BILL ANALYSIS Ó SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS Senator Ricardo Lara, Chair 2015 - 2016 Regular Session SB 513 (Beall) - Carl Moyer Memorial Air Quality Standards Attainment Program: fees ----------------------------------------------------------------- | | | | | | ----------------------------------------------------------------- |--------------------------------+--------------------------------| | | | |Version: May 12, 2015 |Policy Vote: T. & H. 10 - 0, | | | E.Q. 7 - 0 | | | | |--------------------------------+--------------------------------| | | | |Urgency: No |Mandate: No | | | | |--------------------------------+--------------------------------| | | | |Hearing Date: May 18, 2015 |Consultant: Marie Liu | | | | ----------------------------------------------------------------- This bill meets the criteria for referral to the Suspense File. Bill Summary: SB 513 would expand the eligible uses of funds raised by local air districts under the Carl Moyer Memorial Air Quality Standards Attainment Program and the local AB 923 incentive programs. This bill would allow all air districts, regardless of their attainment status of state or federal ambient air quality standards. Fiscal Impact: Minor and absorbable costs to the Air Pollution Control Fund (special) to the Air Resources Board (ARB) to update regulations in accordance with this bill. Unknown cost pressures, at least in the millions of dollars, from the Air Pollution Control Fund (special) for increased uses of the AB 923 program. Unknown costs pressures, at least in the millions of dollars, SB 513 (Beall) Page 1 of ? to the Greenhouse Gas Reduction Fund (special) for projects that may seek funding from both the GGRF and the Moyer Program. Background: The Carl Moyer Memorial Air Quality Standards Attainment Program (Moyer Program) (AB 1571 (Villaraigosa), Chapter 923, Statutes of 1999), administered by ARB and local air districts, funds the incremental cost of cleaner-than-required vehicles, engines, and equipment. The primary objective of the program is to achieve air quality emission reductions that would not otherwise occur through regulations or other legal mandates. The Moyer Program was expanded by AB 923 (Firebaugh), Chapter 707, Statutes of 2004 to cover additional pollutants and engines while also increasing funding to the program by increasing the allowable vehicle registration surcharge and increasing the fees paid on tire sales, with a portion of that increase going to the Moyer Program. AB 8 (Perea) Chapter 401, Statutes of 2013 extended the assessment of the higher tire fee and the ability for locals to assess the $6 vehicle registration surcharge until January 1, 2024. Local Moyer Programs are funded by the motor vehicle registration fees while the statewide Moyer Program is funded by the tire surcharge and fines and penalties from the Air Pollution Control Fund. AB 8 also required ARB to convene a workgroup to evaluate the program. ARB and the air districts convened two public meetings of the workgroup, in June and October 2014, to solicit input from stakeholders. Proposed Law: This bill would make various changes to the Carl Moyer Program. Specifically, this bill would: Allow all air districts, regardless of its state attainment designation, to levy the vehicle registration surcharge for the Moyer Program. This bill would allow these surcharges to be used for the attainment or maintenance of state and federal ambient air quality standards or the reduction of toxic air contaminant emissions from motor vehicles, in addition to the SB 513 (Beall) Page 2 of ? current purpose of implementing the California Clean Air Act. Expand eligible uses of the local surcharges under the Lower-Emission School Bus Program to include: o The repowering of schoolbuses (in addition to purchases of new buses and retrofits) o High costs for replacement of onboard natural gas fuel tanks on school busses and deteriorating natural gas fueling dispensers by removing the statutory cap on grant amounts for these purposes. o Alternative fuel and electric infrastructure projects solicited through a competitive bid process. Expand eligibility in the state's Moyer Program to include: o Energy infrastructure (rather than just electrification infrastructure) to fuel or power covered sources. o Emissions from all marine vessels (not just diesel ones) and all categories necessary for the state and air districts to meet air quality goals. Require that all funded projects, except infrastructure projects, follow-cost effective criteria established by the ARB in collaboration with the districts. The cost effective criteria would be required to take into account the ability for the project to provide ancillary benefits, the cost of emission control technologies, and the cost effectiveness values for NOx, particulate matter, or reactive organic gases for any adopted rule or control measure in the district's implementation plan. SB 513 (Beall) Page 3 of ? Defines "ancillary benefits" to include air quality, climate and public health benefits beyond the reductions in covered emissions, including reductions in GHG emissions, short-lived climate pollutant reductions, and benefits to disadvantaged communities. The ARB would be required to identify ancillary benefits in its grant criteria. This requirement would be in place of statutory cost effective limits set currently set in statute. Change what funding should be considered into the cost of the project. Allow other funding sources to be used for a project without those other funds being factored into the cost effectiveness calculations, including the Greenhouse Gas Reduction Fund. Require the ARB to update grant criteria by July 1, 2017. Require the ARB instead of the California Energy Commission to publish procedures to monitor and audit infrastructure projects. Make various changes to the spending requirements of grants, including the process for when grants are not spent and liquidation requirements. Increase the amount of funds that can be used for program support and outreach by the ARB and the air districts. Change the cost basis to determine incremental cost for the purpose of judging the programs. SB 513 (Beall) Page 4 of ? Staff Comments: This bill makes numerous changes to the Moyer Program, including some changes that give ARB additional discretion such as establishing cost effective calculations (which are currently set in statute) and identifying ancillary benefits. ARB is required to update the grant criteria by July 1, 2017 to incorporate these changes. According to the ARB, these costs will be minor and absorbable. According to the author, the changes in this bill are driven by the continued growing demand for cleaner technologies and the need for emission reductions. By expanding the authorized uses of the Moyer and AB 923 funding, this bill places cost pressures on the funds that support those programs. These cost pressures are at least in the millions of dollars considering the cost of energy infrastructure products. Existing law gives local air districts the authority to levy a vehicle motor registration surcharge. In order to collect these surcharges, the boards of the local air districts (or the board of supervisors in the case of the Sacramento air district) must adopt a resolution providing for both the fee and the corresponding program for the spending of those fees. By expanding the types of eligible projects that can receive grants from the locally-levied fee, this bill may change the way that the boards of the air districts approve the vehicle registration surcharge in order to be consistent with Proposition 26. Given that the previous authority to levy the registration surcharge was scheduled to sunset in 2015 before that date was extended by AB 8, most of the local air districts are likely to need to adopt a new resolution to collect the fees. According to the author, the bill aims to enable leveraging of Moyer and AB 923 program funds with outside funding support of emission reduction projects, including the GGRF. By allowing projects to draw down on funds supporting the Moyer and AB 923 programs as well the GGRF, there will be cost pressures to all funds as projects will be able to simultaneously seek funding from multiple sources. These cost pressures are also in the millions of dollars. SB 513 (Beall) Page 5 of ? -- END --