BILL ANALYSIS Ó AB 2330 Page 1 Date of Hearing: April 12, 2016 ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONS Rudy Salas, Chair AB 2330 (Ridley-Thomas) - As Introduced February 18, 2016 SUBJECT: Real estate licensees. SUMMARY: Requires the Real Estate Commissioner (Commissioner) to disclose on the Bureau of Real Estate's (BRE) website for every licensee, whether that licensee is an associate licensee, and further requires the Commissioner to identify, if the associate licensee is also a broker, every responsible broker with whom the associate licensee is contractually associated. EXISTING LAW: 1)Provides for the licensure and regulation of real estate brokers and salespersons by the Real Estate Commissioner. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) Section 10000 et seq.) 2)Defines a "real estate broker" as a person who, among other things, sells, buys, or rents real property for another for compensation, as specified (BPC Sections 10131-10131.6) AB 2330 Page 2 3)Defines a "real estate salesperson" as a natural person who is employed by a licensed real estate broker for compensation (BPC Sections 10017, 10132) 4)Defines a "responsible broker" to mean the broker responsible for the exercise of control and supervision of licensed salespersons. (BPC Section 10159.7(a)(4)) 5)Defines an associate licensee as a person who is licensed as a real estate broker or salesperson and who acts under the supervision of a broker and as the broker's agent in connection with real estate functions. (Civil Code (CIV) Section 2079.13) 6)Authorizes a real estate broker acting in the capacity of a salesman to another broker under written agreement to perform acts for which a license is required on behalf of the employing broker at any place of business at which the employing broker is currently licensed to perform acts for which a real estate license is required (Title 10 California Code of Regulations (CCR) Section 2728.5) 7)Requires every broker, except a broker acting in the capacity of a salesperson to another broker under written agreement, to maintain on file with the commissioner the address of his principal place of business for brokerage activities, the address of each branch business office and his current mailing address, if different from the business address (10 CCR, Section 2715) AB 2330 Page 3 8)Requires every broker who is acting in the capacity of a salesperson to another broker under written agreement to maintain on file with the commissioner the address of the business location where he expects to conduct most of the activities for which a license is required and his current mailing address. 10 CCR, Section 2715) 9)Requires the Commissioner of the BRE to post on the Internet non-confidential license information of every salesperson or broker licensed by the BRE. (BPC Section 10083.2) 10) Requires transparency in the process of lending and home foreclosures. Also known as the Homeowner's Bill of Rights. (CIV Sections 2920- 2925, relating to Mortgages) THIS BILL: 1)Requires the Commissioner to disclose on the BRE's website for every licensee, whether that licensee is an associate licensee. 2)Requires the Commissioner to identify on its website, if the associate licensee is also a broker, every responsible broker with whom the associate licensee is contractually associated. FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown. This bill is keyed fiscal by the Legislative Counsel. COMMENTS: AB 2330 Page 4 Purpose. This bill is sponsored by the California Association of Realtors . According to the author, "This bill will close an important deficiency in existing law by identifying who a real estate broker is working for when that broker is not acting under his or her own license. Existing provisions, such as the Homeowner's Bill of Rights, already require transparency in other areas of real estate transactions. AB 2330 makes sure that consumers always have access to information that affects one of the biggest purchases of their lifetime." Brokers and Salespersons. To obtain a broker's license, applicants are required to submit evidence of at least two years of experience as a real estate salesperson, in addition to elevated education requirements and passage of a written examination. In order to obtain a real estate broker license, an individual, in most cases, must have held a real estate salesperson's license for at least two years during which time he or she must have been actively engaged in real estate, meet certain real estate education requirements in addition to passing an examination. Broker and salesperson licenses are issued for a four-year period. In general, both types of licenses may be renewed by submitting the appropriate fee and application, and evidence of completion of 45 hours of BRE-approved continuing education courses. These courses include 15 hours of required courses in ethics, agency relationships, trust fund handling, fair housing, and risk management, and at least 18 hours in courses dedicated to consumer protection. The remaining courses, up to 12 hours of electives, may be related either to consumer protection or consumer services that will enable the licensee to achieve a high level of competence in serving the objectives of consumers who may engage the services of licensees to secure the transfer, financing, or similar objectives with respect to real property, including organizational and management techniques. Unlike salespersons, licensed brokers are not required to AB 2330 Page 5 operate under the supervision of another broker. Brokers are authorized to be the direct fiduciary representative of their clients on matters pertaining to the sale of real property. Brokers are also free to form contractual associations and partnerships that are largely governed under the civil code. Salespersons are required to report to the BRE within five days of changing supervising brokers, and the BRE discloses this information online. However, there is no similar requirement to collect and disclose this information for brokers who are acting as a contractual agent of another broker. Associate Licensees. An associate licensee is defined in the civil code as a licensee who is acting as an agent of a broker in connection with real property transactions. A broker can also act as an associate licensee, but the BRE's website does not distinguish between brokers working independently and brokers voluntarily operating under the supervision of another broker. The author writes that without this legislation, a member of the public would not know if, or whom, a licensed real estate professional is supervised by, in case of a complaint. The BRE has not reported complaints regarding this issue, but the author proposes that more transparency regarding employment structure is beneficial to the consumer. Prior Related Legislation. AB 2169 (Cooley) of 2014 would have reiterated the existing structure of Real Estate law that allows salespersons and brokers the choice to contract with other brokers as "independent contractor" or "employer- employee" under their retention agreement. NOTE: This bill was held in the Assembly Committee on Insurance. AB 2540 (Dababneh), Chapter 295, Statutes of 2014 required every real estate broker and salesperson licensee to provide the commissioner with his or her current office or mailing address, current telephone number, and current electronic mail address that he or she uses to perform any activity that requires a real AB 2330 Page 6 estate license, and at which the bureau may contact the licensee, and to update that information no later than 30 days after making a change. The bill also exempts a violation of this requirement from criminal penalties. ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: California Association of Realtors writes in support, "AB 2330 makes a simple, but important, change in the way real estate licensees are shown on the [BRE] license verification website. In short, the bill requires that a salesperson who also maintains a broker's license can still be linked to his or her responsible broker. The current system makes it difficult for consumers to verify who is actually in charge of the licensee, and the change will greatly simplify that task." IMPLEMENTATION ISSUES: It is not clear that the BRE currently has the authority to collect the information relevant to the implementation of this bill. Through its regulations, the BRE requires brokers (and brokers who are associate licensees) to disclose the address at which they expect to conduct most of their business. However, it does not require brokers to list every contractual association they are a party to. Additionally, nothing in the real estate code requires licensed brokers to disclose all of their contractual associations to the BRE. Thus, implementation of this bill may require time for the BRE to promulgate regulations requiring licensed brokers to disclose their contractual relationships with other brokers, so that the BRE may be able to disclose this information on the website. REGISTERED SUPPORT: AB 2330 Page 7 California Association of Realtors REGISTERED OPPOSITION: None on file. Analysis Prepared by:Tessa Nevarez / B. & P. / (916) 319-3301