BILL ANALYSIS Ó SB 894 Page 1 Date of Hearing: June 14, 2016 Counsel: Sandy Uribe ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY Reginald Byron Jones-Sawyer, Sr., Chair SB 894 (Jackson) - As Introduced January 21, 2016 SUMMARY: Requires that firearm owners report the theft or loss of a firearm to a local law enforcement agency within five days of the time they knew, or reasonably should have known, that the firearm had been stolen or lost. Specifically, this bill: 1)Requires a person to report the theft or loss of a firearm he or she owns or possesses to a local law enforcement agency in the jurisdiction in which the theft or loss occurred within five days of the time the person knew, or reasonably should SB 894 Page 2 have known, that the firearm had been stolen or lost. 2)Requires every person who has reported a firearm as lost or stolen to notify the local law enforcement agency within 48 hours if the firearm is subsequently recovered. 3)Provides that the lost or stolen firearm reporting requirement does not apply to: a) Any law enforcement agency or peace officer acting within the course and scope of his or her employment or official duties, if he or she reports the loss or theft to his or her employing agency; b) Any United States Marshal or member of the Armed Forces of the United States or the National Guard, while engaged in his or her official duties; c) Any federally licensed firearms dealer or manufacturer, as specified, who reports the theft or loss in accordance with specified federal law, or the successor thereto, and the applicable regulations; and, d) Any person whose firearm was lost or stolen before January 1, 2017. 4)Provides that a first violation of either of the above reporting requirements provisions is an infraction punishable by a fine not to exceed $100. A second violation is an infraction, punishable by a fine not exceeding $1,000. A SB 894 Page 3 third or subsequent violation is a misdemeanor, punishable by imprisonment in a county jail not exceeding six months, or by a fine not exceeding $1,000, or by both that fine and imprisonment. 5)Makes it an infraction for a person to report to a local law enforcement agency that a firearm has been lost or stolen, knowing the report to be false. A violation is punishable by a fine not exceeding $250 for a first offense, and by a fine not exceeding $1,000 for a second or subsequent offense. 6)Requires every person reporting a lost or stolen firearm to report the make, model, and serial number of the firearm, if known. 7)Requires every sheriff or police chief to submit a description of each firearm which has been reported lost or stolen directly into the Department of Justice Automated Firearms System. 8)Provides that, for purposes of the reporting requirement, a "firearm" includes the frame or receiver of the weapon, but does not include an unloaded antique firearm. 9)Requires firearms dealers to conspicuously post notice of these reporting requirements within the licensed premises, as specified. 10) Specifies that these reporting provisions do "not preclude SB 894 Page 4 or preempt a local ordinance that imposes additional penalties or requirements in regard to reporting the theft or loss of a firearm." EXISTING LAW: 1)Provides that any licensed firearms dealer shall report, within 48 hours of discovery, the loss or theft of specified firearms to the appropriate law enforcement agency in the city, county, or city or county where the licensee's business is located. (Pen. Code, § 26885, subd. (b).) 2)Provides that any time a licensed firearms manufacturer discovers that a firearm has been stolen or is missing from the licensee's premises, the licensee shall report the loss or theft within 48 hours of discovery to specified law enforcement agencies, and shall maintain records of lost or stolen firearms for at least 10 years. (Pen. Code, § 29115.) 3)Requires handguns to be centrally registered at time of transfer or sale due to various transfer forms centrally compiled by the DOJ. DOJ is required to keep a registry from data sent to DOJ indicating who owns what handgun by make, model, and serial number and the date thereof. (Pen. Code, § 11106, subds. (a) & (c).) 4)States that the DOJ must keep a centralized and computerized SB 894 Page 5 list of all lost, stolen, and found serialized property reported to DOJ. (Pen. Code, § 11106, subd. (a).) 5)Requires each sheriff or police executive to submit descriptions of serialized property, or non-serialized property that has been uniquely inscribed, which has been reported stolen, lost, found, recovered, held for safekeeping, or under observation into the DOJ automated property system for firearms or other stolen property. Information about a firearm entered into the system shall remain in the system until the reported firearm has been found, recovered, is no longer under observation, or the record is determined to have been entered in error. (Pen. Code, § 11108, subd. (a).) FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown COMMENTS: 1)Author's Statement: According to the author, "The public overwhelmingly supports laws requiring the reporting of lost or stolen firearms. A nationwide poll in 2011 found that 94% of Americans surveyed favor laws to require the reporting of lost or stolen firearms. "The reporting of lost or stolen firearms will bring several critical improvements to public safety in California. "1.Reduce Gun Trafficking SB 894 Page 6 "When a crime gun is traced by law enforcement to the last known purchaser, that person may falsely claim that the gun was lost or stolen to hide his or her involvement in the crime or in gun trafficking. A reporting law would provide a tool for law enforcement to detect firearms trafficking and prosecute 'straw purchasers,' individuals who buy firearms on behalf of criminals who are prohibited from possessing guns. "An analysis by Mayors Against Illegal Guns - a nationwide coalition of over 600 mayors - found that states without mandatory lost or stolen reporting laws export two and a half times more crime guns across state lines than jurisdictions with such laws. Similarly, researchers from the Johns Hopkins Center for Gun Policy and Research found that state laws requiring the reporting of lost or stolen firearms were associated with crime gun export rates that were 43 percent lower than in states that lacked this policy. "2.Enhance Armed Prohibited Persons System "Mandatory reporting of lost or stolen firearms would enhance the California Department of Justice's efforts to remove firearms from convicted criminals and others identified in the state's Armed Prohibited Persons System (APPS). Currently, these individuals, who own firearms, but are prohibited from possessing them, may falsely claim that their illegally-possessed firearms were lost or stolen. Moreover, with a reporting requirement, the APPS program will be more efficient since law enforcement resources will not be wasted on attempts to recover guns that have been reported lost or stolen. "3.Alert Law Enforcement on Missing Firearms "A reporting requirement would alert law enforcement to the existence of guns stolen by criminals in their communities. It would also make it easier for law enforcement to return lost or stolen firearms to their rightful owners. A 2007 report by the International Association of Chiefs of Police SB 894 Page 7 recommended that state and local governments mandate reporting of lost or stolen firearms. The IACP report concluded that, "law enforcement's early awareness of every lost and stolen gun will enhance their ability to recover those guns and reduce gun violence." 2)Background: Under existing law, licensed firearms manufacturers and dealers are required to report the loss or theft of firearms within 48 hours to specified law enforcement agencies, however, there is not a similar requirement on firearm owners whose firearms are lost or stolen. A report by the International Association of Chiefs of Police (IACP), Taking a Stand: Reducing Gun Violence in Our Communities (2007), recommended that state and local governments mandate individual reporting of lost or stolen firearms. The IACP report concluded that, "Ensuring law enforcement's early awareness of every lost and stolen gun will enhance their ability to recover those guns and reduce gun violence." (International Association of Chiefs of Police, Taking a Stand: Reducing Gun Violence in Our Communities (Sept. 2007), http://www.theiacp.org/LinkClick.aspx?fileticket=%2Fs0LiOkJK5Q %3D&tabid=87.) 3)Prior Governor Veto Messages: This legislation is similar to three prior bills that were vetoed by Governors Brown and Schwarzenegger. SB1366 (DeSaulnier) of 2012, and SB 299 (Desaulnier) of the 2013 were vetoed by Governor Brown. The governor stated in his veto message of SB 299: "I am returning Senate Bill 299 without my signature. Last year I vetoed a nearly identical bill, SB 1366, noting that I was not convinced that criminalizing the failure to report a lost or stolen firearm would improve identification of gun traffickers or help law enforcement disarm people prohibited SB 894 Page 8 from possessing guns. I continue to believe that responsible people report the loss or theft of a firearm and irresponsible people do not. I remain skeptical that this bill would change those behaviors." Similarly, SB 59 (Lowenthal) of the 2005-06 Legislative Session, was vetoed by Governor Schwarzenegger. The Governor's veto message stated in pertinent part, "While I share the Legislature's concern about the criminal use of lost or stolen weapons, the ambiguous manner in which this bill was written would make compliance with the law confusing for legitimate gun-owners and could result in cases where law-abiding citizens face criminal penalties simply because they were the victim of a crime, which is particularly troubling given the unproven results of other jurisdictions in California that have passed similar measures." 4)Penalty Provision: This bill provides that a violation of the reporting requirement is an infraction, punishable by a fine not exceeding two hundred fifty dollars ($250) for a first offense, and by a fine not exceeding one thousand dollars ($1,000) for a second or subsequent offense. It should be noted that AB 1695 (Bonta) also makes it unlawful to report to a local law enforcement agency that a firearm has been lost or stolen, knowing the report to be false. However, AB 1695 punishes the violation as a misdemeanor. Thus, there is a conflict between these two bills. 5)Argument in Support: According to the Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department, "[I]n 2013, the Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department sponsored Senate Bill 299 by Senator DeSaulnier, dealing with reporting requirements of lost or stolen firearms. As with SB 299 of 2013, SB 894 would provide a tool for law enforcement to detect firearms trafficking and charge criminals who engage in it. A requirement to report lost or stolen firearms would assist in the identification and SB 894 Page 9 prosecution of 'straw buyers,' who are individuals that purchase guns legally, then sell them to people who cannot legally purchase firearms, such as gang members, criminals, or minors. When crime guns are traced to 'straw buyers,' they falsely claim that the firearm was lost or stolen. The lack of a reporting requirement enables 'straw buyers' to shield their criminal activity and continue to sell guns illegally to dangerous criminals. A reporting requirement would likewise assist in the prosecution of armed criminals who falsely claim that a crime gun traced to them was lost or stolen when in fact it was used in a crime. The lack of a reporting requirement enables criminals to hide their involvement in a crime and evade apprehension. "SB 894 would also help law enforcement efforts to disarm individuals who possess a firearm and subsequently becomes prohibited by law from purchasing or possessing firearms because of falling into a prohibited class. When law enforcement attempts to recover these illegal firearms, gun owners may falsely claim that the gun was lost or stolen. A reporting requirement would improve the efficiency and implementation of the state's Armed and Prohibited Persons System Program, in which law enforcement agencies work to proactively disarm prohibited individuals before they harm themselves or others. "The reporting requirements in Senate Bill 894 would also alert law enforcement to the existence of a stolen gun in their jurisdictions and facilitate the return of stolen firearms. The recovery of stolen guns protects communities and reduces gun violence." 6)Argument in Opposition: According to the National Rifle Association, "This bill would place firearm owners in jeopardy of prosecution for becoming a victim of a crime by placing criminal liability on the firearm's owner regardless of whether they knew their firearm was stolen, if law enforcement thinks 'they should have known' it was stolen. SB 894 Page 10 "Firearm owners voluntarily and regularly report stolen firearms, but the criminal penalties of SB 894 force crime victims to decline to cooperate with police if a stolen firearm is recovered. A firearms owner who was not aware of the legal requirement to report the loss or theft of a firearm and who is contacted by police investigating a crime faces possible criminal prosecution for failing to report that the firearm was stolen or missing. Such an owner will need to hire a lawyer, who will advise them to remain silent while immunity is negotiated, rather than quickly supplying police the information they need to properly and promptly investigate the crime, which may be time sensitive." 7)Related Legislation: AB 1695 (Bonta) makes it a misdemeanor to falsely report to law enforcement that a firearm has been lost or stolen, and institutes a 10-year ban on owning a firearm for those convicted of making a false report. AB 1695 is pending in the Senate Public Safety Committee. 8)Prior Legislation: a) SB 299 (Desaulnier) of the 2013-14 Legislative Session, would have made it a crime to fail to report the theft or loss of a firearm to a local law enforcement agency within seven days of the time the owner knew, or reasonably should have known, that the firearm was lost or stolen. SB 299 was vetoed. b) SB1366 (DeSaulnier) of the 2011-2012 Legislative Session, would have made it a crime to fail to report the theft or loss of a firearm he/she owns or possesses to law enforcement agency within 48 hours of the time he/she knew or reasonably should have known that the firearm had been stolen or lost. SB 1366 was vetoed. c) SB 59 (Lowenthal), of the 2005-06 Legislative Session, would have required a gun owner to report a lost or stolen firearm within five working days. SB 59 was vetoed. SB 894 Page 11 REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION: Support American Academy of Pediatrics, California Chapter American College of Emergency Physicians, California Chapter California Academy of Family Physicians California Chapters of the Brady Campaign to Prevent Gun Violence City of Santa Barbara City of Santa Barbara Police Department Coalition Against Gun Violence, Santa Barbara County Courage Campaign Holman United Methodist Church Jewish Labor Committee Western Region Law Center to Prevent Gun Violence Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department Physicians for Social Responsibility - Sacramento Chapter Physicians for Social Responsibility - San Francisco Bay Area Chapter Violence Prevention Coalition of Greater Los Angeles Violence Prevention Coalition of Orange County Women Against Gun Violence Youth Alive One Private Individual SB 894 Page 12 Opposition California Rifle and Pistol Association California Sportsman's Lobby California Waterfowl Association Firearms Policy Coalition Gun Owners of California National Rifle Association Outdoor Sportsmen's Coalition Safari Club International Analysis Prepared by:Sandy Uribe / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744