BILL ANALYSIS Ó AB 1371 Page 1 Date of Hearing: April 22, 2013 ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON TRANSPORTATION Bonnie Lowenthal, Chair AB 1371 (Bradford) - As Amended: April 8, 2013 SUBJECT : Bicycles: passing distance SUMMARY : Sets requirements for safe passing of bicyclists by motor vehicles. Specifically, this bill : 1)Authorizes drivers on two-lane highways to drive to the left of double solid yellow or other similar pavement markings to pass a bicyclist proceeding in the same direction under certain conditions. 2)Specifies that if a driver who crosses to the left of double solid yellow or other similar pavement markings to pass a bicyclist is involved in a collision, the driver is solely liable for damages suffered by any person involved in the accident, regardless of roadway conditions. 3)Establishes the "Three Feet for Safety Act" that requires: a) A driver overtaking and passing a bicycle proceeding in the same direction on a highway to do so at a safe distance that does not interfere with the safe operation of the bicycle; b) A driver to provide three feet distance between the vehicle and the bicycle or its operator when passing; and, c) A driver to slow to a reasonable and prudent speed when passing a bicyclist if the driver is unable to provide the minimum three-foot passing distance due to traffic or roadway conditions. 4)Makes failure to comply with the "Three Feet for Safety Act" an infraction punishable by a base fine of $35. 5)Requires a $220 fine to be imposed on the driver of the motor vehicle who is found to be in violation of the "Three Feet for Safety Act" that a collision occurs between a motor vehicle and a bicycle causing bodily injury to the bicyclist. AB 1371 Page 2 6)Makes related, clarifying amendments. EXISTING LAW : 1)Provides that a person riding a bicycle upon a highway has all rights and is subject to all laws applicable to the driver of a motor vehicle. 2)Requires a bicyclist riding on a roadway at a speed less than the normal speed of traffic moving in the same direction to ride as close as practicable to the right-hand curb or edge of the roadway except: a) When overtaking and passing another bicycle or vehicle proceeding in the same direction; b) When preparing for a left turn at an intersection or into a private road or driveway; c) When reasonably necessary to avoid conditions that make it unsafe to ride along the right-hand curb or edge; and, d) When approaching a place where a right turn is authorized. 1)Generally prohibits a driver of a motor vehicle from driving to the left of double parallel solid white or yellow lines. 2)Defines a substandard lane width as a lane that is too narrow for a bicycle and a vehicle to travel safely side by side within the lane. FISCAL EFFECT : Unknown COMMENTS : According to the author, bicyclists continue to be subject to harassment by aggressive drivers who drive too close to them. When this happens, even the slightest movement by the motorist or bicyclist can result in accidents where, typically, the bicyclist suffers catastrophic injuries or death. The author notes that this driving behavior leads to thousands of accidents annually in Los Angeles alone despite the fact that the City of Los Angeles sponsored numerous public awareness campaigns to curb this behavior. AB 1371 Page 3 Therefore, the City of Los Angeles is sponsoring this bill which would require motorists to provide bicyclists with a three-foot buffer zone when passing. The author and the sponsor believe that this bill will help make streets safer and more user-friendly for bicyclists by removing ambiguity in current law regarding a motor vehicle's responsibility to provide a safe passing distance for bicyclists. Under current law, a person riding a bicycle at a speed less than the normal speed of traffic but moving in the same direction as traffic is required to ride "as close" as practicable to the right-hand curb or edge of the roadway" except when the bicyclist is passing another bicycle, preparing to turn left at an intersection or driveway, or when reasonably necessary to avoid conditions that make it unsafe to ride along the right-hand edge of the curb (for example if there are parked cars or other obstructions in the roadway). When passing a bicycle that is proceeding in the same direction as traffic, a driver of a motor vehicle is required to pass the bicycle on the left at a safe distance without interfering with the safe operation of the vehicle or bicycle. Road surface marking are used to convey official information about passing and lane changes. Generally, single broken lines mean passing or lane changing is allowed while a single solid white line mean that passing or lane changing is discouraged but not prohibited while double solid white or yellow lines mean passing or lane changing is prohibited. Existing law prohibits a vehicle from driving to the left of the center of the roadway when passing another vehicle proceeding in the same direction unless the left side is clearly visible and free of oncoming traffic for a sufficient distance. When visibility is unobstructed, the pavement typically are marked with a broken white line which denotes that passing is allowed. If double parallel solid lines are in place, this typically means there is insufficient sight distance and, therefore, the motorist is prohibited from driving to the left of the lines unless the driver is making a legal U-turn, turning left at an intersection or into or out of a driveway, or if signs have otherwise been erected to permit it. This bill would require a driver of a motor vehicle passing a AB 1371 Page 4 bicycle that is proceeding in the same direction to pass the bicycle on the left and provide a minimum clearance of three feet. If the width of the lane does not allow the driver of the vehicle to provide this three-foot distance, the bill specifies that the driver of the vehicle may cross over a double yellow line (or other similar pavement marking) to provide the bicyclist with the three-foot distance. This bill is substantially similar to SB 1464 (Lowenthal) of 2012 and SB 910 (Lowenthal) of 2011 both of which were passed by the Legislature but were vetoed by the Governor. SB 910 set the requirement that drivers provide a three-foot passing distance when overtaking and passing a bicyclist and established fines and penalties for failure to abide by these requirements. That bill also included the provision that if the three-foot passing distance could not be provided, vehicles were required to slow to a speed of 15 miles per hour in order to complete the passing maneuver. In his veto message, the Governor noted that while the bill offered clear improvements to the law, but he acknowledged concerns raised by the California Department of Transportation (Caltrans) and the California Highway Patrol (CHP) that the slow passing speed could increase rear-end collisions and create traffic backups. The Governor encouraged the author to work with the proponents and opponents of this bill to resolve these issues. SB 1464 included amendments to address the concerns raised by the Governor about SB 910. Specifically, SB 1464 deleted the requirement that cars slow to a speed of 15 mph when passing a bicyclist in cases when the three-foot passing distance could not be accommodated and instead authorized drivers to pass over double yellow lines and other similar pavement markings (into oncoming lanes) on two-lane highways in order to pass a bicyclist travelling in same direction and maintain the three foot passing distance. SB 1464 was also vetoed by the Governor, this time on the grounds that authorizing cars to cross the double yellow line could result in head-on collisions for which Caltrans may be held liable since the law would explicitly authorize this inherently dangerous driving maneuver. The Governor noted that Caltrans had proposed a solution that would insulate the state from costly lawsuits while still providing the three-foot buffer for bicyclists and urged that this language be included in future legislation. AB 1371 contains the same language as SB 1464 but incorporates AB 1371 Page 5 language recommended by the Governor to address Caltrans' liability concerns. Specifically, the amendment provides that if a driver is involved in a collision that results from them crossing over double yellow parallel line pavement markings to pass a bicyclist, the driver is solely liable for any damages suffered by as a result of the collision, regardless of roadway conditions. According to the author's office, the language was provided by Caltrans at the Governor's request and therefore fully satisfies concerns respect to SB 1464. Author's amendments: According to the author, several groups have expressed concerns with the language provided by Caltrans regarding driver liability. Therefore, the author intends to amend this bill in committee to remove the language while he continues to work with interested parties to reach a suitable compromise. Previous legislation : SB 1464 (Lowenthal) of 2012 would have sets requirements for the safe passing of bicyclists by motor vehicles and establishes fines and penalties for failure to abide by these requirements. That bill was vetoed by the Governor on the grounds that the bill authorized a dangerous maneuver (crossing double yellow pavement markings) and would weaken the state's defense to lawsuits. SB 910 (Alan Lowenthal) of 2011, would have established a minimum three-foot passing distance and required vehicles to slow to 15 mph when passing a bicyclist with less than three feet of passing distance. That bill was vetoed by the Governor. AB 60 (Nava) of 2008, would have required drivers to pass bicyclists with a minimum clearance of three feet, a violation of which would have been an infraction punishable by a $250 fine. In addition, AB 60 would have made it a misdemeanor or felony if the person operating the motor vehicle in violation of the above requirement caused great bodily harm to the bicycle operator. That bill died in the Assembly Transportation Committee. AB 1941 (Nava) of 2006, would have prohibited a vehicle from driving in a designated two-way left-turn lane, for purposes of overtaking and passing a bicycle or merging into adjacent lanes of travel. In addition, AB 1941 would have required motor vehicle drivers to leave a minimum three foot clearance when AB 1371 Page 6 passing a bicyclist with violations assessed with base fine of $250. In addition, AB 1941 would have made it a felony or a misdemeanor, upon conviction, for a person driving a motor vehicle to cause great bodily injury or death to the bicyclist. That bill failed passage in the Assembly Transportation Committee. REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION : Support Antonio R. Villaraigosa, Mayor of Los Angeles (sponsor) LibraryBikes.org Opposition None on file Analysis Prepared by : Victoria Alvarez / TRANS. / (916) 319- 2093