BILL ANALYSIS Ó Senate Appropriations Committee Fiscal Summary Senator Kevin de León, Chair AB 184 (Gatto) - Statute of limitations. Amended: May 24, 2013 Policy Vote: Public Safety 7-0 Urgency: No Mandate: No Hearing Date: August 30, 2013 Consultant: Jolie Onodera SUSPENSE FILE. AS PROPOSED TO BE AMENDED. Bill Summary: AB 184 would extend the statute of limitations for fleeing the scene of an accident that caused death or permanent, serious injury, to one year after the person is initially identified by law enforcement as a suspect in the commission of the offense, or within the existing statute of limitations (in general, one year for a misdemeanor or three years for a felony from the time of the offense), whichever is later. Fiscal Impact (as proposed to be amended): Unknown; potential increase in state prison commitments and costs potentially in excess of several hundreds of thousands of dollars (General Fund). CDCR data indicates, on average, 65 new commitments to state prison each year over the past three years (2010-2012) under Vehicle Code (VC) § 20001(b)(2). A five percent increase in convictions would result in annual state incarceration costs of $180,000 (General Fund), potentially compounding to $360,000 for overlapping sentences based on serving a mid-term sentence of two years and full sentence credits. Potential moderate increase in state trial court workload to the extent the provisions of this bill result in additional prosecutions that otherwise would not have occurred under the existing statute of limitations. Three additional trials per year (based on the five percent increase in convictions noted above), would result in $60,000 (General Fund*) in additional court-related costs. *Trial Court Trust Fund Background: Existing law prohibits fleeing the scene of an accident. Under existing law, the driver of a vehicle involved in an accident resulting in injury to a person, other than himself or herself, or in the death of a person is required to AB 184 (Gatto) Page 1 immediately stop the vehicle at the scene of the accident, as specified. If a person flees the scene of an accident that results in death or permanent, serious injury, the person is guilty of an alternate felony/misdemeanor, punishable by two, three, or four years in state prison, in county jail for 90 days to one year, by a fine of $1,000 to $10,000, or by both imprisonment and the fine (VC § 20001(b)(2)). The statute of limitations requires commencement of a prosecution within a certain period of time after the commission of an offense. In this case, the statute of limitations would be three years after the commission of the offense (felony), unless it was charged initially as a misdemeanor offense in which case the statute of limitations would be one year. This bill provides that in addition to the existing statute of limitations, when a person flees the scene of an accident resulting in death or serious injury, the statute of limitations to file charges is extended to one year after a person is initially identified by law enforcement as a suspect in the commission of the offense, or the existing statute of limitations, whichever is later. Proposed Law: This bill would provide that notwithstanding any other limitation of time described, if a person flees the scene of an accident that caused death or permanent, serious injury, as defined, a criminal complaint may be filed within the applicable time period described in existing law or one year after the person is initially identified by law enforcement as a suspect in the commission of the offense, whichever is later. Prior Legislation: SB 387 (La Malfa) 2011 would have enacted the "Joshua Lacy Law," which would have extended the statute of limitations on the prosecution of the offense of felony hit and run from within three years to within six years. This measure was held in the Senate Committee on Public Safety due to its Receivership/Overcrowding Crisis Aggravation (ROCA) policy. AB 2484 (Davis) 2012 would have specified that a criminal complaint for vehicular manslaughter, when a person has fled the scene of the accident, may be filed within one year after the person is initially identified by law enforcement as a suspect in that offense, or within the existing statute of limitations (in general, one year for a misdemeanor or three years for a felony from the time of the offense), whichever is later. This measure was not heard in the Senate Committee on Public Safety AB 184 (Gatto) Page 2 due to its ROCA policy. Staff Comments: By extending the statute of limitations on the prosecution of the offense of fleeing the scene of an accident that caused death or permanent, serious injury, the provisions of this bill could result in additional prosecutions, court trials, and convictions with sentences to county jail and state prison. Based on CDCR data for the past three years (2010-2012), the average number of commitments to state prison under VC § 20001(b)(2) for convictions for felony hit and run is 65 commitments per year. Assuming a five to 10 percent increase in prison commitments due to the extended statute of limitations could increase annual state prison costs in the range of $180,000 to $360,000 per year, compounding to $360,000 to $720,000 based on overlapping sentences and a mid-term sentence of two years. To the extent the number of cases impacted by the extended statute of limitations is greater or less, the costs would be affected accordingly. California's prison system continues to operate under federal oversight as it addresses the issues of prison overcrowding and constitutionally adequate health care in its 33 facilities. On January 7, 2013, the state requested the court vacate or modify its order requiring the state to reduce the inmate population. The three-judge panel did not issue judgment on whether to vacate the population limit but issued an order extending the deadline for meeting the population limit from June to December 2013. On June 20, 2013, the three-judge panel ordered the State to immediately take all steps necessary to implement the measures in the Amended Plan, as specified, notwithstanding any state or local laws or regulations to the contrary, and, in any event, to reduce the prison population to 137.5 percent of design capacity by December 31, 2013, through the specific measures contained in that plan, through the release of prisoners from the Low-Risk List, or through the substitution of prisoners due to other measures approved by the court. While this bill independently may not impact the prison population significantly, considered collectively with all pending legislative proposals potentially exacerbating prison overcrowding, the effect of any future increases to the prison population creates significant General Fund cost pressure to the AB 184 (Gatto) Page 3 extent additional prison population growth potentially requires the state to utilize additional contract beds, out-of-state facilities, or capital outlay in order to comply with the court-ordered population limit. To the extent the provisions of this bill result in additional prosecutions and court trials, there would be increased workload on the courts. Based on a daily court rate of $4,000 (8 hours of court time) and a one week trial, an additional three to six court trials per year (associated with the five to 10 percent increase in state prison commitments noted above) would cost in the range of $60,000 to $120,000 per year. Proposed author amendments would limit the statute of limitations to no later than six years after the commission of the offense.