Amended in Senate June 25, 2013

Amended in Senate June 13, 2013

Amended in Assembly April 11, 2013

Amended in Assembly March 21, 2013

California Legislature—2013–14 Regular Session

Assembly BillNo. 1263


Introduced by Assembly Member John A. Pérez

February 22, 2013


An act to add Chapter 13 (commencing with Section 3599.50) to Division 4 of Title 1 of the Government Code, and to add Article 4.6 (commencing with Section 14146) to Chapter 7 of Part 3 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, relating to Medi-Cal.

LEGISLATIVE COUNSEL’S DIGEST

AB 1263, as amended, John A. Pérez. Medi-Cal: CommuniCal.

Existing law provides for the Medi-Cal program, which is administered by the State Department of Health Care Services, under which qualified low-income individuals receive health care services. The Medi-Cal program is, in part, governed and funded by federal Medicaid Program provisions. Existing federal law provides for increased administrative funding for translation and interpretation services provided in connection with the enrollment, retention, and use of services under the Medicaid Program.

This bill would require the department to establish the Medi-Cal Patient-Centered Communication program (CommuniCal), to be administered by a 3rd-party administrator, to, commencing July 1, 2014, provide and reimburse for medical interpretation services to Medi-Cal beneficiaries who are limited English proficient (LEP). This bill would establish the CommuniCal Program Fund in the State Treasury, which would consist of moneys dedicated to the CommuniCal program, to be used upon appropriation by the Legislature to the department solely to fund the CommuniCal program.

Existing law provides for the certification of administrative hearing interpreters and medical examination interpreters for purposes of administrative adjudications.

This bill would require the department to be the certifying body for CommuniCal certified medical interpreters (CCMIs), and to authorize other interpreters meeting specified requirements, including a screening test, to provide CommuniCal services. The bill would require the department to (1) develop, monitor, and evaluate interpreter competency, qualifications, training, certification, and continuing education, (2)begin delete commencingend deletebegin insert byend insert September 1, 2014,begin delete toend delete approve an examination and certification process to test and certify the competency of medical interpreters, and (3)begin delete toend delete maintain a registry of those persons who meet the requirements to provide CommuniCal services. The bill would require the department to establish the Community Advisory Committee for purposes of assisting the department in the above-described tasks. The bill would also require the department to establish and charge fees that do not exceed reasonable costs for applicants to take any department-administered examinations and be certified or authorized and listed in the registry, and would require the department, in consultation with the Community Advisory Committee, to adopt quality standards and medical interpretation certification requirements through regulations.

The Ralph C. Dills Act provides for employer-employee relations between the state and its employees, as specified, including, among other things, the right of state employees to form, join, and participate in the activities of employee organizations for the purpose of representation on all matters of employer-employee relations, as specified.

This bill would provide that CommuniCal interpreters would have the right to form, join, and participate in the activities of a labor organization of their own choosing for the purpose of representation of specified employer-employee matters. The bill would provide that CommuniCal interpreters would not be considered state employees for purposes of the bill, but would have the right to be represented by an exclusive labor organization of their own choosing for the purpose of collective bargaining with the state on matters of mutual concern, as specified.

The bill would provide that upon application by petition, authorization cards, or union membership cards of a labor organization adequately showing that a majority of CommuniCal interpreters in the state desire to be represented exclusively by that labor organization, and no other labor organization is currently certified as the exclusive representative, the Public Employment Relations Board shall certify and grant exclusive representation to that labor organization, and would establish other election procedures to be administered by that board.

The bill would require that any agreement resulting from collective bargaining be legally binding upon the state and committed to writing, and would further require that, upon the completion of discussions and collective bargaining, any agreement be reduced to writing and be presented to the appropriate administrative, legislative, or other governing body in the form of a binding agreement, resolution, bill, law, or other form required for adoption.

The bill would provide that, after the certification of a labor organization, the state shall approve and have deducted, upon authorization in the case of dues deduction, from the appropriate reimbursement or other payment to thebegin delete employeeend deletebegin insert members of the labor organizationend insert the monthly amount of dues or service fees as certified by an executive officer of the labor organization, and shall transmit the amount to the treasurer of the labor organization.

Vote: majority. Appropriation: no. Fiscal committee: yes. State-mandated local program: no.

The people of the State of California do enact as follows:

P3    1

SECTION 1.  

The Legislature finds and declares all of the
2following:

3(a) California has long been recognized as one of the most
4racially and linguistically diverse states; the state is home to
5residents who speak over 200 languages.

6(b) Approximately one in five Californians is limited English
7proficient (LEP) and identifies as speaking English less than very
8well.

9(c) Language access and the right to interpretation services is
10required under Title VI of the federal Civil Rights Act of 1964,
11the Dymally-Alatorre Bilingual Services Act of 1973 (Chapter
P4    117.5 (commencing with Section 7290) of Division 7 of Title 1 of
2the Government Code), the Knox-Keene Health Care Service Plan
3Act of 1975 (Chapter 2.2 (commencing with Section 1340) of
4Division 2 of the Health and Safety Code), Section 11135 of the
5Government Code, Section 1259 of the Health and Safety Code,
6and California civil rights law.

7(d) The demand for medical interpretation services by Medi-Cal
8beneficiaries is significant, with 45.2 percent of Medi-Cal
9beneficiaries speaking a language other than English.

10(e) The state will experience an even greater demand for
11language services as health care reform measures are implemented
12over the next few years and 35 percent of Californians expected
13to become newly eligible for Medi-Cal as a result of the federal
14 Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (Public Law 111-148)
15will speak English less than well.

16(f) In California, language assistance services are provided in
17an uncoordinated manner that lacks transparency and
18accountability, and a majority of services are currently provided
19ad hoc by family members and friends or untrained staff.

20(g) California has the opportunity to meet the growing demand
21early on by accessing millions of dollars in federal matching funds
22to provide medical interpretation services to LEP Medi-Cal
23beneficiaries.

24(h) Professional medical interpretation services help reduce
25avoidable medical errors and provider malpractice liability for
26physicians and other health care providers.

27(i) A coordinated program to offer medical interpreter services
28will improve health care outcomes for LEP Californians and help
29control health care costs that result from a lack of access to
30preventative and primary care.

31

SEC. 2.  

It is the intent of the Legislature to do all of the
32following:

33(a) Create the CommuniCal program, which shall provide
34reliable access to language interpretation for Medi-Cal beneficiaries
35who are limited English proficient.

36(b) Establish a mechanism for accessing federal Medicaid
37matching funds to provide a majority of the funding for the
38CommuniCal program.

P5    1(c) Enable trained and qualified interpreters to meet the demand
2for language services for a significant portion of the estimated
3 3,000,000 Medi-Cal beneficiaries with limited English proficiency.

4(d) Facilitate accurate and timely communication between
5limited-English-proficient patients and their health care providers,
6which will improve quality of care, reduce medical errors, increase
7patient understanding and compliance with health diagnoses and
8care plans, and reduce the cost of health care by eliminating waste,
9such as unnecessary tests and other care.

10

SEC. 3.  

Chapter 13 (commencing with Section 3599.50) is
11added to Division 4 of Title 1 of the Government Code, to read:

12 

13Chapter  13. CommuniCal Medical Interpreters
14

 

15Article 1.  Certification and Registration of CommuniCal
16Medical Interpreters
17

 

18

3599.50.  

(a) For purposes of this chapter, the following
19definitions apply:

20(1) “CommuniCal” means the Medi-Cal Patient-Centered
21Communication program established pursuant to Article 4.6
22(commencing with Section 14146) of Chapter 7 of Part 3 of
23Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.

24(2) “CommuniCal certified medical interpreter” or “CCMI”
25means an interpreter who has been certified pursuant to subdivision
26(b) of Section 3599.51.

27(3) “CommuniCal interpreter” means an interpreter who is
28authorized to provide CommuniCal services pursuant to Section
293599.51.

30(4) “Certifying body” or “department” means the State
31Department of Health Care Services.

32(5) “Community Advisory Committee” means the committee
33established pursuant to Section 3599.53.

34(b) Notwithstanding any other law, the State Department of
35Health Care Services shall serve as the CommuniCal certified
36medical interpreter (CCMI) certifying body. The certifying body
37shall do both of the following:

38(1) Develop, monitor, and evaluate interpreter competency,
39qualifications, training, certification, and continuing education
40requirements for medical interpreters.

P6    1(2) By September 1, 2014, in consultation with the Community
2Advisory Committee, approve an examination and certification
3process to test and certify the competency of medical interpreters
4pursuant to Section 3599.51.

5

3599.51.  

(a) As a condition of certification, an interpreter shall
6complete at least one of the following:

7(1) Pass an examination administered by a nonprofit organization
8selected by the department that is nationally accredited to offer
9certification examinations for health care interpreters.

10(2) Pass an examination developed by a state-established
11language testing and certification program that includes, at a
12minimum, both an oral and written component and the following
13competency standards:

14(A) A documented and demonstratedbegin delete proficiencyend deletebegin insert professional
15level of language fluencyend insert
in both English and the other specified
16language.

17(B) A fundamental knowledge, in both English and the other
18specified language, of health care terminology and concepts
19relevant to health care delivery systems.

20(C) Education and training in interpreter ethics, conduct,
21practice, and confidentiality. The department shall adopt standards
22in interpreter ethics, conduct, practice, and confidentiality
23promulgated by the California Healthcare Interpreters Association,
24the National Council on Interpreting in Health Care, or both.

25(3) Achieve the designation of Certified Healthcare Interpreter
26from the Certification Commission for Healthcare Interpreters
27(CCHI).

28(4) Achieve the designation of Certified Medical Interpreter
29from the National Board of Certification for Medical Interpreters
30(NBCMI).

begin insert

31(5) Hold a current interpreter’s certification pursuant to Article
324 (commencing with Section 68560) of Chapter 2 of Title 8 or
33Article 8 (commencing with Section 11435.05) of Chapter 4.5 of
34Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2.

end insert

35(b) Each interpreter who has met the requirements of subdivision
36(a), is listed on the CommuniCal Medical Interpreter Registry
37established pursuant to subdivision (e), and has been issued a
38certificate by the certifying body shall be known as a CommuniCal
39Certified Medical Interpreter (CCMI).

P7    1(c) (1) In addition to the certification process described in
2subdivision (b), commencing July 1, 2014, the department shall
3authorize CommuniCal services to be provided by an interpreter
4of languages of lesser diffusion or languages for which a CCMI
5examination has not been created. The department shall send an
6authorization letter to any person who satisfies the requirements
7of this subdivision.

8(2) The certifying body, in consultation with the Community
9Advisory Committee, shall authorize an interpreter to provide
10CommuniCal services if the interpreter passes a screening test that
11includes both of the following:

12(A) A written test, which need not be language specific, but
13which shall include the following categories of knowledge, skills,
14and abilities:

15(i) Managing an interpreter encounter.

16(ii) Health care terminology.

17(iii) Interacting with other health care professionals.

18(iv) Preparing for an interpreting encounter.

19(v) Cultural responsiveness.

20(B) An oral test utilizing the target language spoken by the
21interpreter to test his or her linguistic and interpreting skills.

22(d) Commencing July 1, 2014, in order to be eligible to provide
23CommuniCal services pursuant to Article 4.6 (commencing with
24Section 14146) of Chapter 7 of Part 3 of Division 9 of the Welfare
25and Institutions Code, an interpreter shall be certified as a CCMI
26or shall be authorized to provide CommuniCal services pursuant
27to subdivision (c).

28(e) The certifying body shall maintain a list of all interpreters
29who meet the requirements of subdivisions (b) and (c), which shall
30be known as the CommuniCal Medical Interpreter Registry.

31(f) (1) In order to meet anticipated demand for services under
32CommuniCal, the certifying body shall authorize an interpreter to
33provide CommuniCal services, until the interpreter becomes
34certified pursuant to subdivision (b) or receives an authorization
35letter pursuant to subdivision (c), if the person meets all of the
36following requirements:

37(A) The interpreter can demonstrate that as of January 1, 2014,
38he or she has workedbegin delete for a minimum of two yearsend deletebegin insert regularly and
39professionallyend insert
as an in-person medical interpreterbegin insert during the
40previous two yearsend insert
.

P8    1(B) The interpreter is at least 18 years of age.

2(C) The interpreter has a minimum of a United States high
3school diploma or General Education Development (GED), or its
4equivalent from another country.

5(D) The interpreter has demonstrated linguistic proficiency in
6English and another specified language.

7(2) In addition to the provisional authorization provided in
8paragraph (1), the certifying body shall authorize an interpreter to
9provide CommuniCal services, until the interpreter becomes
10certified pursuant to subdivision (b) or receives an authorization
11letter pursuant to subdivision (c), if the person graduated from an
12accredited medical interpreter training program at a college or
13university before January 1, 2014.

14(3) If an interpreter who is authorized to provide CommuniCal
15services pursuant to paragraphs (1) and (2) does not become
16certified or receive an authorization letter by December 31, 2016,
17he or she shall not be authorized to provide CommuniCal services.

18

3599.52.  

(a) The certifying body shall establish and charge
19fees, which do not exceed the reasonable costs, for applicants to
20take any department-administered examination offered pursuant
21to Section 3599.51. The certifying body shall establish and charge
22a single fee that does not exceed the reasonable costs for
23certification, authorization, and listing on the registry. The purpose
24of these fees is to cover the annual projected costs of carrying out
25this article.

26(b) Each CommuniCal interpreter shall pay a registry and
27certification or authorization fee, not to exceed the reasonable
28costs, for the renewal of the certification or authorization and
29continued listing on the registry. The registry and certificate or
30authorization fee shall be due on July 1 of each year.

31(c) The certifying body shall establish, maintain, administer,
32and publish annually an updated registry of CommuniCal
33interpreters. The certifying body may remove the name of a person
34from the registry if any of the following conditions occurs:

35(1) The person is deceased.

36(2) The person notifies the board that the person is unavailable
37for work.

38(3) The person does not submit a registry and certification or
39authorization fee or renewal fee as required by subdivision (b).

P9    1(4) The person fails to meet the quality standards and medical
2certification requirements established pursuant to Section 3599.53.

3(d) For the 2013-14 fiscal year only, the fee for certification,
4authorization, and listing on the registry as described in Section
53599.51 is waived.

6

3599.53.  

(a) The certifying body shall adopt quality standards
7and medical interpretation certification requirements through
8regulations, which shall include, but not be limited to, maintaining
9patient confidentiality and familiarity or experience working with
10medical terminology. It shall determine the testing requirements
11for certification in each language and create a list of those
12languages where standards permit registration of the interpreter.

13(b) For purposes of assisting with the tasks described in
14subdivision (a), the certifying body shall establish the Community
15Advisory Committee. The Community Advisory Committee shall
16include interested stakeholders that reflect the diversity of the state
17in terms of race, ethnicity, gender, sexual orientation, immigration
18status, and geography, including representatives of all of the
19following industries:

20(1) Government.

21(2) Health care providers, such as health care service plans,
22physicians, community and federally qualified health clinics,
23hospitals, or both.

24(3) Limited-English-proficient consumers.

25(4) Health care or language access advocates.

26(5) Medical or health care interpreters.

27(6) Any other expert or individual that the department deems
28appropriate.

29

3599.54.  

The exclusive representative of CommuniCal
30interpreters and a nonprofit organization, and the Community
31Advisory Committee shall partner to create and administer a
32training program for medical interpreters, in order to prepare
33interpreters for any department-administered examination offered
34pursuant to Section 3599.51 or other certification standards
35established for languages of lesser diffusion and provide continuing
36education for those CommuniCal interpreters placed on the registry.
37The Community Advisory Committee shall make recommendations
38on interpreter certification and services.

P10   1

3599.55.  

The relationship of CommuniCal interpreters to all
2parties and recipients of service is one of independent contractor,
3unless otherwise specified by law.

4

3599.56.  

Only CommuniCal interpreters shall be represented
5by a labor organization for purposes of collective bargaining
6pursuant to Article 2 (commencing with Section 3610).

7 

8Article 2.  Collective Bargaining for CommuniCal Certified
9Medical Interpreters
10

 

11

3610.  

(a)  CommuniCal interpreters shall have the right to
12form, join, and participate in the activities of a labor organization
13of their own choosing for the purpose of representation on all
14matters specified in this section. The state action antitrust
15exemption to the application of federal and state antitrust laws is
16applicable to the activities of CommuniCal interpreters and their
17exclusive representatives authorized under this article or other
18applicable law.

19(b)  CommuniCal interpreters shall have the right to be
20represented by an exclusive labor organization of their own
21choosing for the purpose of collective bargaining with the State
22of California on matters of mutual concern, including, but not
23limited to, the following:

24(1) Development, maintenance, and application of the registry.

25(2) The setting of reimbursements and rates for state-funded
26medical interpreter programs.

27(3) The allocation, process, procedure, distribution,
28methodology, and manner of payment of interpreter
29reimbursements and rates.

30(4) Professional development, certification and training,
31recruitment and retention of qualified interpreters, and language
32access quality standards.

33(5) Dispute resolution mechanisms binding on third-party
34administrators and their subcontractors of state-funded interpreter
35programs.

36(6) Mechanisms and funding to improve state-funded medical
37interpreter programs and the stability, funding, rules, regulations,
38and operation of state-funded medical interpretation programs.

39(7) Scheduling systems of interpreter services under state-funded
40interpreter programs.

P11   1(8) Mediums and modes of delivery of interpretation services
2under state-funded medical interpretation programs.

3(9) The improvement and expansion of quality medical
4interpretation services.

5(10) The collection and disbursement of established dues or
6fees to the exclusive representative of CommuniCal interpreters.

7(c) This section shall not apply to work performed as an
8employee of an employer.

9(d) The appropriate bargaining unit for CommuniCal interpreters
10shall be a statewide unit of eligible CommuniCal interpreters.

11(e)  CommuniCal interpreters are not public employees and this
12article does not create an employer-employee relationship between
13CommuniCal interpreters and the state or patient-centered
14communication brokers for any purpose, including, but not limited
15to, state employee eligibility for health or retirement benefits, or
16vicarious liability in tort.

17

3611.  

A labor organization as referenced in this section is
18defined as a labor organization described in Section 501(c)(5) of
19the Internal Revenue Code which has as its primary purpose the
20representation of public service providers in their relations with
21state and other public entities.

22

3612.  

Upon request by a labor organization that is signed by
2320 percent of CommuniCal interpreters, the certifying body shall
24furnish to the labor organization a list of all CommuniCal
25interpreters including full names, telephone numbers,begin delete emailend deletebegin insert e-mailend insert
26 addresses, and mailing or home addresses within five days of the
27request.

28

3613.  

(a) Upon application by petition, authorization cards,
29or union membership cards of a labor organization adequately
30showing that a majority of CommuniCal interpreters in the state
31desire to be represented exclusively by that labor organization,
32and no other labor organization is currently certified as the
33exclusive representative, the Public Employment Relations Board
34(PERB) shall certify and grant exclusive representation of the
35CommuniCal interpreters to the labor organization for the purposes
36set forth in this section.

37(b) Upon application by petition, authorization cards, or union
38membership cards of a labor organization adequately showing that
39less than a majority but at least 30 percent of CommuniCal
40interpreters desire to be represented exclusively by that labor
P12   1organization, and no other labor organization is currently certified
2as the exclusive representative, the matter to determine
3representation shall be set for a mail ballot election administered
4by PERB pursuant to its rules and regulations for administering
5elections. If a PERB regulation or rule conflicts with this section,
6this section shall control.

7(c) PERB shall accept, review, and certify all valid applications
8submitted pursuant to subdivisions (a) and (b) pursuant to its rules
9and regulations. If a PERB regulation or rule conflicts with this
10section, this section shall control.

11(d) Any representation election shall be a mail ballot election.

12(e) Within 10 days of receipt of an adequate petition,
13authorization cards, or union membership cards necessitating an
14election, PERB shall conduct a preelection conference with the
15labor organization and the state prior to scheduling an election for
16the purpose of clarifying issues, obtaining stipulations, executing
17a directed election order or consent election agreement, and taking
18other actions to expedite the process. The labor organization and
19the state shall engage in a good faith effort to reach a consent
20election agreement stipulating the parties to appear on the ballot,
21the form of the ballot, the CommuniCal interpreters eligible to
22vote, the rules governing the election, and the date, time, and other
23specifics of the mail ballot election. The state shall be represented
24by the Department of Human Resources and the State Department
25 of Health Care Services.

26

3614.  

No other labor organization shall be permitted to
27intervene in an election unless prior to the preelection conference,
28by petition, authorization cards, or union membership cards, the
29intervening labor organization adequately shows at least 30 percent
30of CommuniCal interpreters in the state as of January 1 of the year
31the application is made desire to be represented exclusively by the
32intervening labor organization.

33

3615.  

PERB shall proceed to determine all issues or matters
34in dispute. The determination and a directed election order or
35consent election agreement between the labor organization and
36the state shall be made within seven days of the conference.

37

3616.  

(a) PERB shall initiate a mail ballot election within 10
38days of the execution of a directed election order or consent
39election agreement. The election shall provide for an affirmative
40vote for employee representation by the petitioning employee
P13   1organization. The proposition receiving the votes of a majority of
2all valid votes cast shall win the election. Should no option receive
3an absolute majority vote of all valid votes cast, a runoff vote
4between the two options receiving the highest number of votes
5shall occur within seven days.

6(b) A preelection meeting shall occur with the labor organization
7and the state 30 minutes prior to the mailing of ballots for the
8purpose of resolving any final issues prior to the commencement
9of the mail ballot election.

10(c) The election shall be conducted in accordance with the
11procedures established and approved pursuant to the consent
12election agreement or directed election order.

13(d) The supervising official from PERB shall determine the date
14and time ballots must be received for tabulation, which date shall
15not be sooner than 10 days or more than 20 days from the date the
16voting commences. PERB shall be charged with validating the
17ballots against a list of CommuniCal interpreters provided by the
18begin insert Stateend insert Department ofbegin delete Human Resourcesend deletebegin insert Health Care Servicesend insert.

19(e) A labor organization certified by PERB as receiving a
20majority of all valid votes cast is the exclusive representative of
21all CommuniCal interpreters in the state for purposes set forth in
22this section. All CommuniCal interpreters who are eligible for the
23bargaining unit pursuant to Section 3610 subsequent to certification
24of the labor organization shall be part of the bargaining unit and
25represented by the certified labor organization.

26

3617.  

Discussions and collective bargaining between the
27certified labor organization and the state and its designated agents
28in the Department of Human Resources and the State Department
29of Health Care Services shall commence within 30 days upon
30certification and at any time thereafter upon request of the labor
31organization.

32

3618.  

The state and its designated agents in the Department of
33Human Resources and the State Department of Health Care
34Services shall be required to meet with the certified labor
35organization before any regulation is proposed, promulgated, set,
36or otherwise presented concerning any of the purposes for
37collective bargaining set forth in Section 3610.

38

3619.  

Any agreement resulting from collective bargaining shall
39be legally binding upon the state and committed to writing. Upon
40the completion of discussions and collective bargaining, any
P14   1agreement shall be reduced to writing and be presented to the
2appropriate administrative, legislative, or other governing body in
3the form of a binding agreement, resolution, bill, law, or other
4form required for adoption. Nothing herein shall prevent the parties
5from agreeing to and effecting those provisions of an agreement
6which have received legislative approval or those provisions which
7do not require legislative action.

8

3620.  

Nothing in this article shall affect the right of a
9CommuniCal interpreter to authorize a dues or service fee
10deduction from his or her reimbursement.

11

3621.  

(a) After the certification of a labor organization, the
12state shall approve and have deducted, upon authorization in the
13case of dues deduction, from the appropriate reimbursement or
14other payment to members of the labor organization the monthly
15amount of dues or service fees as certified by an executive officer
16of the labor organization and shall transmit the amount to the
17treasurer of the labor organization.

18(b) After the certification of a labor organization, the state shall
19approve and have deducted from the appropriate reimbursement
20or other payment to nonmembers a reasonable fair share service
21fee for the cost of representing them in negotiations, contract
22administration, subsidy rates, benefits, payment systems, training
23opportunities, and other matters related to those purposes listed in
24subdivision (b) of Section 3610. This fair share service fee shall
25not exceed the annual dues paid by members of the labor
26organization. The state shall transmit the amount of the fair share
27fee to the treasurer of the labor organization.

28

3622.  

Dues or fair share service fee obligations shall continue
29in effect as long as the labor organization is the recognized
30bargaining representative, notwithstanding the expiration of any
31agreement between the state and the recognized labor organization.

32

3623.  

(a) The state, through its designated agents in the
33Department of Human Resources and the State Department of
34Health Care Services, shall meet and collectively bargain in good
35faith with representatives of a certified labor organization and shall
36consider fully the proposals made by the labor organization on
37behalf of CommuniCal interpreters. “Meet and collectively bargain
38in good faith” means that the state and its designated agent and
39representatives of a certified labor organization shall have the
40mutual obligation to collectively bargain within a reasonable length
P15   1of time in order to freely exchange information, opinions, and
2proposals.

3(b) The state shall not interfere with, intimidate, restrain, coerce,
4or discriminate against CommuniCal interpreters due to the exercise
5of their rights under this section. A complaint alleging any violation
6of this section shall be processed as an unfair practice charge by
7PERB pursuant to its rules and regulations. The initial
8determination as to whether the charge of unfair practice is justified
9and, if so, the appropriate remedy necessary to effectuate the
10purposes of this section, shall be a matter within the exclusive
11jurisdiction of PERB. PERB shall apply and interpret unfair labor
12practices consistent with existing judicial interpretations of this
13section. If a PERB practice, regulation, interpretation, or rule
14conflicts with this section, this section shall control.

15

3624.  

Any charging party, respondent, or intervenor aggrieved
16by a final decision or order of PERB in an unfair practice case,
17except a decision of PERB not to issue a complaint in such a case,
18and any party to a final decision or order of PERB in a
19representation, recognition, or election matter that is not brought
20as an unfair practice case, may petition for a writ of extraordinary
21relief from that decision or order pursuant to Section 3520.

22

3625.  

Execution of a valid written agreement between the state
23and the certified labor organization shall bar the filing of an
24application or petition for certification of a majority representative
25for the length of the agreement except as otherwise provided in
26this article. No application or petition for certification shall be
27valid within one year of any prior certification.

28

3626.  

Should any court declare any other provision of this
29chapter void, invalid, illegal, or unconstitutional, the remaining
30provisions shall remain in full force.

31

3627.  

(a) The state shall not encourage or discourage
32membership in a labor organization and shall not discriminate
33against any CommuniCal interpreter on the basis of union activity,
34concerted action, union membership, age, sex, race, religious
35beliefs, color, national origin, sexual orientation, gender identity,
36or disability in accordance with and as required by applicable state
37and federal law. A CommuniCal interpreter shall not be subject
38to punitive action, or threatened with punitive action, for the
39exercise of lawful action as an elected, appointed, or recognized
40representative of any bargaining unit.

P16   1(b) Unless otherwise stated in this article, the state may adopt
2reasonable rules and regulations after consultation in good faith
3with representatives of a certified labor organization for the
4administration of CommuniCal interpreter employer-employee
5relations under this article. In the case of any conflict between
6rules and regulations enacted pursuant to this article, including
7those subdivisions adopting PERB rules, regulations, or procedures,
8the provisions of this section shall control.

9

3628.  

Nothing in this chapter may be construed to interfere
10with CommuniCal interpreter rights and responsibilities under
11federal law.

12

SEC. 4.  

Article 4.6 (commencing with Section 14146) is added
13to Chapter 7 of Part 3 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions
14Code
, to read:

15 

16Article 4.6.  CommuniCal
17

 

18

14146.  

For the purposes of this article, the following definitions
19shall apply:

20(a) “CommuniCal” means the Medi-Cal Patient-Centered
21Communication program.

22(b) “CommuniCal certified medical interpreter” or “CCMI”
23means an interpreter certified under the CommuniCal program
24pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 3599.51 of the Government
25Code.

26(c) “CommuniCal interpreter” means an interpreter who is
27authorized to provide CommuniCal services pursuant to Section
283599.51.

29(d) “Community Advisory Committee” means the committee
30established pursuant to Section 3599.53 of the Government Code.

31(e) “Department” means the State Department of Health Care
32Services.

33(f) “Medi-Cal managed care organizations” or “MMCOs” means
34all models of Medi-Cal managed care, including county-organized
35 health systems, geographic managed care, and two-plan models.

36(g) “Patient-centered communication broker” or “broker” means
37any third-party administrator for the CommuniCal program.

38

14146.10.  

(a) The department shall establish the CommuniCal
39program to provide and reimburse for certified medical
P17   1interpretation services to Medi-Cal beneficiaries who are limited
2English proficient (LEP).

3(b) Commencing July 1, 2014, CommuniCal shall offer medical
4interpreter services to Medi-Cal providers serving Medi-Cal
5beneficiaries on either a fee-for-service or managed care basis
6pursuant to this article. The department shall adopt policies to
7prohibit duplicate payments to CommuniCal interpreters and
8Medi-Cal MMCOs for beneficiaries enrolled in an MMCO, in
9consultation with the Community Advisory Committee.

10(c) A health care provider or entity entering into a Medi-Cal
11provider agreement or a Medi-Cal managed care contract with the
12state, including MMCOs and their subcontracting plans, and
13fee-for-service providers, may utilize CommuniCal to provide
14medical interpreter services to Medi-Cal beneficiaries.

15(d) All contracts between MMCOs and their subcontractors,
16including health providers and other health plans, shall include
17provisions describing access to CommuniCal medical interpreter
18services.

19(e) The department shall pursue all available sources of federal
20funding to establish and operate CommuniCal and shall seek any
21federal approvals necessary to implement this article, in
22consultation with the Community Advisory Committee.

23

14146.11.  

CommuniCal shall include the provision of
24in-person, telephonic, and video medical interpretation services
25begin insert by a CommuniCal interpreterend insert. To meet language access
26requirements and ensure patient safety, in-person interpreter
27services shall be the preferred mode of medical interpretation in
28the following instances whenever possible:

29(a) Family meetings regarding medical care.

30(b) Medical encounters involving difficult or agitated patients.

31(c) Medical encounters to make treatment decisions.

32(d) Obtaining informed consent involving review of documents.

33(e) Any medical encounter that, in the physician’s judgment,
34 requires in-person interpretation for the health, safety, or well-being
35of the patient.

36(f) Psychiatric encounters.

37(g) End-of-life discussions.

38(h) Other circumstances identified by the Community Advisory
39Committee.

P18   1

14146.12.  

(a) CommuniCal shall be administered by a
2patient-centered communication broker.

3(b) The department shall create and administer a competitive
4Request for Proposals (RFP), and shall execute the resulting
5contract.

6(c) The broker shall be responsible for all of the following
7duties:

8(1) Registering CommuniCal interpreters with Medi-Cal.

9(2) Verifying the eligibility of an interpreter to provide
10CommuniCal services with the State Department of Health Care
11Services.

12(3) Verifying Medi-Cal eligibility for interpreter services
13utilizing the state’s Medi-Cal Eligibility Data System (MEDS).

14(4) Submitting billing summaries to Medi-Cal, aggregating the
15cost for services provided.

16(5) Ensuring compliance with all Medi-Cal and applicable
17CommuniCal reporting requirements.

18(6) Making payments to CommuniCal interpreters, including
19any dues and service fee deductions.

20(7) Scheduling CommuniCal interpreter appointments with
21Medi-Cal providers.

22(8) Monitoring the quality of CommuniCal interpreter services
23and complying with state oversight requirements of the program,
24in consultation with the Community Advisory Committee,
25including determining the need for multiple brokers to administer
26CommuniCal.

27(9) Creating CommuniCal promotional materials for distribution
28to Medi-Cal providers, MMCOs, and beneficiaries.

29(10) Any other duties determined to be appropriate by the
30Community Advisory Committee.

31(d) The department shall make all applicable Medi-Cal reporting
32requirements known to the broker and shall be responsible for the
33broker’s compliance with these requirements.

34

14146.13.  

(a) Notwithstanding any other law, only interpreters
35certified or authorized pursuant to Article 1 (commencing with
36Section 3599.50) of Chapter 13 of Division 4 of Title 1 of the
37Government Code may participate in CommuniCal.

38(b) CommuniCal interpreters shall be responsible for all of the
39following:

P19   1(1) Performing interpreter services independent of other policies,
2rules, or procedures of conduct, except as provided by this article
3or by applicable law.

4(2) Performing interpreter services independent of direction,
5except as otherwise provided by this article and applicable law.

6(3) Preparing and submitting documentation to the broker in
7support of time worked or other services rendered.

8(4) Directing and controlling the manner and means of
9interpretation services, except as otherwise provided in this article.

10(c) Unless otherwise prohibited by this article or applicable law,
11 CommuniCal interpreters may do any of the following:

12(1) Advertise, promote, or otherwise communicate availability
13for services to clients and the general public.

14(2) Provide office space, equipment, support services, forms,
15supplies, and business cards, except as otherwise provided in this
16article.

17(d) (1) For purposes of the CommuniCal program, CommuniCal
18interpreters are not state employees. CommuniCal interpreters
19shall be independent contractors of the state.

20(2) For purposes of the CommuniCal program, CommuniCal
21interpreters are not employees of the broker, health care providers,
22or consumers.

23(3) The state action antitrust exemption to the application of
24federal and state antitrust laws is applicable to the activities of
25CommuniCal interpreters and their exclusive representatives
26authorized under this article or other applicable law.

27

14146.135.  

(a) The base reimbursement rate for CommuniCal
28interpreters shall be no less than sixty dollars ($60) per hour.

29(b) Reimbursement may be adjusted for factors, including, but
30not limited to, geography, language spoken, availability of
31interpreters, level of certification, travel time, or other factors, in
32consultation with the Community Advisory Committee.

33

14146.14.  

The department shall issue guidance on the
34administration of the CommuniCal program to ensure compliance
35with this article and all applicable state and federal laws by all
36contractors and subcontractors of the program, in consultation with
37the Community Advisory Committee.

38

14146.15.  

(a) The CommuniCal Program Fund is hereby
39created in the State Treasury. Notwithstanding Section 16305.7
40of the Government Code, any interest and dividends earned on
P20   1deposits in the fund shall be retained in the fund for purposes
2specified in subdivision (c).

3(b) Moneys in the fund shall consist of any funds dedicated to
4the CommuniCal program.

5(c) Moneys in the fund shall, upon appropriation by the
6Legislature to the department, be used solely to fund the
7CommuniCal program.



O

    95