BILL ANALYSIS Ó AB 1712 Page 1 Date of Hearing: April 13, 2016 ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS Lorena Gonzalez, Chair AB 1712 (Obernolte) - As Introduced January 26, 2016 ----------------------------------------------------------------- |Policy |Human Services |Vote:|6 - 0 | |Committee: | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |-------------+-------------------------------+-----+-------------| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | ----------------------------------------------------------------- Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: NoReimbursable: No SUMMARY: This bill authorizes child care contractors to use electronic signatures and requires that those signatures have the same force and effect as manual signatures, as specified. FISCAL EFFECT: The California Department of Education (CDE) anticipates the following costs: 1)One-time costs of $73,000 to train audit staff, update related guides and procedures. (Federal funds and GF). AB 1712 Page 2 2)Unknown additional costs for audit fieldwork to verify systems meet required standards, with costs expected to decrease over time. Potential costs could be between the low tens of thousands to the low hundreds of thousands. Costs will largely depend on the duration and complexity of each audit. (Federal funds and GF) COMMENTS: 1)Purpose. According to the author, "California leads the nation when it comes to innovation and technology. However, many of our state government operations have been left in the past. As a result, a number of state agencies are forced to operate in a manner that is both outdated and inefficient. This bill would help modernize one of these out-of-date conventions and correct an oversight in existing law by allowing childcare center contractors to use electronic signatures. Providing child care centers with this option will greatly increase their efficiency and maximize the use of their resources." 2)Background. In California, subsidized child care may be available to families that meet certain eligibility requirements. The three main types of subsidized child care programs include: California Work Opportunity and Responsibility to Kids (CalWORKS) child care, Alternative Payment Programs (APPs) and General Child Care. General Child Care offers child care and education/development services through contracted child care centers and family child care home networks that are administered through public or private agencies. Child care administered by CalWORKs and APPs is offered through a voucher system. AB 1712 Page 3 The Child Development Division of the CDE conducts child care audits. Currently, CDE conducts four to six annual program audits of child care providers, and verifies that the provider has kept the required sign-in and sign-out attendance sheets and they contain the required parent or guardian signatures. AB 271 (Obernolte), Chapter 476, Statutes of 2015, authorizes APPs and child care providers as well as child care contractors to maintain records electronically, in compliance with state and federal standards, as determined by the CDE. AB 271 also authorizes APPs and child care providers to use digital signatures, pursuant to state and federal standards, and requires a digital signature to have the same force and effect as a manual signature. AB 1712 additionally allows child care contractors to use digital signatures. The CDE anticipates that shifting to the electronic recordkeeping system authorized in last year's AB 271 will increase costs to conduct audits by $3,980 per week for a small agency, and a minimum of one additional week would be required. For a larger agency, multiple additional weeks could be required. However, costs are expected to decline over time. Actual costs will ultimately depend on the duration of the annual audits which is largely determined by the level of funding an agency receives, the number of contracts the agency has with the CDE, and the workload necessary to accomplish the objectives of the audit. AB 1712 increases the number of entities subject to audits under the new system. 3)Prior Legislation. a) AB 271 (Obernolte), Chapter 476, Statutes of 2015, expanded the authority of APPs and child care providers and child care contractors to use electronic methods for AB 1712 Page 4 storage of documents or records, and permitted APPs and providers to use digital signatures pursuant to current state standards. b) AB 2101 (Levine), 2014, was substantially similar to AB 271 (Obernolte). It was held on this Committee's Suspense File. c) AB 274 (Bonilla, Chapter 733, Statutes of 2013) allows APPs to maintain records, including child attendance records, electronically in accordance with state and federal auditing standards, but limited the electronic maintenance of records to only those that were generated electronically. Analysis Prepared by:Jennifer Swenson / APPR. / (916) 319-2081