers OF attorney created using the statutory form provided in the Probate Code? FISCAL STATUS : As currently in print this bill is keyed non-fiscal. SYNOPSIS Under current law, there are two basic methods to create a power of attorney. An individual can fill out a power of attorney based on a form provided in the Probate Code, or he or she can create some other writing that meets certain formalities. The current protections against fraud and abuse in each method differ in significant ways. While powers of attorney created without using the statutory form grant general authority to an agent, under that method, an agent needs express consent to perform various activities that could involve significant transfers or abuse of the principal's assets. Currently, these protections explicitly do not extend to powers of attorney created using the statutory form provided in the Probate Code. Powers of attorney created using a statutory form allow a principal to choose what specific areas the principal would like to grant authority. Within each of these areas, an agent is granted wide ranging powers. Many of these powers do not require express consent in the power of attorney document itself as would be required under non-statutory form powers of attorney. To protect against the potential fraud and abuse that might arise from this broader authority, this bill, supported by the Trusts and Estate Section of the State Bar, seeks to extend the same protections that apply in non-statutory power of attorney to statutory powers of attorney. SUMMARY : Seeks to expand the same enumerated protections that AB 1082 Page 2 are extended to non-statutory form powers of attorney to statutory form powers of attorney. Specifically this bill : 1)Extends the provisions governing the authority of an attorney-in-fact (that currently apply to any power of attorney not created using the form provided in the Probate Code) to the statutory form power of attorney. Excludes provisions that grant non-statutory form agents general authority. 2)Revises certain powers of the attorney in fact that require express authority in the power of attorney document. 3)Provides that an attorney-in-fact under either a statutory form or non-statutory form power of attorney can modify, revoke, or terminate a trust as provided for in the trust document, only with express authority granted in the power of attorney instrument. 4)Specifies that the attorney-in-fact may reject, disclaim, release, or consent to a reduction or modification of a share in, or payment from, an estate, trust, or other fund, only with express consent by the principal. 5)Revises the attorney-in-fact's power under a statutory form power of attorney with regard to insurance, annuity, and retirement plan transactions and estate, trust and other beneficiary transactions, requiring express consent to change beneficiaries in these areas. 6)Revises the statutory form power of attorney to notify the principal that the power of attorney does not include all of the powers available under the Probate Code. 7)Provides that the authority of an attorney-in-fact's with respect to family maintenance is not dependent on any other grant of authority for the agent to make gifts on the principal's behalf, and is also not limited by any limitation placed on the agent's authority to make gifts on the principal's behalf. EXISTING LAW : 1)Provides that a power of attorney created without using the statutory form power of attorney grants the attorney-in-fact AB 1082 Page 3 (the agent) "all the authority to act that a person having the capacity to contract may carry out" on behalf of the principal (the person granting an agent the power to act on their behalf). These powers only extend so far as they have not been limited in the power of attorney to certain "actions, subjects, or purposes." (Probate Code Section 4261; all references are to this code unless otherwise indicated.) 2)Provides that an agent acting under a non-statutory power of attorney is not authorized to undertake the following actions unless expressly authorized in the power of attorney: a) Create, modify, or revoke a trust. b) Fund with the principal's property a trust not created by the principal or a person authorized to create a trust on behalf of the principal. c) Make or revoke a gift of the principal's property in trust or otherwise. d) Exercise the right to make a disclaimer on behalf of the principal. e) Create or change survivorship interests in the principal's property or in property in which the principal may have an interest. f) Designate or change the designation of beneficiaries to receive any property, benefit, or contract right on the principal's death. g) Make a loan to the attorney-in-fact. (Section 4264.) 3)Provides that the provisions listed in #2 above do not apply to powers of attorney created using the statutory form power of attorney. (Section 4260.) 4)Establishes a form that can be used to create a power-of-attorney that allows a principal to initial each area where the principal would like to grant authority to an agent to act on his or her behalf. (Section 4401.) 5)Provides within the powers enumerated in the statutory power of attorney form, the attorney-in-fact has broad powers to act including: a) The power to contract in any way with anyone to accomplish the purpose of a transaction. b) Execute legal documents the agent "considers desirable to accomplish a purpose of a transaction." AB 1082 Page 4 c) Or "Ŭi]n general, do any other lawful act with respect to the subject." (Section 4450.) 6)Provides that an attorney-in-fact can designate or change the beneficiaries to an insurance policy, an annuity contract, or a retirement plan. (Sections 4457, 4462.) COMMENTS : A power of attorney is an authorization in writing that grants an agent specified powers to act on behalf of the principal (i.e. the person who because of age or infirmity allows someone else to act on their behalf). (People v. Ranger Ins. Co (1994), 31 Cal.App.4th 13, 21); Section 4022.) The person to whom authority is granted to act on behalf of someone else is called the attorney-in-fact, or the agent of the principal. California law provides for two methods of creating a power of attorney. A power of attorney can be created by filling out a simple statutory form provided in the Probate Code (see Section 4401), or it can be created in a writing meeting certain formal requirements. (See Section 4121.) Under current law, different levels of protection against fraud and abuse apply to each method of creating a power of attorney. Although a power of attorney created without the statutory form grants the attorney-in-fact broad powers to act on behalf of the principal, there are important limitations to these powers. For example, unless the non-statutory form power of attorney expressly allows the agent to create or modify a revocable trust, make or revoke a gift of the principal's property, designate or change the beneficiaries to receive property or benefits, or make a loan to the attorney-in-fact, the agent is granted no power to do so. This serves to limit the ability of the attorney-in-fact to act in situations when the potential for abuse and potential to transfer significant amounts of the principal's assets are especially high. By statute, these same protections do not apply to a power of attorney created using the statutory form. On the statutory power-of-attorney form several specific powers are provided in a list. The principal who is creating the power of attorney then initials which powers he or she would like to grant to the attorney-in-fact (i.e. real property transactions, stock and bond transactions, tax matters, estate, trust and other beneficiary transactions etc.). Once these powers have been initialed on the statutory form, the agent has a broad range of powers to act within each area that has been initialed. For AB 1082 Page 5 example, they may contract with any person under that power, execute various legal forms to carry out the powers that are granted, reimburse themselves for expenditures made in exercising those powers, or "in general, do any other lawful act with respect to the subject." (Section 4450.) As already mentioned, agents acting under a statutory form are also granted significant other powers, such as the power to change the beneficiary on a life insurance, retirement, or annuity plan. Many of these powers could not be granted under a non-statutory power of attorney without express consent, and for the many principals creating a power of attorney without an attorney, it may not be clear to them that they are granting such powers. This bill extends the same protections that now apply to non-statutory powers of attorney to those created by filling out the statutory form. The bill alters the enumerated powers that can now be granted under a statutory form power-of-attorney to protect against potential abuses and significant asset transfers. For example, AB 1082 amends the powers of an agent acting under the powers of estate, trust, and beneficiary transactions category on the statutory form so that an agent would need express consent by the principal to reject, disclaim, release, or consent to a reduction or modification or reduction in a trust or other fund of the principal. Express consent would also be needed to create a trust. The bill also reigns in the powers now granted to agents under the statutory form power of attorney to change beneficiaries in insurance, annuity, and retirement plans of the principal. It also makes clear that no gifts can be made from the principal's assets without the express consent of the principal in the power of attorney form. To notify the principal that the powers being granted in the statutory form power of attorney are being limited, this bill also changes the language in the statutory form. This bill simplifies the provisions applying to both statutory and non-statutory powers of attorney by applying the same core protections to each type of power of attorney. It also remedies the potential for abuse that exists towards laypersons using statutory powers of attorney without the aid of an attorney. This approach is supported by various organizations and bar associations across the country. The Author Believes This Bill is Necessary to Protect the Wishes and Property of the Principal : According to the author of this bill, the purpose of AB 1082 is to "provide the same protections AB 1082 Page 6 in a statutory form power of attorney" that already extend to "all other powers of attorney under California law." This would ensure that "certain potentially abusive powers to dispose of the principal's property during lifetime or at death are not given to an agent" without an express grant of those powers in the power of attorney. The author contends that the difference in levels of protection between a statutory form power of attorney and other forms of powers of attorney creates two problems. First "Ŭi]n some cases, the statutory form power of attorney expressly includes powers that could not be given to an agent using a non-statutory form power of attorney unless the powers were spelled out in the power of attorney document itself." For example, some sections in the Probate Code could be read to allow an agent to designate or change a beneficiary on an insurance policy, annuity or retirement plan, a power prohibited in non-statutory powers of attorney unless express consent is given by the principal. (See Sections 4457 (d), (j) and 4462(b).) Second, the author contends that: Even where the statutory form does not expressly give the agent the power to dispose of the principal's property, the powers that are granted to an agent under the statutory form power of attorney are so broad that they might be used to carry out significant transfers. This includes Section 4450(b) that allows agents to "contract in any manner with any person" in relation to whatever categories of transactions that a principal has authorized on the statutory power-of-attorney form. According to the author, it is also "not clear whether an agent under the statutory form document could make a loan to himself or herself from the principal's property." Because the statutory form power of attorney is most often used without the help of a lawyer, the author contends that the use of statutory form powers of attorney without legal advice creates a greater potential for abuse. Without the aid of an attorney, the principal may "unintentionally grant his or her agent broader powers than the principal realizes or intends." Therefore, protections should be included under the statutory form powers of attorney so that a principal does not give AB 1082 Page 7 significant estate planning powers to an agent unless the principal specifically makes clear that he or she intends to do so. The author also notes that the National Conference of Commissioners on Uniform State Laws (NCCUSL) has adopted the same types of protections granted to non-statutory powers of attorney in California (Section 4264) but also extended these protections to statutory form powers of attorney as well as powers of attorney in general. These protections are reflected in the Uniform Power of Attorney Act, drafted in 2006, as well as laws in other states, including, Kansas, Missouri and Washington. A Growing Consensus Understand the Need to Protect Seniors From Misuse of the Power of Attorney : In preparation of the Uniform Power of Attorney Act, a nationwide survey was conducted by the Joint Editorial Board for Uniform Trust and Estate Acts to determine what provisions should be included in laws governing powers of attorney. The survey polled the elder state law sections of all state bar associations as well as several professional organizations that specialize in elder and estate law across the country. Of those polled, more than seventy percent reached a consensus that a power of attorney statute should require gift making authority to be expressly stated in the power of attorney, and include safeguards against abuse by the agent. It was based on these findings that the NCCUSL drafted the Uniform Power of Attorney Act in 2006, including enhanced protection for both statutory and non-statutory form powers of attorney. (See Prefatory Note, The Uniform Power of Attorney Act (2006), NCCUSL, available at http://www.law.upenn.edu/bll/archives/ulc/dpoaa/2008_final.htm.) Author's Amendment : In order to ensure that individuals using the statutory form understand that if they want to add certain powers to their agents they must separately list those powers, the author rightly proposes to amend the statutory form as follows: On page 4, first paragraph, delete "The powers granted by this document do not include all powers that are available under the Probate Code" and insert: The powers listed in this document do not include all powers that are available under the Probate Code. Additional powers available under the AB 1082 Page 8 Probate Code may be added by specifically listing them under the Special Instructions section of this document ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT : In support of this bill the Trust and Estates Section of the State Bar of California writes: This bill would extend important protections that are already provided for under California's power of attorney law to statutory form powers of attorney?California law allows an individual to use a power of attorney to grant very broad authority to an agent to act on the principal's behalf. However, California Probate Code § 4264 lists certain actions that are so important, or so subject to possible abuse, that they cannot be authorized in a power of attorney unless they are specifically spelled out in the power of attorney document. These restrictions generally involve the ability to dispose of the principal's property, such as the ability to make a gift, to disclaim assets, to make or change a beneficiary designation (such as on a life insurance or annuity policy or a retirement plan) or to change survivorship interests in the principal's property, or to make, amend or revoke a trust?. These types of actions are especially susceptible to abuse, if the agent uses these powers to benefit himself or herself?. Probate Code § 4264 requires that those powers be expressly stated in the power of attorney so that the principal will have an opportunity to consider and make an informed decision about whether to give the agent the power to take those particular actions? These important protections under California law do not presently apply to statutory form powers of attorney. There is no reason why individuals who use the statutory form power of attorney should not be given then same protections that apply to any other person who grants a power of attorney in California. Indeed, because the statutory form power of attorney is most often used by lay persons without legal advice, it is particularly important that the simplified statutory form not grant very broad powers to an agent without the principal's knowledge or informed consent. An individual signing a per-printed statutory power of attorney form would have no way of knowing just from reading the form that checking the boxes for particular powers, or checking "all of the above," might give the agent the power to make gifts to the agent AB 1082 Page 9 or others, or the power to change the beneficiary designations for the principal's life insurance or IRA. ŬThe Trusts and Estates Section of the State Bar of California] therefore supports AB 1082 and believes that its enactment will provide important additional safeguards for all Californians, including those who choose to use the simplified statutory form power of attorney to plan for incapacity and carry out their personal and financial goals. REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION : Support Trust and Estates Section of the State Bar of California Opposition None on file Analysis Prepared by : Drew Liebert and Travis Brooks / JUD. / (916) 319-2334