BILL ANALYSIS Ó
AB 2451
Page 1
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
AB 2451 (John A. Pérez)
As Amended August 20, 2012
Majority vote
-----------------------------------------------------------------
|ASSEMBLY: |69-4 |(May 10, 2012) |SENATE: |21-8 |(August 23, |
| | | | | |2012) |
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Original Committee Reference: INS.
SUMMARY : Extends the statute of limitations to allow a safety
officer's dependents to receive workers' compensation death
benefits where the safety officer dies of cancer or other
"presumed" job-related injuries.
The Senate amendments narrow and clarify the bill by:
1)Extending the existing 240 week statute of limitations to 480
weeks.
2)Clarifying that the recipient of the benefits must be a
dependent at the time of the death of the safety officer.
3)Clarifying that the "date of injury" must have occurred during
the safety officer's active service.
4)Limiting the presumed injuries to which the bill applies to
cancer, tuberculosis, and blood-borne infectious diseases.
5)Providing that the extended limitations period does not apply
to cases which have already been finalized.
6)Providing that the extended limitations period does not apply
to cases where the existing statute of limitations expired
prior to December 31, 2012.
EXISTING LAW :
1)Establishes a comprehensive system for providing benefits to
workers injured on the job, including death benefits payable
to dependents.
2)Provides generally that an injured worker bears the burden to
AB 2451
Page 2
establish that the injury for which benefits are claimed arose
out of or in the course of employment.
3)Provides, for specified peace officer and firefighter
employees, that certain injuries or conditions are presumed to
have arisen out of or in the course of employment.
4)Provides for a statute of limitations defining the period
within which a claim for benefits must be filed, and with
respect to death benefits, specifies that the claim must be
filed within one year of:
a) The date of death, if death occurs less than one year
from the date of injury;
b) The date of last furnishing benefits, if death occurs
more than one year from the date of injury; or,
c) The date of death, if death occurs more than one year
after the date of injury and compensation benefits have
been furnished.
5)Establishes special rules governing the period within which
proceedings must be commenced for asbestosis and HIV/AIDS
cases.
6)Provides further that, notwithstanding the above limitations,
no proceedings may be commenced later than one year after the
date of death or 240 weeks after the date of injury.
7)Establishes a schedule of death benefits, with specific
amounts due depending on whether the dependent is fully or
partially dependent, and depending on the number of fully or
partially dependent beneficiaries. Depending on the
circumstances, the death benefits can be in excess of
$300,000.
8)Provides that when a person otherwise entitled to death
benefits has no dependents, the benefits shall be paid to the
state, and credited to the uninsured employers fund, which
pays for benefits to injured workers who were employed by an
illegally uninsured employer.
9)Specifies that questions about full or partial dependency, and
questions about who the dependents are, shall be determined
AB 2451
Page 3
"in accordance with the facts as they exist at the time of the
injury of the employee."
10)Provides that no person is a dependent unless:
a) He or she is, in good faith, a member of the family or
household of the employee; or,
b) Husband or wife, child, posthumous child, adopted child
or stepchild, grandchild, father or mother, father-in-law
or mother-in-law, grandfather or grandmother, brother or
sister, uncle or aunt, brother-in-law or sister-in-law, or
nephew or niece of the employee.
AS PASSED BY THE ASSEMBLY , this bill:
1)Included heart conditions among the conditions for which the
extended statute of limitations would apply.
2)Provided no cap on how far into the future the safety
officer's death could be and still qualify for the dependent
benefit.
3)Retained the rule that dependency was determined as of the
date of injury, not the date of death.
4)Allowed claims in cases where the existing limitations period
had expired to be revived if death occurred within the bill's
new limitations rule.
COMMENTS : According to the author, this bill is necessary
because surviving family members of fallen firefighters and
peace officers who are "timed out" of the right to receive death
benefits should be extended. Specifically, proponents point to
cases where the safety officer is suffering from a long battle
with cancer, or cases where the cancer is temporarily in
remission. In these cases, the employer is well aware of the
existence of the claim, has had the opportunity to reserve for
the claim, but the fact that the injured safety officer is able
to battle the condition long enough to get past the existing
limitations period, the employer is relieved from paying a death
benefit to dependents once the officer finally succumbs to the
illness.
AB 2451
Page 4
The general rationale for presuming certain injuries or
conditions to be job related is that the conditions are
intuitively likely to be job related, but it is difficult for
the employee to prove. As a result, certain public safety
employees have been granted this special rule in recognition of
the inherent dangers they face on the job. This bill focusses
on the illnesses that are presumed to be job related but which
can linger for extended periods of time, thereby causing
unfairness to the survivors of the safety officer.
In 2004, AB 3051 (Nation and Vargas) proposed a similar rule to
what is being proposed by this bill. AB 3051, however, applied
only to firefighters. Nonetheless, AB 3051 was vetoed. The
veto message sent by Governor Schwarzenegger provided, in
pertinent part:
This bill extends the statute of limitations for the
collection of death benefits that are presumptively
concluded to be service related. Because current law
presumes certain firefighter injuries to be
work-related, this bill will also increase the
potential for the surviving heirs of firefighters who
die from non-work related illnesses to receive workers
compensation death benefits.
Analysis Prepared by : Mark Rakich / INS. / (916) 319-2086
FN: 0005363