BILL ANALYSIS Ó SENATE COMMITTEE ON HEALTH Senator Ed Hernandez, O.D., Chair BILL NO: SB 1308 --------------------------------------------------------------- |AUTHOR: |Nguyen | |---------------+-----------------------------------------------| |VERSION: |March 28, 2016 | --------------------------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------------------------- |HEARING DATE: |April 6, 2016 | | | --------------------------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------------------------- |CONSULTANT: |Scott Bain | --------------------------------------------------------------- SUBJECT : Medi-Cal: county health systems SUMMARY : Prohibits a Medi-Cal managed care plan known as a county organized health system (COHS) from utilizing any funds intended for administrative and operational expenses for staff retreats, promotional giveaways, excessive executive compensation, or promotion of federal or state legislative or regulatory modifications. Prohibits a media campaign or paid advertising purchased by a COHS from featuring in any manner the image or voice of an elected public official or candidate for elected office or directly represent the views of an elected public official or candidate for elected office, unless the name appears in a roster listing containing the names of all officers of the purchasing agency and all names in the roster appear in the same type size, typeface, type color, and location. Existing law: 1)Establishes the Medi-Cal program, which is administered by the Department of Health Care Services (DHCS), under which qualified low-income individuals receive health care services. 2)Requires that DHCS has exclusive authority to negotiate the rates, terms, and conditions of COHS contracts and contract amendments. 3)Permits any county or counties to establish a special commission in order to meet the problems of the delivery of publicly assisted medical care in the county or counties and to demonstrate ways of promoting quality care and cost efficiency. 4)Permits a county board of supervisors, by ordinance, to SB 1308 (Nguyen) Page 2 of ? establish a commission to negotiate the exclusive COHS and to arrange for the provision of health care services under the Medi-Cal program. This bill: 1)Prohibits a COHS from utilizing any funds intended for administrative and operational expenses for staff retreats, promotional giveaways, excessive executive compensation, or promotion of federal or state legislative or regulatory modifications. 2)Prohibits a media campaign or paid advertising purchased by a COHS from featuring in any manner the image or voice of an elected public official or candidate for elected office, or directly represent the views of an elected public official or candidate for elected office. 3)Permits a media campaign or paid advertising purchased by a COHS to include a reference to an elected public official or candidate for elected office if the name appears in a roster listing containing the names of all officers of the purchasing agency and all names in the roster appear in the same type size, typeface, type color, and location. 4)Makes the following legislative findings and declarations: a) COHS collectively serve 2.2 million enrollees in the Medi-Cal program, recent increases in enrollment in the Medi-Cal program have stretched available resources and have the potential to limit access to vital medical care; b) COHS resources should be directed to providing direct care to the maximum extent possible; c) The California Health Benefit Exchange (known as Covered California) has operated with limitations on how taxpayer funding can be used in an effort to direct more resources into direct patient services; d) All advertisement and promotional material produced by COHS should be used to promote access to health care and not to promote board members; and, e) COHS are responsible for billion-dollar annual contracts, which potentially create perceived or real conflicts of interest. FISCAL SB 1308 (Nguyen) Page 3 of ? EFFECT : This bill has not been analyzed by a fiscal committee. COMMENTS : 1)Author's statement. According to the author, this bill would ensure that funds allocated to COHS are used for direct services to the greatest extent possible. The bill will also ensure that COHS funding is not used for political purposes. The bill would mirror the protections in the statutes applying to the California Health Exchange (Covered California) and Proposition 99 (The Tobacco Tax and Health Protection Act). 2)COHS. There are two main systems for the delivery of services to Medi-Cal beneficiaries: fee-for-service (FFS) and Medi-Cal Managed Care (MCMC). MCMC is an organized system for the delivery of medical services in which DHCS contracts with public and private managed care plans to provide health care coverage for Medi-Cal beneficiaries. COHS are one model of Medi-Cal managed care, whereby DHCS contracts with a COHS created by a County Board of Supervisors to be the sole administrator of Medi-Cal benefits for an entire county. There are six COHS operating in 22 counties serving approximately 2.1 million Medi-Cal beneficiaries. Almost all Medi-Cal-eligible beneficiaries in COHS counties are mandatorily enrolled into the COHS plan. The chart below is a list of the COHS, the counties they serve, and the number of Medi-Cal beneficiaries in each COHS as of February 2016: ---------------------------------------------------------- | COHS | Counties | Number of | | | | enrollees | | | | as of May 2015 | |-----------------+---------------------+------------------| | CalOptima | Orange | 765,580 | |-----------------+---------------------+------------------| | CenCal Health | Santa Barbara | 173,082 | | | San Luis Obispo | | |-----------------+---------------------+------------------| | Central | Santa Cruz, |345,723 | | California | Monterey, Merced | | | Alliance for | | | | Health | | | |-----------------+---------------------+------------------| | Gold Coast | Ventura | 205,004 | SB 1308 (Nguyen) Page 4 of ? | Health Plan | | | |-----------------+---------------------+------------------| | Health Plan of | San Mateo | 112,885 | | San Mateo | | | |-----------------+---------------------+------------------| | Partnership |Del Norte, Humboldt, | 567,682 | | Health |Lake, Lassen, Marin, | | | Plan of | Mendocino, Modoc, | | | California | Napa, Shasta, | | | | Siskiyou, Solano, | | | |Sonoma, Trinity, and | | | | Yolo Counties | | ---------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------- |Total COHS Enrollment |2,169,956 | | | | ----------------------------------------------------------- 3)Bill provisions mirror existing law governing Covered California and Proposition 99 funded media campaign. The author's background material and the legislative bill findings cite major changes that could occur in the Medi-Cal program and potentially result in increased General Fund costs as high as the low billions of dollars annually as the phase-in of the state's share of cost for the ACA optional expansion population begins. The author argues the increase in the Medi-Cal caseload, combined with increasing cost pressures, make it imperative that taxpayer funding is not diverted from direct medical services. To address this, this bill contains language modeled on a provision in the state law establishing Covered California, and a provision in the anti-tobacco media campaign funded by Proposition 99 fund, as follows: ----------------------------------------------------------- | Existing law | SB 1308 | |-------------------------------+---------------------------| |Prohibits Covered California |Prohibits a COHS from | |board or its staff from |utilizing any funds | |utilizing any funds intended |intended for | |for the administrative and |administrative and | |operational expenses for staff |operational expenses for | |retreats, promotional |staff retreats, | |giveaways, excessive executive |promotional giveaways, | |compensation, or promotion of |excessive executive | |federal or state legislative |compensation, or promotion | SB 1308 (Nguyen) Page 5 of ? |or regulatory modifications. |of federal or state | |(Government Code Section |legislative or regulatory | |100520.) |modifications. | | | | |Prohibits an Exchange from | | |utilizing any funds intended | | |for the administrative and | | |operational expenses of the | | |Exchange for staff retreats, | | |promotional giveaways, | | |excessive executive | | |compensation, or promotion of | | |Federal or State legislative | | |and regulatory modifications. | | |(Sec. 1311 of the federal | | |Affordable Care Act.) | | | | | |-------------------------------+---------------------------| |Prohibits any Proposition |Prohibits a media campaign | |99-funded media campaign from |or paid advertising | |featuring in any manner the |purchased by a COHS from | |image or voice of any elected |featuring in any manner | |public official or candidate |the image or voice of an | |for elected office, or |elected public official or | |directly represent the views |candidate for elected | |of any elected public official |office or directly | |or candidate for elected |represent the views of an | |office. (Health and Safety |elected public official or | |Code Section 104375,) |candidate for elected | | |office. | | | | | |Permits a media campaign | | |or paid advertising | | |purchased by a COHS | | |include a reference to an | | |elected public official or | | |candidate for elected | | |office if the name appears | | |in a roster listing | | |containing the names of | | |all officers of the | | |purchasing agency and all | | |names in the roster appear | | |in the same type size, | | |typeface, type color, and | SB 1308 (Nguyen) Page 6 of ? | |location. | | | | ----------------------------------------------------------- 4)Opposition. Four county organized health system plans write in opposition to this bill, stating that COHS have publicly appointed boards or commissions with oversight responsibility over the plan, and this bill undermines the concept of local control and responsibility. Opponents argue this bill erroneously takes language that is currently applied to Covered California and applies it to COHS, and singles out COHS among the Medi-Cal managed care models when COHS have among the lowest percentage of administrative costs of any Medi-Cal managed care model, and there is no demonstrated example of the need to apply spending and operational prohibitions to COHS. Opponents argue the promotional items almost always include the plan name and contact information, and this information ensures that as many eligible beneficiaries as possible know who their health plan is and how to contact the plan. Finally, opponents argue it may be advantageous for COHS to use an elected official in an advertisement or media campaign to promote the plan and to encourage their constituents to use the plan's services as the elected official has credibility with his or her constituents and can better convince people to enroll in the program. 5)Proposed author's amendment. The author is proposing amendments to delete the prohibition in this bill against the use of any funds for the promotion of federal or state legislative or regulatory modifications. SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION : Support: None received Oppose: Central California Alliance for Health Gold Coast Health Plan Health Plan of San Mateo Partnership Health Plan -- END -- SB 1308 (Nguyen) Page 7 of ?