BILL ANALYSIS Ó AB 2393 Page 1 CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS AB 2393 (Levine) As Amended July 3, 2014 Majority vote ----------------------------------------------------------------- |ASSEMBLY: |42-31|(May 27, 2014) |SENATE: |21-13|(August 7, | | | | | | |2014) | ----------------------------------------------------------------- Original Committee Reference: TRANS. SUMMARY : Authorizes an increase in the vehicle registration fee used to fund fingerprint identification programs. Specifically, this bill : 1)Authorizes, for counties that have imposed a vehicle registration fee for fingerprint identification programs, the fee to be increased from $1 to $2 (and from $2 to $4 for commercial vehicles). 2)For counties that have not imposed a $1 vehicle registration fee for fingerprint identification programs, authorizes imposition of a $2 fee (and a $4 fee for commercial vehicles). The Senate amendments are technical, clarifying that commercial vehicle surcharges would increase to $4 when a county raises the vehicle surcharge from $1 to $2 and that the surcharge would be $2 for counties that are imposing the surcharge for the first time. FISCAL EFFECT : According to the Senate Appropriations Committee,: 1)One-time Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) programming costs of approximately $40,000 for each county that elects to increase the fee. If a county has never imposed the fee, DMV's programming costs would be $100,000. All DMV costs are recoverable from fee revenues. 2)Unknown local fee revenues, potentially in the millions annually. Actual local revenue gains would depend upon the number of counties exercising the authority to impose the higher fee, and the number of registered vehicles subject to AB 2393 Page 2 the fee. Currently 45 counties impose the fee, which generated $29.8 million in net local revenues in 2012-13. COMMENTS : The Department of Justice (DOJ) started the fingerprint identification program, known as Cal-ID, in the late 1980s to provide a way to verify the identity of persons placed under arrest and to assist law enforcement agencies in other ways, such as identifying human remains and identifying possible criminal suspects, using fingerprint evidence gathered at crime scenes. Limited funding for the technology and equipment hampered implementation of Cal-ID. As a result, the Legislature passed SB 720 (Lockyer), Chapter 587, Statutes of 1997, authorizing counties to impose a $1 surcharge on vehicle registrations in the county and to use the money for the Cal-ID program. SB 720 limited the duration of the program to five years. Subsequent legislation extended authorization for the program twice: AB 879 (Keeley), Chapter 986, Statutes of 2002, extended the program until 2006 and added reporting requirements, and AB 857 (Bass), Chapter 470, Statutes of 2005, extended the program until January 2012. Finally, AB 674 (Bonilla), Chapter 205, Statutes of 2011, repealed the sunset date entirely. According to the sponsors, the Cal-ID program has been a statewide success. They contend it has saved DOJ countless hours of manually scanning inked fingerprint cards. Further, local law enforcement officials assert that since the original legislation, advances in biometric science and technology have developed to the point that law enforcement can now send and receive from the field identification needed to authenticate individuals using not only fingerprints but also retinal scans, facial scans, palm-prints, and thumbprints. These advancements offer significant benefits to law enforcement, such as the ability to: 1)Authenticate individuals remotely and avoid unnecessary transfers to a booking facility; 2)Rapidly identify dangerous individuals; 3)Confirm instances of mistaken identities; and, 4)View a driver's license photograph from the field. AB 2393 Page 3 Although the program has been extended indefinitely, the author points out that the $1 vehicle registration fee has not changed since the inception of the program 17 years ago. This bill is intended to restore some of the lost purchasing power of the original $1 fee as well as to allow law enforcement to take advantage of advances in technology. Writing in opposition to this bill, the Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association argues that the fee increase proposed in this bill runs afoul of constitutional provisions governing the imposition of special taxes, namely that imposition of such a tax requires a two-thirds vote of the electorate. To this point, this bill is a majority vote measure in the Legislature because it does not directly result in a taxpayer paying a higher tax. Instead, this bill delegates to county boards of supervisors the authority to impose a vehicle registrations fee. Ultimately, county counsels will have to determine the appropriate vote threshold at the county level, where a two-thirds vote of the electorate may be required. Previous legislation: SB 720, originally authorized the imposition of a $1 fee for the automated fingerprinting systems, until January 2003. AB 879, extended the program until 2006 (and added reporting requirements). AB 857, extended the program until January 2012. AB 674, extended the program indefinitely. Analysis Prepared by : Janet Dawson / TRANS. / (916) 319-2093 FN: 0004259