BILL ANALYSIS Ó SENATE COMMITTEE ON BUSINESS, PROFESSIONS AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT Senator Jerry Hill, Chair 2015 - 2016 Regular Bill No: AB 320 Hearing Date: July 6, 2015 ----------------------------------------------------------------- |Author: |Wood | |----------+------------------------------------------------------| |Version: |April 23, 2015 | ----------------------------------------------------------------- ---------------------------------------------------------------- |Urgency: |No |Fiscal: |Yes | ---------------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------- |Consultant|Mark Mendoza | |: | | ----------------------------------------------------------------- Subject: Engineers. SUMMARY: Adds the title "environmental engineer" to the list of professional engineers currently given Title Act protection and prevents a person from using that title unless licensed by the Board for Professional Engineers, Land Surveyors, and Geologists; allows existing licensed mechanical, civil, and electrical engineers to hold themselves out as an "environmental engineer" without obtaining additional qualifications. Existing law: 1) Establishes the Professional Engineers Act (Act), administered by the Board for Professional Engineers, Land Surveyors, and Geologists (BPELSG), within the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA), which licenses and regulates professional engineers. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) § 6700 et seq.) 2) Defines "professional engineer" as a person engaged in the professional practice of rendering service or creative work requiring education, training, and experience in engineering sciences and the application of special knowledge of the mathematical, physical, and engineering sciences. (BPC § 6701) 3) Limits the practice of civil, electrical, or mechanical engineering to appropriately licensed persons unless AB 320 (Wood) Page 2 of ? specifically exempted. (BPC § 6704) 4) Directs the DCA, in conjunction with the BPELSG and the Joint Committee on Boards, Commissions, and Consumer Protection, to review the engineering branch titles specified in BPC § 6732 to determine whether certain title acts should be eliminated from this chapter, retained, or converted to practice acts similar to civil, electrical, and mechanical engineering, and whether supplemental engineering work should be permitted for all branches of engineering and requires contracting with an independent consulting firm to perform this comprehensive analysis of title act registration. Requires the BPELSG to reimburse the DCA for costs associated with this comprehensive analysis, and requires the DCA to report its findings and recommendations to the Legislature by September 1, 2002. (BPC § 6704.1) 5) Mandates that the protection of the public to be the highest priority for the BPELSG in exercising its licensing, regulatory, and disciplinary functions. (BPC § 6710.1) 6) Gives authority to the BPELSG to define by regulation the scope of each branch of professional engineering other than civil, mechanical, and electrical. (BPC § 6717). 7) Prevents anyone, other than a professional engineer licensed by the BPELSG, from using the title: "professional engineer," "licensed engineer," "registered engineer," or "consulting engineer," or any of the following branch titles: "agricultural engineer," "chemical engineer," "civil engineer," "control systems engineer," "electrical engineer," "fire protection engineer," industrial engineer," "mechanical engineer," "metallurgical engineer," "nuclear engineer," "petroleum engineer," or "traffic engineer." (BPC § 6732) 8) Makes it a misdemeanor for a person to represent himself or herself as, or use the title of, "professional engineer," "licensed engineer," "registered engineer," or the branch titles specified in BPC § 6732. (BPC § 6787) AB 320 (Wood) Page 3 of ? This bill: 1) Inserts "environmental engineer" into the list of branch titles protected under the Professional Engineers Act. 2) Permits existing licensed mechanical, civil, and electrical engineers to hold themselves out as an "environmental engineer" without obtaining additional qualifications. 3) Makes certain legislative findings and declarations. FISCAL EFFECT: This bill is keyed "fiscal" by Legislative Counsel. According to the Assembly Appropriations' Committee analysis dated May 6, 2015, this bill will result in: One-time costs in the range of $60,000 to $150,000 to BPELSG (special funds) to perform an occupational analysis. Actual costs will depend on whether the study is performed through the Department of Consumer Affairs' Office of Examination Services or through a private vendor. COMMENTS: 1. Purpose. The Professional Engineers in California Government is the Sponsor of the bill. According to the Author, "With the proliferation of the teaching and practice of environmental engineering, it is necessary to recognize and regulate environmental engineers with their own title act since the profession is currently not listed under the Business and Professions Code. Currently, an environmental engineer is licensed as a civil, electrical, or mechanical engineer and uses the principles of engineering, soil science, biology, and chemistry to develop solutions to address environmental problems. AB 320 would create an environmental engineer title act that would license and regulate environmental engineers. The profession is involved in efforts to improve recycling, waste disposal, public health, and water and air pollution control that would ensure the safety of the public." 2. Background. The BPELSG was originally created in the late AB 320 (Wood) Page 4 of ? 1920s and charged with licensing civil and structural engineers. In 1947, engineers in the branches of chemical, electrical, mechanical, and petroleum engineering were given title protection. In 1967, electrical and mechanical engineering changed from title act registrations to practice act registrations, and the Legislature added two new title disciplines: metallurgical and industrial engineering. In 1968, a bill (Chapter 895, Statutes 1968) was passed by the Legislature which authorized the creation of new title acts by the BPELSG. During the early seventies, the BPELSG received petitions from persons representing the branches of aerospace, agriculture, air pollution, communication, control system, corrosion, environmental, fire protection, manufacturing, nuclear, quality, safety, and traffic engineering. Hearings were held, and all petitions were approved except for the petitions of air pollution, aerospace, communication, and environmental engineers. In particular, the Board denied the petition to grant an "environmental engineer" title act because "the proponents did not show to the satisfaction of the Board that Environmental Engineering was a separate and distinct discipline from that of the existing branches of engineering. The testimony presented by the opponents clearly demonstrated that much of the environmental engineering presently performed is being done by registered chemical, civil, electrical and mechanical engineers." However, in light of environmental developments since the 1970's, it appears environmental engineering has become more specialized and more graduates are entering this specialized field. In 1985, SB 1030 (Chapter 732, Statutes of 1985) amended BPC § 6732 to codify the existing engineering disciplines into the Professional Engineers Act, thereby recognizing them by statute rather than by regulation. In 2004, SB 364 (Figueroa, Chapter 789, Statute of 2003), discontinued licensing for manufacturing engineering. Currently, there are nine remaining title acts: agricultural, chemical, control systems, fire protection, industrial, metallurgical, nuclear, petroleum and traffic engineering. 3. Title Act vs. Practice Act Protection. It is important to AB 320 (Wood) Page 5 of ? note the distinction between "title act" and certification or registration regulation versus "practice act" and licensing regulation. A practice act along with licensure confers the exclusive right to practice a given profession on practitioners who meet specified criteria related to education, experience, and examination, and often is embodied in a statutory licensing act (i.e., those who are not licensed cannot lawfully practice the profession). A practice act is the highest and most restrictive form of professional regulation, and is intended to avert severe harm to the public health, safety or welfare that could be caused by unlicensed practitioners. A title act and a certification or registration program, on the other hand, reserves the use of a particular professional (named) designation to practitioners who have demonstrated specified education, experience or other criteria such as certification by another organization. A title act typically does not restrict the practice of a profession or occupation and allows others to practice within that profession; it merely differentiates between practitioners who meet the specified criteria, and are authorized by law to represent themselves accordingly (usually by a specified title) and those who do not. Some title acts also include a state certification or registration program, or reliance on a national certification or registration program, so that those who use the specified title, and hold themselves out to the public, have been certified or registered by a state created or national entity as having met the specified requirements. This entity may also regulate to some extent the activities of the particular profession by setting standards for the profession to follow, and to also provide oversight of the practice of the profession by reporting unfair business practices or violations of the law and either denying or revoking a certification or registration if necessary. AB 320 does not establish a licensing practice act, but instead provides for a title act. It restricts the use of the title "environmental engineer" to only those who have met certain education requirements. 4. Title Acts. As noted above in the existing law section, there are presently nine remaining title acts. Since the inception of title protection for certain engineers, four AB 320 (Wood) Page 6 of ? title acts have been eliminated (quality engineer, corrosion engineer, manufacturing engineer, and safety engineer). To have title act protection, the BPELSG has the authority to monitor and pursue those persons using the title of one of the respected specialties without a license. However, the practice of these specialties in not regulated, and nothing prevents a person from practicing in one of these fields. A person still may call themselves an environmental "consultant" or "specialist". Because of this, the enforcement authority of the BPELSG is limited to a person simply using the title without a license. 5. Practice Acts. Currently, the BPESLG regulates and licenses the practice of civil, electrical, and mechanical engineering and the subspecialties of geotechnical and structural engineering. The BPELSG regulates the actual practice of the field, and the use of these titles without a license is a misdemeanor. The BPELSG has the authority to pursue action against persons practicing in these fields regardless of license status. 6. Institutions and Programs Offering Degree's in Environmental Engineering. Currently, 9 California institutions offer degrees in environmental engineering. They include California Polytechnic State University, San Luis Obispo, California State University, Humboldt, California State University, San Diego, University of California, Berkeley, University of California, Irvine, University of California, Merced, University of California, Riverside, University of Southern California, and Stanford University. While there are an unknown number of annual graduates from some schools, the number typically ranged between 20 and 30 per institution. Proponents argue that students graduating with an environmental engineer degree deserve the ability to take an exam to officially certify their educational competency. 7. National Standardized Examination. Standardized examination materials have been developed by NCEES to test the competency of environmental engineers. These examination materials separately cover the fundamentals of engineering (FE Environmental) and professional engineer competencies (PE Environmental). NCEES is a peer association of state engineering licensure agencies that developed standardized examination materials through the use of hand-picked expert AB 320 (Wood) Page 7 of ? panels specific to each affected engineering discipline. Standardized NCEES examinations are administered in California by BPELSG. 8. Process for Licensure. With the creation of the "environmental engineer" title act, BPELSG will first have to define the practice of "environmental engineer" in regulations. While practice acts are outlined in statute, title acts are written in the regulations. Secondly, BPELSG will have to figure out whether or not the national exam, given by NCEES, is suitable to test a student's ability of environmental engineering. More than likely, BPELSG will use this exam. Lastly, an applicant will have to solicit an application proving his or her educational qualifications and qualifying experience. If BPELSG decides the applicant meets the necessary requirements, BPELSG will then notify NCEES to administer the exam to the applicant. Taking the exam is contingent on the Board's approval. If the applicant passes both the test and application requirements, they can then call themselves an "environmental engineer". The new licensee will receive both a certificate and pocket card from the Board granting authorization to use this title. 9. Arguments in Support. The Professional Engineers in California Government writes, "as programs of environmental mitigation and protection continue to expand in scope and complexity for our air, water, and soil - testing and certification of environmental engineers is needed to establish benchmarks for competency to help protect and safeguard the public." 10.Arguments in Opposition. The American Council of Engineering Companies opposes this bill and underscores that, "For example, a title act Traffic Engineer can design the signalization and arrangement of lanes in an intersection, but a civil engineer must design and take responsible charge for the civil layout and final grades, profiles and construction details. By introducing an 'Environmental Engineer' title act, there may be a similar overlap conflict with some of the areas of practice mentioned in the findings; i.e. solid waste management, water supply and treatment and wastewater treatment. This certainly adds to the confusion regarding to the limitations of title acts." AB 320 (Wood) Page 8 of ? The Board for Professional Engineers, Land Surveyors, and Geologists writes a letter in opposition, noting that "AB 320 will not prevent a person from practicing environmental engineering; it will only prevent a person from using the title, 'Environmental Engineer.' The legislative intent provision in AB 320 indicates it is necessary for public protection to 'regulate the profession'. However, this bill would not regulate the profession; it will only restrict a person from the use of the title. For the last 20 years, the Board has held the position that restricting only the title without also regulating the associated practice does not provide sufficient public protection. The Board reconfirmed this positon in voting to oppose AB 320." 11.Current Legislation. AB 177 (Bonilla) currently extends the sunset date for the Board for Professional Engineers, Land Surveyors, and Geologists, the California Architects Board, and the Landscape Architects Technical Committee until January 1, 2020. ( Status : This bill is currently being heard on July 6, 2015 in this Committee). 12.Proposed Amendments. Since civil, mechanical, and electrical engineers are not permitted to utilize a title act without attaining additional qualifications, the Author should delete the grandfather clause on page 4, lines 10-13. SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION: Support: Professional Engineers in California Government (Sponsor) Opposition: American Council of Engineering Companies Board for Professional Engineers, Land Surveyors, and Geologists -- END -- AB 320 (Wood) Page 9 of ?