BILL ANALYSIS Ó ----------------------------------------------------------------- |SENATE RULES COMMITTEE | AB 759| |Office of Senate Floor Analyses | | |1020 N Street, Suite 524 | | |(916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) | | |327-4478 | | ----------------------------------------------------------------- THIRD READING Bill No: AB 759 Author: Daly (D) Amended: 1/14/14 in Senate Vote: 27 - Urgency PRIOR VOTES NOT RELEVANT SENATE BUSINESS, PROF. & ECON. DEV. COMM : 9-0, 1/13/14 AYES: Lieu, Block, Corbett, Galgiani, Hernandez, Hill, Padilla, Wyland, Yee NO VOTE RECORDED: Vacancy SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE : Senate Rule 28.8 SUBJECT : Alarm companies SOURCE : ADT Security Services DIGEST : This bill expands the locksmith license exemption to include a person registered with the Bureau of Security and Investigative Services (BSIS), pursuant to the Alarm Company Act, if the duties of the person that constitute locksmithing are ancillary to the primary duties and functions of an alarm agent. ANALYSIS : Existing law: 1.Licenses and regulates alarm companies and employees, CONTINUED AB 759 Page 2 locksmith companies and locksmiths, security guards, proprietary private security employers and officers, private investigators, private patrol operators, and repossession agencies and their employees by the BSIS within the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA). 2.Licenses and regulates locksmiths and registers employees of locksmiths by the BSIS by: A. Defining "locksmith" to mean any person who, for any consideration or compensation, engages in the business of rekeying, installing, repairing, opening or modifying locks, or who originates keys for locks, including electronic cloning of transponder keys and any other electronic programming of automotive keys and electronic operating devices, such as key fobs, door and ignition key devices, and successive electronic and other high-security key technology. A "locksmith" does not mean a person whose activities are limited to making a duplicate key from an existing key. B. Prohibiting a person from engaging in the activities of a locksmith unless he/she holds a valid locksmith license, is registered under the locksmith law, or is exempt from the provisions of the locksmith law. C. Exempting from locksmith licensing and regulation certain individuals and practices, including, but not limited to, tow truck operators, retail services limited to rekeying and recombination of locks, law enforcement officers, firefighters, emergency medical personnel, and new motor vehicle dealers. D. Further exempting from locksmith licensing a person registered with the BSIS as an employee of a repossessor, if the duties constituting locksmithing are ancillary to the primary duties and functions of the person's position. 1.Licenses and regulates repossession agencies, as defined, repossessors, and repossessor qualified managers by BSIS under the Collateral Recovery Act. 2.Licenses and regulates alarm company operators and certifies CONTINUED AB 759 Page 3 and registers employees of alarm companies, including alarm agents, under the Alarm Company Act; defines "alarm company operator" to mean any person who, for any consideration, engages in business or accepts employment to install, maintain, alter, sell, monitor, or service alarm systems, or who responds to alarm systems, except for any alarm agent, as specified; and provides that a "person" under this Act means any individual, firm, company, association, organization, partnership, limited liability company (LLC), or corporation. This bill expands the locksmith license or registration exemption to include a person, who is licensed, certified, or registered with the BSIS, pursuant to the Alarm Company Act, if the duties of the person that constitute locksmithing are ancillary to the primary duties and functions of an alarm agent. Background The current issue in this bill relating to alarm companies carrying out certain locksmithing functions was raised late in the first year of this Session by the bill's sponsor. SB 1077 (Price, Chapter 291, Statutes of 2012) authorized an alarm company to be organized and licensed by BSIS as an LLC. In applying this new business structure, licensed alarm companies have ran into difficulty because of the crossover between the practice of locksmithing and alarm companies in installing and monitoring electronic surveillance systems that monitor door locks and allow the alarm company and/or the owner to remotely lock and unlock the doors of a building. Under the provisions of the Locksmith Act, only a licensed locksmith can install and maintain such a system. Therefore, in order for a licensed alarm company to install door locking devices in an alarm system, the alarm company must either obtain a locksmith license or employ or hire a licensed locksmith to carry out those activities. Initially, alarm companies licensed as LLCs, sought to become licensed as locksmiths; however, it was found that licensed locksmiths are not allowed to be organized as LLCs under the law. In addition, since the practice of locksmithing and alarm companies are both licensed and regulated by BSIS, both types of licensees must undergo criminal background checks by the BSIS. CONTINUED AB 759 Page 4 The proponents of this bill contend that requiring an alarm company to also be licensed as a locksmith, or to use a licensed locksmith is unnecessary and duplicative, since both are under the jurisdiction of the BSIS. In addition, proponents would suggest this bill narrowly addresses the issue by authorizing only those locksmithing functions that are ancillary to the primary duties and functions of the alarm company practice. Comments According to the author's office, alarm company operators and locksmiths are licensed and regulated by the Bureau of Security and Investigative Services. Current statue relating to alarm companies does not reflect the emerging home automation security market. Home automation security systems include the ability to control locks, turn off lights remotely, open and close window blinds, and adjust room temperature. Installation and altering of locking mechanisms is a major service component of these security systems. The author's office states, that whereas locksmiths must be licensed by the state, certain professions such as tow truck operators and repossessors are not required to do so. This bill will exempt alarm companies from being required to obtain a locksmith license if locksmithing is part of its service model. FISCAL EFFECT : Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No SUPPORT : (Verified 1/21/14) ADT Security Services (source) California Alarm Association OPPOSITION : (Verified 1/21/14) California Locksmiths Association ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT : The bill's sponsor, ADT Security Services argues: "Licensing requirements and other regulations should be commensurate with the responsibilities performed. In this case, we believe requiring alarm companies to also hold locksmith licenses is duplicative and unnecessary. AB 759 builds on an existing exemption within the Locksmith Law that CONTINUED AB 759 Page 5 was provided to the repossesser industry, because their work with locks is ancillary to their primary duties, just as they are for alarm companies. Alarm companies should continue to be fully licensed as alarm companies, but we do not believe that they should need a second, duplicative license from the BSIS to offer their products within the State of California." The California Alarm Association states: "The security industry is advancing in leaps and bounds. Many new security systems allow homeowners and businesses to control their security systems from their phones or other remote devices. Alarms systems, lights, climate controls, and door locks can now all be controlled remotely. Installing these new technologically advanced systems requires alarm companies to install new door locks. Technically this work could be construed to be locksmithing, which would require the alarm company to get a locksmithing license. However, securing a second license is redundant because both locksmiths and alarm companies are licensed by the BSIS and undergo the same background checks and other similar application processes. AB 759 would remove a costly and burdensome redundancy in the licensing process by allowing alarm companies to install new door locks as long as they are part of a new security system." ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION : According to the California Locksmiths Association, "The bill as now worded would exempt from the California Locksmith Act persons who are registered with the state as an alarm company employee if the person's duties are 'ancillary' to the primary functions of installing, maintaining or monitoring the alarm system. The term 'ancillary' is so vague that it provides an exemption that could be claimed by practically any alarm company employee." They further state, "There is no urgent need for the California Legislature to enact AB 759 as an urgency measure. Instead of the proposed expedited rush towards a new exemption from consumer protection, the development and implementation of new technologies in the field of home automation security systems support a thorough review of these technologies and the identification of appropriate protections for consumers who purchase these products and services. ? There is no finding that the California Locksmith Act is preventing consumers from promptly securing residential and business properties using alarm systems with automated locking features that warrants the AB 759-proposed exemption from the Act." CONTINUED AB 759 Page 6 MW:nl 1/22/14 Senate Floor Analyses SUPPORT/OPPOSITION: SEE ABOVE **** END **** CONTINUED