BILL ANALYSIS Ó ----------------------------------------------------------------------- |Hearing Date:August 29, 2014 |Bill No:SB | | |1159 | ----------------------------------------------------------------------- SENATE COMMITTEE ON BUSINESS, PROFESSIONS AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT Senator Ted W. Lieu, Chair Bill No: SB 1159Author:Lara As Amended:August 22, 2014Fiscal: Yes SUBJECT: Professions and vocations: license applicants: individual tax identification number. SUMMARY: Prohibits licensing boards under the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA) from denying licensure to an applicant based on his or her citizenship or immigration status, and requires a licensing board and the State Bar to require, by January 1, 2016, that an applicant for licensure provide his or her individual taxpayer identification number (ITIN) or a social security number (SSN) for an initial or renewal license. NOTE : The Assembly amendments are considered as a rewrite of this bill and this measure has been referred to the Committee pursuant to Senate Rule 29.10 (d) for consideration. The Committee may, by a vote of the majority, either: (1) hold the bill, or (2) return the bill to the Senate floor for consideration of the bill as amended in the Assembly. Existing law: 1)Provides that each board under the Department of Consumer Affairs, as well as the State Bar and Bureau of Real Estate shall, at the time of issuance of the license, require that the licensee provide their federal employer identification number, if the licensee is a partnership, or social security number for all others. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) § 30 (a)) 2)Specifies that any licensee who does not provide the federal identification number or social security number shall be reported by the licensing board to the Franchise Tax Board and is subject to a SB 1159 Page 2 penalty. (BPC § 30 (b)) 3)Provides that in addition to a penalty, a licensing board may elect to not process any application for an original license if the applicant or licensee fails to provide its federal employer identification number or social security number where requested on the application. (BPC § 30 (c)) 4) Requires a licensing board, upon request of the Franchise Tax Board (FTB), to furnish to the FTB specified information including the federal employer identification number if the entity is a partnership, or social security number, for all others. (BPC § 30 (d)) (Revenue and Taxation Code § 19528) 5) Provides that it is the intent of the Legislature to utilize the social security number or federal employer identification number for the purpose of establishing the identification of persons affected by state tax laws and for purposes of compliance with Section 17520 of the Family Code and, to that end, the information furnished pursuant to this section shall be used exclusively for those purposes. (BPC § 30 (j)) 6) Provides that the Department of Child Support Services (Department) shall maintain a "certified list" that provides names of persons who are found to be out of compliance with a judgment or order for support in a case being enforced under Title IV-D of the Social Security Act. (Family Code (FC) § 17520 (a) (3)) 7) Provides that the Department shall provide the certified list to each board that is responsible for the regulation of licenses, as specified, and that all boards shall collect social security numbers from all applicants for the purposes of matching the names of the certified list to applicants and licensees and of responding to requests for this information made by child support services. (FC § 17520 (d)) 8) Requires that promptly after receiving the certified list from the Department, and prior to issuance or renewal of a license, each board shall determine whether the applicant is on the most recent certified list provided by the Department and provides that the board shall have the authority to withhold issuance or renewal of the license of any applicant on the list. (FC § 17520 (e)) 9) Authorizes the FTB to require any board, the State Bar, the Bureau of Real Estate, and the Insurance Commissioner to provide to the SB 1159 Page 3 FTB specified information, including the licensee's federal employer identification number or SSN; to send a notice to any licensee failing to provide those numbers that describes the information that was missing; the penalty associated with not providing it; that the failure to provide that information within 30 days will result in the assessment of a penalty of $100; and to assess a $100 penalty for any licensee failing to provide its federal employer identification number or his or her social security number. (Revenue and Tax Code (RTC) § 19528) 10)Prohibits, under the federal Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act (P.L. 104-193), certain categories of individuals not lawfully present in the United States from receiving specified public benefits, including "any grant, contract, loan, professional license, or commercial license provided by an agency of a State or local government or by appropriated funds of a State or local government." (8 USC Sec. 1621(c)) 11)Authorizes states to provide that "an alien who is not lawfully present in the United States is eligible for any State or local public benefit for which such alien would otherwise be ineligible?through the enactment of a State law after August 22, 1996, which affirmatively provides for such eligibility." (8 USC Sec. 1621(d)) This bill: 1)Requires a board, as defined, the State Bar, and the Bureau of Real Estate to require, by January 1, 2016, that an individual applicant for licensure provide either an ITIN or SSN. 2)Prohibits any entity within DCA from denying licensure to an applicant based on his or her citizenship or immigration status. 3)Requires every board to implement all required regulatory or procedural changes by January 1, 2016, and authorizes a board to implement these provisions prior to that date. 4) Requires that any applicant failing to provide the federal employer identification number or the federal taxpayer identification number or social security number, if one has been issued to the individual, to be reported by the licensing board to the FTB and provides if the applicant fails to provide that information they shall be subject to a penalty. SB 1159 Page 4 5)In addition to that penalty, prohibits a board from processing an application for an initial license unless the applicant provides his or her ITIN, where requested on the application. 6)Requires a board, upon request of the FTB, to furnish to the FTB specified information, including the licensee's ITIN. 7)Provides that an ITIN furnished pursuant to this bill is not deemed a public record and shall not be open to the public for inspection. 8)Provides that if the board uses a national examination to issue a license, and if a reciprocity agreement or comity exists between California and the state requesting release of the ITIN, the board may release the ITIN to an examination or licensing entity, only for the purpose of verification of licensure or examination status. 9)For purposes of enforcing child support payment provisions, requires any board, the State Bar, and the Bureau of Real Estate to require that each licensee provide the ITIN of each individual licensed on the license and any person who qualifies for the license. 10)Authorizes boards, as specified, to collect an ITIN instead of a SSN for purposes of existing law that requires all boards, as specified, to collect SSNs from applicants for the purposes of matching the names on a certified list, provided by the Department of Child Support Services (DCSS), of persons who are found to be out of compliance with a judgment or order for support, as specified. 11)Authorizes the FTB to require any board, the State Bar, the Bureau of Real Estate, and the Insurance Commissioner to provide to the FTB the licensee's ITIN, and to send a notice to any licensee failing to provide that number that describes the information that was missing; the penalty associated with not providing it, and that failure to provide that information within 30 days will result in the assessment of a penalty of $100. 12)Makes conforming statutory changes to remove the requirement of citizenship, or legal admission or documentary evidence requirements thereof, for the following authorizations to practice or other licensure actions: a) Allow a foreign medical graduate to be eligible for a physician's and surgeon's certificate; b) Allow a foreign medical graduate to participate in professional activities in a medical school as a "visiting SB 1159 Page 5 fellow," and to participate in a fellowship program in specified hospitals or clinics; c) Allow a foreign medical graduate who does not immediately qualify for a physician and surgeon's certificate of registration to practice medicine and who is offered a full-time faculty position at a medical school to be granted a certificate in connection with his or her position; d) Allow the Naturopathic Medicine Committee under the Osteopathic Medical Board to grant a certificate to practice naturopathic medicine to a person who does not hold a naturopathic doctor's license, but who is offered a faculty position in a naturopathic medical education program; and, e) Allow an individual to be licensed as a professional fiduciary. 13)Finds and declares that it is in the best interests of the state to provide persons who are not lawfully present in the United States with the state benefits provided by all licensing acts of entities within DCA. 14)Makes other conforming and technical amendments. FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee: 1)One-time costs to the DCA of up to $130,000 (various special funds) to update forms, publications, and information technology. 2)Unknown potential costs, likely minor, to DCA's boards and bureaus to ensure that new applicants using ITINs are complying with child support judgments. DCA's boards and bureau's currently perform this function using applicants' social security numbers. 3)The bill would likely result in an increase in individuals applying for licenses at the various boards and bureaus within DCA, leading to increased licensing revenues. The amount of the increase is unknown. COMMENTS: 1. Purpose. According to the Author, "Many immigrants come to the [US] as children and attend California's public elementary and SB 1159 Page 6 secondary schools, as well as public and private colleges and universities. Despite the high cost of higher education and limited resources, with hard work, a strong spirit of determination, and the assistance of state laws that provide access to nonresident tuition exemptions, state financial aid, and graduate school admissions tests, these students are now able to attend, participate in, and graduate from California colleges and universities." "Recently, the Legislature has begun to recognize the need to address arbitrary restrictions on professional licenses with the passage of SB 1822 (Bill Berryhill) in 2012 and AB 1024 (Gonzalez) in 2013. However, ambiguity in other sections of state law, in particular [BPC] 30 pertaining to the issuance of professional licenses has created barriers to access, and created an artificial wall that deprives many Californians of their only effective means of economic mobility and self-sufficiency. "Authorizing the use of a social security number or ITIN, if one has been issued, for the application of a professional license would ensure the collection and reporting of information to the [FTB] while clarifying inconsistent laws and removing arbitrary barriers to professional licenses. "The provisions of SB 1159 are consistent with current law and in compliance with federal law. Additionally, recent amendments provide for a delayed implementation of the measure, allowing boards and bureaus sufficient time to comply with the provisions of the bill." The Author states that the "recent amendments, crafted in consultation with the Department of Consumer Affairs, simply provide guidance for the boards and ensure that the bill can be implemented effectively. Specifically, these amendments clarify that otherwise eligible individuals will not be denied a license based solely on their immigration status, and provide sufficient time for successful implementation." 2. Taxpayer Identification Numbers. A Taxpayer Identification Number (TIN) is an identification number used by the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) in the administration of tax laws. It is issued by the Social Security Administration (SSA) or by the IRS. A Social Security Number is issued by the SSA whereas all other TINs are issued by the IRS. The Individual Taxpayer Identification Number, or ITIN, is a tax SB 1159 Page 7 processing number only available for certain nonresident and resident aliens, their spouses, and dependents who cannot get a SSN. It is a 9-digit number, beginning with the number "9" and is formatted like a SSN. To obtain an ITIN, an individual must complete an IRS form. The form requires documentation substantiating foreign/alien status and true identity for the individual. The person may either mail the documentation, along with the required form, present it at the IRS office, or process the application through an acceptable agent authorized by the IRS. 3. Federal Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act. Federal law, the Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act (PRWORA), P.L 104-193, prohibits certain categories of individuals not lawfully present in the United States from receiving certain public benefits, including "any grant, contract, loan, professional license, or commercial license provided by an agency of a State or local government or by appropriated funds of a State or local government." (8 USC Section 1621) (emphasis added) However, the PRWORA also authorizes a state to make those individuals eligible for any state or local public benefit for which he or she would not otherwise be eligible by affirmatively providing for those benefits through an enactment of state law. Professional licenses issued by licensing boards under DCA constitute a public benefit, as defined under federal law, and licensing boards under DCA are considered agencies of the state, thereby triggering the federal requirement in the PRWORA for an enactment of state law to provide those benefits. Accordingly, this bill seeks to affirmatively provide this eligibility to obtain a professional license to individuals who are not lawfully present in the United States. 4. FTB and DCSS's Ability to Identify Licensees. The purpose of requiring an SSN or federal employer identification number is to identify persons with outstanding tax liabilities or who are out of compliance with child support orders. Existing law authorizes the suspension of a delinquent taxpayer's occupational or professional license once a delinquency is at least five months old, and specified notices have been issued by the FTB. Existing law also authorizes license denials and suspensions for failure to pay court-ordered child support debt. According to both the FTB and DCSS, this bill would not affect the ability of the FTB or DCSS to identify persons with outstanding tax liabilities or child support payments because both entities have the capability to identify those persons using their ITIN. SB 1159 Page 8 5. Arguments in Support. The Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce writes in support, and states: "[This bill] would ensure that otherwise eligible applicants are not denied a professional license based solely on their immigration status?Many immigrants come to California as children and are educated in elementary and secondary schools in the state. Despite the high cost of higher education and limited resources, many of them continue on to higher education, availing themselves of state laws that offer access to in-state tuition rates and state financial aid. These young people have worked hard and overcome many obstacles to succeed. Now, they are educated and ready to contribute as professionals. Without access to a professional license, many individuals will be limited in their ability to contribute to our state." The California Immigrant Policy Center writes in support and states: "Without access to a professional license, many individuals will be limited in their ability to participate in the workforce or start a business and thereby limit their economic contributions to the State. It is estimated that California's labor force includes 1.85 million undocumented workers and that households headed by undocumented workers contribute an estimated $2.7 billion in state taxes. As such, we expect SB 1159 to make an impact on the economic opportunity of otherwise eligible immigrants." The National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter , also writes in support, "It is in the best interest of our state to support efforts to educate our workforce and enable our residents, including immigrants to improve their economic mobility and self-sufficiency, which will increase their contributions back to the state." 6. Related Legislation. AB 1024 (Gonzalez, Chapter 573, Statutes of 2013) authorized the Supreme Court to admit to the practice of law an applicant who is not lawfully present in the United States, upon certification by the State Bar that the applicant has fulfilled those requirements for admission, as specified. SB 1822 (Berryhill, Chapter 317, Statutes of 2012) authorized submission of an individual tax identification number or another identification number, as determined by the California Architects Board, in place of a social security number where the applicant is not eligible for a social security number and is not out of compliance with a child support judgment or order, as specified. AB 664 (Jones, Chapter 610, Statutes of 2005) authorized, in SB 1159 Page 9 specified circumstances, submission of a federal tax identification number or another identification number, as determined by the State Bar of California, in place of the applicant's social security number. SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION: Support: American Civil Liberties Union of California California Immigrant Policy Center California Pan-Ethnic Health Network Central American Resource Center - Los Angeles Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights of Los Angeles Councilwoman Cristina N. Carrizosa, City of Pomona Friends Committee on Legislation The Latino and Latina Roundtable of the San Gabriel and Pomona Valley Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce Mexican American Legal Defense and Educational Fund National Association of Social Workers - California Chapter Our Family Coalition Pre-Health Dreamers United Farm Workers (UFW) Opposition: None on file as of August 29, 2014. Consultant:Bill Gage and Mark Mendoza