BILL ANALYSIS Ó SB 188 Page 1 Date of Hearing: June 30, 2015 ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY Mark Stone, Chair SB 188 (Hancock) - As Amended April 14, 2015 SENATE VOTE: 31-4 SUBJECT: Municipal utility district: utility charges: delinquencies KEY ISSUE: Should a statute that permits a municipal utility district to file A lien on real property for unpaiD water and sewer charges be made permanent by removing the January 1, 2016, sunset date? SYNOPSIS Prior to 2010, a municipal utility district (MUD) had only two unattractive options for taking action when a customer neglected to pay water and sewer service bills. The MUD could shut off water service to the delinquent customer, or it could recover its losses by charging more to other ratepayers. In 2010, however, SB 1035 (Hancock) sensibly provided a third, more attractive, option by authorizing a MUD to record a lien on the customer's residential real property in the amount of the unpaid charges, so long as the property owner has proper notice and a meaningful opportunity to challenge the lien. While there are SB 188 Page 2 five MUDs in the state, as a practical matter, SB 1035 only applied to the East Bay Municipal Utility District (EBMUD) because it is the only MUD which provides both water and sewer service to residential customers; the others provide other services as electric, garbage disposal, transportation, and telephone. Because SB 1035 created a new procedure for collecting delinquent charges - and indeed in some ways reversed existing policy - it wisely included a sunset date of January 1, 2016, so that the policy could be revisited. To help evaluate whether the authorization should continue or be abandoned after the sunset date, SB 1035 required any MUD that used the authority (i.e. EBMUD) to provide the Legislature with a report on the number of liens filed and the overall effectiveness of the policy. The report by EBMUD suggests that SB 1035 has been extremely successful, increasing collection rates from 15% to over 90%. Furthermore, it has eliminated the need for many disruptions of services. Prior to 2010, EBMUD terminated service to about 400 master-metered multi-family residential accounts each year due to non-payment of bills. Since having the authority granted under SB 1035, EBMUD has not terminated service to any master-metered multi-family residential buildings. There is no evidence that EBMUD has abused its authority, or that property owners have not received adequate notice or opportunity to challenge liens. This bill removes the sunset provision in existing law, thereby making permanent EBMUD's authority to record a lien on real property for delinquent water and sewer charges. This bill passed off the Senate Floor by a 31-4 vote and more recently passed out of the Assembly Local Government Committee on a 9-0 vote. The bill is sponsored by EBMUD and supported by Alameda County Board of Supervisors, the Association of California Water Agencies, and the California Special Districts Association. There is no known opposition. SUMMARY: Makes permanent provisions of law that authorize a municipal utility district (MUD) to file a lien on real property for unpaid water and sewer utility charges rendered to a lessee, tenant, or subtenant. Specifically, this bill: SB 188 Page 3 1)Deletes the January 1, 2016, sunset date that authorizes a MUD to record a lien against affected real property in the amount of any delinquent fees or charges for furnishing water or sewer services to a residential property. 2)Repeals a code section that requires any MUD that places a lien on a property for water or sewer service on or before December 31, 2014, to submit to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary and Local Government on or before January 1, 2015, a report containing specified information detailing the number of liens, the total dollar amount of those liens, the overall effectiveness of the liens, and any problems associated with the liens. 3)States that it is the intent of the Legislature to remove the sunset date in Section 12811.1 of the Public Utilities Code, relating to the authority of a MUD to collect delinquent water and sewer charges. Specifies that it is not the intent of the Legislature to change existing law regarding the protection provided to a property owner pursuant to Section 12822.6 of the Public Utilities Code, which prohibits a MUD from collecting delinquent charges or penalties from a property owner accrued by a residential tenant in a non-master-metered building. EXISTING LAW: 1)Authorizes a MUD, until January 1, 2016, by resolution or ordinance, to require the owner of record of real property to pay the fees, tolls, rates, rentals, or other charges, including penalties or interest, for services rendered to a lessee, tenant, or subtenant that have become delinquent. Specifies that these unpaid charges are a lien on the property SB 188 Page 4 when filed in the office of the county recorder, as specified, and that the lien has the force, effect, and priority of a judgment lien. (Public Utilities Code Section 12811.1 (a). All subsequent citations refer to the Public Utilities Code, unless otherwise indicated.) 2)Provides that before a MUD may collect delinquent charges it must do the following: a) Prepare and file an annual report of delinquent charges for each affected parcel; b) Give published and mailed notice of the filing of the report and the time and place for a public hearing; c) Hear and consider objections or protests of the report at the public hearing and potentially revise the report; and, d) Provide, by August 10 of each year, a final report to the county recorder to be added to the current tax assessment roll. (Section 12811.1 (c).) 3)Requires the MUD to file a release of the lien within 30 days of receipt of payment of the delinquent charges. (Section 12811.1 (b).) 4)Prohibits a MUD from recovering on the tax roll any delinquent fees, tolls, rates, rentals, or other charges for services for commercial use to a commercial tenant, as specified. (Section 12811.1 (c) (5).) 5)Requires any MUD that places a lien on a property for water or sewer service on or before December 31, 2014, to submit to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary and to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Local Government, on or before January 1, 2015, a report containing the following SB 188 Page 5 information: a) The total number of liens created under this section for water or sewer service and the total dollar amount of those liens; and, b) The overall effectiveness of the liens and any problems associated with the use of those liens. 6)Specifies that the authorization and procedures for recording a lien for unpaid charges shall only apply to a MUD providing water or sewer to residential property and shall not apply to delinquent charges for the furnishing of electrical services. (Section 12811.1 (h).) FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal. COMMENTS: The Municipal Utilities Act authorizes the creation of special districts that are authorized to acquire, construct, own, and operate works providing electrical, heat, water, sewer, garbage disposal, and various transportation and communication services. These special districts, known as Municipal Utility Districts (MUDs), should not be confused with the much more common "municipally owned utilities" (MOUs), which are city-owned utilities rather than special districts. Currently there are only five MUDs in the state. Only two of these provide basic services to residential users. The Sacramento Municipal Utility District (SMUD) provides electricity, while the East Bay Municipal Utility District (EBMUD) provides water and sewer services. Because this bill only applies to residential water and sewer services, EBMUD, the sponsor, is the only district which is affected by its provisions. Background on SB 1035 of 2010. Although the original Municipal Utilities Act authorized MUDs to impose liens against real property to recover delinquent charges, MUDs lost that authority in 1996 when they were prohibited from imposing liens on SB 188 Page 6 property owners whose tenants were delinquent for water or electrical services. In 1998, the same limitation on lien authority was extended to sewer services. The apparent rationale for these limitations was that property owners should not be liable for their tenants' failure to pay their bills. The problem with this approach, however, is that it left the MUD with two unattractive options when a customer neglected to pay water and sewer service bills: shut off water service to the delinquent customer, or recover its losses by charging more to other ratepayers. However, in 2010, SB 1035 (Hancock, Chapter 485, Statutes of 2010) provided a third, more attractive, option by authorizing a MUD to record a lien on residential real property in the amount of any unpaid charges. SB 1035 did a number of things. First, it authorized a MUD to collect delinquent charges by charging the delinquent amount to the property owner's tax roll and placing a lien on the property for unpaid water and sewer charges. (It left in place a restriction against using liens for unpaid electrical service charges, which is why SB 1035 only affected EBMUD, and not SMUD.) Second, SB 1035 authorized a MUD to collect unpaid water and sewer charges, including any penalties or interest, in the same manner as property taxes were collected, unless the account had been established by the tenant. Third, where the delinquent account was in the name of a tenant, SB 1035 authorized the MUD to record a lien on the affected real property in the amount of the delinquent charges, plus interest and penalties, and specified that the lien would have the force, effect, and priority of a judgment lien. EBMUD Report. In order to help evaluate whether the lien authority should continue after a sunset date of January 1, 2016, SB 1035 also required any MUD that used the authority (i.e. EBMUD) to submit to the relevant committees of Legislature, no later than January 1, 2015, a report on the number of liens recorded for water and sewer delinquencies, the dollar amount of those liens, the overall effectiveness of the SB 188 Page 7 liens, and any problems associated with the use of those liens. EBMUD submitted the required report on November 25, 2014. EBMUD's report shows that between January 2011 and June 2013, EBMUD filed 1,195 liens representing $1,384,000 in delinquent charges. It collected $1,298,000, or roughly 94% of the delinquent amount, either directly from the property owners, or via property tax rolls. Between July 2013 and July 2014, EBMUD filed 1,784 liens representing $1,263,000 in delinquent charges. EBMUD has collected $306,000 of the latter amount directly from property owners, and it predicts, based on the prior three years, that it will collect about $899,000 of the remaining $957,000 from the tax rolls. These numbers reflect a high degree of success compared to past years. EBMUD estimates that, overall, it has increased its collection rates from a paltry 15% to over 90% since SB 1035 went into effect. This has also been beneficial to residents, in terms of disruptions to service. Prior to 2010, EBMUD terminated service to about 400 master-metered multi-family residential accounts each year due to non-payment of bills. Since using the authority granted under SB 1035, EBMUD has not terminated service to any master-metered multi-family residential buildings. There is no evidence that EBMUD has abused its authority, or that property owners failed to receive adequate notice and an opportunity to challenge. In light of this clear success, this bill removes the sunset provision in existing law, thereby making permanent EBMUD's authority to record a lien on real property for delinquent charges for residential water and sewer services. All existing procedural requirements and protections remain unchanged in existing law. REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION: SB 188 Page 8 Support East Bay Municipal Utility District (sponsor) Alameda County Board of Supervisors Association of California Water Agencies California Special Districts Association Opposition None on file Analysis Prepared by:Thomas Clark / JUD. / (916) 319-2334