BILL ANALYSIS Ó Bill No: SB 120 SENATE COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL ORGANIZATION Senator Roderick D. Wright, Chair 2013-2014 Regular Session Staff Analysis SB 120 Author: Roth As Introduced: January 17, 2013 Hearing Date: April 9, 2013 Consultant: Art Terzakis SUBJECT Alcoholic Beverages DESCRIPTION SB 120, an urgency measure , reduces the distance of the existing alcohol sales exclusion zone in proximity to La Sierra College (currently known as La Sierra University), in the City of Riverside, from one mile to one-half mile. EXISTING LAW The enactment of the 21st Amendment to the U.S. Constitution in 1933 repealed the 18th Amendment and ended the era of Prohibition. Accordingly, states were granted the authority to establish alcoholic beverage laws and administrative structures to regulate the sale and distribution of alcoholic beverages. Existing law establishes the Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control (ABC) and grants it exclusive authority to administer the provisions of the ABC Act in accordance with laws enacted by the Legislature. Existing law (Penal Code Section 172, et seq) prohibits the sale of alcoholic beverages near certain institutions (e.g., state prisons, youth authority facilities, public and private universities and colleges, or within the State Capitol and any building actually occupied as a home, retreat, or asylum for former military personnel) and provides for numerous exceptions. SB 120 (Roth) continued Page 2 Existing law (Penal Code Section 172g) makes it a misdemeanor to sell, or expose for sale, any intoxicating liquor within one mile of the entrance to La Sierra College in the City of Riverside. This prohibition also applies to within one mile of the grounds or campus of Loma Linda University in the County of San Bernardino or within one mile of the grounds of the University of Santa Clara in the City of Santa Clara. This liquor prohibition does not apply to ale, porter, wine or beer, as specified. Additionally, the law does not apply to a "bona fide" eating place by the holder of an on-sale general alcoholic beverage license or an on-sale beer and wine license issued by the Department of ABC. Furthermore, the law provides that a person who violates this provision is subject to a fine of not less than $100, imprisonment in jail of not less than 50 days nor more than one year, or both that fine and imprisonment. Existing Law (Business & Professions Code Section 25608) generally prohibits, with specified exceptions, the possession, consumption and sale of alcoholic beverages in any public school (K-14) or any grounds thereof. Over the years, numerous legislative exceptions have been granted to school districts to allow for the possession and use of alcoholic beverages on school grounds. (See prior legislation below.) BACKGROUND Purpose of SB 120: The author's office notes that Penal Code Section 172 was enacted in 1872 for the purpose of prohibiting the sale of alcoholic beverages in proximity to prisons, youth authorities, the University of California and other such facilities. The author's office also points out that in the many years since the statute's enactment it has been amended to include additional UC and CSUS campuses, as well as private colleges and universities. A number of exemptions to the prohibition of alcohol sales around the specified institutions have also been enacted. The author's office indicates that in 1967, Senator Gordon Cologne, authored legislation (SB 557), at the request of La Sierra University, run by Seventh-day Adventists, to include the campus within an existing alcohol dry zone (Penal Code Section 172g). Since adoption of the alcohol SB 120 (Roth) continued Page 3 sales ban around the boundaries of La Sierra University, the affected area has dramatically changed and is no longer rural - it is now zoned residential and business. According to the author's office, in 2006, the City of Riverside reached an agreement with a development company to develop new shops and restaurants in the aging Five Points neighborhood which is in close proximity to the campus. The city has also spent several million dollars in road improvements to prepare for the new development. The author's office contends that because of the existing ban on the sale of alcoholic beverage products within a one-mile radius around La Sierra University locating certain businesses that desire to sell alcohol would violate existing state law. The author's office emphasizes that this measure simply reduces the existing exclusion zone around the university by a half-mile to help facilitate the proposed new business development. Additionally, the author's office claims that the University, which sponsored the 1967 measure creating the dry zone, has no position on SB 120. The sponsor of this measure, the City of Riverside, states that negotiations are underway with a major grocery store chain and other business entities; however, the ability to sell alcoholic beverages is critical to their business models and necessary for them if they are to occupy spaces in the planned development. PRIOR/RELATED LEGISLATION SB 339 (Wolk), Chapter 702, Statutes of 2011. Among other things, authorized alcoholic beverages to be possessed, sold, or used during an event held at a community center owned by a city located on public school grounds, if the event is held when students are not present at the facility, as specified. AB 1860 (Tom Berryhill), Chapter 239, Statutes of 2010. Allowed any county office of education or school district in the state that owns and operates an overnight retreat facility to have an event at the overnight retreat facility where alcoholic beverages can be possessed, consumed or sold, provided the event is held during weekends or at times when pupils are not on the grounds. Existing law had SB 120 (Roth) continued Page 4 only granted Marin and Stanislaus Counties such authority. AB 1748 (Hill), Chapter 84, Statutes of 2010. Expanded an existing exception to the general prohibition against the consumption of alcoholic beverages on publicly owned school property (K-14) applicable to special events held at a community college in a county of the first class (Los Angeles) and in a county of the fourth class (Alameda) to also include a community college located in a county of the 10th class (San Mateo). AB 888 (Price) 2009-10 Session. Would have added a new provision to the ABC Act prohibiting an individual from possessing or consuming an open alcoholic beverage container on city and county streets, alleys, and sidewalks within 600 feet of a public or private school, with specified exceptions. (Vetoed by Governor on the basis that existing law already allows local government the ability to enact ordinances to restrict or prohibit the possession or consumption of alcohol in public areas.) AB 1643 (Smyth), Chapter 79, Statutes of 2010. Removed the prohibition against serving alcohol at a public kindergarten K-12 school housed on the campus of a college, as long as the event is held at a time when children are not present. In addition, the only allowable events at which alcohol can be served in this instance are fundraisers held to benefit a nonprofit corporation. AB 1448 (Tom Berryhill) Chapter 399, Statutes of 2009. Authorized the possession, consumption, or sale of alcoholic beverages for an event during the weekend or at other times when pupils are not on the grounds of an overnight retreat facility owned and operated by the County Office of Education in Stanislaus County. AB 172 (Smyth) Chapter 398, Statutes of 2009. Similar to AB 1643 (Smyth) of 2010. (AB 1448 - Tom Berryhill Chapter 399 of 2009 inadvertently chaptered out AB 172) AB 3071 (Governmental Organization Committee), Chapter 508, Statutes of 2008. Authorized the possession, use, sale or consumption of alcoholic beverages in connection with special events held at the facilities of a public community college, located in Los Angeles County or Alameda County. SB 120 (Roth) continued Page 5 AB 1598 (Price), Chapter 149, Statutes of 2007. Created a new exception to the existing prohibition against the sale or consumption of alcoholic beverages on the grounds of a public school to enable culinary arts programs at a campus of a California Community College to buy, use, sell or consume wine or beer only in connection with a sponsored dinner, course of instruction, or meal demonstration. SB 1486 (Hollingsworth), Chapter 72, Statutes of 2006. Authorized alcoholic beverages to be served and consumed on the grounds of the "Water Conservation Garden" located on the campus of Cuyamaca College in Rancho San Diego. SB 220 (Chesbro), Chapter 203, Statutes of 2005. Authorized Napa Valley College to sell wine it produces as part of the College's instructional program in viticulture and enology. AB 767 (Mullin), Chapter 204, Statutes of 2005. Authorized the possession and consumption of alcoholic beverages in residential facilities or housing offered for rent, lease, or sale exclusively to faculty or staff of San Mateo Community College. SB 572 (Maddy), Chapter 90, Statutes of 1997. Authorized the possession and use of alcoholic beverages during nonprofit fundraising events held at Memorial Stadium on the Bakersfield College campus. "Events" does not include football games or other athletic contests held at the college. SB 113 (Thompson), Chapter 238, Statutes of 1993. Authorized the possession and use of alcoholic beverages on public school grounds as follows: (a) at events sponsored by Napa Community College (currently known as Napa Valley College) which has an instructional program on viticulture and enology; and, (b) at a professional minor league baseball game conducted at the stadium of a community college (Butte Community College) located in a county with a population of less than 250,000 inhabitants. AB 4029 (Lancaster), Chapter 1240, Statutes of 1984. Deleted La Verne College from the list of educational institutions subject to the one-mile alcoholic beverage sales prohibition. SB 120 (Roth) continued Page 6 SUPPORT: As of April 5, 2013: City of Riverside (sponsor) OPPOSE: None on file as of April 5, 2013. FISCAL COMMITTEE: No. **********