BILL ANALYSIS Ó AB 487 Page 1 Date of Hearing: April 7, 2015 Counsel: David Billingsley ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY Bill Quirk, Chair AB 487 (Gonzalez) - As Introduced February 23, 2015 As Proposed to be Amended in Committee SUMMARY: Requires that when an inmate requests to advance a parole hearing, notice be sent to the district attorney of the county in which the offense was committed, in addition to the victim. Failure to notify the district attorney or victim of a request to advance the hearing shall postpone any action being taken on the hearing advancement until the notice is properly made. Specifically, this bill: 1)Requires that when an inmate requests that the parole board advance a parole hearing to an earlier date, by submitting a written request to the board, notice be sent to the district attorney of the county in which the offense was committed and to the victim, if the victim requested notification. 2)Requires notice of the inmate's request to advance the parole hearing to be forwarded by the parole board to the district attorney and the victim, if the victim requested notification, no less than 30 days before the board may grant the inmate's request. 3)Specifies that a failure to notify the district attorney or AB 487 Page 2 the victim, if the victim requested notification, of a request to advance the hearing shall postpone any action being taken on the hearing advancement until the notice is properly made. EXISTING LAW: 1)Provides guidelines for the Board of Parole Hearings to schedule parole hearings for prisoners in California Department of Correction and Rehabilitation for whom they are appropriate. (Pen. Code, § 3041.5.) 2)Requires the board set a date to reconsider whether an inmate should be released on parole that ensures a meaningful consideration of whether the inmate is suitable for release on parole. (Pen. Code, § 3041.5.) 3)Requires that within 10 days following any meeting where a parole date has been set, the board shall send the prisoner a written statement setting forth his or her parole date, the conditions he or she must meet in order to be released on the date set, and the consequences of failure to meet those conditions. (Pen. Code, § 3041.5, subd. (b)(1).) 4)Requires that within 20 days following any meeting where a parole date has not been set, the board shall send the prisoner a written statement setting forth the reason or reasons for refusal to set a parole date, and suggest activities in which he or she might participate that will AB 487 Page 3 benefit him or her while he or she is incarcerated. (Pen. Code, § 3041.5, subd. (b)(2).) 5)Specifies that the board shall schedule the next hearing, after considering the views and interests of the victim, as follows: a) Fifteen years after any hearing at which parole is denied, unless the board finds by clear and convincing evidence that the criteria relevant to the setting of parole release dates enumerated in subdivision (a) of Section 3041 are such that consideration of the public and victim's safety does not require a more lengthy period of incarceration for the prisoner than 10 additional years. (Pen. Code, § 3041.5, subd. (b)(3)(A).) b) Ten years after any hearing at which parole is denied, unless the board finds by clear and convincing evidence that the criteria relevant to the setting of parole release dates enumerated in subdivision (a) of Section 3041 are such that consideration of the public and victim's safety does not require a more lengthy period of incarceration for the prisoner than seven additional years. (Pen. Code, § 3041.5, subd. (b)(3)(B).) AB 487 Page 4 c) Three years, five years, or seven years after any hearing at which parole is denied, because the criteria relevant to the setting of parole release dates enumerated in subdivision (a) of Section 3041 are such that consideration of the public and victim's safety requires a more lengthy period of incarceration for the prisoner, but does not require a more lengthy period of incarceration for the prisoner than seven additional years. (Pen. Code, § 3041.5, subd. (b)(3)(c).) 6)Allows the Board of Parole Hearings discretion, after considering the views and interests of the victim, advance a parole hearing to an earlier date, when a change in circumstances or new information establishes a reasonable likelihood that consideration of the public and victim's safety does not require the additional period of incarceration of the prisoner. (Pen. Code, § 3041.5, sub. (b)(4).) 7)Allows an inmate to request that the board exercise its discretion to advance a hearing set pursuant to paragraph (3) of subdivision (b) to an earlier date, by submitting a written request to the board, with notice, upon request, and a copy to the victim which shall set forth the change in circumstances or new information that establishes a reasonable likelihood that consideration of the public safety does not require the additional period of incarceration of the inmate. (Pen. Code, § 3041.5, sub. (d)(1).) AB 487 Page 5 8)Mandates that the board shall have sole jurisdiction, after considering the views and interests of the victim to determine whether to grant or deny a written request to advance the hearing, and its decision shall be subject to review by a court or magistrate only for a manifest abuse of discretion by the board. The board shall have the power to summarily deny a request that does not comply with the provisions of this subdivision or that does not set forth a change in circumstances or new information as required. (Pen. Code, § 3041.5, sub. (d)(2).) 9)Specifies an inmate may make only one written request to advance a hearing during each three-year period. Following either a summary denial of a request to advance a hearing, or the decision of the board after a hearing to not set a parole date, the inmate shall not be entitled to submit another request for a hearing pursuant to subdivision to set a parole date until a three-year period of time has elapsed from the summary denial or decision of the board. (Pen. Code, § 3041.5, sub. (d)(3).) 10)Specifies that within 10 days of any board action resulting in the postponement of a previously set parole date, the board shall send the prisoner a written statement setting forth a new date and the reason or reasons for that action and shall offer the prisoner an opportunity for review of that action. (Pen. Code, § 3041.5, sub. (b)(5).) 11)Requires that within 10 days of any board action resulting in the rescinding of a previously set parole date, the board AB 487 Page 6 shall send the prisoner a written statement setting forth the reason or reasons for that action, and shall schedule the prisoner's next hearing as specified. (Pen. Code, § 3041.5, sub. (b)(6).) 12)Requires the board conduct a parole hearing as a de novo hearing. Findings made and conclusions reached in a prior parole hearing shall be considered in but shall not be deemed to be binding upon subsequent parole hearings for an inmate, but shall be subject to reconsideration based upon changed facts and circumstances. When conducting a hearing, the board shall admit the prior recorded or memorialized testimony or statement of a victim or witness, upon request of the victim or if the victim or witness has died or become unavailable. At each hearing the board shall determine the appropriate action to be taken based on the criteria set forth in Penal Code Section 3041. (Pen. Code, § 3041.5, sub. (c).) FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown COMMENTS: 1)Author's Statement: According to the author, "AB 487 is a way to ensure that all victims are notified when an inmate files a petition to advance their parole date. By requiring that the Board of Parole Hearings also notify the District Attorney of the County in which the offense was committed, there will be no doubt that a representative advocating for the victim's interests will be available for comment in those situations that merit such involvement. 2)Marsy's Law (Proposition 9, 2008): Proposition 9 was passed by the voters of in 2008. Proposition 9 included a victims' bill of rights. Among the protections in the victims' bill of rights, was the right for victims to be noticed of criminal proceedings in which they were a victim. Proposition 9 also AB 487 Page 7 provided victims with the right to be heard at criminal proceedings. Victims can express their views personally, or through a representative. Criminal proceedings where victims have a right to notice and expression of views include parole hearings for inmates serving indeterminate life terms in the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR). California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation has an Office of Victim and Survivor Rights and Services (OVSRS) that provides assistance to victims surrounding issues involving inmates in CDCR. OVSRS handles requests by victims for notification regarding inmates involved in their crime. OVSRS currently handles requests by victims for notification regarding parole hearing dates for offenders sentenced to life imprisonment. 3)Argument in Support: According to Bonnie Dumanis, San Diego County District Attorney, Notes that California voters passed the Victims' Bill of Rights Act(Marsy's Law) in 2008, which amend the state's Constitution and certain Penal Code sections to protect and expand the legal rights of victims of crime to including (among 17 others) the right to be noticed and to be heard, upon request, at any proceeding, including post-conviction release decisions. "Unfortunately, existing law only requires that the Board of Parole Hearings notify the victims or next of kin if an inmate files a petition to advance the their parole date, and omits the District Attorney in the notification process. Moreover, it has come to our attention that some victims are not getting notified in a timely fashion. Assembly Bill 487 would provide a safety net to ensure that when an inmate files such a petition, the district Attorney of jurisdiction will also be notified. Failure to notify the victim and the district Attorney of record will make void the requested petition and reinstate the original hearing date. "Our office is a significant stakeholder in parole hearings, and our prosecutors appear at about 45 hearings each year and advocate the State's position with respect to public safety, AB 487 Page 8 and sometime serve as the voice of crime victims and their next of kin. This bill would fix a large omission in the hearing advancement process, consisting of notice of potential hearing advancements, and an opportunity to be heard, after we have expended significant time and resources to convict this inmate. ". . ., AB 487 would give the District Attorney the opportunity to immediately notify victim and extent of kin upon learning of a hearing advancement. Marsy's Law advocated predictability and promised to eliminate endless and repeated parole hearings which re-traumatize crime victims and their families. Currently, victims are being re-traumatized and have no one to turn to, as the District Attorney is circumvented in the entire process. Ab 487 does not take away any power or authority from the Board of Parole Hearings, as it will still decide the matter of advancement as it see just and fit. There is no downside to simply providing significant stakeholders with an opportunity to weigh-in before that decision is made." 4)Argument in Opposition: According to The California Public Defenders Association, "This bill would require notification of the district attorney of the county in which the offense was committed, or his or her designee, to receive notification of specified parole proceedings and would require nullification of action taken on the hearing advancement if the district attorney of the county in which the offense was committed, or his or her designee, and the victim are not notified. "This bill requires prior notification of the committing county's district attorney. It does not affect the rights of victims. Under current law, district attorneys are notified of parole hearings in cases where the inmate was convicted of an offense carrying a life term (So called "Lifer Hearings"). AB 487 expands this notification requirement to situations where an inmate is requesting an earlier parole date. A failure to so notify the District Attorney requires postponement of the hearing. "This bill simply adds a possible impediment to a timely AB 487 Page 9 hearing through no action of the inmate." 5)Related Legislation: SB 230 (Hancock), of this legislative session, would specify that the purpose of the meeting between the Board of Parole Hearings and an inmate during the 6th year before the inmate's minimum eligible parole date is to review and document the inmate's activities and conduct pertinent to parole eligibility. The bill would require a panel of 2 or more commissioners or deputy commissioners to meet with each inmate one year before the inmate's minimum eligible parole date in order to grant or deny parole, as specified. The bill would prohibit an inmate from being released before reaching his or her minimum eligible parole release date unless the inmate is eligible for earlier release pursuant to his or her youth offender parole eligibility date. Existing law authorizes the Governor to request a review of a decision by the board to grant or deny parole to an inmate up to 90 days before the inmate's scheduled release date. The bill would authorize the Governor to request a review of a decision by the board to grant or deny parole at any time before the inmate's scheduled release. The bill would make conforming changes. REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION: Support Association for Los Angeles Deputy Sheriffs Association of Deputy District Attorneys California College and University Police Chiefs Association California Correctional Supervisors Organization California District Attorneys Association California Narcotic Officers Association California State Sheriffs' Association Chief Probation Officers of California County of San Diego Crime Victims United of California Los Angeles Police Protective League Riverside Sheriffs Association San Diego County District Attorney AB 487 Page 10 Opposition California Public Defenders Association Taxpayers for Improving Public Safety Analysis Prepared by: David Billingsley / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744