BILL ANALYSIS Ó AB 2855 Page 1 Date of Hearing: April 19, 2016 ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PRIVACY AND CONSUMER PROTECTION Ed Chau, Chair AB 2855 (Frazier) - As Amended April 7, 2016 SUBJECT: Charitable solicitations: financial disclosures SUMMARY: Requires a charity's website and marketing materials to include a prominent link to the Attorney General's (AG) website for charitable solicitations, and requires the Attorney General to publish consumer education information online about charities. Specifically, this bill: 1)Requires a charity's website home page to include a prominent link that directs consumers to the AG's website containing information about consumer rights and protections and charity research resources. 2)Requires a charity's materials used for charitable solicitations to include the AG's website address for information about consumer rights and protections, and charity research resources. 3)Requires, no later than July 1, 2017, the AG to develop and publish on the AG's website, information about consumer rights and protections and charity research resources that will better prepare potential donors to research a charity before AB 2855 Page 2 making a decision to give. EXISTING LAW: 1)Generally provides the AG with supervisory and enforcement powers over charitable corporations, trustees, commercial fundraisers, fundraising counsel and commercial co-venturers who solicit or hold property for charitable purposes through the Supervision of Trustees and Fundraisers for Charitable Purposes Act (Act) (Government Code Section (GC) 12580 et seq.) 2)Requires charities to register and file annual financial reports with the AG, with certain exceptions, such as schools, hospitals, and churches. (GC 12585 et seq.) 3)Requires a person working for a charity to provide a prospective donor with a card or other printed materials that list, among other things, the name and address of the charity or the fundraiser, the organization's tax or non-tax exempt status, and the percentage of the gift or purchase that may be deducted on the donor's tax return. No disclosure is required if the person is a volunteer who is 18 or younger and the organization is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) Section 17510.3) 4)Requires a charity to maintain financial records using generally accepted accounting principles as defined by the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants, the Governmental Accounting Standards Board, or the Financial Accounting Standards Board. (BPC 17510.5) AB 2855 Page 3 5)Prohibits an individual, corporation, or other entity that solicits funds for a charity from retaining more than 50 percent of the net proceeds collected as a fee for fundraising services. (BPC 17510.87) 6)Requires any charity that collects more than 50% of its annual income and takes in more than one million ($1,000,000) in charitable contributions from California donors in California in a calendar year, and that spent more than 25% of its annual income on "nonprogram activities" (i.e., salaries, fundraising, travel expenses, and overhead associated with managing and administering the charity), to submit a report to the AG detailing its nonprogram activity expenses as well as the salaries of the five highest compensated employees; and requires the AG to make these reports available to the public. (BPC 17510.9) 7)Requires the AG to publish an annual report on charities registered with the AG. (BPC 17510.95) 8)Establishes civil penalty of up to $1,000 for a first violation of the Act, a fine of up to $2,500 for subsequent violations, and a civil penalty of up to $10,000 for a violation of the Act with intent to deceive or defraud any charity or individual, and authorizes the AG to suspend the registration of a charity that violates the Act. (GC 12591.1 et seq.) FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown COMMENTS: AB 2855 Page 4 1)Purpose of this bill . This bill is intended to give consumers more information about how to research a charity before making a gift by requiring charities to provide a link in their solicitation materials to the AG's website containing information about charitable giving, and by requiring the AG to publish educational materials specifically about consumer rights and protections and charity research resources. This measure is author-sponsored. 2)Author's statement . According to the author's office, "In recent years, there has been a focus on calling for greater transparency of the financial activity of charities that solicit donations from individuals seeking to contribute to a good cause. The Federal Trade Commission recently charged the Cancer Fund of America, Cancer Support Services, Children's Cancer Fund of America and The Breast Cancer Society of operating sham charities than bilked $187 million from consumers. According to the FTC's press release on the matter, individuals donating to their causes were told they 'would help cancer patients, including children and women suffering from breast cancer, but the overwhelming majority of donations benefitted only the perpetrators, their families and friends, and fundraisers.' The executive leadership [of these organizations] 'used the organizations for lucrative employment for family members and friends, and spent consumer donations on cars, trips, luxury cruises, college tuition, gym memberships, jet ski outings, sporting event and concert tickets, and dating site memberships.' The FTC further noted that the charities 'hired professional fundraisers who often received 85% or more of every donation.' " 3)Exposing questionable activities of charities . According to the author, many charities have been criticized in media reports for making questionable financial decisions with the money donated to them to fulfill their stated missions. CNN called The Kids Wish Network "the worst charity in America" because it raised "millions of dollars in donations in the AB 2855 Page 5 name of dying children and their families" while spending "less than 3 cents on the dollar helping kids." According to the CNN report, the charity directed $110 million in donations to its corporate sponsors and an additional $4.8 million to the charity's founder and his consulting firm. ("Above the law: America's worst charities," CNN, June 13, 2013) The Wounded Warrior Project has also garnered attention from the media for spending only 60% of its funding on veterans while other veteran charities such as the Disabled American Veterans Charitable Service Trust and the Fisher House spend 96% and 91% fulfilling their mission to serve veterans. According to a CBS report, Wounded Warrior Project spent $26 million on conferences and meetings, which was "about the same amount the group spends on combat stress recovery -- its top program." ("Wounded Warrior Project accused of wasting donation money," CBS, January 26, 2016) 4)Charities currently submit annual public financial reports to the AG . Most charities in California must file annual financial reports with the Attorney General's Registry of Charitable Trusts (Registry). These reports must be filed by all public benefit corporations and charitable trusts, unless they are exempted by statute. Currently, only hospitals, schools, and churches are exempt from the annual filing requirements. In addition, all charitable trustees and fundraising professionals are required to register and file annual financial disclosure reports with the Registry. AB 2855 Page 6 Registered charities are required to file a copy of their tax Form 990 on an annual basis with the Registry, as well as with the Internal Revenue Service (IRS). Through a partnership with the IRS, GuideStar (www.guidestar.org) publishes the electronically-filed Form 990s submitted to the IRS. The Registry is accessible through a Registry Search tool on the AG's existing webpage for charities: www.oag.ca.gov/charities. The Registry Search tool allows a charity's public filings to be viewed and downloaded from the Registry database. These public filings include a copy of the annual IRS return (Forms 990, 990-PF, and 990-EZ) filed with the Registry, as well as registration forms and documents that organizations are required to file with the AG. In addition, the Registry maintains a current index of all registered California charities. 5)The AG investigates and prosecutes bad actor charities and fundraisers . The AG is responsible for regulating charities and the professional fundraisers who solicit on their behalf. The attorneys and auditors of the AG's Charitable Trusts Section investigate and bring legal actions against charities and fundraising professionals that misuse charitable assets or engage in fraudulent fundraising practices. Charities that violate California's laws are subject to suspension, revocation and civil fines. 6)Prior legislation applied a similar requirement on moving companies . In 2012, the Legislature passed and the Governor signed AB 2118 (Butler), Chapter 544, Statutes of 2012, which required household goods carriers to add links to their websites that direct consumers to the Public Utilities Commission's website containing consumer education information for customers of moving companies. Similarly, the author contends that it makes good sense to help consumers ensure that their dollars would be well spent by AB 2855 Page 7 assisting them in researching charities, whether they are using those dollars to buy consumer products and services or make a charitable gift. 7)Recent amendments revise and recast the bill . This bill was amended on April 7, 2016, to delete the existing provisions of the bill and insert the current language. This bill would now require charities to provide a link on their website to the AG's webpage with consumer resources for charitable giving. The bill would not require a charity to create a website, but if the charity has an existing website, then the website must contain a link on the homepage to the AG's website. In addition, the bill requires charities to include the AG's website address in documents the charity uses to solicit donations. For example, if the charity mails a solicitation letter or hands out a brochure to prospective donors, then the letter or brochure would need to contain a link to the AG's website where a consumer can find out more information about charities. Materials that do not contain an overt solicitation would not need to include the link. Lastly, the bill requires the AG to develop and post on its website educational materials for consumers, so that they can learn about how to research charities to help determine whether they should make a donation. While the prior version of the bill had more prescriptive provisions than the current version, a coalition of nonprofit organizations remain opposed to the bill, contending that these requirements are a significant burden and would create problems for most charities. AB 2855 Page 8 8)Arguments in opposition . The California Association of Nonprofits (CalNonprofits) states in opposition to this bill that, "AB 2855 (Frazier)?would require every charity seeking funds to support their work to include on their web sites and any document a charity produces which includes fundraising language to include a link to the Attorney General's web site. While the web site disclosure requirement in subsection (a) is burdensome, expensive, duplicative, confusing and likely both unconstitutional and unenforceable, the 'any document' requirement in subsection (b) is all those things on steroids." CalNonprofits further states that, "Burdening nonprofits in and beyond California with required speech on 'any document' which seeks donor support to simply advertise what the public can easily find is unnecessarily punitive without serving any compelling public interest. Imagine all the 'documents' that non-profit organizations create to solicit funds to support their mission-based work: signs on coin collection jars, private letters to individual donors, billboards and other large-scale outdoor advertisements, flyers posted in laundromats, neighborhood association newsletters, to name just a few. And AB 2855's provisions would apply to any charity - regardless of where they are based - that solicits donations from Californians. So, every inbound piece of mail from any charity in the world would have to include this unnecessary disclosure. The additional cost of including this provision on 'any document' would be extraordinary." The California Association of Private School Organizations states in opposition that this bill "will have little, if any, impact upon unscrupulous operators while burdening legitimate charities with a set of draconian requirements that invite the perception of impropriety. We say this because most sham operations rely upon direct mail and telemarketers, rather than websites, and those that utilize websites will simply cease doing so if AB 2855 should become law. While the bad AB 2855 Page 9 actors can simply side-step AB 2855's provisions and continue to prosper, legitimate charities such as the 1,450 nonprofit, K-12 private schools served by our member organizations will remain beholden to its onerous requirements." 9)Reconsideration vote . This bill failed passage in this committee on April 12, 2016, but was granted reconsideration. 10)Prior legislation . AB 556 (Irwin), Chapter 299, Statutes of 2015, expanded the definition of a "commercial fundraiser for charitable purposes" in order to strengthen the AG;s ability to enforce disclosure requirements for charity fundraisers, and establishes a ten-year statute of limitations for enforcement actions against charity fundraisers, consultants and other third parties who engage in fraud or prohibited conduct. AB 2327 (Feuer), Chapter 483, Statutes of 2012, enhanced the penalties applicable to a violation of the Act and gave the AG authority to suspend the registration of a charitable organization that violates the Act. SB 2015 (Sher), Chapter 475, Statutes of 2000, amended the UETA to grant the AG additional enforcement tools and resources, including: ability to assess late fees, authority to suspend or revoke registrations, the ability to impose criminal penalties for violations of the Act, and the appropriation of all fines, penalties, attorney's fees and costs to the AG for the administration and enforcement of that Act. AB 2855 Page 10 SB 1262 (Sher), Chapter 919, Statutes of 2004, imposed audit requirements on charities that receive or accrue a gross revenue of $500,000 dollars or more, require specific disclosures during a solicitation or fundraising campaign, and require specific provisions in written contracts between fundraisers and the charitable organization. Support None on file. Opposition Actors and Others for Animals AgLantis Alameda Homeless Network/Midway Shelter Alliance for Nonprofit Excellence AB 2855 Page 11 Alliance of Arizona Nonprofits American Sports Institute Angels Nest TLP Arkansas Nonprofit Alliance Arts for LA Arts for Oakland Kids Aspire Creative Arts Program Autism Advocates in Action Support Group Axis Advocacy Balboa Park Cultural Partnership Berkeley Organizing Congregations for Action Berkeley Student Cooperative Black Arts Los Angeles, Inc. AB 2855 Page 12 California Aquatic Therapy & Wellness Center, Inc. DBA Pools of Hope California Arts Advocates California Association of Nonprofits (CalNonprofits) California Association of Private School Organizations California Budget & Policy Center California Hepatitis C Task Force, Inc. California Partnership to End Domestic Violence California Professional Firefighters California ReLeaf California State Alliance of YMCAs California Symphony Care of the Soul Foundation, Inc. Catholic Big Brothers Big Sisters, Inc. AB 2855 Page 13 Center for Human Services Center for Nonprofit Advancement Center for Non-Profits Center for Sierra Nevada Conservation Center for Volunteer & Nonprofit Leadership CFIDS & Fibromyalgia Self-Help Program Chamberlain's Children Center Chimineas Ranch Foundation Chinese Performing Arts of America Citadel Ministries, Inc. City Garage Theatre Coastal Kids Home Care Colorado Nonprofit Association AB 2855 Page 14 Community Action Agency of Butte County Community Counts Inc. Community Housing Partnership ConnectHealthcare Connecticut Connuity Nonprofit Alliance, Inc. Contra Costa Youth Council Cope Family Center Del Norte Child Care Council Del Norte Senior Center, Inc. Delaware Alliance for Nonprofit Advancement - DANA Descanso Gardens Guild, Inc. EarthShare California Faith in Action: Interfaith Volunteer Caregivers of Solano AB 2855 Page 15 County Fallbrook Citizens' Crime Prevention Committee Fighting Back Partnership Folsom's Hope Forefront Foundation for Successful Solutions Foundation for Sustainable Development Four Paws To Freedom Fresno Food Commons Glenwood Dads Club Global Citizen Year GSA Network Hawaii Alliance of Nonprofit Organizations AB 2855 Page 16 Health Connected Healthy Adventures Foundation Hope for Santa Maria Hopkins Bank and Orchestra Boosters Humboldt Skatepark Collective Icthus International Idaho Nonprofit Center Infectious Disease Association of California Inland Temporary Homes Institute for Wildlife Studies Kennedy King Memorial Scholarship Fund Kentucky Nonprofit Network KidWorks Community Development AB 2855 Page 17 LA Harbor International Film Festival Lake County Theatre Company LA's BEST After School Enrichment Program Latino Educational Fund Legal Aid Association of California Library & Literacy Foundation for San Joaquin Life Charities, Inc. DBA Rescue Task Force Lions Sight & Hearing Foundation of Southern CA Lodi Community Art Center Long Term Care Ombudsman Services of San Luis Obispo County Louisiana Association of Nonprofit Organizations Lummis Day Community Foundation Maine Association of Nonprofits AB 2855 Page 18 Maryland Nonprofits Marin Villages Mateel Community Center McKinleyville Community Collaborative Meals on Wheels Santa Maria Valley Michigan Nonprofit Association Minnesota Council of Nonprofits Mission Peak Wind Symphony Mississippi Center for Nonprofits Montana Nonprofit Association Mount Diablo Interpretive Association Mountain Ranch Youth Alliance Mountain Valley Elder Care AB 2855 Page 19 Museum of Teaching and Learning Music in the Vineyards Inc. Napa Valley Community Housing National Council of Nonprofits Neuropathy Action Foundation New Advances for People with Disabilities New Door Ventures New Hampshire Center for Nonprofits New Morning Youth & Family Services New York Council of Nonprofits Nipomo Area Recreation Association Nonprofit Association of the Midlands, Omaha NE Nonprofit Finance Fund AB 2855 Page 20 North Carolina Center for Nonprofits North Dakota Association of Nonprofit Organizations North Peninsula Food Pantry & Dining Center of Daly City O'Hanlon Center for the Arts Oklahoma Center for Nonprofits Operation SafeHouse Orchard Valley Fine Arts Foundation, Inc. Our Healing Hearts Pacifica's Environmental Family Pasadena YouthBuild PDAP of Ventura County, Inc. Peninsula Family Service Pennsylvania Association of Nonprofit Organizations AB 2855 Page 21 People Acting in Community Together Philharmonic Society of Orange County Pittsburg Community Theatre Point Arena Lighthouse Presidio Graduate School Program for Torture Victims Progressive Employment Concepts, Inc. Project High Hopes Providers' Council Massachusetts Rebuilding Together Silicon Valley Recovery Café San Jose Redbud Audubon Redwood Bluegrass Associates AB 2855 Page 22 Redwood Cove Community Center, Inc. Redwood Parks Association Riverside Museum Associates Rock School Scholarship Fund Role Players Ensemble Rona Barrett Foundation Sacramento Area Bicycle Advocates Sacramento International Gay & Lesbian Film Festival San Diego Hua Xia Chinese School San Diego Youth Symphony and Conservatory San Francisco SAFE, Inc. San Francisco SPCA Sanchez Art Center AB 2855 Page 23 Santa Clara City Library Foundation & Friends Save Mount Diablo School of Unity and Liberation SCRAP Serving People in Need (dba SPIN) SF-Marin Food Bank Sickle Cell Disease Foundation of CA Slavic Chorale Solano Symphony Orchestra Sons of Charity Inc. SoundVision Productions South Carolina Association of Nonprofit Organizations Southeast Symphony Association, Inc. AB 2855 Page 24 Southern California Center for Nonprofit Management Special Kids Foundation, Inc. Spirit Awakening Foundation Spirit House Center for Attitudinal Healing St. John Boys Home, Inc. Sunny Hills Services Susan G. Komen Orange County Sustainable Agriculture Education (SAGE) Symphony of the Redwoods Teacher Resource Center of the North Bay Tenderloin Neighborhood Development Corporation (TNDC) The Arc and United Cerebral Palsy California Collaboration The Bolsa Chica Land Trust AB 2855 Page 25 The Center for Healthy Generations The Down Syndrome Connection of the Bay Area The Eel River Multigenerational Center The Foraker Group - Alaska's State Nonprofit Association The Humane Society of the United States The Network of Care The Nonprofit Association of Oregon The OMI Cultural Participation Project The Place Within Counseling Folsom The River Otter Ecology Project The Soldiers Project The Taylor Family Foundation Theatre Bay Area AB 2855 Page 26 Transition House Traverso Santana Design Tri-City Hospital Foundation Trips for Kids Triumphant Life Tustin Preservation Conservancy United Way of Kern County United Ways of California Utah Nonprofits Association Washington Nonprofits Villa Esperanza Services Volunteer Council of the East Bay (VCEB) We Are the Next AB 2855 Page 27 West Oakland Environmental Indicators Project West Virginia Nonprofit Association Women's Economic Ventures World of Children Wyoming Nonprofit Network Youth 2 Leaders Education Foundation Analysis Prepared by:Jennie Bretschneider / P. & C.P. / (916) 319-2200