BILL ANALYSIS �
AB 1420
Page 1
Date of Hearing: May 4, 2011
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL ORGANIZATION
Isadore Hall, Chair
AB 1420 (Committee on Governmental Organization) - As
Introduced: March 21, 2011
SUBJECT : Emergency Management Assistance Compact.
SUMMARY : Removes the March 1, 2012 sunset date for the
operation of the Emergency Management Assistance Compact (EMAC).
The purpose of EMAC is to provide mutual aid among the states
in meeting any emergency or disaster. Specifically, this bill :
1) Repeals the requirement that the EMAC, which becomes
inoperative on March 1, 2012, and repealed as of January 1,
2012, thereby making the compact operative indefinitely.
EXISTING LAW :
1) Establishes the California Emergency Services Act (Act) and
charges the California Emergency Management Agency (Cal EMA)
with the responsibility for overseeing and coordinating
emergency preparedness, response, recovery, and homeland
security activities.
2) Declares the intent of the State of California to continue
its long history of sharing emergency response resources with
other states during emergencies and times of disasters by
entering into the EMAC.
3) Ratifies, approves, and sets forth the provisions of the
EMAC which allows for the provision of mutual aid between
California and other states in the event of an emergency or
disaster that requires more resources than the state can
provide. Providing mutual aid to another state is voluntary and
the decision of whether or not to provide assistance is made
based on the amount of resources available at the time of
emergency. Under the existing law, California's ratification of
EMAC expires on March 1, 2012, and as of January 1, 2013, is
repealed.
FISCAL EFFECT : Unknown.
AB 1420
Page 2
COMMENTS :
Purpose of the bill : AB 1420 repeals the current sunset
provision (AB 1564 (Nava, Chapter 414, Statutes of 2007)
applicable to the EMAC. The EMAC statute will become inoperable
March 1, 2012, which will make it difficult for California to
receive or provide aid to other states during disasters. EMAC
is an interstate compact, ratified by Congress, which enables
mutual aid among the states in meeting any emergency or
disaster, whether natural or man-made. EMAC has now been
adopted by all 50 states, as well as the six U.S. territories.
Background : In the 1970s, California played a major role in
creating the Interstate Civil Defense and Disaster Compact
(ICDDC), which was eventually adopted by nearly all other states
and ratified by Congress. The compact enabled states to share
emergency management resources during times of disaster and
encouraged the coordination of emergency preparedness activities
between states.
In 1992, a group of southern states initiated a project to
update the ICDDC. That project resulted in EMAC, which was
ratified by Congress in 1996 and has now been adopted by all 50
states, including California. Upon adoption of EMAC, many
states rescinded the older ICDDC. California did not rescind
it.
In 2005, California enacted urgency legislation (AB 823, Nava,
Chapter 233, Statutes of 2005) to adopt EMAC. This provision
became effective September 13, 2005. In 2007, legislation (AB
1564, Nava, Chapter 414, Statutes of 2007) extended the EMAC
sunset date for a period of five years. However, unless a new
provision is enacted to either extend the sunset date or make
the compact permanent, EMAC will cease to be operative on March
1, 2012 and will sunset on January 1, 2013.
The California Professional Firefighters Association (CPF) had
initial concerns with the adoption of EMAC. Their concern
stemmed from the EMAC requirement that emergency responders be
considered agents of the receiving state for tort liability and
immunity purposes. CPF argued that California firefighters and
other emergency personnel should be protected by California law
when they are sent to other states in emergency situations. A
compromise, however, was reached near the close of the 2005
legislative session that, despite these liability provisions,
AB 1420
Page 3
requires California to make whole emergency personnel injured or
killed in another state.
EMAC allows states impacted by a disaster to request and receive
assistance from other member states quickly and efficiently.
Each year, California sends resources, such as firefighting
equipment, rescue aircraft, search teams, emergency managers,
and other specialized personnel and equipment, to assist other
states during disasters. Similarly, California has received
emergency assistance from other states over the years when
facing disasters such as earthquakes and firestorms. The EMAC
mutual aid system has worked successfully and has benefitted
both California and other states in numerous situations; some
examples of EMAC resource sharing are outlined below.
In 2005, California sent a wide assortment of emergency
personnel to New Orleans and Biloxi, Mississippi to assist
with their response and recovery from Hurricane Katrina. The
resources sent included law enforcement officers from the
California Highway Patrol, personnel to help staff the states'
State Operations Centers, fire personnel and equipment,
various aircraft, care and shelter workers, building
inspectors, California National Guard troops, and various
medical teams.
During 2007 and 2008, California sent Swift Water Rescue Teams
and emergency management personnel to Gulf States affected by
hurricanes Rita, Ike, and Gustav.
When southern California experienced catastrophic wild fires
in 2007, the state requested EMAC assistance. A total of
forty-three (43) states sent aid to California. Over 27,000
out-of-state firefighters were deployed to California to help
with firefighting and fire prevention efforts. This is the
largest and most significant instance of California receiving
aid through the EMAC. Without the EMAC aid, California would
not have been able to fight the large firestorm effectively.
The quick, legally established EMAC process allows for relative
ease in sharing emergency resources between the states that
adopted EMAC. Prior to adopting EMAC, sharing resources between
states, as seen in the examples above, would have been much more
difficult. California had few options - it could either share
resources through some federal legal mechanism, or it could
create an ad hoc agreement with the other state(s) needing or
AB 1420
Page 4
providing assistance, but only as permitted by existing law
(Government Code Section 8619).
If California allows EMAC to sunset, no established process
beyond ad hoc state-to-state agreements will be in place to
allow California to receive assistance should another large
scale event occur. Although the ICDDC still exists in statute,
there is a provision in the law that states it shall be in
effect only among those states that have enacted or adopted it.
Since all the other states have adopted EMAC and no longer use
the ICDDC, this compact would not provide the protection
California needs to receive aid from other states during an
emergency.
Continuation of EMAC will allow uninterrupted sharing of
resources between California and the rest of the country.
Because the EMAC statute will become inoperable on March 1,
2012, legislation must be enacted immediately to repeal that
date and permanently establish EMAC in statute.
Prior legislation: AB 1564 (Nava), Chapter 414, Statutes of
2007. Extended from January 1, 2008, to January 1, 2013, the
operation of the EMAC. In addition, the bill prohibits the
state from giving or receiving assistance for any condition
resulting from a labor controversy.
SB 548 (Hollingsworth), Chapter 127, Statutes of 2007. Extended
the July 1, 2007 sunset for the Disaster Response-Emergency
Operations Account (DREOA) to January 1, 2009 and declares an
urgency.
SB 1102 (Hollingsworth), Chapter 561, Statutes of 2005.
Extended the sunset date applicable to the DREOA within the
Special Fund for Economic Uncertainties from January 1, 2006 to
July 1, 2007.
AB 823 (Nava), Chapter 233, Statutes of 2005. Enacted a
modified version of the EMAC however, it became inoperative on
March 1, 2007.
SB 1102 (Budget Committee), Chapter 227, Statutes of 2004.
Among other things, this measure continued until January 1, 2006
the DREOA within the Special Fund for Economic Uncertainties and
allocated $1 million to the Account at the beginning of each
fiscal year.
AB 1420
Page 5
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION :
Support
California Emergency Management Agency (Sponsor)
California Military Department
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by : Eric Johnson / G. O. / (916) 319-2531