BILL ANALYSIS Ó SENATE COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL ORGANIZATION Senator Isadore Hall, III Chair 2015 - 2016 Regular Bill No: SB 1138 Hearing Date: 4/12/2016 ----------------------------------------------------------------- |Author: |Hueso | |-----------+-----------------------------------------------------| |Version: |2/18/2016 Introduced | ----------------------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------------------------------------ |Urgency: |No |Fiscal: |Yes | ------------------------------------------------------------------ ----------------------------------------------------------------- |Consultant:|Felipe Lopez | | | | ----------------------------------------------------------------- SUBJECT: Space Day DIGEST: This bill requires the Governor to proclaim an undetermined date in each year to be Space Day and requires the legislative body of each city, county, or city and county to, by ordinance, require every resident, business, and public entity to dim or turn off their lights between 9 p.m. and 10 p.m. on the date designated as Space Day. ANALYSIS: Existing law: 1)Requires the Governor to Proclaim the following days each year as follows: a) September 28 as "Cabrillo Day." b) January 15 as "Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., Day." c) March 7 as "Arbor Day." d) February 19 as "A Day of Remembrance: Japanese American Evacuation." e) Fourth Friday in September as "Native American Day." f) First Sunday in October as "Stepparents Day." g) April 21 as "John Muir Day." h) March 30 as "Welcome Home Vietnam Veterans Day." i) December 7 as "Pearl Harbor Day." j) March 31 as "Cesar Chavez Day." aa) Month of February as "Black History Month." SB 1138 (Hueso) Page 2 of ? bb) Third Saturday in June as "Juneteenth National Freedom Day: A Day of Observance." cc) April 24 as "California Day of Remembrance of the Armenian Genocide." dd) May 22 as "Harvey Milk Day." ee) January 30 as "Fred Korematsu Day of Civil Liberties and the Constitution." ff) February 6 as "Ronald Reagan Day." gg) January 23 as "Ed Roberts Day." hh) October 25 as "Larry Itliong Day." This bill: 1)Requires the Governor to proclaim an undetermined date in each year to be Space Day and designate that date as having special significance in public schools and educational institutions. 2)Requires the Governor to encourage public schools and educational institutions to conduct suitable commemorative exercises on that date. 3)Specifies Space Day to promote space observation and appreciation, promote California's aerospace industry, and encourage students to pursue careers in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics. 4)Requires the legislative body of each city, county, or city and county to, by ordinance, require every resident, business, and public entity to dim or turn off their lights between 9 p.m. and 10 p.m. on the date designated as Space Day. Background Purpose of the bill. According to the author, "today in urban regions of California light pollution, a term which is used to describe the adverse effects of artificial light, has greatly inhibited observation of the night sky. Researchers have noted that increased urban sky glow is responsible for making the Milky Way nearly impossible to view for many of California's urban regions. Unfortunately, many Californian's must now travel far from their home, away from the glow of artificial light sources, to view the majestic night sky." Light Pollution. Light pollution is a term that refers to the brightening of the night sky caused by streetlights and other SB 1138 (Hueso) Page 3 of ? man-mad sources, which inhibits the observation of stars and planets and has been argued to have a disruptive effect on natural cycles. Light pollution is a side effect of industrial civilization. Its sources include building exterior and interior lighting, advertising, commercial properties, offices, factories, streetlights, and illuminated sporting venues. The biggest contributor to light pollution includes roadway lightings, especially in major cities and highways. Most experts state that light emitted from roadways, is approximated to constitute about 35% to 50% of all light pollution. Unintended Consequences. The bill currently requires that the legislative body of each city, county, or city and county shall, by ordinance, require every resident, business, and public entity to dim or turn off their lights between 9 p.m. and 10 p.m. on the date designated as Space Day. While the intention is to reduce light pollution and make the night sky more visible, such a requirement raises various issues. The bill's current requirement is unclear as to which lights should be dimmed or turned off. A strict reading of the bill would mean that all lights, including street lights, car lights, hospital lights, etc, would be required to be turned off. This would mean that all businesses, including restaurants, gas stations, bars, etc., that do not have dimming lights would be forced to either turn off their lights, or more realistically close their business during this time period. Sporting events would be affected since the requirement to turn off their lights would make playing any sporting event practically impossible. In addition, it is unclear what the enforcement of such an ordinance would entail. Suggested Amendments. As previously stated, the current requirement to turn off the lights would have a plethora of unintended consequences. Therefore, the author may wish to delete the current requirement and instead specify that the Governor shall encourage residents, businesses, and public entities to dim or turn off their lights between 9 p.m. and 10 p.m. on the date designated as Space Day. The bill currently does not specify what date the Governor shall proclaim as Space Day. However, National Space Day as well as International Space Day is observed on the first Friday in May. Therefore, the author may wish to amend the bill to specify that SB 1138 (Hueso) Page 4 of ? the Governor shall proclaim the first Friday in May as Space Day. Author's Amendments. The author will be presenting amendments in committee to exempt from the light reduction requirements public safety providers and first responders which include, city or county law enforcement agencies, jails, fire departments, hospitals, clinics, mental health hospitals, or any other entity that is deemed to provide necessary public services. In addition, the author will be presenting amendments in committee to exempt from the light reduction requirements agencies necessary for critical community services which shall include airports, bridges, port authorities, public spaces where large numbers of citizens congregate or any other entity that is deemed to provide necessary community services. It is unclear what would be defined as entities that are deemed to provide necessary community services and what are public spaces where large numbers of citizens congregate. However, it should be noted that if enough entities are exempted, light pollution would remain an issue and thus eliminate the intended goal of the bill. Prior/Related Legislation AB 2598 (Ting, 2016) requires the Governor to annually proclaim the date corresponding with the start of the lunar calendar as Lunar New Year's Day. (Pending in Assembly Education Committee) AB 7 (Bonta, Chapter 29, Statutes of 2015) required the Governor to annually proclaim October 25 as Larry Itliong Day. AB 1775 (Furutani, Chapter 241, Statutes of 2010) required the Governor to annually proclaim January 30 as Fred Korematsu Day of Civil Liberties and the Constitution. SB 944 (Runner, Chapter 114, Statutes of 2010) required the Governor to annually proclaim February 6 as Ronald Reagan Day. SB 1256 (Hancock, Chapter 115, 2010) required the Governor to annually proclaim January 23 as Ed Roberts Day. SB 572 (Leno, Chapter 626, Statutes of 2009) required the Governor to annually proclaim May 22 as Harvey Milk Day. SB 1138 (Hueso) Page 5 of ? AB 717 (Cook, Chapter 158, Statutes of 2009) required the governor to annually proclaim March 30 as Welcome Home Vietnam Veterans Day. FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes SUPPORT: San Diego Air & Space Museum (Sponsor) International Dark-Sky Association OPPOSITION: CalAsian Chamber of Commerce California Attractions and Parks Association California Chamber of Commerce California Grocers Association California Hotel & Lodging Association California Manufacturers & Technology Association California Restaurant Association California Retailers Association National Federation of Independent Business ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the San Diego Air & Space Museum, "space day is designed to promote space observations and appreciation among California's citizens, promote California's global aerospace industry, and to encourage students to pursue careers in science, technology, engineering and math." ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSSITION: Opponents of the bill argue that, "the impacts that SB 1138 would have on private business and the public health and safety system will be substantial as it will not just disrupt operations for that single hour blackout period but, depending on the operation, several hours before and after companies have to shut down then restart their processes. This would pose a logistical challenge as many businesses would not have a choice but to make a calculated decision that could result in prematurely terminating afternoon and/or evening shifts or eliminating hours. For example, restaurants would likely close the entire evening therefore not scheduling employees to work, which would result in personnel not working their anticipated hours during that pay period." SB 1138 (Hueso) Page 6 of ? Opponents also argue that, "dimming or eliminating lighting in a workplace or business is not always safe or feasible. It is not practical and almost always unsafe to have employees working in dimmed conditions when operating machinery, cooking or preparing food, or using industrial equipment. It could also put employees and/or consumers in an unwanted health or public safety situation, which could potentially expose the business to costly litigation. The unintended consequence of this requirement would be to deny certain businesses the ability to operate safely and efficiently, not just during the timeframe called for in this bill but for the additional preparation time on both ends of this lighting ban/restriction." DUAL REFERRAL: Senate Governance and Finance Committee