BILL ANALYSIS Ó SENATE COMMITTEE ON HEALTH Senator Ed Hernandez, O.D., Chair BILL NO: SB 994 --------------------------------------------------------------- |AUTHOR: |Hill | |---------------+-----------------------------------------------| |VERSION: |April 14, 2016 | --------------------------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------------------------- |HEARING DATE: |April 20, 2016 | | | --------------------------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------------------------- |CONSULTANT: |Vince Marchand | --------------------------------------------------------------- SUBJECT : Antimicrobial stewardship policies SUMMARY : Requires primary care clinics and specialty clinics, by January 1, 2018, and physicians, podiatrists and dentists when applying for their next renewal license, to adopt and implement an antibiotic stewardship policy, as defined. Existing law: 1)Requires general acute care hospitals, by July 1, 2015, to adopt and implement an antimicrobial stewardship policy (ASP) in accordance with guidelines established by the federal government and professional organizations; develop a physician supervised multidisciplinary antimicrobial stewardship committee, subcommittee, or workgroup; and report antimicrobial stewardship program activities to each appropriate hospital committee undertaking clinical quality improvement activities. 2)Requires skilled nursing facilities (SNFs), by January 1, 2017, to adopt and implement an ASP that is consistent with antimicrobial stewardship guidelines developed by the federal Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), the federal Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, the Society for Healthcare Epidemiology of America, or similar recognized professional organizations. Specifies that failure of a SNF to comply with this requirement is subject to citation and civil penalty provisions in existing law. 3)Requires, on or after January 1, 2018, a licensed veterinarian who renews his or her license to complete a minimum of one credit hour of continuing education on the judicious use of medically important antimicrobial drugs, as defined, every four years as part of his or her continuing education SB 994 (Hill) Page 2 of ? requirements. 4)Licenses and regulates primary care clinics and specialty clinics by the Department of Public Health (DPH). Specialty clinics include surgical clinics, chronic dialysis clinics, rehabilitation clinics, and alternative birth centers. Requires clinics, unless accredited by a recognized accrediting organization or unless it meets other specified exceptions, to be periodically inspected for compliance with licensing laws and regulations no less than once every three years, and as often as necessary to ensure the quality of care being provided. 5)Licenses and regulates physicians through the Medical Board of California, osteopathic physicians through the Osteopathic Medical Board, podiatrists through the Board of Podiatric Medicine, and dentists through the Dental Board of California. This bill: 1)Requires a primary care clinic or a specialty clinic, as defined, on or before January 1, 2018, to adopt and implement an ASP, as defined. 2)Requires physicians, osteopathic physicians, podiatrists, and dentists, who practice in a setting other than a licensed primary care or specialty clinic, general acute care hospital, or SNF, to adopt and implement an ASP, as defined, before applying for a renewal license. 3)Requires physicians, osteopathic physicians, podiatrists, and dentists, upon filing an application with their respective licensing board for a renewal license, to certify in writing, on a form prescribed by their respective board, that he or she has both adopted an ASP and is in compliance with that policy. 4)Requires the licensing boards for physicians, osteopathic physicians, podiatrists, and dentists, to audit during each year a random sample of licensees who have certified compliance with the ASP policy, but prohibits the boards from auditing an individual licensee more than once every four years. Requires licensees selected for an audit to submit to his or her respective licensing board, on a form prescribed by that board, a copy of his or her ASP. 5)Requires a licensing board of a physician, osteopathic SB 994 (Hill) Page 3 of ? physician, podiatrist, or dentist, if the board determines that an audited licensee has failed to comply with the ASP requirement, to require that licensee to comply during the following renewal period. Specifies that failure to comply within the following renewal period constitutes unprofessional conduct, as specified. 6)Defines an ASP as efforts to promote the appropriate prescribing of antimicrobials for patients, with the goal of reducing antimicrobial overuse and misuse and minimizing the development of antimicrobial resistant infections, that is consistent with one of the following parameters: a) Antimicrobial stewardship guidelines published by the CDC, the federal Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, the Society for Healthcare Epidemiology, the Infectious Disease Society of America, or similar recognized professional organizations; or, b) Evidence-based methods. Requires, to the extent practicable, evidence-based antimicrobial stewardship policies to include more than one intervention or component. Defines "evidence-based methods" as antimicrobial prescribing intervention methods that have been proven effective through outcome evaluations or studies, including, but not limited to, audit and feedback, academic detailing, clinical decision support, delayed prescribing practices, poster-based interventions, accountable justification, and peer comparison. 7)Makes various legislative findings and declarations, including that the CDC estimates that at least two million Americans are infected with, and 23,000 Americans dies as a result of, antibiotic-resistant infections, and that in one year, 262.5 million courses of antibiotics are written in outpatient settings, with the CDC estimating that over one-half of the antibiotics prescribed in outpatient settings are unnecessary. Also finds and declares that the President's National Action Plan for Combating Antibiotic-Resistant Bacteria calls for the establishment of antibiotic stewardship activities in all healthcare delivery settings, including outpatient settings, by 2020. FISCAL SB 994 (Hill) Page 4 of ? EFFECT : This bill has not been analyzed by a fiscal committee. COMMENTS : 1)Author's statement. According to the author, the CDC estimates that at least 23,000 Americans die as a result of antibiotic resistant infections every year and the threat is a growing. A recent study commissioned by the United Kingdom determined that by 2050, worldwide, more people will die from antibiotic resistant infections than from cancer. While not the only cause, the overuse and misuse of antibiotics in medicine is a significant contributing factor driving the development of antibiotic resistance and if we are to truly solve the problem, among other things, we need to focus on promoting more judicious antibiotic prescribing. A majority of antibiotics are prescribed in non-hospital health care settings, such a medical offices where physicians, physician assistants and nurse practitioners work. Based on data from other countries, an estimated 80% of antibiotic prescriptions are written in the outpatient setting. The CDC estimates at least 50% of the antibiotic prescribing in outpatient settings is unnecessary or inappropriate. SB 994 will promote better antibiotic prescribing and ultimately help reduce the burden of antibiotic resistant infections by requiring antibiotic stewardship policies in outpatient healthcare settings. Antibiotic stewardship improves prescribing decisions through educational interventions. 2)Background. According to the CDC, antibiotic resistance is a quickly growing, extremely dangerous problem. World health leaders have described antibiotic-resistant bacteria as "nightmare bacteria" that "pose a catastrophic threat" to people in every country in the world. Most infections occur in the community, like skin infections with Methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) and sexually transmitted diseases. However, most deaths related to antibiotic resistance occur from drug-resistant infections picked up in healthcare settings, such as hospitals and nursing homes. According to a February 2013 joint letter from the Infectious Diseases Society of America (IDSA) and the Society for Health Epidemiology of America (SHEA) to the National Quality Forum, ample data exist from both inpatient and outpatient settings demonstrating that antibiotics are often prescribed sub-optimally or inappropriately. Antibiotics are misused in a variety of ways. They are often administered when they are not needed, continued when they are no longer SB 994 (Hill) Page 5 of ? necessary, or prescribed at the wrong dose. Broad-spectrum agents may be used unnecessarily against bacteria that are very susceptible or the wrong antibiotic may be given to treat a particular infection. Over the past 30 years, bacteria that are extremely resistant to traditional treatments or resistant to multiple drugs have spread widely among patients in healthcare settings. In some cases these pathogens have been pan-resistant, meaning that they are resistant to all available antibiotics. The unique nature of antibiotics, in which the use of the drugs in one patient can impact the effectiveness of the drug in a different patient, make antibiotic overuse a serious patient safety issue and public health threat. The World Health Organization has characterized antibiotic resistance as "a crisis that has been building up over decades, so that today common and life-threatening infections are becoming difficult or even impossible to treat." Resistant infections not only result in increased morbidity and mortality, but increased economic burdens. For example, studies have shown that antibiotic-resistant infections are associated with longer lengths of stay and increased mortality, both in the hospital and in intensive care units. 3)Presidential Executive Order and Action Plan. In September of 2014, President Obama issued an executive order, titled "Combating Antibiotic-Resistant Bacteria." Among other things, this executive order requires the Health and Human Services Agency, by the end of calendar year 2016, to review existing regulations and propose new regulations or other actions, as appropriate, that require hospitals and other inpatient healthcare delivery facilities to implement robust antibiotic stewardship programs that adhere to best practices, such as those identified by the CDC. The executive order also established a federal task force that is required to, as appropriate, define, promulgate, and implement stewardship programs in other healthcare settings, including office-based practices, outpatient settings, emergency departments, and institutional and long-term care facilities, such as nursing homes, pharmacies, and correctional facilities. In March 2015, the White House issued the National Action Plan for Combating Antibiotic-Resistant Bacteria (Action Plan). The Action Plan lays out a five-year plan to achieve five distinct goals by 2020: 1) slow the emergence of resistant bacteria, 2) strengthen One-Health surveillance efforts, 3) advance the development and use of rapid diagnostic tests to identify SB 994 (Hill) Page 6 of ? resistant bacteria, 4) accelerate the development of new antibiotics, other treatments, and vaccines, and 5) improve international collaboration to achieve these goals. 4)California's program. In February 2010, the DPH Healthcare Associated Infection (HAI) Program developed a statewide antimicrobial stewardship program (ASP) initiative in order to strengthen and promote optimization of antimicrobial utilization in California health care facilities. According to DPH, the purpose of an antimicrobial stewardship program in a healthcare facility is to measure and promote the appropriate use of antimicrobials by selecting the appropriate agent, dose, duration and route of administration in order to improve patient outcomes, while minimizing toxicity and the emergence of antimicrobial resistance. Although guidelines exist for developing ASPs, there is limited information on practical implementation of these guidelines, particularly in resource-limited settings. According to DPH, its partners in this statewide initiative include the Division of Healthcare Quality and Promotion at CDC, Infectious Disease Association of California, and SHEA. According to the DPH website, current program activities include: a) The HAI Program has launched a statewide Antimicrobial Stewardship Program Collaborative, with the goal of ensuring that all California hospitals have a functional and robust ASP to promote patient safety and to decrease antimicrobial resistance. The Collaborative will extend for one year from January through December 2015; b) Spotlight on ASP Project, which helps define antimicrobial stewardship programs and activities, and spotlights volunteer hospitals that want to highlight and share with others their ASP progress; c) Utilization of a statewide assessment of ASPs present in California healthcare facilities (May 2010 - March 2011) to develop evidence-based recommendations on how to implement or strengthen ASPs given available resources and facility attributes; d) Developing recommendations with the Antimicrobial Stewardship Subcommittee of the California HAI Advisory Committee; e) Defining activities that comprise ASPs in California hospitals; and, f) The California Antibiogram Project, which collects SB 994 (Hill) Page 7 of ? information on specific antimicrobial-organism combinations across California general acute care hospitals. 5)Double referral. This bill was heard in the Senate Business, Professions and Economic Development Committee on April 11, 2016, and passed with a 7-0 vote. 6)Prior legislation. SB 361 (Hill, Chapter 764, Statutes of 2015), required SNFs to adopt and implement an antimicrobial stewardship policy by January 1, 2017. SB 27 (Hill, Chapter 758, Statutes of 2015), restricted the use of antimicrobial drugs in livestock, required a veterinarian's prescription or feed directive for use, eliminated the over-the-counter availability of these drugs, required the CDFA to develop antimicrobial stewardship guidelines and best management practices for veterinarians, as well as livestock owners and their employees on the proper use of antimicrobial drugs, and to develop a program to track antimicrobial drug use in livestock. SB 1311 (Hill, Chapter 843, Statutes of 2014), required general acute care hospitals, by July 1, 2015, to adopt and implement an antimicrobial stewardship policy, as specified; develop a physician supervised multidisciplinary antimicrobial stewardship committee, subcommittee, or workgroup; appoint at least one physician or pharmacist who has attended training specifically on antimicrobial stewardship to the committee, subcommittee, or workgroup, as specified; and, report antimicrobial stewardship program activities to appropriate hospital committees, as specified. SB 158 (Florez, Chapter 294, Statutes of 2008), established an infection surveillance, prevention, and control program within DPH to provide oversight of hospital prevention and reporting of general acute care hospital-associated infections, expanded the responsibilities of DPH's HAI Advisory Committee, and requires all hospitals to institute a patient safety plan for the purpose of improving the health and safety of patients and reducing preventable patient safety events. SB 1058 (Alquist, Chapter 296, Statutes of 2008), established the Medical Facility Infection Control and Prevention Act, which requires hospitals to implement specified procedures for SB 994 (Hill) Page 8 of ? screening, prevention, and reporting specified health care associated infections also known as HAIs. Requires hospitals to report positive MRSA and other HAI test results to DPH and requires DPH to make specified information public on its website. SB 739 (Speier, Chapter 526, Statutes of 2006), created a state HAI advisory committee to make recommendations regarding reporting cases of HAI in hospitals. Requires each general acute care hospital, after January 1, 2008, to implement and annually report to DPH its implementation of infection surveillance and infection prevention process measures that have been recommended by CDC Healthcare Infection Control Practices Advisory Committee, as suitable for a mandatory public reporting program. Required, initially, these process measures to include the CDC guidelines for central line insertion practices, surgical antimicrobial prophylaxis, and influenza vaccination of patients and healthcare personnel. Requires DPH, in consultation with the HAI advisory committee, to make this information public no later than six months after receiving the data. Required that general acute care hospitals develop a process for evaluating the judicious use of antibiotics, the results of which shall be monitored jointly by appropriate representatives and committees involved in quality improvement activities. SB 1487 (Speier, 2004), would have required specified hospitals to have written infection control plans and report to Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development (OSHPD) data, including the rate of HAIs and risk-adjusted infection rate data according to the risk-adjustment methodology determined by CDC. SB 1487 was vetoed by then Governor Schwarzenegger, whose veto message suggested that it was unnecessary because of other national efforts, which could call into question the quality and validity of the data without proper auditing, and because it would impose significant costs to hospitals and OSHPD. 7)Support. The Alliance for the Prudent Use of Antibiotics (APUA) states in support, a majority of antibiotics are prescribed in non-hospital health care settings, such as medical offices where physicians, physician assistants and nurse practitioners work, dentist offices, and podiatric offices. APUA states that many different solutions are needed, but one of the most important actions that can be taken to SB 994 (Hill) Page 9 of ? slow the development of antibiotic resistance is to ensure that antibiotics are used judiciously and only when needed. The California Hospital Association also supports this bill, stating that ASPs are already required in hospitals and nursing homes, and this bill will require ambulatory health care settings that serve non-hospitalized patients to establish an ASP. 8)Opposition. The California Medical Association (CMA) states in opposition that the most recent data from the CDC suggests that California is ahead of the curve as it relates to the issue of excessive antibiotic prescribing, and that California is one of the states at the low end of per capita antibiotic prescribing. CMA states that although well-intentioned, this bill would be onerous and confusing to comply with, and that the criteria for successfully meeting the bill's requirements are unclear and ripe for misinterpretation. CMA also points out that requiring licensing boards to ensure, though an annual audit of a random sample, that licensees have both adopted and are in compliance with an ASP has the potential to create significant workload for the licensing board. The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) states in opposition that while the language seeks to exempt people who only practice in licensed facilities, it is unlikely to significantly reduce the bill's reach since may physicians practice in several settings, with both hospital privileges and a private practice. AAP argues that a physician may then be subject to multiple different ASPs, resulting in confusion. This bill is also opposed by the California Dental Association (CDA), which states that this bill is premature, confusing, and raises enforcement feasibility questions. CDA states that just five months ago, the CDC presented to the American Dental Association on antibiotic stewardship, and detailed the lack of data or evidence on the prescribing behaviors of dentists. According to CDA, the CDC discussed the challenges of implementing any interventions without the data from which to develop them, and stated that the next steps would be to measure and characterize antibiotic prescribing by dentists. 9)Inclusion of dentists and podiatrists. The concern over the inappropriate prescribing of antibiotics in outpatient settings has historically focused on the use of antibiotics in primary care settings to treat what are often viral infections, rather than bacterial infections. The data on dental and podiatric prescribing behavior is less robust. With SB 994 (Hill) Page 10 of ? regard to dental prescribing, the author cites a review of studies published in July of 2010 in the journal Therapeutics and Clinical Risk Management (TCRM report), which reviewed studies on dental prescribing published worldwide. According to the TCRM report, dentists prescribe between 7% and 11% of all common antibiotics, mainly for the treatment of infections that originate in the tooth or surrounding tissue. The TCRM report concluded that the prescribing practices of dentists are inadequate and this is manifested by over-prescribing, and recommended improving antibiotic prescribing practices in dental offices. However, this was a review of literature worldwide, and there does not appear to be much data specific to the United States. The American Dental Association, in a statement that it made supporting the responsible use of antibiotics, pointed to a study published in March of 2015 in the journal Clinical Infectious Diseases which looked at oral antibiotic prescribing data among all outpatients, and it found that after family practitioners, pediatricians and internists, dentists were the next most-frequent prescriber of oral antibiotics in an outpatient setting at 10% of all prescriptions. 10)Policy Comment. Currently, the CDC and other organizations have only published antibiotic stewardship guidelines for hospitals and other institutional settings. According to the author, the CDC is expected to publish antibiotic stewardship guidelines for outpatient settings later this year. While this bill allows compliance through "evidence-based methods," such as poster-based interventions or accountable justification (writing justifications for prescribing antibiotics in the patient's medical record), given the lack of published guidelines specific to outpatient settings, the author may wish to consider a delayed implementation to allow for these guidelines to be published. SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION : Support: Alliance for the Prudent Use of Antibiotics California Hospital Association County Health Executives Association of California Oppose: American Academy of Pediatrics California Dental Association California Medical Association SB 994 (Hill) Page 11 of ? -- END --