BILL ANALYSIS Ó AB 541 Page 1 Date of Hearing: April 15, 2013 ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON TRANSPORTATION Bonnie Lowenthal, Chair AB 541 (Daly) - As Introduced: February 20, 2013 SUBJECT : Illuminated signs on public transit buses SUMMARY : Establishes a pilot program for the University of California at Irvine (Irvine), allowing their transit buses to advertise on their side-mounted illuminated signs until January 1, 2019. Specifically, this bill : 1)Authorizes, until January 1, 2019, Irvine to establish a pilot program allowing their publicly-owned transit buses to be equipped with illuminated signs that display advertisements. 2)Establishes conditions governing the use of illuminated display advertising signs including: a) Signs shall emit diffused non-glaring light; b) Signs shall not be greater than 4,464 square inches in area; c) Signs shall not be installed in a position that interferes with the visibility of required lamps, reflectors, or other devices; d) Signs shall not be forward or backward facing (i.e., not on the front or rear of the bus); and, e) Light emitting diodes for illumination may include red provided the colored formed by the mixing of light from the diodes in the advertising is not red. 1)Prohibits buses from using the streaming or paging mode for the illuminated signs when the vehicles are operated on state freeways. 2)Requires Irvine to submit a specified report to the Legislature by July 1, 2018, on the viability of advertisement sales of the illuminated signs. 3)Limits the number of buses with illuminated signs to 25 for AB 541 Page 2 two years, after which Irvine may increase the total number to 30. 4)Sunsets the provisions of this bill on January 1, 2019. EXISTING LAW : 1)Establishes, until January 1, 2017, a pilot program for the City of Santa Monica (Santa Monica) allowing their transit buses to advertise on their side-mounted illuminated signs. Establishes the specifications and prohibitions of the illuminated signs. Prohibits the buses from using the streaming or paging mode for the illuminated signs when the vehicles are operated on state freeways. Requires Santa Monica to submit a report to the Legislature by July 1, 2016, on the incidence of adverse impacts, if any. 2)Authorizes buses, operated by a publicly-owned transit system on regularly scheduled service to be equipped with illuminated destination signs. 3)Authorizes dynamic messaging on all illuminated signs if the practice adheres to prescribed requirements. 4)Defines "lighting equipment" as an illuminated sign installed on a bus that utilizes an electronic display to convey the route designation, route number, run number, or any combination thereof. FISCAL EFFECT : Unknown COMMENTS : Public transit agencies have long used static signs placed on the sides of buses to display advertising. Transit agencies receive revenue from firms that use the signs for advertising. A project sponsored by the Transit Cooperative Research Program, a joint venture of the Federal Transit Administration and the Transportation Research Board, identified the emerging media of digital bus advertising as a revenue stream for transit agencies. The digital signs are ultra-thin, lightweight, light emitting diode (LED) screens that can easily be mounted on the sides of buses. Digital advertising allows for customize advertising, including a rate structure that varies by the time of day, because the advertising being displayed can be managed remotely. AB 541 Page 3 It is, therefore, possible to render the advertising static when the buses are operating on freeways. According to the author, the Irvine Student Government Department has full oversight on the Anteater Express, the university's public transportation fleet. They anticipate that the revenue generated from advertisement sales will backfill budgetary cuts within their department. They believe that this bill "not only aims to fund much needed student services, but also highlights their entrepreneurial spirit and embodies sound public-private partnership." Legislation was enacted in 2011 (see following "Related bills" section) that allows the City of Santa Monica (Santa Monica) to use illuminated advertising on the sides of their public transit buses for a limited, five-year period. The Santa Monica transit staff expects the illuminated billboards to raise additional revenue for operating its transit system. Last year, their staff reported that its static advertising generates about $4.1 million annually, but expect the digital signs to increase its advertising revenue to about $8 million. However, in light of public transit agencies in other states selling digital advertising at reduced levels than anticipated, Santa Monica is readjusting expectations and moving slowly into this new business venture. Santa Monica staff report their intent to hire a consultant to help them determine how many signs to begin with and what they might charge to optimize revenues. Although existing law enables them to equip up to 25 buses with illuminated signs, because of the high capital start-up cost, Santa Monica may begin the program with only five signs to test its viability. The Santa Monica pilot study will look at the adverse impacts attributed to having the illuminated signs on their public transit buses. There have been many distracted driving studies conducted by a variety of constituencies and focused on a number of potential distractions. There are studies that use data to prove illuminated billboards do not lead to negative outcomes, and other studies that refute these conclusions. Nearly all studies admit that, in most instances, it is very difficult to identify one single factor that led to an adverse incident such as an automobile accident. Research tends to show that accidents arise from an accumulation of factors, including distractions in the vehicle and outside, weather conditions, and even within the driver's mind. Allowing Irvine to participate AB 541 Page 4 in this pilot program at this time will provide policymakers with additional information on the impacts of this program on driver safety especially if Santa Monica's program is either slow or unable to develop. This bill is modeled after prior legislation and provides Irvine with the authorization to implement a digital advertising pilot program for their campus and surrounding areas. Further, it is believed that since the two locations (Santa Monica and Irvine) are sufficiently apart and the localized transit routes do not overlap, the selling of ads for the digital displays by either transit entity should not be adversely affected. Suggested amendment : The existing statutory reporting requirements of AB 607 (Brownley), Chapter 529, Statutes of 2011, imposed on Santa Monica that requires them to provide a safety report on the incidence of adverse impacts due to the utilization of LED advertising signs on their transit buses, should replace AB 541's existing requirement of Irvine to report on the economic viability of LED advertising. The author has agreed to accept this amendment. Related bills : AB 1984 (Wagner), of 2012, a similar bill that passed this committee but subsequently failed passage in the Senate Transportation and Housing Committee for reasons that the results of the existing pilot program should be consulted prior to the program being expanded for other public transit entities. AB 2375 (Knight), of 2012, would have authorized, until January 1, 2018, a pilot program for Antelope Valley Transit Authority to use illuminated signs for advertising on their public transit buses. That bill was held in the Senate Transportation and Housing Committee for reasons similar to AB 1984. SB 1295 (Huff), of 2012, would have allowed local school districts to advertise on the exterior of the yellow school buses. That bill passed the Senate Transportation and Housing Committee but failed passage in the Senate Education Committee. AB 607 (Brownley), Chapter 529, Statutes of 2011, established a pilot program for the City of Santa Monica allowing their transit buses to use illuminated signs for purposes of advertising. Requires the city to report on the program by July AB 541 Page 5 1, 2016. REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION : Support None on file Opposition None on file Analysis Prepared by : Ed Imai / TRANS. / (916) 319-2093