BILL ANALYSIS Ó SB 983 Page 1 Date of Hearing: June 21, 2016 ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY Mark Stone, Chair SB 983 (Morrell) - As Amended May 16, 2016 SENATE VOTE: 39-0 SUBJECT: MORTGAGES AND DEEDS OF TRUST: TRUSTEE FEES KEY ISSUE: SHOULD THE statutory BASE FEES that A TRUSTEE MAY CHARGE FOR CONDUCTING THE NONJUDICIAL FORECLOSURE PROCESS BE INCREASED BY $50-the first such increase since 2002? SYNOPSIS This bill, sponsored by the United Trustees' Association, seeks a modest $50 increase to four base fee amounts that trustees are allowed to charge for carrying out their duties in executing the nonjudicial foreclosure process. The author notes that these particular fees have been capped at their current levels since 2002 and have not been increased in the 14 years since then, despite a corresponding increase of 34% in the California CPI. By contrast, the $50 increase in fees proposed by this bill represents an increase ranging from 12% to 20% of the four different base amounts-in every case, substantially lower than the 34% increase that would have been imposed if the increase were based strictly on the increase in the California CPI since 2002. Given the far greater increases in the costs of housing and size of home loans since 2002, the $50 fee increase seems modest and not unreasonable. After being significantly reduced in scope by amendments taken in the Senate Judiciary Committee, SB 983 Page 2 this bill was approved unanimously by the Senate and has no known opposition. SUMMARY: Increases by a total of $50 the statutory base fees that a trustee is allowed to charge for carrying out his or her duties in executing the nonjudicial foreclosure process-a 12% to 20% increase in the fees, depending on the unpaid sum of the loan. Specifically, this bill: 1)Increases the base amount in the trustee's or attorney's fee that may be charged during the nonjudicial foreclosure process or until the notice of sale is deposited in the mail to the trustor at any time prior to the decree of foreclosure, from $300 to $350 if the unpaid principal sum of the loan is $150,000 or less, or from $250 to $300 if the unpaid principal sum of the loan exceeds $150,000. 2)Increases the base amount in the trustee's or attorney's fee that may be charged for executing the trustee sale of the property through the nonjudicial foreclosure process, from $425 to $475 if the unpaid principal sum of the loan is $150,000 or less, or from $360 to $410 if the unpaid principal sum of the loan exceeds $150,000. 3)Eliminates an unnecessary reference to rescission of a pending trustee's sale, and makes other clarifying and technical changes. EXISTING LAW: 1)Provides that trustee's or attorney's fees which may be charged during the non-judicial foreclosure process or until the notice of sale is deposited in the mail to the trustor or at any time prior to the decree of foreclosure, shall not exceed $300 if the unpaid principal sum secured is $150,000 or less, or $250 if the unpaid principal sum secured exceeds $150,000, plus a specified percentage of the unpaid principal sum. (Civil Code Section 2924c. All further references are to this code unless otherwise stated.) SB 983 Page 3 2)Provides that commencing with the date that the notice of sale is deposited in the mail and until the property is sold pursuant to the power of sale contained in the mortgage or deed of trust, a beneficiary, trustee, or mortgagee may demand and receive from a trustor or mortgagor reasonable costs and expenses actually incurred in enforcing the terms of the obligation, as specified, and trustee's or attorney's fees in an amount that does not exceed $425 if the unpaid principal sum secured is $150,000 or less, or $360 if the unpaid principal sum secured exceeds $150,000, plus a specified percentage of the unpaid principal sum. (Section 2924d.) 3)Requires a mortgagee, beneficiary, or authorized agent to record a rescission of a notice of default or cancel a pending trustee sale, if applicable, upon the borrower executing a permanent foreclosure prevention alternative, and then, in the case of a short sale, requires the rescission or cancellation of the pending trustee's sale to occur when the short sale has been approved and proof of funds or financing has been provided, as specified. (Section 2924.11 (f).) FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed non-fiscal. COMMENTS: This bill, sponsored by the United Trustees' Association, seeks a modest $50 increase to the base fees that trustees are allowed to charge for carrying out their duties in executing the nonjudicial foreclosure process. According to the author: The purpose of SB 983 is to permit nonjudicial foreclosure trustees to regain a modest percentage of purchasing power eroded due to the effects of cost of living increases since the last increases authorized in 2001, by providing $50 dollar increases in base trustees' fees contained in Civil Code sections 2924c and 2924d. The bill makes no changes in the formulas establishing additions to the base fees based upon SB 983 Page 4 percentages on unpaid principal balances. . . These fees have not been increased since 2001 (effective January 1, 2002). Like all businesses, trustees have seen cost increases in the past 15 years, and we believe that modest increases in these fees are appropriate at this time. Background on Non-Judicial Foreclosure. Non-judicial foreclosure (sometimes referred to as a "private trustee's sale") is the preferred method used by lenders in California to exercise the remedy of foreclosure when the loan is not repaid by the borrower according to the terms of a mortgage agreement. The procedural requirements for non-judicial foreclosure are set forth in Civil Code Sections 2924 to 2924 (h). As the author notes, the procedures must be precisely complied with under existing case law because "substantial compliance" is not enough. Ordinarily, the borrower will execute a deed of trust in favor of the lender which makes the real property the security for the loan and names someone to act as trustee. The function of this trustee under a deed of trust is either to initiate foreclosure at the lender's direction in the event of a breach, or to reconvey the trust deed once the obligation has been satisfied in full. The trustee initiates the foreclosure process by preparing, executing, and recording the Notice of Default. For the next three months, there is a redemption period in which the borrower may attempt to cure the default. If the borrower were unsuccessful, a Notice of Sale would be recorded and the process would culminate in a trustee's sale where the property would be sold to the highest bidder. The auctioneer conducts this sale as instructed by the trustee and reports the results back to the trustee. The trustee notifies the beneficiary and prepares the Trustee's Deed, which vests title inthe name of the successful bidder. If there are no bids for the property that exceed the opening bid, the property reverts to the beneficiary (in this case, the bank or lender) who then takes title to the property under the Trustee's SB 983 Page 5 Deed. Because there is no statutory right of redemption following a non-judicial foreclosure under California law, the property at this point becomes officially "bank-owned." Existing law specifies statutory base fee amounts and the method for calculating the total amount of those fees. Existing law, specifically Civil Code Sections 2924c and 2924d, specifies the maximum allowable fees that a trustee may receive in compensation for executing his or her duties in the nonjudicial foreclosure process. According to the author, the law permits trustees to charge a base fee based upon the unpaid principal balance of the loan, which declines as the unpaid principal amount of the loan increases. The trustee may also charge a percentage of the unpaid principal balance, which again declines as the unpaid principal balance increases. Different fees are established based upon the stage of the foreclosure: one set covers foreclosures after the recording of notices of default but prior to notices of sale; a second set applies after notices of sale but prior to trustee's sales; a third set applies upon trustee's sales. This fee differentiation is intended to compensate for additional work performed by trustees as the foreclosure moves forward. It is important to note that these fees are not cumulative: each set of fees goes away and the new fees apply as the foreclosure process unfolds. Under current law, allowable trustee fees are capped at various stages of the foreclosure process. For foreclosure proceedings that are resolved at the Notice of Default stage, a trustee may charge no more than $300 if the unpaid principal sum secured is $150,000 or less. If the unpaid principal sum secured exceeds $150,000, a trustee may charge $250 plus one-half of 1 percent of the unpaid principal sum secured between $50,000 and $150,000, plus one-quarter of 1 percent of the unpaid principal sum secured between $150,000 and $500,000, plus one-eighth of 1 percent of the unpaid principal sum secured in excess of $500,000. For foreclosure proceedings that are resolved at or after the Notice of Sale stage, a trustee may charge no more than $425 if the unpaid principal sum secured is $150,000 or less. If the unpaid principal sum secured exceeds $150,000, a SB 983 Page 6 trustee may charge $360 plus 1 percent of the unpaid principal sum secured between $50,000 and $150,000, plus one-half of 1 percent of the unpaid principal sum secured between $150,000 and $500,000, plus one-quarter of 1 percent of the unpaid principal sum secured in excess of $500,000. This bill provides for a modest increase in the allowable base fees trustees may charge for executing the nonjudicial foreclosure process. This bill would increase each of the four base fee amounts, described above, by $50 (i.e. $300 to $350, $250 to $300, $425 to $475, and $360 to $410.) The author notes that these amounts represent the maximum permissible base fee amounts-trustees may impose fees that are less than these maximum amounts if they choose. The current trustee rate structure became effective January 1, 2002, as enacted by SB 958 (Ackerman), Ch. 438, Stats. 2001, and has not been increased in the 14 years since then. Committee staff notes that the cost of living, according to the California CPI, has increased by approximately 34 percent since 2002, the last year the trustee fees were adjusted. By contrast, the $50 fee increase proposed by this bill is substantially lower than the amount that would be allowed if the increase were based strictly on the California CPI. For example, this bill raises the $425 base fee to $475, an increase of 11.7%. If the $425 base fee were increased based on CPI alone (i.e. at a 34% rate), then the fee amount would be increased by $145.17 (instead of $50), to a total of $570.17 (instead of the proposed $475). Staff also notes that while a consumer who seeks to redeem a property through non-judicial foreclosure would have to pay the trustee the increased base rate as part of the redemption process. However, the $50 increase almost assuredly will not comprise a significant part of the redemption price. For all of these reasons, the fee increases proposed under this bill seem to represent a modest and reasonable adjustment in the fees that trustees are authorized to charge for their duties in this process. SB 983 Page 7 REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION: Support United Trustees Association Opposition None on file Analysis Prepared by:Anthony Lew / JUD. / (916) 319-2334