BILL ANALYSIS Ó SENATE COMMITTEE ON VETERANS AFFAIRS Senator Jim Nielsen, Chair 2015 - 2016 Regular Bill No: SB 1458 Hearing Date: 4/12/16 ----------------------------------------------------------------- |Author: |Bates | |-----------+-----------------------------------------------------| |Version: |4/6/16 | ----------------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------- |Urgency: |No |Fiscal: |Yes | ----------------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------- |Consultant:|Wade Teasdale | | | | ----------------------------------------------------------------- Subject: Property taxation: exemptions: disabled veterans DESCRIPTION Summary: Expands eligibility of the "disabled veterans property tax exemption" to include persons, who were discharged from military service under "other than dishonorable conditions." Existing law: 1)Authorizes the Legislature to exempt partially or fully from property tax, the home of a disabled veteran - or the veteran's spouse, including an unmarried surviving spouse - if the veteran's disabling injury incurred in military service; and the veteran is blind in both eyes; lost the use of two or more limbs; or is totally disabled. [California Constitution, Article XIII, Section 4(a)] a) Applies also to the veteran's spouse, including an unmarried surviving spouse, if the veteran has, as a result of a service-connected injury or disease, died while on active duty in military service. b) Does not apply if the home is receiving another real property exemption. 1)Provides a partial exemption for eligible disabled veterans. (RTC Section 205.5) 2)Defines an eligible veteran as a person who, among other SB 1458 (Bates) Page 2 of ? things, is serving in or has served in and has been discharged under honorable conditions from service in the United States Army, Navy, Air Force, Marine Corps, or Coast Guard. (RTC Section 205.5) This bill: 1)Regarding eligibility for the disabled veterans property tax exemption, modifies the military discharge standard to include both of the following criteria: a) Discharged from military service "under other than dishonorable conditions"; and b) Determined by the United States Department of Veterans Affairs (USDVA) to be eligible for federal veterans' health and medical benefits. 2) Provides that no appropriation is made and the state shall not reimburse local agencies for property tax revenues lost by them pursuant to the bill. BACKGROUND Disabled Veterans Property Tax Exemption California provides qualified disabled veterans and their unmarried surviving spouses with a property tax exemption that applies to their home's assessed value. Eligibility provisions require that the claimant demonstrate award of disability rating from the USDVA that: 1) Rates the veteran's disability at 100%; or 2) Rates the veteran's disability compensation at 100% because the veteran is unable to secure and maintain gainful employment. The law also allows surviving spouses to receive the exemption if the spouse's death was service-connected. To be eligible for the exemption, surviving spouses must receive a USDVA determination that the spouse's death was service-connected. A USDVA determination is necessary for (1) active duty personnel deaths (i.e., the service person was not a "veteran") and (2) veterans without a 100% rating when alive, but whose cause of death is deemed service-connected. Surviving spouses of veterans SB 1458 (Bates) Page 3 of ? with a 100% disability rating during their lifetime continue to receive the exemption after the veteran's death so long as they do not remarry. The exemption amount depends upon the claimant's income. According to the State Board of Equalization, Fiscal year 2016-17, the basic exemption adjusted for inflation will be $127,510. If the claimant's income is less than $57,258, the exemption amount will be $191,266. For Fiscal Year 2015-16, 37,653 disabled veterans or their unmarried surviving spouses were granted the exemption. ----------------------------------------------------------------- | | | Lower | | Qualification | | Income | | | | Exemption | | | Basic | Amount | | | | $40,000 | | | Exemptio| adjusted | | | | for | | | n | inflation | | | | $57,258 | | | Amount | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |-------------------------------------+-------------+-------------| | Disabled Veteran | $100,000 | $150,000 | | | | | | Disability Rating = 100% | adjuste | adjuste | | Disability Compensation = | d for | d for | | 100% | inflati | inflati | | Blind | on | on | | Lost Two or More Limbs | | | | | $127,510 |$191,266 | | Spouse of Military Personnel | | | | Surviving Spouse: Disabled | | | | Veteran | | | | Surviving Spouse: Active | | | | Duty Death | | | | Surviving Spouse: | | | | | | | | Posthumous service-connected | | | SB 1458 (Bates) Page 4 of ? | | | | | death finding | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |-------------------------------------+-------------+-------------| | Claims Granted: 37,653 | 33,196 | 4,457 | | | | | ----------------------------------------------------------------- ----------------------------------------------------------------- | Source: California State Board of Equalization, Legislative | | | |and Research Division, 2016 | | | | | | | ----------------------------------------------------------------- Types of Military Discharges The military separates its personnel from active service by formally discharging them. Discharges may be either administrative or punitive. Each of the five different discharge statuses is determined by the characterization of an individual's service. The character of service slides along a scale with "honorable" at the high end and "dishonorable" at the low end. The types of discharges fall under one of two categories: "Administrative" or "punitive." Punitive discharges are reserved for the most negative cases and imposed only by special and general courts martial. Administrative separations cannot be awarded by a court-martial and are not punitive in nature. Enlisted personnel may be administratively separated with a characterization of service or a description of separation. Administrative discharges include: 1)Honorable. This is the most common discharge status. It presumes creditable service and good behavior. All service members will earn an Honorable Discharge unless they SB 1458 (Bates) Page 5 of ? experience significant problems and receive a lower type of discharge, 2)General (under honorable conditions).Sometimes referred to as a "General Discharge," it is granted if an individual's commander determines that the service has been generally honest and faithful, even if the person ran into some trouble. General Discharges are given for a variety of reasons, including failure to progress in training; failure to maintain military standards in, appearance, weight, or fitness; or for disciplinary infractions, including drug or alcohol abuse. 3)Other than Honorable. An "OTH" discharge usually is given when an individual's service represents a broader pattern of departure from the conduct and performance expected of all military members. It can result from notable drug or alcohol problems, but also can be based on other misconduct, such as abuse of authority, fraternization, or a pattern of continued misconduct. OTH discharges bar the individual from reenlisting into any component of the Armed Forces, including the federal reserves and National Guard. Punitive discharges are authorized punishments of courts-martial and can only be imposed as an approved court-martial sentence following an individual's conviction for violating the Uniform Code of Military Justice. There are two types of punitive discharges: 1)Bad Conduct Discharge. This can be imposed by both special and general courts-martial. This discharge is usually given for convictions of crimes such as absent without leave, drunk on duty, driving while under the influence, adultery, writing bad checks, and disorderly conduct. 2)Dishonorable Discharge. This is the worst type of military discharge a service member can receive, and can be imposed only by a general court-martial. In most cases, a Dishonorable Discharge also involves being sentenced to serve time in a military prison. Discharge Requirements for Veterans Benefits Basic eligibility for federal veterans benefits depends upon the type of military service performed, duration of service, and SB 1458 (Bates) Page 6 of ? character of discharge or separation. The discharging military branch makes those determinations; the USDVA reviews the military's description of the "character of discharge" to determine whether a person meets the basic eligibility requirements for receipt of VA benefits under title 38 of the United States Code. A discharge characterized by a military service as "under honorable conditions" is binding on the USDVA and requires it to provide benefits if other eligibility requirements are met. A Dishonorable Discharge explicitly bars the USDVA from providing benefits. The OTH and Bad Conduct discharges bar an individual from presumptive eligibility for federal benefits. In these cases, however, the USDVA, as administering agency of benefits, may be asked to make an independent assessment of the character of service. The USDVA reviews facts and circumstances surrounding the incident(s) that led to the discharge, as reported by the military, as well as any supporting evidence from the claimant or third parties. On a case-by-case basis, VA determines whether the incidents that led to the OTH or Bad Conduct discharge may be found to have been "under conditions other than dishonorable," and thus whether basic eligibility for VA benefits can be established. Therefore, while recipients of OTH and Bad Conduct discharges were not separated "under honorable conditions," for the purposes of determining benefit eligibility, they may be found to have been separated "under other than dishonorable conditions." Attached to this analysis is a table, which describes the federal veterans benefits available to an individual based on type of discharge. This table was produced by the United States Army and provided by the California National Guard. COMMENT Committee comments : 1)The California Constitution does not condition the disabled veteran property tax exemption on the nature of an individual's discharge status. That condition, which is in statute, is the provision of law which SB 1458 seeks to SB 1458 (Bates) Page 7 of ? change. 2)Discharge status: i) Traditionally, when defining the term "veteran" for the purposes of establishing eligibility for state-provided veterans benefits, California hews toward Honorable Discharge, which is the highest federal standard. The general definition of "veteran" is contained in Military and Veterans Code (MVC) Sec. 980 is "any person who did all of the following": 1) Served in the active military, naval, or air service of the United States for a period of not less than 90 consecutive days or was discharged from the service due to a service-connected disability within that 90-day period. 2) Received an Honorable Discharge or was released from active duty under honorable conditions. a) For example, the Military and Veterans Code (MVC) Section 987.52 defines eligibility for the CalVet Home Loan Program as meeting either of the following: i) Any veteran as defined in MVC Section 980; ii) Any person who is on active duty in the military or naval service of the United States, whose service may or may not have been continuous, and who is in all other respects qualified pursuant to MVC Section 980. b) One recent departure from tradition is the Veterans Housing and Homelessness Prevention (VHHP) Program, which does not condition its provision of housing or supportive services on a potential beneficiary's discharge status. The VHHP defines an eligible veteran as follows: "Veteran" means any person who served in the active military, naval, or air service of the United States, or as a member of the National Guard who was called to and released from active duty or active service, for a period of not less than 90 consecutive days or was discharged from the service due to a service-connected disability within that 90-day period. [MVC SB 1458 (Bates) Page 8 of ? Sec. 987.003(d)] Related /Prior Legislation SB 1104 (Stone, pending Senate Governance and Finance Committee, 2016) fully exempts the home of a disabled veteran from property tax and prohibits any future Proposition 13-related inflation adjustments to the assessed value of homes of honorably discharged veterans over the age of 65. SB 1183 (Bates, pending Senate Veterans Affairs Committee, 2016) fully exempts from property tax the home of any person eligible for the disabled veterans' exemption. AB 1556 (Mathis/Weber, pending Assembly Revenue and Taxation Committee, 2016) almost identical to SB 1183 (Bates, 2016). AB 188 (Block & Butler, Chapter 202, Statutes of 2011) provides that the disabled veterans' property tax exemption applies when an unmarried surviving spouse is confined to a health care facility. POSITIONS Sponsor: Hon. George Runner, Member, State Board of Equalization Support: American G.I. Forum of California American Legion - Department of California AMVETS - Department of California California Association of County Veterans Service Officers California State Commanders Veteran Council Military Officers Association of America - California Council of Chapters Veterans of Foreign Wars - Department of California Vietnam Veterans of American - California State Council Oppose: None received -- END -- SB 1458 (Bates) Page 9 of ?