BILL ANALYSIS Ó
SB 901
Page 1
Date of Hearing: August 24, 2012
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON REVENUE AND TAXATION
Felipe Fuentes, Chair
SB 901 (Steinberg) - As Amended: August 22, 2012
Majority vote. Fiscal committee.
SUBJECT : California Opportunity and Prosperity Act:
undocumented immigrants: state income taxes
SUMMARY : Enacts the California Opportunity and Prosperity Act
(COPA). Specifically, this bill :
1)Establishes a voluntary program (Program) to be administered
by the Department of Justice (DOJ) until January 1, 2018.
2)Provides that a "qualified person" may participate in the
Program, as specified. Specifically, a "qualified person's"
written application for the Program admission shall be made as
prescribed by the DOJ. The application shall include a
photograph or other electronically transmissible image of the
applicant. Upon receiving an application, the DOJ shall
determine whether the applicant meets the definition of a
"qualified person."
3)Defines a "qualified person" as a natural person who:
a) Is not eligible to receive a social security number;
b) Files a state income tax return, with a valid individual
taxpayer identification (ID) number, for the most recent
taxable year that a return is required;
c) Is not employed by a federal or state public entity, as
defined;
d) Declares that he/she is able to speak and understand
English or is enrolled in, or has applied to enroll in, an
English-as-a-second-language class;
e) Has not been convicted of a felony;
f) Is not a member or suspected member of a terrorist
organization, as specified;
SB 901
Page 2
g) Is not a public charge within the meaning of federal
law;
h) Declares that he/she has been a continuous resident of
California since at least January 1, 2008;
i) Consents to a background check and the disclosure of any
information necessary to confirm Program eligibility; and,
j) Consents to the disclosure of his/her name and federal
taxpayer ID to the Franchise Tax Board (FTB), as specified.
4)Provides that the language requirement specified above shall
not apply to any person who:
a) Is unable to speak or understand English because of a
physical or developmental disability or mental impairment;
b) Is over 50 years old and has been living in the United
States (U.S.) for at least 20 years; or,
c) Is over 55 years old and has been living in the U.S. for
at least 15 years.
5)Provides that if the DOJ determines that an applicant meets
the definition of a qualified person, the DOJ shall admit the
applicant into the Program and shall provide the applicant
with a confirmation of admission, which shall be valid for one
year.
6)Requires the DOJ to renew a person's Program admission
annually upon payment of a renewal application fee and a
demonstration that the person continues to meet the definition
of a qualified person.
7)Requires the DOJ to charge each Program applicant a fee or
annual renewal fee sufficient to cover the agency's reasonable
administrative costs, including startup costs and costs
associated with confirming Program eligibility.
8)Provides that, on or before December 31, 2013, and on or
before December 31 of each successive year, until January 1,
2018, the DOJ shall provide the FTB with the name and federal
SB 901
Page 3
taxpayer ID number of each qualified person admitted into the
Program during that calendar year. The FTB, in turn, shall
use this information solely to prepare a mandated report, and
shall not disclose the information for any purpose, unless
expressly provided by this bill.
9)Provides that, on or before December 31, 2014, and on or
before December 31 of each successive year, until January 1,
2019, the FTB shall submit a report to the Legislature that
details the tax receipts collected during the immediately
preceding taxable year from qualified persons who participated
in the Program. This report shall not contain any information
that identifies any specific qualified person.
10)Provides that any information disclosed by a Program
applicant or participant shall be used solely to administer
the Program and for no other purpose.
11)Specifies that any record containing any identifying
information of a Program applicant or participant shall not be
disclosed for any purpose, except as provided, to the extent
necessary to enforce a liability under the Revenue and
Taxation Code or the Family Code, or as otherwise required by
federal or state law. Provides that if identifying
information is disclosed for an authorized purpose, the
recipient "shall use the information solely for that purpose
and shall not disseminate the information any further."
12)Provides that all identifying information shall be
confidential and exempt from disclosure under the California
Public Records Act.
13)Authorizes both the DOJ and FTB to adopt regulations
necessary to implement the Program.
14)Provides that, on January 1, 2019, or as soon thereafter as
practicable, all Program records containing any identifying
information shall be destroyed, including Program applications
and records provided to the FTB. This provision, however,
shall not obligate the FTB to destroy any tax returns or other
records necessary to conduct an audit or appeal or to process
any taxpayer claim for refund.
15)Specifies that the above provisions shall automatically
sunset on January 1, 2020.
SB 901
Page 4
16)Provides that, on or after July 1, 2013, the Governor is
"authorized and directed" to submit, as a ministerial act on
behalf of the state, a request to the President asking the
President to direct the Department of Homeland Security
(DHS), the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), and
other relevant federal agencies not to expend resources during
the Program's operation Ýon] either of the following:
a) The apprehension, detention, or removal of a qualified
person in the Program or the qualified person's spouse or
eligible dependent, unless the qualified person, spouse or
eligible dependent meets one of the priority enforcement
criteria set forth in the then-existing ICE policy on civil
immigration enforcement; or,
b) The prosecution of a person, for employing a qualified
person, pursuant to 8 U.S. Code Section 1324a.
17)Provides that, on or after July 1, 2013, the Governor is
further authorized and directed, as a ministerial act on
behalf of the state, to request that the President provide any
available waivers, exemptions, or authorizations necessary to
provide a safe harbor for individuals and businesses from
federal civil and criminal liability arising out of a
qualified person's participation in the Program or the
employment of a qualified person.
18)Specifies that this bill's provisions are severable. If any
provision or its application is held invalid, that invalidity
shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be
given effect.
EXISTING FEDERAL LAW :
1)Regulates immigration pursuant to the Immigration and
Nationality Act (INA), which governs the rights, duties, and
obligations associated with being an alien in the U.S. The
INA also governs issues such as length of stay, and specifies
which aliens may become legal citizens.
2)Provides, per Presidential directive, that individuals who
demonstrate that they meet specified criteria will be
eligible, on a case by case basis, for deferred action with
respect to deportation.
SB 901
Page 5
3)Defines "terrorist activity" as any activity that is unlawful
under the laws of the place where it is committed and which
involves certain specified acts, including the high-jacking or
sabotage of any conveyance, or the seizing or detaining of
another individual to compel a third party to do or abstain
from doing any act as a condition for the individual's
release.
4)Deems inadmissible any alien who, in the opinion of the
consular officer at the time of application for a visa, or in
the opinion of the Attorney General (AG) at the time of
application for admission or adjustment of status, is likely
at any time to become a public charge.
EXISTING STATE LAW :
1)Creates within state government the DOJ, under the direction
and control of the AG.
2)Requires the FTB to, among other things, administer personal
and corporation income tax laws and certain other nontax
programs, including the collection of specified delinquent
debt.
FISCAL EFFECT : Unknown. According to the FTB, this measure
would not impact state revenues, and would likely result in
minor fiscal costs. According to the Legislative Analyst's
Office analysis of a similar ballot initiative, the measure
would result in an unknown net change in annual state tax
revenues through fiscal year (FY) 2017-18, but probably without
a significant impact on overall General Fund (GF) revenues, and
annual state administrative costs through FY 2017-18 in the
hundreds of thousands or low millions of dollars, supported by
required participant fees.
COMMENTS :
1)Author's Statement : The author has provided the following
statement in support of this bill:
"SB 901 gives qualified unauthorized residents who pay state
income taxes the option to enter a program whose participants
may gain relief from federal enforcement and whose labor may
be decriminalized. In these difficult economic times, this
SB 901
Page 6
program will also generate $325 million in new revenue as more
undocumented workers start filing taxes in hopes of enrolling
in the program."
2)Arguments in Support : Proponents of this measure argue that
"SB 901 is a common sense policy that benefits responsible
immigrants and the state of California by potentially
generating over $300 million in new state taxes for the
general fund." Proponents also state that this measure
"establishes a framework for long-term law-abiding California
resident undocumented taxpayers that will bring them out of
the shadows and allow them to contribute to our state."
Finally, proponents believe that more than one million hard
working immigrants and business owners "would finally be able
to pay hundreds of millions of dollars in taxes that can be
used to invest in education, law enforcement, and health
services and upon federal agreement receive exemption from
federal enforcement and sanctions."
3)The COPA : SB 901 proposes an innovative approach to increase
tax compliance by encouraging undocumented immigrants to file
their California income tax returns and pay their
corresponding tax liability. It creates a way for those
law-abiding undocumented immigrants, who pay their state taxes
and are certified as eligible by the DOJ, to potentially be
shielded from federal enforcement actions. Specifically, SB
901 establishes a voluntary pilot program, until January 1,
2018, to be administered by the DOJ, and allows eligible
undocumented immigrants to participate in this program. If
certified as eligible, the applicant will receive a
confirmation of admission, which will be valid for one year.
The benefits of participating in the Program include potential
relief from federal enforcement action for the participants,
their families, and participants' employers, provided the
Governor petitions the President, as directed by SB 901, and
the President agrees to grant relief. The Program is intended
to help long-term California residents who have not been
convicted of a felony, are not members of a terrorist
organization, and do not pose a clear risk to national
security. The eligibility criteria set forth by this measure
are similar to those outlined by J. Morton, Director of ICE,
in his letter addressing the factors that should be considered
by ICE personnel in exercising prosecutorial discretion (ICE
letter).
SB 901
Page 7
According to its Director, ICE is confronted with more
administrative violations than its resources can address, and
thus, must regularly exercise prosecutorial discretion in the
ordinary course of enforcement. "Prosecutorial discretion" is
"the authority of an agency charged with enforcing a law to
decide to what degree to enforce the law against a particular
individual." (ICE letter, p.2). Thus, on June 15, 2012,
President Obama issued an executive order that deferred
deportation action against certain young undocumented
immigrants, 30 years or younger. Deferred action is a
discretionary determination to defer removal of an individual
as an act of prosecutorial discretion, and does not confer
lawful status upon an individual. Janet Napolitano, Secretary
of the DHS, issued a statement explaining the exercise of the
agency's prosecutorial discretion in the case of certain young
people who were brought to the U.S. as children. Under the
program, eligible immigrants, who came to the U.S. before they
were 16 and have graduated from high school or served in the
U.S. military, are allowed to request permission to stay in
the country and simultaneously apply for a work permit for two
years. The DHS describes steps that immigrants will need to
take - including a $465 paperwork fee designed to offset the
program's cost - and explains that those immigrants will not
be granted citizenship. It is estimated that at least 700,000
young undocumented immigrants will be eligible for this
deferred federal action.
According to the Pew Hispanic Center, the estimated number of
undocumented immigrants in the U.S. was 11.5 million in 2011,
with 24% of those immigrants residing in California. The
power to regulate national immigration policy rests with the
federal government. Nevertheless, states have attempted to
impact immigration policy in different ways over the years,
both legislatively and through ballot initiatives. For
example, the State of California has, in the past, attempted
to deny public services to undocumented immigrants, while
expanding responsibilities for persons to investigate or
report individuals with an unclear or uncertain immigration
status (Proposition 187, 1994).
SB 901 does not seek to change federal immigration law per se,
nor does it provide a pathway to citizenship or any other
benefits. Instead, it is intended to influence the federal
government's exercise of "prosecutorial discretion." An
initiative establishing a similar program - the COPA - was
SB 901
Page 8
introduced last December. According to the author's office,
after the introduction of the initiative, legal counsel
informed the initiative committee that legislation was also an
appropriate means by which to pursue this policy.
Consequently, the committee decided not to pursue the
initiative.
4)What is a Taxpayer Identification Number ?: A Taxpayer
Identification Number (TIN) is a federal identification number
issued by either the Social Security Administration (SSA) or
the Internal Revenue Service (IRS), and is used in the
administration of tax laws. While Social Security numbers
(SSNs) are issued by the SSA, all other TINs are issued by the
IRS. A TIN must be provided on returns, statements, and other
tax-related documents.
To obtain a SSN, an individual must complete Form SS-5 and
submit evidence of identity, age, and U.S. citizenship or
lawful alien status. Generally, only noncitizens authorized
to work in the U.S. by the DHS can get a SSN.
The individual TIN (or ITIN), on the other hand, was
established so that taxpayers who do not qualify for a SSN can
still file taxes. An ITIN is only available for certain
nonresident and resident aliens, their spouses, and dependents
who cannot obtain a SSN. To obtain an ITIN, an individual
must complete and submit IRS Form W-7, which requires
documentation substantiating the applicant's true identity and
foreign or alien status. Each ITIN applicant must also attach
a federal income tax return to the Form W-7 or present
evidence to substantiate an exception to the filing
requirement. The IRS notes that ITINs are issued regardless
of immigration status because both resident and nonresident
aliens may have a U.S. filing or reporting obligation under
the Internal Revenue Code. As such, an ITIN does not
authorize work in the U.S. or provide eligibility for either
Social Security benefits or the federal Earned Income Tax
Credit.
5)Increased Tax Compliance : Since undocumented immigrants are
not eligible to receive a SSN, many of them are forced to work
"under the table." Advocates of SB 901 believe that this
measure will incentivize many undocumented immigrants who may
not currently pay their taxes to come into compliance with the
state's income tax laws, thereby increasing revenues to the
SB 901
Page 9
GF. According to the author's office, this measure may
potentially generate up to $325 million in GF revenues
annually. Committee staff notes that, since there is no
guarantee that participants will be relieved from federal
enforcement efforts, it is unclear how many immigrants will
decide to participate in the Program.
6)Implementation Consideration : SB 901 would require the FTB to
destroy documents related to Program participants, unless the
documents are necessary to conduct an audit or appeal, or to
process any taxpayer claim for refund. FTB staff notes that
this bill's language fails to address whether the information
could be maintained for purposes of collection. FTB staff
recommends, in order to avoid possible conflicts between the
FTB and taxpayers, to amend this measure to allow FTB to
utilize the participant information for purposes of tax
collection.
7)Double-referral : This bill was double-referred with the
Assembly Judiciary Committee. Should this bill pass out of
this Committee, please refer to the Assembly Judiciary
Committee's analysis of this bill for a more comprehensive
exploration of this bill's impact on immigration law.
8)Related Legislation : ACA 27 (Fuentes), introduced in the
2011-12 Legislative Session, proposes a similar voluntary
program to encourage undocumented immigrants to file their
state income tax returns and also directs the Governor, on or
after January 1, 2013, to request the President not to expend
any federal resources to detain or deport a qualified Program
participant, nor to prosecute a person employing such a
participant. ACA 27 was never referred to committee.
9)Suggested technical amendments : The author may wish to
consider the following technical amendments to this bill:
i) On page 5, line 15, delete "during" and insert "with
respect to"; and,
ii) On page 6, line 29, delete "of" and insert "on".
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION :
Support
SB 901
Page 10
Puerto el Triunfo Inc.
Central American resource Center (CARECEN)
Pueblo Y Salud, Inc.
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by : Oksana Jaffe & M. David Ruff / REV. &
TAX. / (916) 319-2098