BILL ANALYSIS Ó SENATE COMMITTEE ON AGRICULTURE Senator Cathleen Galgiani, Chair 2015 - 2016 Regular Bill No: AB 1894 Hearing Date: 6/21/16 ----------------------------------------------------------------- |Author: |Committee on Agriculture | |-----------+-----------------------------------------------------| |Version: |5/18/16 Amended | ----------------------------------------------------------------- ---------------------------------------------------------------- |Urgency: |No |Fiscal: |Yes | ---------------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------- |Consultant:|Anne Megaro | | | | ----------------------------------------------------------------- Subject: Food and agriculture: omnibus bill SUMMARY : This bill would update frozen dairy dessert food safety requirements to incorporate new technologies; clarify the authority of the California Department of Food and Agriculture (CDFA) Dairy Marketing Branch to fund educational and research activities; align citrus handler assessment fee due dates; delete term limits for members of the California Sheep Commission; and clarify Williamson Act contracted land cancellation values and fees. BACKGROUND AND EXISTING LAW : Dairy. CDFA's Dairy Marketing Branch is required to develop and maintain satisfactory milk marketing conditions, bring about and maintain a reasonable amount of stability and prosperity in the production of market milk, and provide means for carrying on essential educational activities. The authority to achieve these goals is liberally construed. California law requires that all milk and milk products be pasteurized, processed, and packaged at a single site unless otherwise exempted by law or by regulations as determined by the secretary of CDFA (Food and Agriculture Code § 34008). The few exceptions include licensed milk products plants that are used exclusively for the production of ice cream or ice milk AB 1894 (Committee on Agriculture) Page 2 of ? manufactured from a mix or premix that is supplied by a separate licensed milk products plant, and soft-serve products such as frozen yogurt. Citrus. The California Citrus Advisory Committee was created within CDFA to develop and make recommendations to the secretary on all matters regarding the citrus program including the assessment rate and inspection program. The assessment rate is currently levied on producers per 40 pound carton of fruit and set at a maximum $0.011 for navel oranges, $0.005 for lemons, and $0.006 for Valencia oranges and mandarins. The assessment is collected by handlers and remitted to CDFA by the 10th day of the month. These funds are used for crop surveys and to reimburse county agricultural commissioners, in specified counties, for implementing the inspection program, which ensures citrus product quality. The California Citrus Pest and Disease Prevention Committee (CCPDPC) within CDFA was created to advise the secretary on efforts to prevent and manage citrus pests and diseases. An assessment is levied on citrus producers and deposited into the Citrus Disease Management Account for the sole purpose of combating citrus-specific pests and diseases. The current assessment rate is $0.09 per 40 pound carton and is due to CDFA by the end of the month. Sheep. The California Sheep Commission (CSC) was created in 1985 to address sheep and sheep product advertising, promotion, marketing research, production research, and sheep protection. The CSC may adopt and modify rules and regulations, provide CSC administration and enforcement, enter into contracts, collect industry information, establish an assessment rate, expend funds, and investigate and prosecute civil violations of CSC law. The CSC must also undergo a mandatory referendum hearing conducted by CDFA every five years to determine whether or not the commission shall continue operating. The last referendum vote was successfully conducted in 2014, extending the continuation of the CSC through March 31, 2020. Williamson Act. The California Land Conservation Act of 1965, also known as the Williamson Act, authorizes a city or county to enter into 10-year contracts with agricultural landowners to keep AB 1894 (Committee on Agriculture) Page 3 of ? contracted land in agricultural production. The contracted land is valuated accordingly for property tax purposes, thus providing tax relief to property owners in exchange for not developing the property for non-agricultural purposes. Existing law: 1) Prohibits the manufacturing and packaging of hard frozen dairy products when the establishment is open to the public. 2) Requires manufacturers to post an ingredient list for frozen yogurt on the premises if they sell directly to the public. 3) Requires ice cream mix, frozen dairy dessert mix, and frozen dessert mix to comply with all the requirements for ice cream, frozen dairy desserts, and frozen desserts, respectively. 4) Authorizes CDFA to develop and maintain satisfactory marketing conditions, bring about and maintain a reasonable amount of stability and prosperity in the production of market milk, and provide means for carrying on essential educational activities. 5) Requires the payment of specified citrus assessment fees by the 10th day of the month following the month for which the assessment is payable. 6) Limits the number of terms held by members of the California Sheep Commission to four consecutive terms. 7) Requires the Department of Conservation to provide a preliminary valuation of Williamson Act contracted land to the county and city 60 days before the effective date of the agreed upon cancellation valuation if the contract includes an additional cancellation fee. PROPOSED LAW : This bill: AB 1894 (Committee on Agriculture) Page 4 of ? 1) Allows the manufacturing and packaging of hard frozen dairy products when the establishment is open to the public. 2) Removes the requirement that manufacturers post an ingredient list for frozen yogurt on the premises if they sell directly to the public. 3) Requires frozen yogurt mix to comply with all state and federal requirements for frozen yogurt. 4) Aligns citrus handler assessment fee due dates to that of other commodity assessment fee due dates. 5) Defines "educational and research activities" within milk marketing code to mean any effort to develop and improve the management practices of dairy producers and processors, including environmental sustainability of land, air quality, and water quality. 6) Clarifies the authority of CDFA's Dairy Marketing Branch to fund educational and research activities. 7) Clarifies the authority of CDFA to use milk handler assessment fees to administer and enforce milk marketing and stabilization laws. 8) Removes term limits for members on the California Sheep Commission. 9) Clarifies that the Department of Conservation shall provide a preliminary valuation of Williamson Act contracted land to the county and city if the contract includes an additional cancellation fee only if the department and landowner first agree upon a cancellation value. 10) Makes technical and conforming corrections. ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author, the amendments regarding frozen dairy desserts "is an appropriate change due in the past 24 years, the improvements in machinery used, food worker training and AB 1894 (Committee on Agriculture) Page 5 of ? adoption of GMPs by most restaurants and fast food chains, and the network of local public health inspection and oversight all help provide the needed safeguards for the making and selling of these products." According to CDFA, the broad interpretation of milk marketing laws authorizes CDFA to fund environmental research projects, such as projects helping "regulators better understand the impacts of dairy on air and water quality issues. Continuing to provide sound scientific data to regulators helps them focus their enforcement activities in a manner that protects the health of our citizens, while providing them with an ample supply of dairy products. The ambiguous nature of current statute does, however, bring into question the continued pursuit of these research projects. [?] This bill would clarify the Department's existing authority to fund these important environmental research projects using existing funds." COMMENTS : Frozen dairy desserts. This bill would maintain current food safety standards while incorporating new frozen dessert technologies. Additionally, CDFA states that some of these requirements are burdensome, unnecessary, and inconsistent with the dairy industry's business model. Dairy research. As environmental awareness grew in the 1990s, environmental regulation of dairy farms followed. Concerns regarding manure and dairy waste, water quality, land use, air quality, and impacts of dairy processing plants needed to be better understood. The dairy industry realized that regulations would be extremely costly and that additional research, data, and scientific evidence were needed. Regulators would then be able to use this new information to identify what regulations would be most effective and beneficial to the environment and the industry. These research projects continue to be funded today, although there is no expressed authority for CDFA to use industry funds to support these activities. However, given CDFA's statutory mandate to bring stability and prosperity to the production of market milk and provide for essential educational activities, this authority can be liberally construed to include environmental research activities. This bill clarifies the existing authority. AB 1894 (Committee on Agriculture) Page 6 of ? Citrus. This bill would align the due date for assessment fees collected from citrus producers and remitted to CDFA by citrus handlers to that of other commodity assessment fees. Currently, an assessment fee levied for an inspection program is due by the 10th day of the month. According to CDFA, a thorough review of existing law identifies that citrus industry assessments are payable on the tenth day of the following month from which the citrus was received, giving the citrus industry only 10 days to remit payment to the department. However, other programs, such as the Standardization Program, are afforded 40 days. Therefore, it would be unfair and without substantiation to establish different payment standards for one program over another. This bill would clarify the due date for a citrus assessment and set it for the end of the month. Sheep. The California sheep industry had an $82 million agricultural commodity value in 2014. The total number of sheep and lambs has remained relatively steady since 2005; however, the industry has declined since the CSC was first created in 1985. As such, the decreasing size makes it more difficult for the CSC to fill vacant board seats created by current term limits. Nonetheless, the industry is supportive of the CSC and has asked that it continue in operation until at least 2020. This bill would delete term limits for CSC members. Williamson Act. AB 707 (Wood) of 2015 requires the Department of Conservation to provide a preliminary valuation of Williamson Act contracted land to the county and city 60 days before the effective date of the agreed upon cancellation valuation if the contract includes an additional cancellation fee. This bill would clarify that this would occur only if the department and landowner first agree upon a cancellation value. RELATED LEGISLATION : AB 707 (Wood), Chapter 631, Statutes of 2015. Requires the Department of Conservation to provide a preliminary valuation of Williamson Act contracted land to the county and city 60 days before the effective date of the agreed upon cancellation valuation if the contract includes an additional cancellation fee. AB 1894 (Committee on Agriculture) Page 7 of ? PRIOR ACTIONS : ------------------------------------------------------------------ |Assembly Floor: |79 - 0 | |--------------------------------------+---------------------------| |Assembly Appropriations Committee: |20 - 0 | |--------------------------------------+---------------------------| |Assembly Agriculture Committee: | 9 - 0 | | | | ------------------------------------------------------------------ SUPPORT : California Department of Food and Agriculture OPPOSITION : None received -- END --