BILL ANALYSIS Ó SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS Senator Ricardo Lara, Chair 2015 - 2016 Regular Session AB 2027 (Quirk) - Victims of crime: nonimmigrant status ----------------------------------------------------------------- | | | | | | ----------------------------------------------------------------- |--------------------------------+--------------------------------| | | | |Version: August 1, 2016 |Policy Vote: PUB. S. 6 - 0 | | | | |--------------------------------+--------------------------------| | | | |Urgency: No |Mandate: Yes | | | | |--------------------------------+--------------------------------| | | | |Hearing Date: August 1, 2016 |Consultant: Jolie Onodera | | | | ----------------------------------------------------------------- This bill meets the criteria for referral to the Suspense File. Bill Summary: AB 2027 would provide that upon the request of an immigrant victim, a certifying official from a certifying entity, as defined, is required to certify "victim cooperation" on the Form I-914, Supplement B (Form I-914B), when the victim was a victim of human trafficking and has been cooperative, is being cooperative, or is likely to be cooperative to the investigation or prosecution of human trafficking. This bill would require certifying entities to fully complete and sign specify timelines within which a certifying entity must process a Form I-914B request and would require a certifying entity that receives a request for a Form I-914B declaration to report to the Legislature on or before January 1, 2018, and annually thereafter, on the number of Form I-914B declarations requested, signed, and denied. Fiscal Impact: TCVAP benefits : Potentially significant future increase in annual state costs (General Fund) for the Trafficking and Crime Victims Assistance Program (TCVAP), which provides AB 2027 (Quirk) Page 1 of ? state-funded benefits (including cash assistance, services, child care, and food benefits), to the extent a greater number of victims are able to file formal T Visa applications. Applicants are eligible for TCVAP when a T Visa application has been, or is preparing to be, filed with USCIS and eligibility continues until and unless a recipient's application for a T Visa has been finally administratively denied, the recipient has not applied for a T Visa within one year of applying for state benefits, or the victim becomes federally eligible. For every 25 to 50 new cases, annual costs could range from $0.3 million to $0.6 million (General Fund) for grants, services, and administration. Additionally, to the extent existing TCVAP cases remain eligible for program benefits for a longer period of time due to this measure, annual costs would increase cumulatively each year. Form I-914 declaration process : Potential costs to state and local agencies defined as certifying entities to implement the expedited process, including completing, signing, and processing Forms I-914B within specified timelines. To the extent the new requirements are determined to place a higher level of service on local agencies than required under federal law, local agency expenditures could qualify as a reimbursable state mandate (General Fund). Annual report : Likely minor costs to state and local agencies acting as certifying entities to compile and submit the annual report to the Legislature. To the extent local agency expenditures qualify as a reimbursable state mandate, agencies could only claim reimbursement of costs incurred if $1,000 or more (General Fund). State agency certifying entities : Minor ongoing impact to the Department of Industrial Relations and the Department of Justice, as these agencies are already conducting this process for U Visa applicants. The CDCR is projected to incur minor, if any, costs should they be required to act as a certifying entity. Background: Existing federal law provides for T nonimmigrant status, which is set aside for victims (and their qualifying family members) of human trafficking who meet certain eligibility requirements and cooperate with law enforcement or government officials' reasonable requests for assistance in the investigation or prosecution of human trafficking. Congress created the T nonimmigrant visa (T Visa) with the passage of the Victims of AB 2027 (Quirk) Page 2 of ? Trafficking and Violence Protection Act in October 2000. The legislation was intended to strengthen the ability of law enforcement agencies to investigate and prosecute cases of domestic violence, sexual assault, human trafficking, and other crimes, while also protecting victims of crimes who have suffered substantial mental or physical abuse due to the crime. The T Visa extends critical protections to immigrant crime victims by providing temporary lawful status as a "T nonimmigrant" for up to four years, work authorization, and an opportunity to adjust to lawful permanent resident status after three years. T Visa issuances for principal applicants are capped at 5,000 annually. However, to date, the annual cap has never been reached and visas remain available to applicants who qualify. To apply (petition) for a T Visa from the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS), a petitioner is required to submit a Form I-914, Petition for T Nonimmigrant Status (Form I-914) to request temporary immigration benefits as a victim of a severe form of human trafficking, and are strongly encouraged to submit a Form I-914 Supplement B, Declaration of Law Enforcement Officer for Victim of Trafficking in Persons (Form I-914B) from a certifying agency, which must be a federal, state, or local law enforcement agency, prosecutor, or authority, or federal or state judge, authorized to certify that the petitioner submitting the Form I-914 is a victim of human trafficking and is, has been, or is likely to be cooperative in the investigation or prosecution of that criminal activity. The Form I-914B serves as the primary evidence that the applicant is or has been a victim of human trafficking and that the applicant has complied with reasonable requests from law enforcement. Although a completed Form I-914B is not required to apply for a T Visa, the federal instructions for the T Visa indicate that submission of the I-914B is strongly advised, as the form demonstrates that the applicant has complied with any reasonable requests from federal, state, or local law enforcement in the investigation or prosecution of the trafficking crime of which the applicant was a victim. This bill creates a rebuttable presumption that when specified factors are met, a victim or victim's family member shall have their Form I-914B completed and processed to facilitate the application for a T Visa. AB 2027 (Quirk) Page 3 of ? Proposed Law: This bill would provide that upon the request of the victim or the victim's family member, a certifying official from a certifying entity shall certify victim cooperation on the Form I-914 Supplement B (Form I-914B) declaration, when the victim was a victim of human trafficking and has been cooperative, is being cooperative or is likely to be cooperative to the investigation or prosecution of human trafficking. This bill: Provides that for the purposes of determining cooperation there is rebuttable presumption that a victim is cooperative, has been cooperative, or is likely to be cooperative to the investigation or prosecution of human trafficking, if the victim has not refused or failed to provide information and assistance reasonably requested by the law enforcement agency. Requires a certifying official to fully complete and sign the Form I-914B declaration and, regarding victim cooperation, include specific details about the nature of the crime investigated or prosecuted and a detailed description of the victim's cooperation or likely cooperation to the detection, investigation, or prosecution of the criminal activity. Requires a certifying entity to process a Form I-914B declaration within 90 days of the request unless the noncitizen is in removal proceedings in which case the certification shall be processed within 14 days of request. Provides that a current investigation, filing of charges, or a prosecution or conviction are not required for the victim to request and obtain a Form I-914B declaration from a certifying official. Provides that a certifying official may only withdraw the certification if the victim refuses to provide information and assistance when reasonably requested. Specifies that a certifying entity is prohibited from disclosing the immigration status of a victim or person requesting the Form I-914B declaration, except to comply with federal law or legal process, to allow prosecutors to comply with their constitutional obligations to provide material evidence to defendants in pending criminal proceedings pursuant to Brady v. Maryland (1963) U.S. 83, or if authorized by the victim or person requesting the declaration. Provides for a certifying entity that receives a request for a AB 2027 (Quirk) Page 4 of ? Form I-914B declaration to report to the Legislature on or before January 1, 2018, and annually thereafter the number of victims that requested Form I-914B declarations from the entity, the number of those that were signed and the number that were denied. Defines "certifying entity" as: o A state or local law enforcement agency; o A prosecutor; o A judge; o The Department of Industrial Relations; o Any other state or local government agencies that have criminal, civil, or administrative investigative or prosecutorial authority relating to human trafficking. Defines "certifying official" as any of the following: o The head of the certifying entity; o A person in a supervisory role who has been designated to issue Form I-914 Supplement B certification; o A judge; o Any other certifying official as defined under federal law. Provides that "human trafficking" means "severe forms of trafficking in persons" pursuant to federal law and includes either of the following: o Sex trafficking, as specified. o The recruitment, harboring, transportation, provision, or obtaining of a person for labor or services, through the use of force, fraud, or coercion for the purpose of subjection to involuntary servitude, peonage, debt bondage, or slavery. Provides that "human trafficking" also includes criminal offenses for which the nature and elements of the offenses are substantially similar to the criminal activity described above, and the attempt, conspiracy, or solicitation to commit any of those offenses. Related Legislation: SB 674 (de Leon) Chapter 721/2015 requires that upon the request of a victim or victim's family member, a certifying entity to certify "victim helpfulness" on the Form I-918 Supplement B (Form I-918B), when the victim was a victim of a qualifying criminal activity and has been helpful, is being AB 2027 (Quirk) Page 5 of ? helpful, or is likely to be helpful to the detection or investigation or prosecution of that criminal activity. Staff Comments: This bill will potentially result in a greater number of Form I-914B declarations completed, enabling a greater number of victims to submit formal T Visa applications with supporting information to USCIS for consideration and approval. As a result, a greater number of victims and their family members may become eligible for state-funded TCVAP benefits. Additionally, a greater number of victims and their family members who are currently receiving TCVAP benefits may remain eligible for TCVAP benefits for a longer period of time. The TCVAP, which is administered by the Department of Social Services (DSS), was authorized by SB 1569 (Chapter 672/ 2006) and became effective on January 1, 2007. This program assists eligible non-citizen victims of human trafficking and domestic violence or other serious crimes by providing them with state-funded benefits and services. Under TCVAP, eligible trafficking (T Visa) and serious crime (U Visa) victims may receive benefits and services under the following state-funded programs: TCVAP Cash Assistance (for single adults or families without children), California Food Assistance Program (CFAP), Cash Assistance Program for Immigrants (CAPI), CalWORKs, and In-Home Supportive Services (IHSS). The TCVAP-eligible persons may also receive state-funded Medi-Cal that is administered by the Department of Health Care Services (DHCS). The 2016 May Revision estimates nearly 1,900 crime victims (both U and T Visa) served under the TCVAP cash assistance and CalWORKs programs at a cost of $10.6 million in FY 2016-17. According to the DSS implementing instructions for the TCVAP (ACL 06-60, December 21, 2006), victims are eligible when a T Visa application has been, or is being prepared to be, filed with USCIS, or if a T Visa has been granted. The TCVAP requires victims of human trafficking to file for a T nonimmigrant visa with the appropriate federal agency as the first step to apply for federal status. This is necessary to demonstrate that they are taking steps to meet the conditions for federal eligibility in order to qualify for state public social services. To remain eligible for benefits and services, victims of trafficking must show evidence that they have applied AB 2027 (Quirk) Page 6 of ? for the T visa within one year from the date of application for state public social services. In determining potential eligibility for these applicants, county welfare agencies are required to verify that an application for a T Visa has been filed (which could include a copy of the Form I-914B declaration). Eligibility for state-funded services continue until and unless the recipient's application for a T Visa has been finally administratively denied, the victim does not submit an application for a T Visa within one year of applying for state benefits, or the applicant becomes eligible for federal benefits. While the magnitude of the potential increase is unknown, for every 25 to 50 new cases, annual costs could range between $0.3 million and $0.6 million (General Fund). To the extent the number of cases impacted is greater or fewer, annual costs would be impacted accordingly. Additionally, to the extent existing TCVAP cases remain eligible for program benefits for a longer period of time due to this measure, annual costs would increase cumulatively each year. USCIS data indicates over 2,200 T Visa applications received in Federal Fiscal Year 2015 and a current backlog of pending T Visa applications of about 1,600 nationwide as of March 2016. As a result, the TCVAP caseload is estimated to cumulatively increase as eligibility extends until an applicant receives a final administrative denial. According to the U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) publication, U and T Visa Law Enforcement Resource Guide, "The T visa declaration is not conclusive evidence that the applicant meets these eligibility requirements, as only USCIS can make this determination. In addition, by signing a T visa declaration, the certifying agency, official or judge is not sponsoring or endorsing the victim for a T visa. USCIS considers the T visa declaration as one part of the evidence in the T visa application. USCIS also conducts a full background check and, in considering each T visa application and the applicant's credibility, examines the totality of the evidence and the circumstances of each case. Signing a declaration is at the certifying agency's discretion which should be exercised on a case-by-case basis consistent with U.S. laws and regulations, and the policies and procedures outlined in this Guide, as well as internal policies of the certifying agency . (p. 11)" AB 2027 (Quirk) Page 7 of ? This bill requires certifying entities to fully complete and sign the Form I-914B declaration, as well as meet specified processing timelines of within 90 days or within 14 days of a request if the noncitizen is in removal proceedings. The potential increase in workload would vary by agency dependent on the volume of requests received. To the extent this requirement is determined to place a higher level of service on local agencies than required under federal law, specifically with regard to the mandated timelines, local agency expenditures could potentially qualify as a reimbursable state mandate (General Fund). Staff notes, as drafted, it is unclear whether a certifying entity would be required to complete a Form I-914B for a qualified victim regardless of whether the certifying entity is responsible for the investigation or prosecution of the qualifying criminal activity. An informational notice from the Los Angeles City Attorney's Office notes that in order for the City Attorney's Office to sign the form, the case in which the person was a victim must have been handled by the City Attorney's Office. Statements from the notice: "The case in which you were a victim must have been handled by the Los Angeles City Attorney's Office. That means that the law enforcement agency that responded to the crime was Los Angeles Police Department. If your case was handled by the Sheriff's Department or by any other police department, then this is not the correct office for you to ask for help." "If your client was helpful to the Los Angeles Police Department and not the Los Angeles City Attorney's Office, then your request should be made directly to the Los Angeles Police Department. This Office will not certify based on helpfulness to the police department alone." To the extent the provisions of this bill require local agencies to change current policies and practices, any workload and associated costs that are determined to place a higher level of service on local agencies could potentially qualify as a reimbursable state mandate (General Fund). Given the scope of information required to be reported, state AB 2027 (Quirk) Page 8 of ? and local agencies acting as certifying entities are estimated to incur minor costs to compile and submit the annual report to the Legislature. To the extent local agency expenditures qualify as a reimbursable state mandate, agencies could only claim reimbursement for costs incurred of $1,000 or more (General Fund). -- END --